Let's brainstorm, if we have some good ideas, LotV can create an even better SC experience.
Currently (as lalush points out) P and Z don't gain a noticeable income boost per expansion after the 3rd expansion due to worker saturation/supply cap. This leads to turtle/harass type games that generally end up being decided by who's deathball is more cost efficient. Rarely do we see split armies fighting on multiple fronts like in BW (splits are generally limited to drops, zealots, and ling runbys, which are more of a multitasking nuisance than an actual threat).
Blizzard has already spent so much time and money developing the game to this state... so there won't be any drastic changes to the fundamentals in LotV (worker saturation, pathing, although maybe supply cap can be changed because that only affects mid-late game) because that would throw out 3 years of careful balancing and metagame development.
Now with that in mind (for practicality's sake, we have to compromise), what sort of changes could Blizzard potentially implement now or in the next expansion?
1) Micro that can change the tide of a battle. For example in BW, reavers, mines, blocking ling pathing with probes, etc. I think the lack of this is what made WoL less entertaining-- HotS is a big step up in this regard. In HotS, medivac boost, roach/ling/bling busts and defense, seeker missiles, vipers, etc
2) Unique playstyles. If all Terrans/Tosses/Zergs played the same style, spectating would get boring quick. MKP's signature bio playstyle early on was just fantastic to watch and root for.
3) (credit to lalush for this one) larger maps with 12+ expansion locations, maybe with a higher supply cap. This would encourage many more smaller skirmishes rather than a sudden death deathball fight for the last mineable expansions. A higher supply cap would also eliminate the 3base maximum income issue.
On July 13 2013 20:56 graNite wrote: with zealots and sentrys yes, but the colossus is too boring for many players/viewers.
totally agree, my first gut feeling when WoL came out was that a lot of the micro intensive units (reaver, scourge, mines, lurkers) got dumbed down versions.
Also in general, what are some cool micro units/abilities that you'd like to see in LotV guys? I'm thinking... -changing the way zealots path/charge so there's room for maneuvering -more high-risk/high-reward units or abilities -reintroduce the reaver -
game needs to be hard enough for casual players to appreciate the level of play being executed by pros. lol and sc2 both pale in comparison to bw when it comes to spectator friendly, because all those clutch things pros did in bw was just so much rarer to see
We need several things that would really entertain spectators and make this game much more deep than it its current form.
1) Need to do something to boring units either by changing its functions and/or look e.g. colossus/corrupters. Even if they have a single one dimensional purpose in the game, at least make the graphical animations look more pleasing to the eye.. like what if corrupters had a 3D attack animation similiar to the BW devourer?
2) Bring back the high ground mechanic. This way we can actually see positioning taken to a new level (now its about securing bases for economy AND high ground so that you dont get cut off or suffocated) instead of the old "dancing" with the opponent til you get the right concave.. This could potentially break up the deathball and lead to more multi engagements through the game which is WAY more exciting to watch. It really shows who the better player is.
3) Need to do something to the economy. Too many workers = less units in the field, too many workers = worker harasses are much more impactful, too many workers = no need for going above 3 bases.. There needs to be an incentive to get more bases or you simply lose out and on top of that this game emphasizes way too much on worker harass. This emphasis needs to be spread around so that its just not about killing workers to win.
4) This game needs more zone control/positional units and no more harass/offensive units. Creates more interesting engagements than the basic flanks and better concaves. And a careful use of these units along with high ground could lay steps of comeback games..
5) Even if blizzard who "apparently" tested the unit spacing so that you don't literally blob up.. should implement it because it simply looks much more natural. Why not just add it if doesn't add to the gameplay but it does so visually i.e. better for the spectators?
6) Bring back some of the hard but high reward mechanics. E.g. removing smart cast on offensive AOE spells while buffing those spells. Bring back the holy shit storm moments when the progamer literally pulls off something thats insanely hard to do (like clicking on individual HTs to cast storms off during a battle).
