I wonder if it will be possible to use these even during the beta down period. Anyone has anyinsights on this? If yes then it would be pretty awesome

| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
babyToSS
233 Posts
I wonder if it will be possible to use these even during the beta down period. Anyone has anyinsights on this? If yes then it would be pretty awesome ![]() | ||
|
Two_DoWn
United States13684 Posts
On May 24 2010 09:35 Manifesto7 wrote: Show nested quote + On May 24 2010 09:33 Skvid wrote: On May 24 2010 09:17 Mastermind wrote: On May 24 2010 09:14 Shade692003 wrote: On May 24 2010 09:06 eXNewB wrote: On May 24 2010 08:54 Gamer0ne wrote: Nobody is taking the beta seriously anymore ![]() IT'S BETA!!!!! omg what is wrong with you people! seriously the replies in this thread seem like a bunch of babies crying A) THE GAME IS NOT EVEN OUT YET B) be happy bliz let you play it in the first place C) you have not paid a dime yet for this game so sick of people cussing Blizzard when really you should be thanking them for the opportunity to play "the next big competitive game" User was warned for this post I agree with you 100%. I don't know why you were warned for making sense. He wasn't warned. Notice how the post isn't edited? He is just being an idiot and pretending he was warned. i don't think you can color encode your posts in these forums, which is awesome because some people like to type in shitty fonts and colors just so their posts stand out. Try using the colour in the tag. [red ] [/red ] I dont think you should have done that... | ||
|
fatduck
United States148 Posts
On May 24 2010 09:13 theDreamStick wrote: So I'm an ECE student that's going to focus on networking/security. But I'm still a student, so what would I know. Here's my guess: Essentially, they tried to implement UDP. Probably involved a small amount of code. Shouldn't really mess things up that badly. For those that don't know, UDP is actually pretty good for games. TCP: reliable internet connection. If I send the integers 1, 2, 3, 4 over the internet to you, you WILL receive them in the exact same order. UDP: an unreliable connection. Packets can be lost, or sent out of order. Imagine if you were running a clock on a server. I wouldn't care about a packet that got lost 5 seconds ago because that's not the current time anymore. You can't actually make packets not get lost, or sent out of order...TCP packets just contain a bunch more overhead that allows the receiver to rearrange packets, signal the sender to slow down, and a whole bunch of other shit. UDP is a connectionless, best-effort protocol, where the sender essentially just streams packets across the internet, and reliability has to be maintained at the application layer instead of the transport layer. Most likely, the reliability mechanism Blizzard implemented for UDP networking is not working properly with a large number of dropped or delayed packets - something that may not have shown up in internal testing. Anyway, go Tartans ![]() | ||
|
Failsafe
United States1298 Posts
On May 24 2010 09:36 Two_DoWn wrote: Show nested quote + On May 24 2010 09:35 Manifesto7 wrote: On May 24 2010 09:33 Skvid wrote: On May 24 2010 09:17 Mastermind wrote: On May 24 2010 09:14 Shade692003 wrote: On May 24 2010 09:06 eXNewB wrote: On May 24 2010 08:54 Gamer0ne wrote: Nobody is taking the beta seriously anymore ![]() IT'S BETA!!!!! omg what is wrong with you people! seriously the replies in this thread seem like a bunch of babies crying A) THE GAME IS NOT EVEN OUT YET B) be happy bliz let you play it in the first place C) you have not paid a dime yet for this game so sick of people cussing Blizzard when really you should be thanking them for the opportunity to play "the next big competitive game" User was warned for this post I agree with you 100%. I don't know why you were warned for making sense. He wasn't warned. Notice how the post isn't edited? He is just being an idiot and pretending he was warned. i don't think you can color encode your posts in these forums, which is awesome because some people like to type in shitty fonts and colors just so their posts stand out. Try using the colour in the tag. [red ] [/red ] I dont think you should have done that... It's part of the TL initiative to clean itself up. Offer people something cool, obvious and abusable. Then when they abuse it, ban them. It's simple and effective. Anyway, as for the whole SC2 beta fiasco, I don't know anything about games or programming or networking, but Blizzard isn't doing itself any favors with this whole ordeal. The balancing work has been dubious at best, and there's not much excuse for variance in balancing decisions. The network problems are horrendous but excusable since they're obviously a consequence of an important change. On the other hand, constantly bringing the