
A New Way to Play - Page 2
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
Saracen
United States5139 Posts
![]() | ||
|
Knee_of_Justice
United States388 Posts
Frankly, if "lazy defense" werent so, well... lazy, it would be an awfully annoying game. Reaper, muta, voidray nonsense for example would be so much more difficult to deal with. P doesnt really have a good counter to muta harass except phoenix (which zerg just outproduces/ tech switches to corruptors anyways). While I am excited for the future and hope that the community can make SC2 the best that it can be, i think that there are some very serious design flaws with the game that blizzard needs to address. The players will always do their best to make the most of the game, but blizzards job is to help us (via patch). | ||
|
teamsolid
Canada3668 Posts
| ||
|
Wr3k
Canada2533 Posts
| ||
|
Subversion
South Africa3627 Posts
| ||
|
RoarMan
Canada745 Posts
The part about Terran ( Sc's only lesbian couple rofl ) made me lol so hard :DThe Lazy Defense thing is kind of interesting, and I do agree to an extent, although I think the laziest defense thus far is Planatery with Auto-Repair, no offense guys . I really wonder why they nerfed Contaminate so hard, I thought it was just getting interesting with players finding it quite useful in some turtle situations. | ||
|
Steamboatlol
United States161 Posts
| ||
|
Floophead_III
United States1832 Posts
3 vultures can lay down mines and contain an area. 1 reaver can solo hold a ramp. 1 lurker can make an entire area impassible. 1 DT can stop a push. In SC2 the units don't seem to fit that strength of zone control nearly as well. This makes splitting forces much riskier. You can't rely on 2 units to keep an area secured. DTs are the only unit that seems to hold this role, but they're much higher risk since they don't yield a transition to storm, just archons. Add to that the strength of harassers capable of single-handedly wrecking a mineral line in seconds: -banshees -hellions -reapers -banelings -dts/storm -infestors -even colossi Add to that drops, nydus, nukes, and recall and it seems like the number of harass options is just so much greater than in BW. I think that the strength of harass plus the weakness of zone control actually favors 1/2 base turtle allin/timing attack based play. Harass based play is extremely strong, but it carries inherent risks. Because players don't feel very safe from harass often they just go for these 1 punch attacks which are very safe but very dull and 1-dimensional. People just need to get more comfortable with dealing with harass and playing more active defense. | ||
|
Mios
United States686 Posts
you say that harassers can wait until opponent's army leaves the base to effectively harass, which would work if it didn't take 15 seconds for their substantially larger army to arrive at your base. maps need to change in a big way as well. | ||
|
albis
United States652 Posts
On September 03 2010 07:43 ltortoise wrote:and warp prisms are kind of strange because you can just bring a probe or 3 with your army to build forward pylons. . i was talking to a friend about how pvp is hugely just a race to warpgate, proxy pylons and spaming in units. he said you should only be able to warp in units in a radius around your nexus which made me think how good of an idea that would be. pvp doesnt grant the defender an advantage because of proxy pylons and warp ins. but if it was restricted to nexus;s, it would keep its defensive nature, but shed all the proxy bs. what made me quote your comment was if the were true. and then you could also warp from warpprisims. suddenly they become a standard unit of your army, yet have to be constantly stopped a repositioned. which sounds super fun and intense. i dunno. just seams like more pvx would enter lategame | ||
|
vyyye
Sweden3917 Posts
I believe that will evolve along with every macro oriented build. Like in the last Day9 where he talks about "having lots of shit" over having "fancy shit", in a lot of cases two colossi really doesn't matter if you're up against the biggest MMM ball to grace the earth. But obviously, it's hard to say now what the game will evolve to (unless you're Artosis... ), is the reason some players manage so well with a macro centric build because it's simply not the norm? I don't know, no one does at this stage. We saw some Ts in recent tournaments attempt FE builds and they got shut down when the oponent figured out the one base timing bush that hard countered them. Talking about MorroW and Cluck. I really hope this game evolves into a more macro oriented metagame, though it's impossible to say at this stage. We've already seen some macro -> harass potential from some players (BratOk comes to mind), but while it's definitely obnoxious it sometimes feel like it's just not worth it. BratOk does so many amazing things with drops, which yes, it often wins him the game but sometimes the 'lazy defence' kicks in and he'll lose because of it. Well, I suppose we'll see where the game decides to go, how it decides to evolve. We're still in the early stages of (hopefully) a game we'll be playing in 2020. | ||
