|
On January 13 2016 09:27 Crusnik wrote:Show nested quote +On January 13 2016 08:47 Frolossus wrote:On January 13 2016 04:17 Crusnik wrote: Ew. I would rather not have voice chat than use vent tbh, its so freaking hard to get that sweet spot for voice activation. Discord I've barely used, Dolby Axon was nice, but it went down like 5-6 times a day last year and I just got a TS server for my friends to use instead, lol. the idea is that you want everyone to be using PTT, not using voice activation. That kinda defeats the purpose of playing in a stack then, no? I don't want to have to press another button just to say someone in coming to gank while trying to ping/draw the approach route. Depends, PTT is better experience for the group, Open mic is better for serious play and voic activation is best only for the person with it on.
|
United States47024 Posts
Perfect voice activation should be indistinguishable from PTT, it's just that all voice activation is varying degrees of imperfect.
|
The days of unified platforms are now pretty much over, and most new chat programs are or have become terrible.
Google was pretty much the last place to have chat over a standard protocool but they killed XMPP for proprietary Google Hangouts. Facebook Messenger is pretty widely used but they don't even have a desktop app because keep a webpage open all the time is both convenient for them and for your average user who doesn't care about performance efficiency. Skype went from the de-facto video chat (because MSN Messenger sucked) into Microsoft turning them into the MSN Messenger of the new decade.
Also, RIP XFire
|
Xfire the true struggler of communicators ;_:
I've just googled and apparently there's an unofficial Messenger app, not sure if I wanna bother testing it http://messengerfordesktop.com/
|
United States47024 Posts
On January 13 2016 09:52 Zess wrote: Google was pretty much the last place to have chat over a standard protocool but they killed XMPP for proprietary Google Hangouts. XMPP Google Talk still functions and integrates with the new Google Hangouts. Google just killed their own proprietary clients (which were shit anyway) and don't talk to other XMPP servers (but that doesn't affect 99% of users). Clients that support XMPP can still connect to Google Talk the old fashioned way.
Basically if you were using a third-party client like Pidgin to use Google Talk (which you should be anyway), Google Hangouts only resulted in a minimal change to your user experience.
|
On January 13 2016 09:27 Crusnik wrote:Show nested quote +On January 13 2016 08:47 Frolossus wrote:On January 13 2016 04:17 Crusnik wrote: Ew. I would rather not have voice chat than use vent tbh, its so freaking hard to get that sweet spot for voice activation. Discord I've barely used, Dolby Axon was nice, but it went down like 5-6 times a day last year and I just got a TS server for my friends to use instead, lol. the idea is that you want everyone to be using PTT, not using voice activation. That kinda defeats the purpose of playing in a stack then, no? I don't want to have to press another button just to say someone in coming to gank while trying to ping/draw the approach route. i don't care how serious the game is, i'd rather not hear you breathe into the mic all day, if you bind it to a mouse button it's not any harder to do during gameplay either. imo open mic is impractical if you have >3 people in a group at a time. more than that and it becomes too hard to listen to what everyone is saying and you have to deal with multiple people breathing into their mics
|
United States47024 Posts
The last time when I felt voice detection was bad enough to necessitate PtT was when people were still using Ventrilo.
Pretty much all of the current VOIP options are good enough that if you're hearing someone breathe into their mic, it's because either they didn't bother to configure their settings or because their mic is completely awful, not because voice detection is bad.
At that point it becomes a matter of convenience--is it more inconvenient to have to press a button every time you talk, or is it more inconvenient to spend 10-15 minutes fine-tuning the threshold for voice detection and then more or less never having to worry about it again?
|
On January 13 2016 10:45 TheYango wrote: The last time when I felt voice detection was bad enough to necessitate PtT was when people were still using Ventrilo.