servers down without any meaningful warning to players is ridiculous. The one thing I think can be universally approved is that if they do shut down the beta for an extended period between now and June 1st, they should definitely give us a few extra days to make up the difference. We don't pay them for the beta, but they don't pay us either. We give them a valuable service they couldn't otherwise have, and that's a little surplus utility for them. We get to play the game early, and that's a little surplus utility for us. It happens that the power relationship is completely asymmetric and Blizzard holds all the keys to the castle, but I don't think anyone subscribes to the might makes right argument. It would be nice if Blizzard had been more considerate to the Beta testers during certain decisions in this process. Even if they truly are a greed-fueled corporate monster, pursuing profit without any regard for consumers, they should still recognize that people respond badly to being fucked with unnecessarily. Although not many people on this board will cancel their pre-orders, I think it's safe to say that not everyone is so attached to the Starcraft franchise that they won't be able to pass this game up if Blizzard fucks around unnecessarily | ||
|
Design
17 Posts
On May 24 2010 09:01 Two_DoWn wrote: Can someone just explain to me how a patch can fuck a game up so badly? I'm not at all programming savy, so im not sure if this is an apt analogy, but if i am writing a paper and decide i want to change a word to something else (change ultra health) i just go in and make the change, and it doesnt mess up the rest of my paper. If i want to change a paragraph around (add facebook/ map publishing to bnet) I add the paragraph, then go back to make sure I didnt repeat myself in another paragraph and that the paper still makes sense. Did blizzard just not go back and check to see if the paper still made sense? Or does my analogy not make sense and I should stick to writing. I know it's already been said but here's my 2 cents. This is what well designed software should be like but it is quite hard to reach this point until well after the finished product has gone live and obscure bugs can be found. Rather, imagine that you have a few different books, each with over 10,000 pages that reference each other multiple times and are each being written by multiple people. These books are updated, and the parts that are referenced in another book need to be changed. Now imagine that they only used copy paste to change these referenced sections in the corresponding book without actually seeing if it makes sense. That is how the more obscure errors occur. Probably not the best analogy, but the point being that software systems can be very complicated and some things can screw with other stuff without it being immediately obvious. In the case of Bnet though, it seems as if they haven't even run the spell checker. It's quite obvious to me that they haven't run enough tests internally before patching and are running into silly issues that should never have reached the live beta. Many of the bugs I have seen over the lifespan of the beta really seem like they should have been found easily if they did basic tests. I'm guessing that they are working on such a tight schedule that they don't have time to thoroughly test everything they implement. But, it's fairly easy to make assumptions without knowing exactly how they have designed everything. In an ideal world beta testing should really be for the most obscure of bugs that popped up for some weird reason. I dunno why they would even release a patch before they knock off for the weekend. So many things can go wrong. | ||
|
Dawme
France58 Posts
| ||
|
fatduck
United States148 Posts
On May 24 2010 09:49 Dawme wrote: Seems very odd to me that they are modifying something so low level than the netcode 2 months before release.. Since the codebase is versioned, reverted back to the old netcode is trivially simple. Why wouldn't they change it now, while it can be tested by thousands of people on the internet, who have problems that obviously don't occur in internal testing? Seems like perfect beta testing to me. | ||
|
synapse
China13814 Posts
On May 24 2010 09:14 Shade692003 wrote: Show nested quote + On May 24 2010 09:06 eXNewB wrote: On May 24 2010 08:54 Gamer0ne wrote: Nobody is taking the beta seriously anymore ![]() IT'S BETA!!!!! omg what is wrong with you people! seriously the replies in this thread seem like a bunch of babies crying A) THE GAME IS NOT EVEN OUT YET B) be happy bliz let you play it in the first place C) you have not paid a dime yet for this game so sick of people cussing Blizzard when really you should be thanking them for the opportunity to play "the next big competitive game" User was warned for this post I agree with you 100%. I don't know why you were warned for making sense. Complaining about people complaining. Besides, he isn't right - just because beta is something that Blizzard doesn't have to let you play doesn't mean it shouldn't be good and without huge problems like freezing every single game. Really sad that patch 13 (where force fields finally arent invincible) had to screw up beta ![]() | ||
