|
and lurkers arnt important..... Take out the only accessible siege unit the zerg has and replace it with a range 0 1 time use only unit :-/
Really the biggest problem is that it isn't hard to tank the nat from behind rocks. But it will be almost impossible to move them out of there unless you have air units and they have no AA.
I'm not a fan of trying to kill rocks while tanks are shooting at me :-/
|
I'm so glad I switched from zerg.
|
On October 07 2010 14:34 FinestHour wrote: is there somewhere maybe in the sc2 credits that has the names of the map developers for the game? i might have to mail them some packages with some surprises inside
rofl, you guna send them some intelligence?
|
|
|
On October 07 2010 14:50 Obsolescence wrote:Show nested quote +On October 07 2010 14:35 mOnion wrote: this got old fast. honestly there going to be places like this on every map but what makes the position strong is
1) its ability to be reinforced 2) the path your opponent must take to get to you
and none of these are significant really. Dear Mr. mOnion, Please, find 2 examples of any other ladder map where you can nuke your opponents main without walking up his ramp or dropping on his plateau. I ask for 2 because on Xel'Naga I believe you can partially nuke their mineral line, but you must walk through their natural to do so. With exception to the other new map obviously. Also, please, find just 1 example of another ladder map where you can siege tank deny your opponents gas at their natural from behind the protection of destructible rocks. With exception to the other new map obviously. If you can find these scenarios in other maps I'll happily concede that this is nothing special.
besides the fact that the guy above me provided a couple examples, my point is still valid regardless.
just because you set the parameters to the 2 things listed doesn't mean there aren't other similar things in other maps.
1) steppes you can hit opps nat from low ground and position is easily reinforced 2) metal you can hit opps gold from xelnaga towers 3) LT you can hit opps nat from high ground
these are things you would've found in ur little analysis and all i'm saying is that it was cute the first time but every map is going to have places where a single tank can hit something important. its not a big deal unless its supplemented by the 2 reasons i initially listed
|
Well this map will particularly difficult for Zerg. Oh yay.
Siege tank marine timing pushes are going to be so hard to deal with. Maybe taking down rocks to begin with, before any timing windows for mineral line harass starts? At least to delay until mutas are out. Which are only going to be useful to gain minimal map control.
3 Well placed turrets should shut down any muta harass. Forget getting into the main mineral line.
And to top it off I'm already imagining a high ground planetary fortress third expo in the center. Going to be virtually impossible to take down. A couple well placed seige tanks and the nice small chokes in between the high-ground expo. rofl...
|
lol, i just love the smiley faces - wish i could nuke someone's main and that face would appear :D
but i dont play T so i cant nuke anything
|
wait. I thought they nerfed siege tanks because they thought they were too good against light units, so now they add maps where tanks can target light units from relative safety? Why nerf em at all if they can just attack the mineral line with no consequence...
In other news, just played the map a bit to test it out, and it is a pretty cool map, I like the blistering sands-esque walling tight the main and breaking the back door rocks when its time to move out, and it seemed to work just like it did on BS, but better because the building wall is on the high ground!
|
15 nex PvZ, finally a map where you can just do it any game. <3
|
On October 07 2010 15:53 mOnion wrote:Show nested quote +On October 07 2010 14:50 Obsolescence wrote:On October 07 2010 14:35 mOnion wrote: this got old fast. honestly there going to be places like this on every map but what makes the position strong is
1) its ability to be reinforced 2) the path your opponent must take to get to you
and none of these are significant really. Dear Mr. mOnion, Please, find 2 examples of any other ladder map where you can nuke your opponents main without walking up his ramp or dropping on his plateau. I ask for 2 because on Xel'Naga I believe you can partially nuke their mineral line, but you must walk through their natural to do so. With exception to the other new map obviously. Also, please, find just 1 example of another ladder map where you can siege tank deny your opponents gas at their natural from behind the protection of destructible rocks. With exception to the other new map obviously. If you can find these scenarios in other maps I'll happily concede that this is nothing special. besides the fact that the guy above me provided a couple examples, my point is still valid regardless. just because you set the parameters to the 2 things listed doesn't mean there aren't other similar things in other maps. 1) steppes you can hit opps nat from low ground and position is easily reinforced 2) metal you can hit opps gold from xelnaga towers 3) LT you can hit opps nat from high ground these are things you would've found in ur little analysis and all i'm saying is that it was cute the first time but every map is going to have places where a single tank can hit something important. its not a big deal unless its supplemented by the 2 reasons i initially listed
Well you're right, I was a bit too assertive in the exclusivity of these scenarios, but I still think these new maps are significantly different (none of those examples involve hiding behind a destructible rocks except kulas [which was removed]). Perhaps I'm wrong, I suppose we'll all find out in the future.
|
On October 07 2010 14:34 FinestHour wrote: is there somewhere maybe in the sc2 credits that has the names of the map developers for the game? i might have to mail them some packages with some surprises inside
Jokes about mail bombing game developers? That's some classy shit, dude.
|
all i have to say is.
why bloody chose jungle basin over crossfire (peaks of beakdu remake)
honestly, blizzard needs to pay attention to what makes maps good and what makes them crap.
|
These maps and your sarcasm crush my zerg soul. D:
|
I actually laughed at the OP Looks fun to play custom vs friends the first few times and nuke the bloody shit out of them from those positions, tho it will get tedious to play Z( my race ) vs T on this map. So much shit you need to watch while playing
|
Oh you think its bad with Terran eh? Try this on for size.