Pretty much all of the current VOIP options at least get close enough that if you're hearing someone breathe into their mic, it's because either they didn't bother to configure their settings or because their mic is completely awful, not because voice activation is bad. it's way easier to be unassuming that people understand how to properly set up voice activation and test all cases where it won't work by just using PTT.
vent is still unobtrusive and has worked fantastically for me for many years.
|
On January 13 2016 10:45 TheYango wrote: The last time when I felt voice detection was bad enough to necessitate PtT was when people were still using Ventrilo.
Pretty much all of the current VOIP options are good enough that if you're hearing someone breathe into their mic, it's because either they didn't bother to configure their settings or because their mic is completely awful, not because voice detection is bad.
At that point it becomes a matter of convenience--is it more inconvenient to have to press a button every time you talk, or is it more inconvenient to spend 10-15 minutes fine-tuning the threshold for voice detection and then more or less never having to worry about it again? hearing coughs or outside conversations or mechanical keyboards can be equally annoying.
|
On January 13 2016 10:52 PrinceXizor wrote:Show nested quote +On January 13 2016 10:45 TheYango wrote: The last time when I felt voice detection was bad enough to necessitate PtT was when people were still using Ventrilo.
Pretty much all of the current VOIP options are good enough that if you're hearing someone breathe into their mic, it's because either they didn't bother to configure their settings or because their mic is completely awful, not because voice detection is bad.
At that point it becomes a matter of convenience--is it more inconvenient to have to press a button every time you talk, or is it more inconvenient to spend 10-15 minutes fine-tuning the threshold for voice detection and then more or less never having to worry about it again? hearing coughs or outside conversations or mechanical keyboards can be equally annoying. additionally, roommates, wives, girlfriends, parents, dogs etc at your shoulder
|
United States47024 Posts
There are actually a lot of games where PtT becomes an annoyance because the game itself uses a large part of the keyboard and holding your PtT key while you do other things is impractical. It's usually fine for games that rely on WASD movement because those games are designed around your hand position being largely static anyway, but for something like Starcraft where you regularly reach for hotkeys like 0 or P, the conventional unobstructive PtT key options become really unwieldy.
On January 13 2016 10:52 PrinceXizor wrote: hearing coughs or outside conversations or mechanical keyboards can be equally annoying. So I have a mute button for those exceptional situations and use it when its called for. Just because 10% of the time I have to use the mute button doesn't mean I want to use PtT 100% of the time.
|
On January 13 2016 10:53 TheYango wrote: There are actually a lot of games where PtT becomes an annoyance because the game itself uses a large part of the keyboard and holding your PtT key while you do other things is impractical. It's usually fine for games that rely on WASD movement because those games are designed around your hand position being largely static anyway, but for something like Starcraft where you regularly reach for hotkeys like 0 or P, the conventional unobstructive PtT key options become really unwieldy. try either mouse wheel or mouse 4/5 if you have it. most games only use either left or right click for most things so if you press mouse wheel in you can either use your index finger or middle finger.
if you do have mouse 4/5 then just use your thumb on your mouse hand which probably isn't doing anything anyways
|
On January 13 2016 10:53 TheYango wrote:Show nested quote +On January 13 2016 10:52 PrinceXizor wrote: hearing coughs or outside conversations or mechanical keyboards can be equally annoying. So I have a mute button for those exceptional situations and use it when its called for. Just because 10% of the time I have to use the mute button doesn't mean I want to use PtT 100% of the time. This is why i said PTT is best for the group and voice activate is best for the individual using it.
|
United States47024 Posts
On January 13 2016 10:56 Frolossus wrote: try either mouse wheel or mouse 4/5 if you have it. most games only use either left or right click for most things so if you press mouse wheel in you can either use your index finger or middle finger.
if you do have mouse 4/5 then just use your thumb on your mouse hand which probably isn't doing anything anyways Except I do use middle mouse in RTS games and I've used exclusively lightweight 2/3-button mice since I first used an LMO for BW, and I don't think I'd switch back to a bulky gaming mouse just for that.
