• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 02:42
CET 08:42
KST 16:42
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Team Liquid Map Contest #235[ASL22] Finals Preview: Sweet Victory!12[ASL22] Ro4 Preview: Mirror Mirror6[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: Within Reach5[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: In A Tizzy11
Community News
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over1Dark completes military service, returns to SC215[BSL23] RO16 Group Stage20Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?2Weekly Cups (Oct 26 - Nov 1): MaxPax, herO, Solar win0
StarCraft 2
General
Team Liquid Map Contest #23 Dark completes military service, returns to SC2 Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over StarCraft open world shooter announced at BlizzCon No more SC2 streamers on team liquid?
Tourneys
Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-22 Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) Dark returns! GSL CK #7 4v4 Team Battle (Nov 19) soO & FanTaSy return! SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4 (Nov 16)
Strategy
[H] ZvP Mid-Late Game: Stalkers Collossi HT
Custom Maps
[G] How to playtest arcade maps Starcraft 2 Advance [D] the control group Simple Questions/Answers
External Content
Mutation # 552 Secret Storm The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 551 Robotic Revival Mutation # 550 Graveyard Shift
Brood War
General
List of top players active on ShieldBattery BW General Discussion NaDa's Body Shield Battery Server New Patch BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/
Tourneys
SC1 Kevin Scrim hosted by SOOP (Nov 18-19) [IPSL] Winter 26-27 Round of 16! [Megathread] Daily Proleagues 2v2v2v2 Tournament Stage 2: Players
Strategy
Pluto's TvP 5Marine 2Medic Push Simple Questions, Simple Answers Infested Terran strategies in 2026 Nuke strategy worked in K-League 2026-11-09
Other Games
General Games
Nintendo Switch Thread Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Free Space RTS Game, optimised f. Phone/Tablet etc List of Game Threads The PlayStation 5
Dota 2
League of Legends
[TL LoL EUW IHs] Teemo shall perish
Heroes of the Storm
Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Trading/Investing Thread Artificial Intelligence Thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine
Fan Clubs
Fan Club Resource Thread Reynor Fan Club The Flash Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
Football (Soccer) Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
The time I organised my…
AssyrianKing
Why I built Repalyzer (1.1.…
BlueStar
Innovate or Game Over?
TrAiDoS
ShieldBattery on Mac
Kraekkling
Can Bots Beat Pros?? Starcr…
namkraft
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Socialism Anyone?
GreenHorizons
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 10174 users

Blizzard: Out of touch? - Page 31

Forum Index > SC2 General
Post a Reply
Prev 1 29 30 31 32 33 Next All
JustTray
Profile Joined May 2011
127 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-06-13 20:03:36
June 13 2011 20:02 GMT
#601
On June 14 2011 04:51 DarkPlasmaBall wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 13 2011 12:12 jsdk wrote:
I think what bothers me the most is their mentality of "we'll fix balance in the expansion." I seem to remember a community manager saying that he couldn't believe that people would think that they would have an imbalanced game until an expansion was released. He wrongly thought Blizzard was still the same company.

The problem with that is that they can't know exactly what's imbalanced (or not) unless they openly communicate to the pros, instead of telling them to wait a year for some magical fix that might happen. And then guess what? Not everything is fixed because they keep shrugging people off, and then "wait until the next expansion..." Fantastic.


I think what bothers me the most is that people whine about Blizzard when they don't care to pay attention to what Blizzard has actually been doing.

They don't put off fixing balance. They have been fixing balance. The statistics show that the game has been getting more and more balanced.

Furthermore, they've been talking to pros, looking at forums, looking at their own statistics, and playing the game themselves, ever since the beta.

They've been using every possible form of input and feedback available, which is why the game is very, very close to balanced at the moment.


Also slightly off topic, but relevant to your post. I've played Dayvie in 2v2 RT vs AT ladder about a dozen times in the last couple months. Every single time I've been an random team vs his arranged team. I had an ally, who I got matched with vs them 6 times in a row leave the game at the start every single time.

David Kim's response to this clearly broken RT vs AT mechanic that gave him 6 free wins? I quote, "Your MMR is too high."

That was the top balance designer's actual comment in game as to why the matchmaking was partnering me with a random teamate who quit the game over and over vs an incredibly highly skilled 2v2 arranged team that designs the game.

If that doesn't sum up Blizzard's absolute ineptitude, I don't know what can.

Edit - In case anyone thinks I'm making it up, his partner is and has always been Slayers_BekHo, they play and they play PT occasionally.
karpo
Profile Joined October 2010
Sweden1998 Posts
June 13 2011 20:10 GMT
#602
On June 14 2011 05:02 JustTray wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 14 2011 04:51 DarkPlasmaBall wrote:
On June 13 2011 12:12 jsdk wrote:
I think what bothers me the most is their mentality of "we'll fix balance in the expansion." I seem to remember a community manager saying that he couldn't believe that people would think that they would have an imbalanced game until an expansion was released. He wrongly thought Blizzard was still the same company.

The problem with that is that they can't know exactly what's imbalanced (or not) unless they openly communicate to the pros, instead of telling them to wait a year for some magical fix that might happen. And then guess what? Not everything is fixed because they keep shrugging people off, and then "wait until the next expansion..." Fantastic.


I think what bothers me the most is that people whine about Blizzard when they don't care to pay attention to what Blizzard has actually been doing.

They don't put off fixing balance. They have been fixing balance. The statistics show that the game has been getting more and more balanced.

Furthermore, they've been talking to pros, looking at forums, looking at their own statistics, and playing the game themselves, ever since the beta.

They've been using every possible form of input and feedback available, which is why the game is very, very close to balanced at the moment.


Also slightly off topic, but relevant to your post. I've played Dayvie in 2v2 RT vs AT ladder about a dozen times in the last couple months. Every single time I've been an random team vs his arranged team. I had an ally, who I got matched with vs them 6 times in a row leave the game at the start every single time.

David Kim's response to this clearly broken RT vs AT mechanic that gave him 6 free wins? I quote, "Your MMR is too high."

That was the top balance designer's actual comment in game as to why the matchmaking was partnering me with a random teamate who quit the game over and over vs an incredibly highly skilled 2v2 arranged team that designs the game.

If that doesn't sum up Blizzard's absolute ineptitude, I don't know what can.

Edit - In case anyone thinks I'm making it up, his partner is and has always been Slayers_BekHo, they play and they play PT occasionally.


so your subjective experience with 6 games in RT vs AT 2vs2 shows "Blizzard's absolute ineptitude", give me a break...

Didn't they fix RT vs AT btw?
Nakas
Profile Joined May 2010
United States148 Posts
June 13 2011 20:11 GMT
#603
On June 14 2011 04:23 karpo wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 14 2011 04:14 Two_DoWn wrote:
On June 14 2011 02:48 Seide wrote:
When Browder mentions that "uncertainty" when going into battles and mentions he liked that "there are things someone can do to swing the battle", I have to disagree, that because of how strong aoe is and how units clump, it actually takes away from this uncertainty, as units simply die too quick for someone to do those things that can swing the battle.

Uncertainty was how well you could psi storm, dodge emps, put clumps of tanks in stasis, and all across 2 or 3 screens of units. Now its just "let me slam my ball into yours and see who wins." The only uncertainty is because you cant actually tell how many units there are in a given space because all balls look the same. Uncertainty is good when it derives from micro. Its shit when it comes from visual misrepresentation.


