|
On October 08 2010 12:29 mrfatbush wrote: Does anyone think if lost temple or blistering sands were invented just now EVERYONE would be outrated.
"wtf theres a cliff next to my nat?" "wtf theres a second entrance to my main?"
Or am I missing something crucial which makes this map so much worse than LT or BS
While LT and BS are fun maps, they are hardly "balanced" in terms of TL's thinking. What they want is Proleague Kespa maps where there are no way to tank or exploit undesirable things.
While these new maps seems fun, it'd be nice if blizzard does some extensive testing and release maps that are actually "balanced" as well as fun maps, as maps contribute significantly to racial balance as well.
|
On October 08 2010 12:29 mrfatbush wrote: Does anyone think if lost temple or blistering sands were invented just now EVERYONE would be outrated.
"wtf theres a cliff next to my nat?" "wtf theres a second entrance to my main?"
Or am I missing something crucial which makes this map so much worse than LT or BS
pretty sure when they were first shown during beta. people did whine.
especially about lost temple. i mean they made that map 10 years ago with the same abuseable cliff. ten years later they still havent learned.
|
|
|
On October 07 2010 20:16 dogabutila wrote: I almost feel like the map would work better without the rocks.
if only i could thumbs up posts i swear blizzard add in destructable rocks and assume all play around those rocks is null and void untill the rocks die
|
I havent had a chance to play this map yet, what do you guys think? As a zerg player is it "zerg friendly?"
|
Impossible to hold your 3rd. At the watch towers... seriously, those chokes. Who the hell designed them? It's rediculous as Z. Remove the whole cliffs between the xelnaga towers in the middle so you can actually surround.
|
On October 10 2010 05:20 KaiserJohan wrote: Impossible to hold your 3rd. At the watch towers... seriously, those chokes. Who the hell designed them? It's rediculous as Z. Remove the whole cliffs between the xelnaga towers in the middle so you can actually surround.
agree. would make the map much better.
also its an allin-every-game-map in pvp which sucks. no chance for a macro game there ...
|
It's not my favorite due to the small size but the internal natural is pretty nice.
I see the rock door as primarily beneficial to zerg since the long route around isn't a problem for zerg defense but it's nice for ling/bling shenanigans.
|
By far the worst ladder map from my point of view, there's a good reason why it was available at release but not in the initial ladder pool. It's a really bad map. Your natural is quite easy to take, but if you do you still lose to aggressive 1-base play because your natural is really open if your opponent destroys the destructible rocks. On the other hand it's a BAD macro map, because your 3rd is almost impossible to take safely, while the map itself is really small.
For me it's almost as bad as Incineration Zone. Actually, the more I think about it, i liked Incineration Zone more, because it actually resulted in some pretty nice games and it had a nice tileset, although it was imbalanced. Jungle Basin just rewards stupid 1-base timing pushes and is horribly designed.
|
On October 07 2010 15:53 mOnion wrote:Show nested quote +On October 07 2010 14:50 Obsolescence wrote:On October 07 2010 14:35 mOnion wrote: this got old fast. honestly there going to be places like this on every map but what makes the position strong is
1) its ability to be reinforced 2) the path your opponent must take to get to you
and none of these are significant really. Dear Mr. mOnion, Please, find 2 examples of any other ladder map where you can nuke your opponents main without walking up his ramp or dropping on his plateau. I ask for 2 because on Xel'Naga I believe you can partially nuke their mineral line, but you must walk through their natural to do so. With exception to the other new map obviously. Also, please, find just 1 example of another ladder map where you can siege tank deny your opponents gas at their natural from behind the protection of destructible rocks. With exception to the other new map obviously. If you can find these scenarios in other maps I'll happily concede that this is nothing special. besides the fact that the guy above me provided a couple examples, my point is still valid regardless. just because you set the parameters to the 2 things listed doesn't mean there aren't other similar things in other maps. 1) steppes you can hit opps nat from low ground and position is easily reinforced 2) metal you can hit opps gold from xelnaga towers 3) LT you can hit opps nat from high ground these are things you would've found in ur little analysis and all i'm saying is that it was cute the first time but every map is going to have places where a single tank can hit something important. its not a big deal unless its supplemented by the 2 reasons i initially listed
Exactly all 3 of these things fit his 2 reasons while the ones here the op don't fit it all the time.
The rush distance on steps is soooo short that even though their are no "Rocks" even slowass thors and tanks can reinforce in a timely manner. While your opponent must walk down a large ramp and then move towards a concave of tanks.
On meta hitting the gold from the tower is easily reinforced especially if you hold the other gold or if your main base is one of the plateaus nearby. Your opponent has to walk down a large ramp then move towards the tanks already shelling at you into a concave.
LT enough said there even thors can hit you and about the route your opponent must take... O yea there isn't one without drop or air.
Here with siegeing the main is so much different then maps like step because the travel distance is longer its harder to reinforce. And as far as the rocks go protecting the tank at the natural if you are worried about that then kill them. Thats what tended to happen on KR the rocks to get onto the raised ground by the natural were targeted pretty fast by zerg players so if tanks, reapers, or what not got up there the zerg would be able to attack them.