On January 13 2016 10:56 PrinceXizor wrote: This is why i said PTT is best for the group and voice activate is best for the individual using it. With a little common sense, courtesy, and foresight, it really shouldn't matter for the group so long as the person using voice detection took the time to set things up and mutes himself when it makes sense.
|
On January 13 2016 10:58 TheYango wrote:Show nested quote +On January 13 2016 10:56 Frolossus wrote: try either mouse wheel or mouse 4/5 if you have it. most games only use either left or right click for most things so if you press mouse wheel in you can either use your index finger or middle finger.
if you do have mouse 4/5 then just use your thumb on your mouse hand which probably isn't doing anything anyways Except I do use middle mouse in RTS games and I've used exclusively lightweight 2/3-button mice since I first used an LMO for BW, and I don't think I'd switch back to a bulky gaming mouse just for that. Show nested quote +On January 13 2016 10:56 PrinceXizor wrote: This is why i said PTT is best for the group and voice activate is best for the individual using it. With a little common sense, courtesy, and foresight, it really shouldn't matter for the group so long as the person using voice detection took the time to set things up and mutes himself when it makes sense. if it is one person and one client maybe. but when you have multiple VOIP clients used for multiple groups of people and frequently pick up players for whatever game to fill party slots that are not regulars to your client and expect them to go through the same long setup and testing every time is impractical. every time you switch computers, get a new mic or headset or reinstall your operating system you have to redo all the setup and testing.
|
United States15536 Posts
|
I use Mouse 4. Speaking of Mumble's greatness, it actually allows me to reserve that button so that other programs don't react to this input, pretty useful when browsing net (also there used to be a bug in Dota2 where this button always activated talking even if it was unbound). Teamspeak and Discord yet to stop being shit in that regard.
Also I think PTT as default works better because people are too lazy to set up proper voice activation yet they think it will be fine and then I have to mute half the TS in order to stay sane.
|
On January 13 2016 10:41 Frolossus wrote:Show nested quote +On January 13 2016 09:27 Crusnik wrote:On January 13 2016 08:47 Frolossus wrote:On January 13 2016 04:17 Crusnik wrote: Ew. I would rather not have voice chat than use vent tbh, its so freaking hard to get that sweet spot for voice activation. Discord I've barely used, Dolby Axon was nice, but it went down like 5-6 times a day last year and I just got a TS server for my friends to use instead, lol. the idea is that you want everyone to be using PTT, not using voice activation. That kinda defeats the purpose of playing in a stack then, no? I don't want to have to press another button just to say someone in coming to gank while trying to ping/draw the approach route. i don't care how serious the game is, i'd rather not hear you breathe into the mic all day, if you bind it to a mouse button it's not any harder to do during gameplay either. imo open mic is impractical if you have >3 people in a group at a time. more than that and it becomes too hard to listen to what everyone is saying and you have to deal with multiple people breathing into their mics PTT just screws you over if you're trying to play anything semi seriously. Besides, even if I'm not playing and i'm just hanging out to chat for a few hours, do you really expect me to be using push to talk while not even holding my mouse?
I think the majority of the eu people at least (and the mericans who i spent most time on ts with) all use voice activation, and generally you can't even tell unless they have dogs or a violin concerto in the background :p
|
On January 13 2016 18:04 killerdog wrote:Show nested quote +On January 13 2016 10:41 Frolossus wrote:On January 13 2016 09:27 Crusnik wrote:On January 13 2016 08:47 Frolossus wrote:On January 13 2016 04:17 Crusnik wrote: Ew. I would rather not have voice chat than use vent tbh, its so freaking hard to get that sweet spot for voice activation. Discord I've barely used, Dolby Axon was nice, but it went down like 5-6 times a day last year and I just got a TS server for my friends to use instead, lol. the idea is that you want everyone to be using PTT, not using voice activation. That kinda defeats the purpose of playing in a stack then, no? I don't want to have to press another button just to say someone in coming to gank while trying to ping/draw the approach route. i don't care how serious the game is, i'd rather not hear you breathe into the mic all day, if you bind it to a mouse button it's not any harder to do during gameplay either. imo open mic is impractical if you have >3 people in a group at a time. more than that and it becomes too hard to listen to what everyone is saying and you have to deal with multiple people breathing into their mics PTT just screws you over if you're trying to play anything semi seriously. Besides, even if I'm not playing and i'm just hanging out to chat for a few hours, do you really expect me to be using push to talk while not even holding my mouse? I think the majority of the eu people at least (and the mericans who i spent most time on ts with) all use voice activation, and generally you can't even tell unless they have dogs or a violin concerto in the background :p HEY NOW
But yeah, I'm probably the only person still using PTT except sometimes I'm too lazy to set it up so you hear violin concertos.