Let me slam my ball into your and see who wins might be true in regular low rank ladder matches. It's not really true in actual high end tournaments. Why to people so often resort to hyperbole and exaggerations when they want to argue a point on these forums?


The TSL4 finals wasn't high-level? Many of those games in that final PvT match could be summed up with the phrase "let me slam my ball into yours and see who wins."
DarkPlasmaBall
Profile Blog Joined March 2010
United States46742 Posts
June 13 2011 20:11 GMT
#604
On June 14 2011 05:02 JustTray wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 14 2011 04:51 DarkPlasmaBall wrote:
On June 13 2011 12:12 jsdk wrote:
I think what bothers me the most is their mentality of "we'll fix balance in the expansion." I seem to remember a community manager saying that he couldn't believe that people would think that they would have an imbalanced game until an expansion was released. He wrongly thought Blizzard was still the same company.

The problem with that is that they can't know exactly what's imbalanced (or not) unless they openly communicate to the pros, instead of telling them to wait a year for some magical fix that might happen. And then guess what? Not everything is fixed because they keep shrugging people off, and then "wait until the next expansion..." Fantastic.


I think what bothers me the most is that people whine about Blizzard when they don't care to pay attention to what Blizzard has actually been doing.

They don't put off fixing balance. They have been fixing balance. The statistics show that the game has been getting more and more balanced.

Furthermore, they've been talking to pros, looking at forums, looking at their own statistics, and playing the game themselves, ever since the beta.

They've been using every possible form of input and feedback available, which is why the game is very, very close to balanced at the moment.


Also slightly off topic, but relevant to your post. I've played Dayvie in 2v2 RT vs AT ladder about a dozen times in the last couple months. Every single time I've been an random team vs his arranged team. I had an ally, who I got matched with vs them 6 times in a row leave the game at the start every single time.

David Kim's response to this clearly broken RT vs AT mechanic that gave him 6 free wins? I quote, "Your MMR is too high."

That was the top balance designer's actual comment in game as to why the matchmaking was partnering me with a random teamate who quit the game over and over vs an incredibly highly skilled 2v2 arranged team that designs the game.

If that doesn't sum up Blizzard's absolute ineptitude, I don't know what can.

Edit - In case anyone thinks I'm making it up, his partner is and has always been Slayers_BekHo, they play and they play PT occasionally.


It's your ally's fault for leaving the game, not David Kim's fault for having a partner. If you don't like the fact that Random Teams puts you with a Random Teammate who might leave at any moment, then don't play Random Teams -.-' Duh. Get a friend.

I can't believe you'd blame Blizzard for the fact that your partner left the game because he was intimidated by the opponents. How ridiculous. That's what happens when you play on a Random Team. You run the risk of playing with a dumb ally. Or you run the risk of playing with a totally kick-ass ally. That's why it's called Random Teams.
"There is nothing more satisfying than looking at a crowd of people and helping them get what I love." ~Day[9] Daily #100
Nabes
Profile Joined November 2010
Canada1800 Posts
June 13 2011 20:12 GMT
#605
On June 14 2011 05:10 karpo wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 14 2011 05:02 JustTray wrote:
On June 14 2011 04:51 DarkPlasmaBall wrote:
On June 13 2011 12:12 jsdk wrote:
I think what bothers me the most is their mentality of "we'll fix balance in the expansion." I seem to remember a community manager saying that he couldn't believe that people would think that they would have an imbalanced game until an expansion was released. He wrongly thought Blizzard was still the same company.

The problem with that is that they can't know exactly what's imbalanced (or not) unless they openly communicate to the pros, instead of telling them to wait a year for some magical fix that might happen. And then guess what? Not everything is fixed because they keep shrugging people off, and then "wait until the next expansion..." Fantastic.


I think what bothers me the most is that people whine about Blizzard when they don't care to pay attention to what Blizzard has actually been doing.

They don't put off fixing balance. They have been fixing balance. The statistics show that the game has been getting more and more balanced.

Furthermore, they've been talking to pros, looking at forums, looking at their own statistics, and playing the game themselves, ever since the beta.

They've been using every possible form of input and feedback available, which is why the game is very, very close to balanced at the moment.


Also slightly off topic, but relevant to your post. I've played Dayvie in 2v2 RT vs AT ladder about a dozen times in the last couple months. Every single time I've been an random team vs his arranged team. I had an ally, who I got matched with vs them 6 times in a row leave the game at the start every single time.

David Kim's response to this clearly broken RT vs AT mechanic that gave him 6 free wins? I quote, "Your MMR is too high."

That was the top balance designer's actual comment in game as to why the matchmaking was partnering me with a random teamate who quit the game over and over vs an incredibly highly skilled 2v2 arranged team that designs the game.

If that doesn't sum up Blizzard's absolute ineptitude, I don't know what can.

Edit - In case anyone thinks I'm making it up, his partner is and has always been Slayers_BekHo, they play and they play PT occasionally.


so your subjective experience with 6 games in RT vs AT 2vs2 shows "Blizzard's absolute ineptitude", give me a break...

Didn't they fix RT vs AT btw?



they have not yet, but i doubt they ever will
karpo
Profile Joined October 2010
Sweden1998 Posts
June 13 2011 20:14 GMT
#606
On June 14 2011 05:11 Nakas wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 14 2011 04:23 karpo wrote:
On June 14 2011 04:14 Two_DoWn wrote:
On June 14 2011 02:48 Seide wrote:
When Browder mentions that "uncertainty" when going into battles and mentions he liked that "there are things someone can do to swing the battle", I have to disagree, that because of how strong aoe is and how units clump, it actually takes away from this uncertainty, as units simply die too quick for someone to do those things that can swing the battle.

Uncertainty was how well you could psi storm, dodge emps, put clumps of tanks in stasis, and all across 2 or 3 screens of units. Now its just "let me slam my ball into yours and see who wins." The only uncertainty is because you cant actually tell how many units there are in a given space because all balls look the same. Uncertainty is good when it derives from micro. Its shit when it comes from visual misrepresentation.


Let me slam my ball into your and see who wins might be true in regular low rank ladder matches. It's not really true in actual high end tournaments. Why to people so often resort to hyperbole and exaggerations when they want to argue a point on these forums?


The TSL4 finals wasn't high-level? Many of those games in that final PvT match could be summed up with the phrase "let me slam my ball into yours and see who wins."


What game did that. I remember seing two contains, one blink stalker rush and a epic hold by Thorzain. Last game was alot of positioning and had great EMP's etc.
r_con
Profile Blog Joined May 2011
United States824 Posts
June 13 2011 20:15 GMT
#607
On June 14 2011 04:33 DarkPlasmaBall wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 14 2011 04:08 r_con wrote:
On June 14 2011 03:55 DarkPlasmaBall wrote:
Blizzard gets feedback from multiple outlets, including the pro-gamers, their own forums, and all the statistics they collect. And they take it very seriously. And, quite frankly, they know a heck of a lot more about their game than Sen does.

Furthermore, if you've been paying any attention to the evolution of SC2 so far, you'd notice that the game has been approaching a more balanced ratio overall for 1v1.

I really couldn't disagree more with the OP. Just because Blizzard doesn't want to patch, buff, or nerf, every single idea that people come up with doesn't mean they're *out of touch* with everyone. It would destroy the game to change everything for no legitimate reason, and at least Blizzard is honest with us.