|
Bloodyrock
Ireland150 Posts
| ||
|
flamewheel
FREEAGLELAND26782 Posts
On May 24 2010 09:17 Mastermind wrote: Show nested quote + On May 24 2010 09:14 Shade692003 wrote: On May 24 2010 09:06 eXNewB wrote: On May 24 2010 08:54 Gamer0ne wrote: Nobody is taking the beta seriously anymore ![]() IT'S BETA!!!!! omg what is wrong with you people! seriously the replies in this thread seem like a bunch of babies crying A) THE GAME IS NOT EVEN OUT YET B) be happy bliz let you play it in the first place C) you have not paid a dime yet for this game so sick of people cussing Blizzard when really you should be thanking them for the opportunity to play "the next big competitive game" User was warned for this post I agree with you 100%. I don't know why you were warned for making sense. He wasn't warned. Notice how the post isn't edited? He is just being an idiot and pretending he was warned. No, it's possible to be warned without having the post edited. Edit: Mani beat me to it, so as to not make this post completely fail: What is going to happen to the TL Altitude then? I'm assuming just a rescheduling, and since the sponsors are really only worried about the amount of money that gets distributed, not when, it shouldn't be that big of a difference to wait a week or so? Of course, that's assuming that all four of the players + whoever's casting/streaming is available at that time. Sheesh, Blizz ![]() | ||
|
oob
Sweden630 Posts
I realize this is prolly my graphics card fucking up, but it was quite hillarious. I even won the game with just mass marauders rallied to my opponents base. | ||
|
Pekkz
Norway1505 Posts
| ||
|
NuKedUFirst
Canada3139 Posts
On May 24 2010 09:55 flamewheel91 wrote: Show nested quote + On May 24 2010 09:17 Mastermind wrote: On May 24 2010 09:14 Shade692003 wrote: On May 24 2010 09:06 eXNewB wrote: On May 24 2010 08:54 Gamer0ne wrote: Nobody is taking the beta seriously anymore ![]() IT'S BETA!!!!! omg what is wrong with you people! seriously the replies in this thread seem like a bunch of babies crying A) THE GAME IS NOT EVEN OUT YET B) be happy bliz let you play it in the first place C) you have not paid a dime yet for this game so sick of people cussing Blizzard when really you should be thanking them for the opportunity to play "the next big competitive game" User was warned for this post I agree with you 100%. I don't know why you were warned for making sense. He wasn't warned. Notice how the post isn't edited? He is just being an idiot and pretending he was warned. No, it's possible to be warned without having the post edited. Edit: Mani beat me to it, so as to not make this post completely fail: What is going to happen to the TL Altitude then? I'm assuming just a rescheduling, and since the sponsors are really only worried about the amount of money that gets distributed, not when, it shouldn't be that big of a difference to wait a week or so? Of course, that's assuming that all four of the players + whoever's casting/streaming is available at that time. Sheesh, Blizz ![]() Well, they said a few days so I am guessing it will be back sometime Wednesday (?) hopefully the tournament doesn't suffer because of this. | ||
|
Dawme
France58 Posts
On May 24 2010 09:51 fatduck wrote: Show nested quote + On May 24 2010 09:49 Dawme wrote: Seems very odd to me that they are modifying something so low level than the netcode 2 months before release.. Since the codebase is versioned, reverted back to the old netcode is trivially simple. Why wouldn't they change it now, while it can be tested by thousands of people on the internet, who have problems that obviously don't occur in internal testing? Seems like perfect beta testing to me. Well off course you can always do it but it's not really part of the normal process of game dev to wake up near the release date and say "heh let's change our 3d engine" or "let's change our netcode". These things are supposed to be developped and tested at the very beginning so this change must have been motivated by something really strong to justify it. | ||
|
relay
Norway30 Posts
| ||
|
Design
17 Posts