|
On January 13 2016 19:03 Fildun wrote:Show nested quote +On January 13 2016 18:04 killerdog wrote:On January 13 2016 10:41 Frolossus wrote:On January 13 2016 09:27 Crusnik wrote:On January 13 2016 08:47 Frolossus wrote:On January 13 2016 04:17 Crusnik wrote: Ew. I would rather not have voice chat than use vent tbh, its so freaking hard to get that sweet spot for voice activation. Discord I've barely used, Dolby Axon was nice, but it went down like 5-6 times a day last year and I just got a TS server for my friends to use instead, lol. the idea is that you want everyone to be using PTT, not using voice activation. That kinda defeats the purpose of playing in a stack then, no? I don't want to have to press another button just to say someone in coming to gank while trying to ping/draw the approach route. i don't care how serious the game is, i'd rather not hear you breathe into the mic all day, if you bind it to a mouse button it's not any harder to do during gameplay either. imo open mic is impractical if you have >3 people in a group at a time. more than that and it becomes too hard to listen to what everyone is saying and you have to deal with multiple people breathing into their mics PTT just screws you over if you're trying to play anything semi seriously. Besides, even if I'm not playing and i'm just hanging out to chat for a few hours, do you really expect me to be using push to talk while not even holding my mouse? I think the majority of the eu people at least (and the mericans who i spent most time on ts with) all use voice activation, and generally you can't even tell unless they have dogs or a violin concerto in the background :p HEY NOW But yeah, I'm probably the only person still using PTT except sometimes I'm too lazy to set it up so you hear violin concertos.
I still use PTT. It's basically the only way you can do voice chat at lans back in the day so the habit is ingrained pretty deeply in my soul. Trying to listen to footsteps is super hard when everyone is rocking open mic with noise in the background. Can't play competitively like that.
On January 13 2016 18:04 killerdog wrote:Show nested quote +On January 13 2016 10:41 Frolossus wrote:On January 13 2016 09:27 Crusnik wrote:On January 13 2016 08:47 Frolossus wrote:On January 13 2016 04:17 Crusnik wrote: Ew. I would rather not have voice chat than use vent tbh, its so freaking hard to get that sweet spot for voice activation. Discord I've barely used, Dolby Axon was nice, but it went down like 5-6 times a day last year and I just got a TS server for my friends to use instead, lol. the idea is that you want everyone to be using PTT, not using voice activation. That kinda defeats the purpose of playing in a stack then, no? I don't want to have to press another button just to say someone in coming to gank while trying to ping/draw the approach route. i don't care how serious the game is, i'd rather not hear you breathe into the mic all day, if you bind it to a mouse button it's not any harder to do during gameplay either. imo open mic is impractical if you have >3 people in a group at a time. more than that and it becomes too hard to listen to what everyone is saying and you have to deal with multiple people breathing into their mics PTT just screws you over if you're trying to play anything semi seriously. Besides, even if I'm not playing and i'm just hanging out to chat for a few hours, do you really expect me to be using push to talk while not even holding my mouse? I think the majority of the eu people at least (and the mericans who i spent most time on ts with) all use voice activation, and generally you can't even tell unless they have dogs or a violin concerto in the background :p
Back in my day someone talking about playing seriously or semi seriously yet talking about online would be mocked. Times have changed man. Online heroes is no longer an insult ;(. Feels wrong.
|
|
|
|
|
|