Your premises and arguments are clearly flawed, and even your random facts are just plain ridiculous. Roaches, marauders, and immortals are the SC2 versions of dragoons? Umm... not even close. None of them can attack air, none of them have famously terrible pathing, and they each have unique abilities (burrow move, concussive shells, hardened shields). So if your argument was that those three units were ranged units that happened to cost a little gas... then okay.

You're grasping at straws, and I don't see it going anywhere useful. How about we wait until the expansions come out? And if you think certain units are boring, then go make your own game with cooler versions of them -.-'


I agree with you. But i think the concept of just an overall solid unit should be exclusive to one race. The marauder and the stalker and roach are just great "meat" units. The problem is that they closely overlap due to there health. a Roach feels like a marauder, and a marauder feels like a stalker. But if you compare say, hydras to dragoons, or vultures to roaches, they are way different.

What i think we are essentially saying is that the units overlap in overall feel too much. In broodwar, the only good ranged high health, pretty good against everything unit was the dragoon. Now zerg and terran have that kind of unit too(not exactly the same of course).



What you've posited is that there exists a single trio of units that has a similar feel to them. In other words, that there is one Zerg unit that kind of feels like one Terran unit, and that both kind of feel like a Protoss unit. Roach ~ Marauder ~ Stalker.

1. First off, I would be worried if this were the norm for the races. In other words, if pretty much every Terran unit matched each Zerg and Protoss unit. I think it's quite obvious that this isn't the case. In fact, Blizzard has said over and over again that they make sure that there isn't an equivalent of each unit for each niche or mirror unit to match. And yet the match-up statistics show that the game is relatively balanced in 1v1. I think that's rather amazing.

2. Secondly, I actually reject your claim that Roach ~ Marauder ~ Stalker. I see a match only in cost. The differences?
-Marauders counter the other two straight up.
-The multiple abilities of each: burrow-move vs. stim and concussive vs. blink and air attack. Very different indeed.

3. We see a lot of variation in 1v1 games. If we only saw pure marauders out of Terran players, or all Protosses going pure stalkers, then we'd have a problem. What we see instead is a variety of builds (which does undoubtedly change as the metagame shifts), so I really don't see problems here. Some units are used more than others, true. But that doesn't imply that we need this thread to bash Blizzard in the way the OP is. It certainly doesn't mean Blizzard is *out of touch*.



variation does not necessarily lead to good strategy or exciting battles, the "marauders counter the other two straight up doesn't get my point. They all serve the same basic role, despite have different ways of doing it. The stalker and the marine accomplish doing damage and avoiding damge in different ways. The tank and roach accomplish damage in different ways. The hydra in broodwar, and the dragoon in broodwar, accomplished goals in different ways because the health differential was so high. The stalker, the marauder and the roach, are all relatively mobile ranged units with lots of health and a good consistent attack with decent dps.

They are dragoons with an ability, nothing more, and all they all fill the same role.

Flash Fan!
JustTray
Profile Joined May 2011
127 Posts
June 13 2011 20:17 GMT
#608
On June 14 2011 05:10 karpo wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 14 2011 05:02 JustTray wrote:
On June 14 2011 04:51 DarkPlasmaBall wrote:
On June 13 2011 12:12 jsdk wrote:
I think what bothers me the most is their mentality of "we'll fix balance in the expansion." I seem to remember a community manager saying that he couldn't believe that people would think that they would have an imbalanced game until an expansion was released. He wrongly thought Blizzard was still the same company.

The problem with that is that they can't know exactly what's imbalanced (or not) unless they openly communicate to the pros, instead of telling them to wait a year for some magical fix that might happen. And then guess what? Not everything is fixed because they keep shrugging people off, and then "wait until the next expansion..." Fantastic.


I think what bothers me the most is that people whine about Blizzard when they don't care to pay attention to what Blizzard has actually been doing.

They don't put off fixing balance. They have been fixing balance. The statistics show that the game has been getting more and more balanced.

Furthermore, they've been talking to pros, looking at forums, looking at their own statistics, and playing the game themselves, ever since the beta.

They've been using every possible form of input and feedback available, which is why the game is very, very close to balanced at the moment.


Also slightly off topic, but relevant to your post. I've played Dayvie in 2v2 RT vs AT ladder about a dozen times in the last couple months. Every single time I've been an random team vs his arranged team. I had an ally, who I got matched with vs them 6 times in a row leave the game at the start every single time.

David Kim's response to this clearly broken RT vs AT mechanic that gave him 6 free wins? I quote, "Your MMR is too high."

That was the top balance designer's actual comment in game as to why the matchmaking was partnering me with a random teamate who quit the game over and over vs an incredibly highly skilled 2v2 arranged team that designs the game.

If that doesn't sum up Blizzard's absolute ineptitude, I don't know what can.

Edit - In case anyone thinks I'm making it up, his partner is and has always been Slayers_BekHo, they play and they play PT occasionally.


so your subjective experience with 6 games in RT vs AT 2vs2 shows "Blizzard's absolute ineptitude", give me a break...

Didn't they fix RT vs AT btw?


Point is RT vs AT is not a balanced matchup, one of the main reasons being that 2 arranged players are not going to backstab eachother, vs in RT, one player may choose to BM the other, making matching the two against one another only break both ladders.

Instead, the "expert" answer to this flaw is not that their system is broken, which it is, but instead that "I'm too good" aka "your MMR is too high", implying that I'm matching againt a highly skilled arranged team because of my own high skill, and the only way matches are therefore "fair" is to partner with a lower quality teamate.

So yes, not addressing the issue and instead deflecting it in the way they did shows only a vast ineptitude towards the way matchmaking should work.
JustTray
Profile Joined May 2011
127 Posts
June 13 2011 20:20 GMT
#609
On June 14 2011 05:11 DarkPlasmaBall wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 14 2011 05:02 JustTray wrote:
On June 14 2011 04:51 DarkPlasmaBall wrote:
On June 13 2011 12:12 jsdk wrote:
I think what bothers me the most is their mentality of "we'll fix balance in the expansion." I seem to remember a community manager saying that he couldn't believe that people would think that they would have an imbalanced game until an expansion was released. He wrongly thought Blizzard was still the same company.

The problem with that is that they can't know exactly what's imbalanced (or not) unless they openly communicate to the pros, instead of telling them to wait a year for some magical fix that might happen. And then guess what? Not everything is fixed because they keep shrugging people off, and then "wait until the next expansion..." Fantastic.


I think what bothers me the most is that people whine about Blizzard when they don't care to pay attention to what Blizzard has actually been doing.

They don't put off fixing balance. They have been fixing balance. The statistics show that the game has been getting more and more balanced.

Furthermore, they've been talking to pros, looking at forums, looking at their own statistics, and playing the game themselves, ever since the beta.

They've been using every possible form of input and feedback available, which is why the game is very, very close to balanced at the moment.


Also slightly off topic, but relevant to your post. I've played Dayvie in 2v2 RT vs AT ladder about a dozen times in the last couple months. Every single time I've been an random team vs his arranged team. I had an ally, who I got matched with vs them 6 times in a row leave the game at the start every single time.

David Kim's response to this clearly broken RT vs AT mechanic that gave him 6 free wins? I quote, "Your MMR is too high."

That was the top balance designer's actual comment in game as to why the matchmaking was partnering me with a random teamate who quit the game over and over vs an incredibly highly skilled 2v2 arranged team that designs the game.