HOTS compared to WoL was a huge improvement but... the devs aren't willing to admit and tackle the real problems which I see no problems in why they shouldn't. Everyone wants the game to be deep (hence why theres so many excellent TL articles/posts done by users who go the extra mile and explain/analyse all the gameplay issues in SC2) and surpass BW yet they refuse to come down from that really high horse of theres...
On July 13 2013 22:00 YyapSsap wrote: We need several things that would really entertain spectators and make this game much more deep than it its current form.
1) Need to do something to boring units either by changing its functions and/or look e.g. colossus/corrupters. Even if they have a single one dimensional purpose in the game, at least make the graphical animations look more pleasing to the eye.. like what if corrupters had a 3D attack animation similiar to the BW devourer?
2) Bring back the high ground mechanic. This way we can actually see positioning taken to a new level (now its about securing bases for economy AND high ground so that you dont get cut off or suffocated) instead of the old "dancing" with the opponent til you get the right concave.. This could potentially break up the deathball and lead to more multi engagements through the game which is WAY more exciting to watch. It really shows who the better player is.
3) Need to do something to the economy. Too many workers = less units in the field, too many workers = worker harasses are much more impactful, too many workers = no need for going above 3 bases.. There needs to be an incentive to get more bases or you simply lose out and on top of that this game emphasizes way too much on worker harass. This emphasis needs to be spread around so that its just not about killing workers to win.
4) This game needs more zone control/positional units and no more harass/offensive units. Creates more interesting engagements than the basic flanks and better concaves.
5) Even if blizzard who "apparently" tested the unit spacing so that you don't literally blob up.. should implement it because it simply looks much more natural. Why not just add it if doesn't add to the gameplay but it does so visually i.e. better for the spectators?
6) Bring back some of the hard but high reward mechanics. E.g. removing smart cast on offensive AOE spells while buffing those spells. Bring back the holy shit storm moments when the progamer literally pulls off something thats insanely hard to do (like clicking on individual HTs to cast storms off during a battle).
HOTS compared to WoL was a huge improvement but... the devs aren't willing to admit and tackle the real problems which I see no problems in why they shouldn't. Everyone wants the game to be deep (hence why theres so many excellent TL articles/posts done by users who go the extra mile and explain/analyse all the gameplay issues in SC2) and surpass BW yet they refuse to come down from that really high horse of theres...
Blizzard probably won't remove the boring units, even though it would be much better for the game. Another interesting point is that one-dimensional use is very boring-- reapers harass/suicide scout, oracles earlygame harass, and do basically nothing else.
Changing unit pathing could be VERY interesting. This would make fights based more on positioning than unit comp.
SPEAKING OF UNIT COMP, making the right mix of units was more important than any micro in WoL, a BIG pitfall in game design for WoL.
Definitely more micro intensive units as well as more sexy micro mechanics, things that make you say wow. The only thing that does this for me is marine splits. Sure splitting lings takes just as much skill but it doesn't look super fancy and cool like splitting marines does. Making sure every unit has a place in the game, e.g raven, they are hardly ever seen but create some really damn cool micro situations.
what makes you want to watch pro-games (besides self improvement)
The commentary mostly i think, specially when its artosis. Then the competitive environment of tournaments, am curious who will win and i have my favorites i can root for. i always like to see socke play for example even though he is not the best player, nor playing my favorit race to watch. Also the gameplay a bit, though i dont realy care for anny specific unit. More the idea of 2 people controlling different armies and beeing able to follow the whole battle with a helicopter vieuw.
On July 13 2013 20:50 NovemberstOrm wrote: I would love to see more micro units in LotV.
Yep me too definitly !
maybe remove colossus and give toss a micro robo unit?
Suggesting impossible to happen changes is useless. Blizzard won't remove already established unit with a big impact in the game. They can only maybe change it or tone it down to create more space for new units in vol.