On May 24 2010 10:21 Dawme wrote: Show nested quote + On May 24 2010 09:51 fatduck wrote: On May 24 2010 09:49 Dawme wrote: Seems very odd to me that they are modifying something so low level than the netcode 2 months before release.. Since the codebase is versioned, reverted back to the old netcode is trivially simple. Why wouldn't they change it now, while it can be tested by thousands of people on the internet, who have problems that obviously don't occur in internal testing? Seems like perfect beta testing to me. Well off course you can always do it but it's not really part of the normal process of game dev to wake up near the release date and say "heh let's change our 3d engine" or "let's change our netcode". These things are supposed to be developped and tested at the very beginning so this change must have been motivated by something really strong to justify it. I agree with this. The thing that really boggles my mind is how apparently experienced developers can not predict that there is the possibility that their implementation will cause errors when released to a large population. Or maybe they did predict it, they were just silly enough to decide to test that fact over a weekend, and didn't have staff on hand to fix it when it failed. You really can't have a game that is meant to be an 'online experience' without the 'online experience'. It's just so fundamental. The Starcraft II developers won't be able to get their balance testing data while Bnet is not working. Starting to think that maybe a bunch of monkeys overran the Bnet office and started mashing on the keys. Yes, and I realise that it will be fixed after a few days. But at this stage of the beta, when they are so close to shutting it down, every day they can collect data is important. | ||
|
zava
Germany6 Posts
like "we can piss our community off really bad, they will come back crawling once we shut down bnet for a while "maybe even though they are efficient and ultra they thought "what the hell, they will eat all of our shit, this is starcraft II!" meanwhile they play starcraft all day long on a private bnet worker server | ||
|
brucebruce
United States22 Posts
On May 24 2010 11:07 zava wrote: I guess they know that no matter what they do, starcraft II will be sold billions of times throughout the world. maybe they got a little cocky like "we can piss our community off really bad, they will come back crawling once we shut down bnet for a while "maybe even though they are efficient and ultra they thought "what the hell, they will eat all of our shit, this is starcraft II!" meanwhile they play starcraft all day long on a private bnet worker server They're having their own in-office tournament right now, 64 man bracket | ||
|
ZenDeX
Philippines2916 Posts
On May 24 2010 11:15 brucebruce wrote: Show nested quote + On May 24 2010 11:07 zava wrote: I guess they know that no matter what they do, starcraft II will be sold billions of times throughout the world. maybe they got a little cocky like "we can piss our community off really bad, they will come back crawling once we shut down bnet for a while "maybe even though they are efficient and ultra they thought "what the hell, they will eat all of our shit, this is starcraft II!" meanwhile they play starcraft all day long on a private bnet worker server They're having their own in-office tournament right now, 64 man bracket KingHillBilly, CowGoMoo and dayvie will dominate. | ||
|
FrogOfWar
Germany1406 Posts
On May 24 2010 09:53 synapse wrote: Show nested quote + On May 24 2010 09:14 Shade692003 wrote: On May 24 2010 09:06 eXNewB wrote: On May 24 2010 08:54 Gamer0ne wrote: Nobody is taking the beta seriously anymore ![]() IT'S BETA!!!!! omg what is wrong with you people! seriously the replies in this thread seem like a bunch of babies crying A) THE GAME IS NOT EVEN OUT YET B) be happy bliz let you play it in the first place C) you have not paid a dime yet for this game so sick of people cussing Blizzard when really you should be thanking them for the opportunity to play "the next big competitive game" User was warned for this post I agree with you 100%. I don't know why you were warned for making sense. Complaining about people complaining. Besides, he isn't right - just because beta is something that Blizzard doesn't have to let you play doesn't mean it shouldn't be good and without huge problems like freezing every single game. Still weird, being warned for being wrong, or for dissenting and asking people to look at it from another perspective. Anyways, concerning UDP: TCP involves a lot of extra overhead. We're changing stuff to see what would happen on both the client and server. The current issues we're having doesn't involve UDP. http://forums.battle.net/thread.html?topicId=24915153163&sid=5000&pageNo=2#37 | ||
| ||
StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War League of Legends Counter-Strike Other Games |
|
RSL Revival
AI Arena Tournament
BSL
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
OSC
IPSL
Ret vs ggnore13
nOmaD vs Aether
BSL
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
WardiTV Weekly
Kung Fu Cup
Solar vs Classic
ByuN vs SHIN
[ Show More ] PiGosaur Cup
The PondCast
KCM Race Survival
|
|
|