If that doesn't sum up Blizzard's absolute ineptitude, I don't know what can.

Edit - In case anyone thinks I'm making it up, his partner is and has always been Slayers_BekHo, they play and they play PT occasionally.


It's your ally's fault for leaving the game, not David Kim's fault for having a partner. If you don't like the fact that Random Teams puts you with a Random Teammate who might leave at any moment, then don't play Random Teams -.-' Duh. Get a friend.

I can't believe you'd blame Blizzard for the fact that your partner left the game because he was intimidated by the opponents. How ridiculous. That's what happens when you play on a Random Team. You run the risk of playing with a dumb ally. Or you run the risk of playing with a totally kick-ass ally. That's why it's called Random Teams.


It is not a logical solution to say that RT is imbalanced therefore you have to not play it. The logical solution is not to "not play RT," but to not match RT vs AT. The risk of playing with a crappy ally is EXACTLY why AT should never match with RT, you simply don't have that risk, and there's no amount of handicapped points you can implement that will balance RT vs AT out.

You guys shows Blizzard's flawed logic perfectly. Instead of addressing the actual issues, they let their pride get in the way and assume everything is correct, when in practice, you can see, (most recently represented by the RT vs AT issue I brought up, but also many, many balance/map issues) that there are significant issues that are being ignored.
Persev
Profile Blog Joined April 2010
United States127 Posts
June 13 2011 20:23 GMT
#610
The reply "your mmr is to high" probably means that when you have become so good at random teams your mmr places you vs top set teams. Its a chance to test your communication skills , micro, maco, unit integration vs top teams. Its a very good sign that you can be paired up vs set teams because it means your very skilled. The fact that your paired up vs set teams doenst' mean the game is imbalanced. It means your a good player with solid team skills and you've hit a ceiling and further improvement is only vs set arranged teams. Right?

As for the quitting you know this old saying is true:" Quitters can't win. Winners don't quit." You saw that over and over in the MLG games. There is no such thing as a free win. You saw MMA killing his own CC and you saw Idra leave when the game was his. Unless your faced with an A+ hacker leaving at the start of the game is just fulfilling your own negativity.

Theres also something called pretense of knowledge syndrome. We are suffer from it. We think we know something but in actually its quite different from what we think we see. I will say that the match making system is a huge black box to me. I would rage hard when I used to get a Gold partner vs top teams. It was utter disaster so I have empathy with what your feeling. The flip side of the coin is you have the chance to rise to the occasion and come up with ways to improve to even exceed set teams.

On June 14 2011 05:02 JustTray wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 14 2011 04:51 DarkPlasmaBall wrote:
On June 13 2011 12:12 jsdk wrote:
I think what bothers me the most is their mentality of "we'll fix balance in the expansion." I seem to remember a community manager saying that he couldn't believe that people would think that they would have an imbalanced game until an expansion was released. He wrongly thought Blizzard was still the same company.

The problem with that is that they can't know exactly what's imbalanced (or not) unless they openly communicate to the pros, instead of telling them to wait a year for some magical fix that might happen. And then guess what? Not everything is fixed because they keep shrugging people off, and then "wait until the next expansion..." Fantastic.


I think what bothers me the most is that people whine about Blizzard when they don't care to pay attention to what Blizzard has actually been doing.

They don't put off fixing balance. They have been fixing balance. The statistics show that the game has been getting more and more balanced.

Furthermore, they've been talking to pros, looking at forums, looking at their own statistics, and playing the game themselves, ever since the beta.

They've been using every possible form of input and feedback available, which is why the game is very, very close to balanced at the moment.


Also slightly off topic, but relevant to your post. I've played Dayvie in 2v2 RT vs AT ladder about a dozen times in the last couple months. Every single time I've been an random team vs his arranged team. I had an ally, who I got matched with vs them 6 times in a row leave the game at the start every single time.

David Kim's response to this clearly broken RT vs AT mechanic that gave him 6 free wins? I quote, "Your MMR is too high."

That was the top balance designer's actual comment in game as to why the matchmaking was partnering me with a random teamate who quit the game over and over vs an incredibly highly skilled 2v2 arranged team that designs the game.

If that doesn't sum up Blizzard's absolute ineptitude, I don't know what can.

Edit - In case anyone thinks I'm making it up, his partner is and has always been Slayers_BekHo, they play and they play PT occasionally.

Be nice!
Nakas
Profile Joined May 2010
United States148 Posts
June 13 2011 20:23 GMT
#611
On June 14 2011 05:14 karpo wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 14 2011 05:11 Nakas wrote:
On June 14 2011 04:23 karpo wrote:
On June 14 2011 04:14 Two_DoWn wrote:
On June 14 2011 02:48 Seide wrote:
When Browder mentions that "uncertainty" when going into battles and mentions he liked that "there are things someone can do to swing the battle", I have to disagree, that because of how strong aoe is and how units clump, it actually takes away from this uncertainty, as units simply die too quick for someone to do those things that can swing the battle.

Uncertainty was how well you could psi storm, dodge emps, put clumps of tanks in stasis, and all across 2 or 3 screens of units. Now its just "let me slam my ball into yours and see who wins." The only uncertainty is because you cant actually tell how many units there are in a given space because all balls look the same. Uncertainty is good when it derives from micro. Its shit when it comes from visual misrepresentation.


Let me slam my ball into your and see who wins might be true in regular low rank ladder matches. It's not really true in actual high end tournaments. Why to people so often resort to hyperbole and exaggerations when they want to argue a point on these forums?


The TSL4 finals wasn't high-level? Many of those games in that final PvT match could be summed up with the phrase "let me slam my ball into yours and see who wins."


What game did that. I remember seing two contains, one blink stalker rush and a epic hold by Thorzain. Last game was alot of positioning and had great EMP's etc.


The final game for 15k was basically decided by two balls colliding into each other.
DarkPlasmaBall
Profile Blog Joined March 2010
United States46742 Posts
June 13 2011 20:24 GMT
#612
On June 14 2011 05:15 r_con wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 14 2011 04:33 DarkPlasmaBall wrote:
On June 14 2011 04:08 r_con wrote:
On June 14 2011 03:55 DarkPlasmaBall wrote:
Blizzard gets feedback from multiple outlets, including the pro-gamers, their own forums, and all the statistics they collect. And they take it very seriously. And, quite frankly, they know a heck of a lot more about their game than Sen does.

Furthermore, if you've been paying any attention to the evolution of SC2 so far, you'd notice that the game has been approaching a more balanced ratio overall for 1v1.

I really couldn't disagree more with the OP. Just because Blizzard doesn't want to patch, buff, or nerf, every single idea that people come up with doesn't mean they're *out of touch* with everyone. It would destroy the game to change everything for no legitimate reason, and at least Blizzard is honest with us.

Your premises and arguments are clearly flawed, and even your random facts are just plain ridiculous. Roaches, marauders, and immortals are the SC2 versions of dragoons? Umm... not even close. None of them can attack air, none of them have famously terrible pathing, and they each have unique abilities (burrow move, concussive shells, hardened shields). So if your argument was that those three units were ranged units that happened to cost a little gas... then okay.