But isn't all this sarcasm for the OP unnecessary , I mean yes it is important to let blizzard know but in all honesty right before desert oasis was removed from the ladder they changed the map to make that one cliff further away from the gas in the main. I would expect the same thing to happen here eventually. That in itself to me is proof enough that blizzard will attempt to fix small things with their maps to make them better. (Note I said Better not balanced)
|
On October 08 2010 12:42 TyrantPotato wrote:Show nested quote +On October 08 2010 12:29 mrfatbush wrote: Does anyone think if lost temple or blistering sands were invented just now EVERYONE would be outrated.
"wtf theres a cliff next to my nat?" "wtf theres a second entrance to my main?"
Or am I missing something crucial which makes this map so much worse than LT or BS pretty sure when they were first shown during beta. people did whine. especially about lost temple. i mean they made that map 10 years ago with the same abuseable cliff. ten years later they still havent learned.
You ever think they WANT those abusable cliffs to be there?
|
|
|
United Kingdom12071 Posts
On October 10 2010 07:21 kojinshugi wrote:Show nested quote +On October 08 2010 12:42 TyrantPotato wrote:On October 08 2010 12:29 mrfatbush wrote: Does anyone think if lost temple or blistering sands were invented just now EVERYONE would be outrated.
"wtf theres a cliff next to my nat?" "wtf theres a second entrance to my main?"
Or am I missing something crucial which makes this map so much worse than LT or BS pretty sure when they were first shown during beta. people did whine. especially about lost temple. i mean they made that map 10 years ago with the same abuseable cliff. ten years later they still havent learned. You ever think they WANT those abusable cliffs to be there?
It's a map gimmick, I think maps would be boring if there were no gimmicks like it to be fair, and I never even really abuse the cliff most of the time, it's just something to add into the playbook really.
It's like maps where you can warp things over a gap by just having a pylon, it's just something you really have to look out for IMO.
|
Most of the people in this thread sound like they only played python in BW
|
On October 10 2010 05:08 Angelbelow wrote: I havent had a chance to play this map yet, what do you guys think? As a zerg player is it "zerg friendly?" As Kaiserjohn said - it's awful. Small chokes, narrow spaces and cliffs everywhere - there is not one place on this map where its possible to position a Z army even remotly useful. Instead it's absolutly fantastic for Collossi/Tank/Thor and drop play. In addition T/P have it extremly easy to take a second base but it's nearly impossible to secure a third as Z.
Kulas was a horrible map as well - but instead of learning something from their mistakes they made another map that's unplayable for one of the three races. I really don't get the decision to make this a ladder map.
|
Australia549 Posts
On October 10 2010 05:08 Angelbelow wrote: I havent had a chance to play this map yet, what do you guys think? As a zerg player is it "zerg friendly?"
This map makes Kulas look zerg friendly.
|
this map remind anyone else of carthage?
|
Oh boy. Where do I start.
As zerg, this map is terrible. Yes you can take your natural safely but guess what, terran and protoss can too. On top of that they can wall off and be safe from agression even if they take that natural.
Then there is the rocks in the back of the natural, which coincidently are en route to your third. Now protoss can go in via the natural and forcefield that ramp that links your nat to your main. Then after that it can forcefield that ramp again to lock your forces in.
You always expand TOWARDS your opponent. Thus its impossible to withstand any agression unless your army is there, which means they can easily abuse drops.
The middle area is a high ground. Which coincidently features two expansions. Terran blocks off the ramp on your side and now he has a big guardtower for the entire middle of the map. Effectively oblitterating everything from a safe distance. While being able to take those middle expansions.
Everything beside the main is a choke.
If you're zerg. Downvote this map ASAP. Its like a mix of kulas and steppes of war. With a hint of incineration zone.
|
I'm zerg, but I find the map interesting because it looks very good for burrow ambushes.
All the tight chokes make it easy to predict where the terran ball will mass, so baneling burrow, and Fungal growth will be more effective than usual.
In addition, a quick creep spread out to the ramp and a few roaches will stop most T harassment, allowing you to pump drones off 2 base, which will benefit the zerg more than say... a fast expanding terran or protoss.
There is a window where a 2 base zerg can outproduce a 2 base protoss/terran, because of the nature of the hatchery. T/P have to also spend more minerals on gateways/rax, so they will be behind for a length of time.
|
On October 11 2010 03:31 Chaosvuistje wrote: If you're zerg. Downvote this map ASAP. Its like a mix of kulas and steppes of war. With a hint of incineration zone. I agree.
On October 12 2010 03:57 Johnny_Vegas wrote: There is a window where a 2 base zerg can outproduce a 2 base protoss/terran, because of the nature of the hatchery. T/P have to also spend more minerals on gateways/rax, so they will be behind for a length of time. While this is true, Zerg typically also need to outproduce T and P at a later stage of the game so they can use their higher tech to assault the enemy base. The units you get when you just need two bases aren't very good at breaking into the enemy fortifications, where the tight chokes work greatly against us. Most importantly, their nat is extremely safe on this map, requiring you to break down a set of rocks before you can even send in lings, and even then you have to funnel through a choke.
What this means is that often times you'll be stuck on a 2base vs 2base scenario for a long time, with the Terran and Protoss pouring on pressure from their two bases at your ramp and at the rocks (which they can break much easier). Ultimately they can even use their map control to secure a third, while they slowly starve you out.
|
|
|
|
|
|