Low entry barrier.
[D] What makes for a good spectator eSport? - Page 3
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
Maxilicious
221 Posts
Low entry barrier. | ||
|
Ecstatic
United States160 Posts
| ||
|
xuanzue
Colombia1747 Posts
BW was easier to watch than SC2. | ||
|
pmp10
3403 Posts
For the former it's the easy to pick-up and hard to master formula. For the latter it's mostly visual fidelity and sufficient tension in the game. And I have to disagree with 1st point you made. Micro actually hurts the spectator experience because of how ridiculous it looks. | ||
|
rift
1819 Posts
| ||
|
Ecstatic
United States160 Posts
On July 14 2013 01:37 rift wrote: Comebacks. Don't see those too much these days. If they happened frequently that would kill the excitement of a comeback. It still happens, I remember Fantasy came back from a huge deficit against a Z recently, though I don't remember who it was. | ||
|
timurStas
68 Posts
| ||
|
lamprey1
Canada919 Posts
By the end of the day they have a pretty good grasp on all the basics of the game. "easy to learn, difficult to master" | ||
|
tomsKa
United States39 Posts
| ||
|
Qwyn
United States2781 Posts
| ||
|
HystericaLaughter
Australia720 Posts
Also one of the most important things is the action curve, you want the action to start reasonably early and at low-intensity, slowly and steadily ramping up in pace and excitement before culminating in a victory for one side. | ||
|
Brian333
657 Posts
The most basic requirement is that people need to play the game. The question that needs to be asked is how do you get people to play the game. Just look at LoL. I'm sure I'm not alone when I say I don't know wtf is going on in any given skirmish. Even people who play the game still comment on how it's hard to watch. Does that stop it from being hugely successful? Nope. | ||
|
sabas123
Netherlands3122 Posts
| ||
|
NEEDZMOAR
Sweden1277 Posts
On July 13 2013 23:47 Big J wrote: I disagree with his point that micro is a problem, but I can where he is coming from. There is nothing special in seeing (most) micromoves, as they are repetetive and always the same. Meanwhile, when you watch sports, there is always something different. I think that's where micro has to go. Instead of against banelings --> split against tanks --> targetfire against zealots --> kite stuff, that gets figured out fast and then is just always the same, just with tiny differences in execution. Then you look at football and watch Messi and it's like against a single opponent in a certain situation --> pass or outrun or trick1 or trick3 or trick7 against two opponents in a certain situation --> pass or outrun or trick2 or trick3 ... You always find yourself questioning "what does player X do next and how will his opponent react?" - in microterms! Right now we only have this interaction in strategy and even there it is very set, though I believe this is more of a balancing problem (not enough viable strategies). It makes the games less predictable and introduces more uncertainity for the viewer in any situation (while not being random!). And most of all, it introduces style. Messi and Ronaldo and Neymar are all different players that play differently but all of them are successful if they play their unique style right. On the flipside, a Protoss that does not blink properly will not be successful, not matter what he does with his attention instead. But I believe such a game would have to be built completely differently. With less macrorequirements (more time to use your micropotential, less fatality from making mistakes at home) and less unittypes (every unit in itself should have interesting relations with every other unit) yeah thats exactly what I meant, watching blink micro the first time is amazing, not as awesome the 100th time youre watching it :>) In general, watching pros countering their opponents using refined strats, tricks and sometimes builds specialized to counter players rather than races is to me what makes Sc2 great, that "ooh I why didnt I think of that" or "damn I wish I had Lifes apm so I could pull off the things he's doing" that, among many other things is why sc2 is an awesome spectator sport imo ![]() | ||
|
Targe
United Kingdom14103 Posts
I do feel however we've had this thread a lot or times. | ||
|
TheRavensName
United States911 Posts
Anyways, moving on... Personally, the one thing I want back more then anything is wraith and muta micro. That was some of the most tense and impressive moments for me when I was spectating. | ||
|
LaLuSh
Sweden2358 Posts
I will be going through all of these in greater detail at some point in the future. Hopefully this year ![]() SC2's fundamental design is bad, so I don't see how any fluff/unit changes will ever lead to what we want: * A low-volatility game that at the highest levels both rewards skill and allows for the manifestation of skill. * High impact units that are entertaining to watch and don't break balance (impossible with the current production mechanics, however much you whine and beg for them, high impact units can't be balanced without a defender's advantage or without the possibility for economically asymmetrical matchups). * Reward players who expand aggressively and seek to play an offensive/attacking type of Starcraft as opposed to rewarding players who camp and are the most cost efficient with the deathball in their current possession. None of these are magically going to appear however much you wish for them. If the game design doesn't allow for wasteful/attacking style of play after a 3 base economy, then no amount of creative unit designing is going to fix the fact that succesful players are going to play safe and passive rather than take the risks of constantly attacking. If macro mechanics aren't toned down slightly, then the 200 supply cap will keep dictating the pace and strategies for a majority of the games, as opposed to just being a number that most of the time isn't even a factor (Broodwar). Without introducing a proper defender's advantage, there will be no drastic waning of strength of deathball armies the further away they venture from production facilities. The major reason BW was so fun to watch was because spellcasters and certain units were impossibly imbalanced -- but they took several minutes to traverse the map and reinforce the attacking army. The defending army was always in a drastically better position (not saying this doesn't exist in SC2, but compared to BW, the defender's advantage is maybe 20% the strength it was). So stop wishing for creative funky units designs, open your eyes and see the real reason why Blizzard keep introducing this "fake swarminess" to the game with swarm hosts popping free units to simulate a semblance of the willingness to constantly attack. BW was beautiful becaus the game was very asymmetric. Every matchup had huge economical asymmetries built into them. One race would almost always assume the role of the constantly wasteful aggressor, desperately trying to keep the economy of the race with the "imbalanced" composition in check. In SC2, these features that used to promote attractive and beautiful gameplay, cease to exist once players are finished saturating their third bases. Do not try to bend the game. That's impossible. Instead... only try to realize the truth. There is no swarm. | ||
|
purakushi
United States3310 Posts
![]() Also, great conclusion >< | ||
|
Gben592
United Kingdom281 Posts
And, variety and unpredictability. | ||
|
LaLuSh
Sweden2358 Posts
On July 14 2013 05:06 purakushi wrote: Been waiting for a post by you, LaLuSh ![]() Also, great conclusion >< Though I should say that I actually think warp-in can exist in an RTS if the game contains sufficient complexity in other areas. Does SC2 have sufficient complexity and buffers to have something like warp-in in it without fucking up the game? Absolutely not. | ||
| ||