You're grasping at straws, and I don't see it going anywhere useful. How about we wait until the expansions come out? And if you think certain units are boring, then go make your own game with cooler versions of them -.-'


I agree with you. But i think the concept of just an overall solid unit should be exclusive to one race. The marauder and the stalker and roach are just great "meat" units. The problem is that they closely overlap due to there health. a Roach feels like a marauder, and a marauder feels like a stalker. But if you compare say, hydras to dragoons, or vultures to roaches, they are way different.

What i think we are essentially saying is that the units overlap in overall feel too much. In broodwar, the only good ranged high health, pretty good against everything unit was the dragoon. Now zerg and terran have that kind of unit too(not exactly the same of course).



What you've posited is that there exists a single trio of units that has a similar feel to them. In other words, that there is one Zerg unit that kind of feels like one Terran unit, and that both kind of feel like a Protoss unit. Roach ~ Marauder ~ Stalker.

1. First off, I would be worried if this were the norm for the races. In other words, if pretty much every Terran unit matched each Zerg and Protoss unit. I think it's quite obvious that this isn't the case. In fact, Blizzard has said over and over again that they make sure that there isn't an equivalent of each unit for each niche or mirror unit to match. And yet the match-up statistics show that the game is relatively balanced in 1v1. I think that's rather amazing.

2. Secondly, I actually reject your claim that Roach ~ Marauder ~ Stalker. I see a match only in cost. The differences?
-Marauders counter the other two straight up.
-The multiple abilities of each: burrow-move vs. stim and concussive vs. blink and air attack. Very different indeed.

3. We see a lot of variation in 1v1 games. If we only saw pure marauders out of Terran players, or all Protosses going pure stalkers, then we'd have a problem. What we see instead is a variety of builds (which does undoubtedly change as the metagame shifts), so I really don't see problems here. Some units are used more than others, true. But that doesn't imply that we need this thread to bash Blizzard in the way the OP is. It certainly doesn't mean Blizzard is *out of touch*.



variation does not necessarily lead to good strategy or exciting battles, the "marauders counter the other two straight up doesn't get my point. They all serve the same basic role, despite have different ways of doing it. The stalker and the marine accomplish doing damage and avoiding damge in different ways. The tank and roach accomplish damage in different ways. The hydra in broodwar, and the dragoon in broodwar, accomplished goals in different ways because the health differential was so high. The stalker, the marauder and the roach, are all relatively mobile ranged units with lots of health and a good consistent attack with decent dps.

They are dragoons with an ability, nothing more, and all they all fill the same role.



I know that variation doesn't lead to good strategy or exciting battles.

The players are in charge of that.

And if your criteia for being a dragoon look-alike are "relatively mobile ranged units with lots of health and a good consistent attack with decent dps", then most units in the game are dragoons. I already explained why they weren't beforehand. Sure, you can pick out small similarities, but roaches actually aren't tanks or dragoons just because you can find a small likeness between them.

All this comparison to BW is getting really old. SC2 isn't BW. Not every SC2 unit was created to directly copy a BW one in every aspect, and not every race has the same type of unit.

Anyways, I'm out for now. Enjoy your day
"There is nothing more satisfying than looking at a crowd of people and helping them get what I love." ~Day[9] Daily #100
DarkPlasmaBall
Profile Blog Joined March 2010
United States46742 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-06-13 20:28:22
June 13 2011 20:27 GMT
#613
On June 14 2011 05:20 JustTray wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 14 2011 05:11 DarkPlasmaBall wrote:
On June 14 2011 05:02 JustTray wrote:
On June 14 2011 04:51 DarkPlasmaBall wrote:
On June 13 2011 12:12 jsdk wrote:
I think what bothers me the most is their mentality of "we'll fix balance in the expansion." I seem to remember a community manager saying that he couldn't believe that people would think that they would have an imbalanced game until an expansion was released. He wrongly thought Blizzard was still the same company.

The problem with that is that they can't know exactly what's imbalanced (or not) unless they openly communicate to the pros, instead of telling them to wait a year for some magical fix that might happen. And then guess what? Not everything is fixed because they keep shrugging people off, and then "wait until the next expansion..." Fantastic.


I think what bothers me the most is that people whine about Blizzard when they don't care to pay attention to what Blizzard has actually been doing.

They don't put off fixing balance. They have been fixing balance. The statistics show that the game has been getting more and more balanced.

Furthermore, they've been talking to pros, looking at forums, looking at their own statistics, and playing the game themselves, ever since the beta.

They've been using every possible form of input and feedback available, which is why the game is very, very close to balanced at the moment.


Also slightly off topic, but relevant to your post. I've played Dayvie in 2v2 RT vs AT ladder about a dozen times in the last couple months. Every single time I've been an random team vs his arranged team. I had an ally, who I got matched with vs them 6 times in a row leave the game at the start every single time.

David Kim's response to this clearly broken RT vs AT mechanic that gave him 6 free wins? I quote, "Your MMR is too high."

That was the top balance designer's actual comment in game as to why the matchmaking was partnering me with a random teamate who quit the game over and over vs an incredibly highly skilled 2v2 arranged team that designs the game.

If that doesn't sum up Blizzard's absolute ineptitude, I don't know what can.

Edit - In case anyone thinks I'm making it up, his partner is and has always been Slayers_BekHo, they play and they play PT occasionally.


It's your ally's fault for leaving the game, not David Kim's fault for having a partner. If you don't like the fact that Random Teams puts you with a Random Teammate who might leave at any moment, then don't play Random Teams -.-' Duh. Get a friend.

I can't believe you'd blame Blizzard for the fact that your partner left the game because he was intimidated by the opponents. How ridiculous. That's what happens when you play on a Random Team. You run the risk of playing with a dumb ally. Or you run the risk of playing with a totally kick-ass ally. That's why it's called Random Teams.


It is not a logical solution to say that RT is imbalanced therefore you have to not play it. The logical solution is not to "not play RT," but to not match RT vs AT. The risk of playing with a crappy ally is EXACTLY why AT should never match with RT, you simply don't have that risk, and there's no amount of handicapped points you can implement that will balance RT vs AT out.

You guys shows Blizzard's flawed logic perfectly. Instead of addressing the actual issues, they let their pride get in the way and assume everything is correct, when in practice, you can see, (most recently represented by the RT vs AT issue I brought up, but also many, many balance/map issues) that there are significant issues that are being ignored.


Right. Because Arranged Teams are never between two people of different leagues -.-' Two friends who happen to be master and silver level will never play together, and there's never a chance that one person in an AT may have to leave.

Arranged Teams can have crappy allies too. Get over it.

Anyways, I'm out for now. Enjoy your day
"There is nothing more satisfying than looking at a crowd of people and helping them get what I love." ~Day[9] Daily #100
karpo
Profile Joined October 2010
Sweden1998 Posts
June 13 2011 20:27 GMT
#614
On June 14 2011 05:23 Nakas wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 14 2011 05:14 karpo wrote:
On June 14 2011 05:11 Nakas wrote:
On June 14 2011 04:23 karpo wrote:
On June 14 2011 04:14 Two_DoWn wrote:
On June 14 2011 02:48 Seide wrote:
When Browder mentions that "uncertainty" when going into battles and mentions he liked that "there are things someone can do to swing the battle", I have to disagree, that because of how strong aoe is and how units clump, it actually takes away from this uncertainty, as units simply die too quick for someone to do those things that can swing the battle.