|
RifleCow
Canada637 Posts
| ||
|
Najda
United States3765 Posts
I get way to caught up in just trying to directly win and not do anything "cute" to use Day[9]'s term. | ||
|
herberdotcom
7 Posts
Let's not derail this thread, but here's a replay that features some tactically effective nydus usage (MysticPrime vs. ChiTaPrime.) http://www.sc2rep.com/replays/show/id/927 | ||
|
LuciD`
United States81 Posts
Refreshing to see some praise about the game that I feel many people are overlooking with the outcries of imbalance and general inferiority of the game. Thank you for this. | ||
|
a176
Canada6688 Posts
Atleast medivacs and warpin have their use no matter the situation, but nydus becomes relegated to a purely defensive role that only enables slightly faster transportation over creep, because maps are so small, units on creep travel fast and far with ease. Then looking at the various ideas that the phases of the game - early game, mid game, late game - are nothing compared to the BW counterparts due to the speed and timing of builds and teching, and utter effectiveness of certain units in very low numbers. I feel the game requires major balancing before you can truly start talking about new methods and strategies to use, because, in modern day SC2, your strategy is probably the result of an "imbalance" and will be patched out in no time, as virtually every strategy in beta has disappeared. | ||
|
Cofo
United States1388 Posts
On September 03 2010 14:24 Mios wrote: one basing will always be effective, even though the game would be more interesting if expanding was easier and safer to do. expansions cost ~500 with gas buildings and then another ~1200 in workers and it takes too much time to pay off early game, creating a window of opportunity for the one baser to have a substantially larger army. this won't change. expansions need to require less workers and be up faster if we want a diverse strategy game to develop imo. you say that harassers can wait until opponent's army leaves the base to effectively harass, which would work if it didn't take 15 seconds for their substantially larger army to arrive at your base. maps need to change in a big way as well. Have you ever even watched BW? The same exact logic can apply there, yet we see tons of expanding. And the fact that we didn't see lots of expanding in BW at first even further suggests that SC2 can develop the same. Yes, there is a window where you're more vulnerable to an attack, that's why it's a risk. That's why it's called a timing attack. | ||
|
Setanta
99 Posts
I'll add though that I think warp prisms are hugely underused! Especially in PvZ, where Zerg no longer has Scourge so you can have 2-3 warp prisms just flying around harassing expansions by warping in Zealots, killing Drones super fast by warping in Templar (with the energy upgrade so they can storm straight away) etc. Makes me want to play Protoss.. | ||
|
Backpack
United States1776 Posts
On September 03 2010 14:50 albis wrote: i was talking to a friend about how pvp is hugely just a race to warpgate, proxy pylons and spaming in units. he said you should only be able to warp in units in a radius around your nexus which made me think how good of an idea that would be. pvp doesnt grant the defender an advantage because of proxy pylons and warp ins. but if it was restricted to nexus;s, it would keep its defensive nature, but shed all the proxy bs. what made me quote your comment was if the were true. and then you could also warp from warpprisims. suddenly they become a standard unit of your army, yet have to be constantly stopped a repositioned. which sounds super fun and intense. i dunno. just seams like more pvx would enter lategame the whole point of warp gates is so you DON'T have to warp in right at your nexus >.< | ||
|
The Touch
United Kingdom667 Posts
On September 04 2010 07:06 Backpack wrote: the whole point of warp gates is so you DON'T have to warp in right at your nexus >.< Surely the point is that you don't have to warp in right at your gateway By restricting warpgates to a radius around the nexus, you could still warp units in right at a new expansion, despite all your warpgates being at your main. Hell, you might even see a fast expand proxy nexus going down in your opponent's natural, or at least farther away than your own natural. That could open up the game to some more entertaining risk-reward decisions. | ||
| ||
) made me lol so hard :D