1 - Places where you can place Pylons and be able to warp in to the Nat. There are 2 spots I did not place a pylon that works in this pic, more on that in a moment.
![[image loading]](http://img63.imageshack.us/img63/1748/warp1h.jpg)
2 - Downside with having vision over the Expo is that the Expo has vision over your pylons, its easily scouted by patrolling the edge. Solution is to place pylon behind a tree, it still works provided you have something else there to provide vision.
![[image loading]](http://img101.imageshack.us/img101/892/warp2j.jpg)
3 - Best for last, showing the pylon placement on the otherside. However this time I added the "bastard" pylon I did not place in pic1. Why is this pylon a bastard? Because that spot can warp in at all 3 sides, from 1 single pylon! Works top + bottom.
![[image loading]](http://img696.imageshack.us/img696/3685/warp3.jpg)
Have fun abusing the crap out of this, I know I will.
|
Please, find 2 examples of any other ladder map where you can nuke your opponents main without walking up his ramp or dropping on his plateau. I ask for 2 because on Xel'Naga I believe you can partially nuke their mineral line, but you must walk through their natural to do so. With exception to the other new map obviously.
Also, please, find just 1 example of another ladder map where you can siege tank deny your opponents gas at their natural from behind the protection of destructible rocks. With exception to the other new map obviously.
If you can find these scenarios in other maps I'll happily concede that this is nothing special.
Nuking the main? Xel'Naga is the freebie. Metalopolis (Which just so happens to be the most balanced map on the ladder) is the other one. Hell, you can cannon it.
Sieging the natural? Kulas? Lost Temple? (Cliff) Steppes?
BTW, in the OP, the tank sieging the main is not an issue - it requires high ground vision, and has to be so close to the cliff that even a roach could kill it.
|
You know, this isn't really that bad at all....
The biggest concern is problems warping in, not tankplay.
Ugh ima go cheese some terrans with 4gate. Wall in front? HAHAHAHAHAHHAHA.
|
Australia7069 Posts
On October 07 2010 18:27 Chronicle wrote:Oh you think its bad with Terran eh? Try this on for size. 1 - Places where you can place Pylons and be able to warp in to the Nat. There are 2 spots I did not place a pylon that works in this pic, more on that in a moment. + Show Spoiler +2 - Downside with having vision over the Expo is that the Expo has vision over your pylons, its easily scouted by patrolling the edge. Solution is to place pylon behind a tree, it still works provided you have something else there to provide vision. + Show Spoiler +3 - Best for last, showing the pylon placement on the otherside. However this time I added the "bastard" pylon I did not place in pic1. Why is this pylon a bastard? Because that spot can warp in at all 3 sides, from 1 single pylon! Works top + bottom. + Show Spoiler +Have fun abusing the crap out of this, I know I will.
hahahaah. So lets get this straight. its like delta, with a back natural, except theres about 15 spots you can warp in instead of 1. add to that theres no front natural so you're forced to take the back. Awesome.
This makes me really glad they managed to make the thumbs down option work properly during beta so i dont have to play terrible terrible maps like this
|
On October 07 2010 18:34 Kiante wrote:Show nested quote +On October 07 2010 18:27 Chronicle wrote:Oh you think its bad with Terran eh? Try this on for size. 1 - Places where you can place Pylons and be able to warp in to the Nat. There are 2 spots I did not place a pylon that works in this pic, more on that in a moment. 2 - Downside with having vision over the Expo is that the Expo has vision over your pylons, its easily scouted by patrolling the edge. Solution is to place pylon behind a tree, it still works provided you have something else there to provide vision. 3 - Best for last, showing the pylon placement on the otherside. However this time I added the "bastard" pylon I did not place in pic1. Why is this pylon a bastard? Because that spot can warp in at all 3 sides, from 1 single pylon! Works top + bottom. ![[image loading]](http://img696.imageshack.us/img696/3685/warp3.jpg) Have fun abusing the crap out of this, I know I will. hahahaah. So lets get this straight. its like delta, with a back natural, except theres about 15 spots you can warp in instead of 1. add to that theres no front natural so you're forced to take the back. Awesome. This makes me really glad they managed to make the thumbs down option work properly during beta so i dont have to play terrible terrible maps like this
Pretty much. The area is large enough that you cannot block warps with your own building but ontop of that the pylon is harder to kill because its at the other side of the rocks, you have to run all the way around.
|
I almost feel like the map would work better without the rocks.
|
|
|
|
|
|