Uncertainty was how well you could psi storm, dodge emps, put clumps of tanks in stasis, and all across 2 or 3 screens of units. Now its just "let me slam my ball into yours and see who wins." The only uncertainty is because you cant actually tell how many units there are in a given space because all balls look the same. Uncertainty is good when it derives from micro. Its shit when it comes from visual misrepresentation.


Let me slam my ball into your and see who wins might be true in regular low rank ladder matches. It's not really true in actual high end tournaments. Why to people so often resort to hyperbole and exaggerations when they want to argue a point on these forums?


The TSL4 finals wasn't high-level? Many of those games in that final PvT match could be summed up with the phrase "let me slam my ball into yours and see who wins."


What game did that. I remember seing two contains, one blink stalker rush and a epic hold by Thorzain. Last game was alot of positioning and had great EMP's etc.


The final game for 15k was basically decided by two balls colliding into each other.


It was decided by Naniwa losing focus and getting his sentries EMP'ed time and again.
karpo
Profile Joined October 2010
Sweden1998 Posts
June 13 2011 20:29 GMT
#615
On June 14 2011 05:20 JustTray wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 14 2011 05:11 DarkPlasmaBall wrote:
On June 14 2011 05:02 JustTray wrote:
On June 14 2011 04:51 DarkPlasmaBall wrote:
On June 13 2011 12:12 jsdk wrote:
I think what bothers me the most is their mentality of "we'll fix balance in the expansion." I seem to remember a community manager saying that he couldn't believe that people would think that they would have an imbalanced game until an expansion was released. He wrongly thought Blizzard was still the same company.

The problem with that is that they can't know exactly what's imbalanced (or not) unless they openly communicate to the pros, instead of telling them to wait a year for some magical fix that might happen. And then guess what? Not everything is fixed because they keep shrugging people off, and then "wait until the next expansion..." Fantastic.


I think what bothers me the most is that people whine about Blizzard when they don't care to pay attention to what Blizzard has actually been doing.

They don't put off fixing balance. They have been fixing balance. The statistics show that the game has been getting more and more balanced.

Furthermore, they've been talking to pros, looking at forums, looking at their own statistics, and playing the game themselves, ever since the beta.

They've been using every possible form of input and feedback available, which is why the game is very, very close to balanced at the moment.


Also slightly off topic, but relevant to your post. I've played Dayvie in 2v2 RT vs AT ladder about a dozen times in the last couple months. Every single time I've been an random team vs his arranged team. I had an ally, who I got matched with vs them 6 times in a row leave the game at the start every single time.

David Kim's response to this clearly broken RT vs AT mechanic that gave him 6 free wins? I quote, "Your MMR is too high."

That was the top balance designer's actual comment in game as to why the matchmaking was partnering me with a random teamate who quit the game over and over vs an incredibly highly skilled 2v2 arranged team that designs the game.

If that doesn't sum up Blizzard's absolute ineptitude, I don't know what can.

Edit - In case anyone thinks I'm making it up, his partner is and has always been Slayers_BekHo, they play and they play PT occasionally.


It's your ally's fault for leaving the game, not David Kim's fault for having a partner. If you don't like the fact that Random Teams puts you with a Random Teammate who might leave at any moment, then don't play Random Teams -.-' Duh. Get a friend.

I can't believe you'd blame Blizzard for the fact that your partner left the game because he was intimidated by the opponents. How ridiculous. That's what happens when you play on a Random Team. You run the risk of playing with a dumb ally. Or you run the risk of playing with a totally kick-ass ally. That's why it's called Random Teams.


It is not a logical solution to say that RT is imbalanced therefore you have to not play it. The logical solution is not to "not play RT," but to not match RT vs AT. The risk of playing with a crappy ally is EXACTLY why AT should never match with RT, you simply don't have that risk, and there's no amount of handicapped points you can implement that will balance RT vs AT out.

You guys shows Blizzard's flawed logic perfectly. Instead of addressing the actual issues, they let their pride get in the way and assume everything is correct, when in practice, you can see, (most recently represented by the RT vs AT issue I brought up, but also many, many balance/map issues) that there are significant issues that are being ignored.


And you assume you are correct and that they don't know what they're doing. Maybe they match AT vs RT because queues would be horrible and they'd have to match alot less evenly matched people against eachother that way?
JustTray
Profile Joined May 2011
127 Posts
June 13 2011 20:32 GMT
#616
On June 14 2011 05:23 Persev wrote:
The reply "your mmr is to high" probably means that when you have become so good at random teams your mmr places you vs top set teams. Its a chance to test your communication skills , micro, maco, unit integration vs top teams. Its a very good sign that you can be paired up vs set teams because it means your very skilled. The fact that your paired up vs set teams doenst' mean the game is imbalanced. It means your a good player with solid team skills and you've hit a ceiling and further improvement is only vs set arranged teams. Right?

As for the quitting you know this old saying is true:" Quitters can't win. Winners don't quit." You saw that over and over in the MLG games. There is no such thing as a free win. You saw MMA killing his own CC and you saw Idra leave when the game was his. Unless your faced with an A+ hacker leaving at the start of the game is just fulfilling your own negativity.

Theres also something called pretense of knowledge syndrome. We are suffer from it. We think we know something but in actually its quite different from what we think we see. I will say that the match making system is a huge black box to me. I would rage hard when I used to get a Gold partner vs top teams. It was utter disaster so I have empathy with what your feeling. The flip side of the coin is you have the chance to rise to the occasion and come up with ways to improve to even exceed set teams.

Show nested quote +
On June 14 2011 05:02 JustTray wrote:
On June 14 2011 04:51 DarkPlasmaBall wrote:
On June 13 2011 12:12 jsdk wrote:
I think what bothers me the most is their mentality of "we'll fix balance in the expansion." I seem to remember a community manager saying that he couldn't believe that people would think that they would have an imbalanced game until an expansion was released. He wrongly thought Blizzard was still the same company.

The problem with that is that they can't know exactly what's imbalanced (or not) unless they openly communicate to the pros, instead of telling them to wait a year for some magical fix that might happen. And then guess what? Not everything is fixed because they keep shrugging people off, and then "wait until the next expansion..." Fantastic.


I think what bothers me the most is that people whine about Blizzard when they don't care to pay attention to what Blizzard has actually been doing.

They don't put off fixing balance. They have been fixing balance. The statistics show that the game has been getting more and more balanced.

Furthermore, they've been talking to pros, looking at forums, looking at their own statistics, and playing the game themselves, ever since the beta.

They've been using every possible form of input and feedback available, which is why the game is very, very close to balanced at the moment.


Also slightly off topic, but relevant to your post. I've played Dayvie in 2v2 RT vs AT ladder about a dozen times in the last couple months. Every single time I've been an random team vs his arranged team. I had an ally, who I got matched with vs them 6 times in a row leave the game at the start every single time.

David Kim's response to this clearly broken RT vs AT mechanic that gave him 6 free wins? I quote, "Your MMR is too high."

That was the top balance designer's actual comment in game as to why the matchmaking was partnering me with a random teamate who quit the game over and over vs an incredibly highly skilled 2v2 arranged team that designs the game.

If that doesn't sum up Blizzard's absolute ineptitude, I don't know what can.

Edit - In case anyone thinks I'm making it up, his partner is and has always been Slayers_BekHo, they play and they play PT occasionally.




I understand you're trying to be diplomatic, and I respect that. However, I play vs the #1 teams in the world frequently. I've beaten Protech and Power two out of the last 3 times, and I believe they're at about a 85% win rate.

My point, which you bring up, is that there is no "challenge" in the way RT pairs vs AT. It comes down to one simple thing, is your random teamate a master level 1v1 player or not. If he is not, auto lose vs coordinated team. If he/she is, likely easy victory.

Sadly the meta game for RT vs AT does boil down that simply. You say it's a challenge, I say it's a ridiculously unfair system that is broken based on the fact that the system tries to make your win rate 50% even in team games where we have RT vs AT ALL THE TIME. The issue is that the AT gets a shared MMR for each player, while that's being compared to the AVERAGE of the random team.

So if my MMR is 1500, my opponent AT is 1250, the game is going to pair me with a 1000 MMR noob to balance the match out. Turns out though that the AT was recently formed of masters players and thus has not achieved their final MMR, so they're vastly superior in combined skill to my team.

I really don't know how to present it anymore simply. The fact that even the lead game balancer cannot acknowledge this broken system is once again evidence that Blizzard is out of touch with the game, IE the point of the thread.
Giantt
Profile Joined December 2010
Bulgaria82 Posts
June 13 2011 20:34 GMT
#617
As previously mentioned - win % cannot be considered a benchmark since the battle.net matchmaking system is designed to keep you at ~50%

A comment about the "uninteresting units":
1.As a Zerg player I feel that the roach has the characteristics of a non-zerg unit that has been added in an attempt to give a proper t1 defence unit.
Speed & Burrow movement makes it a bit interesting but still... I feel like with a bit more defence capability to queens and some move speed/hp boost to hydras, maybe giving them the speed and burrow upgrades - roaches could be dumped.
Another point I have is that you cannot have hydras without roaches in most of the cases - feels like hydras got their stats cut because you are supposed to have roaches in front (Voted 1st place)

2. Corruptor is 2nd place.
That unit, that is supposed to dominate the sky for Zerg fails to serve its purpose - limited as it is.

3.Collosus 3rd place
Collo + force fields kills all ground(but terran mech maybe) extremely efficiently for little micro required.
karpo
Profile Joined October 2010
Sweden1998 Posts
June 13 2011 20:35 GMT
#618
On June 14 2011 05:32 JustTray wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 14 2011 05:23 Persev wrote:
The reply "your mmr is to high" probably means that when you have become so good at random teams your mmr places you vs top set teams. Its a chance to test your communication skills , micro, maco, unit integration vs top teams. Its a very good sign that you can be paired up vs set teams because it means your very skilled. The fact that your paired up vs set teams doenst' mean the game is imbalanced. It means your a good player with solid team skills and you've hit a ceiling and further improvement is only vs set arranged teams. Right?

As for the quitting you know this old saying is true:" Quitters can't win. Winners don't quit." You saw that over and over in the MLG games. There is no such thing as a free win. You saw MMA killing his own CC and you saw Idra leave when the game was his. Unless your faced with an A+ hacker leaving at the start of the game is just fulfilling your own negativity.

Theres also something called pretense of knowledge syndrome. We are suffer from it. We think we know something but in actually its quite different from what we think we see. I will say that the match making system is a huge black box to me. I would rage hard when I used to get a Gold partner vs top teams. It was utter disaster so I have empathy with what your feeling. The flip side of the coin is you have the chance to rise to the occasion and come up with ways to improve to even exceed set teams.

On June 14 2011 05:02 JustTray wrote:
On June 14 2011 04:51 DarkPlasmaBall wrote:
On June 13 2011 12:12 jsdk wrote:
I think what bothers me the most is their mentality of "we'll fix balance in the expansion." I seem to remember a community manager saying that he couldn't believe that people would think that they would have an imbalanced game until an expansion was released. He wrongly thought Blizzard was still the same company.

The problem with that is that they can't know exactly what's imbalanced (or not) unless they openly communicate to the pros, instead of telling them to wait a year for some magical fix that might happen. And then guess what? Not everything is fixed because they keep shrugging people off, and then "wait until the next expansion..." Fantastic.


I think what bothers me the most is that people whine about Blizzard when they don't care to pay attention to what Blizzard has actually been doing.

They don't put off fixing balance. They have been fixing balance. The statistics show that the game has been getting more and more balanced.

Furthermore, they've been talking to pros, looking at forums, looking at their own statistics, and playing the game themselves, ever since the beta.

They've been using every possible form of input and feedback available, which is why the game is very, very close to balanced at the moment.


Also slightly off topic, but relevant to your post. I've played Dayvie in 2v2 RT vs AT ladder about a dozen times in the last couple months. Every single time I've been an random team vs his arranged team. I had an ally, who I got matched with vs them 6 times in a row leave the game at the start every single time.

David Kim's response to this clearly broken RT vs AT mechanic that gave him 6 free wins? I quote, "Your MMR is too high."

That was the top balance designer's actual comment in game as to why the matchmaking was partnering me with a random teamate who quit the game over and over vs an incredibly highly skilled 2v2 arranged team that designs the game.

If that doesn't sum up Blizzard's absolute ineptitude, I don't know what can.

Edit - In case anyone thinks I'm making it up, his partner is and has always been Slayers_BekHo, they play and they play PT occasionally.




I understand you're trying to be diplomatic, and I respect that. However, I play vs the #1 teams in the world frequently. I've beaten Protech and Power two out of the last 3 times, and I believe they're at about a 85% win rate.

My point, which you bring up, is that there is no "challenge" in the way RT pairs vs AT. It comes down to one simple thing, is your random teamate a master level 1v1 player or not. If he is not, auto lose vs coordinated team. If he/she is, likely easy victory.

Sadly the meta game for RT vs AT does boil down that simply. You say it's a challenge, I say it's a ridiculously unfair system that is broken based on the fact that the system tries to make your win rate 50% even in team games where we have RT vs AT ALL THE TIME. The issue is that the AT gets a shared MMR for each player, while that's being compared to the AVERAGE of the random team.

So if my MMR is 1500, my opponent AT is 1250, the game is going to pair me with a 1000 MMR noob to balance the match out. Turns out though that the AT was recently formed of masters players and thus has not achieved their final MMR, so they're vastly superior in combined skill to my team.

I really don't know how to present it anymore simply. The fact that even the lead game balancer cannot acknowledge this broken system is once again evidence that Blizzard is out of touch with the game, IE the point of the thread.


What should they do then? There's obviously a reason they keep RT vs AT in. Maybe it's cause the pool of players and their spread would be thin and finding good matchups would be even harder with the change? Do you know if that's the case?
Roxy
Profile Joined November 2010
Canada753 Posts
June 13 2011 20:38 GMT
#619
Sure.. the ladder results in win rates of about 50% for every race

That does not mean the game is balanced, that means that the ladder is working as intended

Judging balance based on the results of ladder wins or losses is not a viable method for measuring balance because it does not take skill into consideration.



http://sc2ranks.com/us/941824/Roxy - Masters Protoss: "Respect my authoritai"
JustTray
Profile Joined May 2011
127 Posts
June 13 2011 20:42 GMT
#620
On June 14 2011 05:29 karpo wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 14 2011 05:20 JustTray wrote:
On June 14 2011 05:11 DarkPlasmaBall wrote:
On June 14 2011 05:02 JustTray wrote:
On June 14 2011 04:51 DarkPlasmaBall wrote:
On June 13 2011 12:12 jsdk wrote:
I think what bothers me the most is their mentality of "we'll fix balance in the expansion." I seem to remember a community manager saying that he couldn't believe that people would think that they would have an imbalanced game until an expansion was released. He wrongly thought Blizzard was still the same company.

The problem with that is that they can't know exactly what's imbalanced (or not) unless they openly communicate to the pros, instead of telling them to wait a year for some magical fix that might happen. And then guess what? Not everything is fixed because they keep shrugging people off, and then "wait until the next expansion..." Fantastic.


I think what bothers me the most is that people whine about Blizzard when they don't care to pay attention to what Blizzard has actually been doing.

They don't put off fixing balance. They have been fixing balance. The statistics show that the game has been getting more and more balanced.

Furthermore, they've been talking to pros, looking at forums, looking at their own statistics, and playing the game themselves, ever since the beta.

They've been using every possible form of input and feedback available, which is why the game is very, very close to balanced at the moment.


Also slightly off topic, but relevant to your post. I've played Dayvie in 2v2 RT vs AT ladder about a dozen times in the last couple months. Every single time I've been an random team vs his arranged team. I had an ally, who I got matched with vs them 6 times in a row leave the game at the start every single time.

David Kim's response to this clearly broken RT vs AT mechanic that gave him 6 free wins? I quote, "Your MMR is too high."

That was the top balance designer's actual comment in game as to why the matchmaking was partnering me with a random teamate who quit the game over and over vs an incredibly highly skilled 2v2 arranged team that designs the game.

If that doesn't sum up Blizzard's absolute ineptitude, I don't know what can.

Edit - In case anyone thinks I'm making it up, his partner is and has always been Slayers_BekHo, they play and they play PT occasionally.


It's your ally's fault for leaving the game, not David Kim's fault for having a partner. If you don't like the fact that Random Teams puts you with a Random Teammate who might leave at any moment, then don't play Random Teams -.-' Duh. Get a friend.

I can't believe you'd blame Blizzard for the fact that your partner left the game because he was intimidated by the opponents. How ridiculous. That's what happens when you play on a Random Team. You run the risk of playing with a dumb ally. Or you run the risk of playing with a totally kick-ass ally. That's why it's called Random Teams.


It is not a logical solution to say that RT is imbalanced therefore you have to not play it. The logical solution is not to "not play RT," but to not match RT vs AT. The risk of playing with a crappy ally is EXACTLY why AT should never match with RT, you simply don't have that risk, and there's no amount of handicapped points you can implement that will balance RT vs AT out.

You guys shows Blizzard's flawed logic perfectly. Instead of addressing the actual issues, they let their pride get in the way and assume everything is correct, when in practice, you can see, (most recently represented by the RT vs AT issue I brought up, but also many, many balance/map issues) that there are significant issues that are being ignored.


And you assume you are correct and that they don't know what they're doing. Maybe they match AT vs RT because queues would be horrible and they'd have to match alot less evenly matched people against eachother that way?



I don't assume anything. My information is based on fact. Read excaliber's post about MMR and matchmaking. That is exactly how it works and is supported by David Kim's message about my MMR being too high, forcing me vs Arranged Teams with subpar teamates.

If the queues were really a problem, then they would/should post that information to the community to support their reasoning. In fact, the only support they've ever given was a completely illogical post stating that because AT and RT have different ladders, the fact that they play against eachother is irrelevant, which is demonstrably false, given that if an Arranged Team played nothing but Random Teams, and another Arranged Team played nothing but Arranged Teams, you would expect the one vs the RT to do better, and appear to be more skilled based on the inherent flaws with RT vs AT I listed and others.

Again, it all comes back to community communication and addressing the issues the community presents. While many may in fact be unfounded, they do not go away until addressed. Additionally, I will add that the community does in fact call many of the nerfs that go into play. Most recently the stim nerfs, infestor minor nerfs, warp gate nerfs, etc all called for by the community. Void ray nerfs, reaper nerfs, roach nerfs, also all requested by the community in the past, and have been balanced for 1v1 and teams.

So since this is my last post - Blizzard, show ALL the data. Statistics can show anything Blizzard wants them to. Without the raw data, the community cannot be expected to assume anything Blizzard says is supported by evidence. Another example is High Templar pre warp in storm vs Infestors. Blizzard told us Storms were far too powerful, dealing too much damage. Well, infestors are more devistating now in AOE and support than storms ever were, and yet, there has been zero data about the amount of damage infestors are dealing per cost. My guess as to why is that if we saw the data, we would see that infestors have nearly identically taken the role that the OP templar previously held, and yet we've gone weeks without a significant nerf.

Show us all the data. Let the community be informed and you won't have this perception about blizzard.
Prev 1 29 30 31 32 33 Next All
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
Next event in 2h 19m
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
ProTech152
SortOf 139
StarCraft: Brood War
Calm 2093
Bisu 402
Hyuk 271
ToSsGirL 212
Soulkey 140
Snow 34
ZergMaN 23
Noble 19
Larva 9
sOs 9
[ Show more ]
Force[name] 7
League of Legends
JimRising 825
Super Smash Bros
Mew2King71
Heroes of the Storm
Trikslyr45
Other Games
summit1g12328
WinterStarcraft616
ceh9303
C9.Mang0245
Happy232
ViBE60
Organizations
Other Games
gamesdonequick588
[ Show 10 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Dota 2
• lizZardDota2218
League of Legends
• Rush1431
Upcoming Events
The PondCast
2h 19m
University League
2h 19m
LiuLi Cup
3h 19m
Rogue vs TBD
Maru vs TBD
OSC
8h 19m
Replay Cast
15h 19m
GSL
1d 3h
Maru vs Dark
Patches Events
1d 6h
OSC
1d 8h
Replay Cast
1d 15h
KCM Race Survival
2 days
[ Show More ]
Ultimate Battle
2 days
ZerO vs Bisu
RSL Revival
3 days
BSL
3 days
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
4 days
IPSL
4 days
Ret vs ggnore13
nOmaD vs Aether
BSL
4 days
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
4 days
WardiTV Weekly
5 days
Kung Fu Cup
6 days
Solar vs Classic
ByuN vs SHIN
PiGosaur Cup
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Proleague 2026-11-16
Blizzard Classic Cup 2026
HCC Season 3

Ongoing

Acropolis #5
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
International ShieldBattery League
BSL Season 23
IPSL Winter 2026-27
Calamity Cup Div. A Season 8
Underdog Cup 2026 Div 2-3
Stake Ranked Episode 6
BLAST Rivals Fall 2026
IEM Beijing 2026
PGL Masters Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 5
1win Private Club #2
Thunderpick World Champ. '26
ESL Pro League Season 24
Stake Ranked Episode 4
1win Private Club #1
Logitech G Play Connect 2026
SL StarSeries Fall 2026
FISSURE Playground #3
BLAST Open Fall 2026

Upcoming

Sector 591
YSL S4
SC4ALL II: Brood War
NBSL 2026 Xiamen LAN
BSL 23: Non-Korean Championship
HSC XXX
Stellar Fest 2: Lunar Cup
StarCraft2 Weekly Open Tournament 2026 Grand Finals
SC4ALL II: StarCraft II
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
RSL Offline Finals
IEM Kraków 2027
PGL Bucharest 2027
BLAST Bounty Winter 2027
PGL Major Singapore 2026
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.