On December 29 2015 19:39 nafta wrote: Yea those 5 aoe crits from a basic bandit camp in a row that tilt everyone into 4 negative sanities that make me lose all control sure were pure lack of skill. The game does feel unfair when it comes to rng sometimes. Still a great game though.
It's a roguelike, and plays like one. RNG deaths like that occur in any roguelike, even though most good ones tend to try and make them less common. Characters are disposable and should die frequently, sometimes inexplicably to RNG. But somehow the setup doesn't cue some people into this fact and they get inordinately attached to characters and their investment in them.
On December 29 2015 19:39 nafta wrote: Yea those 5 aoe crits from a basic bandit camp in a row that tilt everyone into 4 negative sanities that make me lose all control sure were pure lack of skill. The game does feel unfair when it comes to rng sometimes. Still a great game though.
It's a roguelike, and plays like one. RNG deaths like that occur in any roguelike, even though most good ones tend to try and make them less common. Characters are disposable and should die frequently, sometimes inexplicably to RNG. But somehow the setup doesn't cue some people into this fact and they get inordinately attached to characters and their investment in them.
This is debatable. There is RNG inherent in any roguelike but in one like Isaac for example (let's not get into a discussion on the semantics of what a 'true roguelike' is right now, it doesn't change the point I'm trying to make since Isaac is at the very least considered as such) player skill vastly trumps RNG to the point where the best players are speedrunning/streaking with wins over 200.
I think it's pretty dependent on the game itself how much a factor RNG plays into the difficulty or perceived difficulty. In the case of DD they very clearly wanted RNG to be a much bigger factor than some others in more recent years (FTL, Necrodancer just to name a couple), and perhaps this is what's rubbing some members of the community the wrong way?
Not really attached/invested. It is just annoying how much work it can create to get back a lot of those heroes. A system that lets you pay gold for levels if you have x unlocked at higher levels would be really good imo. Obviously not geared but just higher level.
Say you have 18 champs at 3 or higher it is just so hard to level up the newbies. They always tilt so incredibly fast you just gotta get a new group going regularly.
On December 30 2015 02:27 WaveofShadow wrote: This is debatable. There is RNG inherent in any roguelike but in one like Isaac for example (let's not get into a discussion on the semantics of what a 'true roguelike' is right now, it doesn't change the point I'm trying to make since Isaac is at the very least considered as such) player skill vastly trumps RNG to the point where the best players are speedrunning/streaking with wins over 200.
Isaac is actually a very interesting comparison here because the practice of pruning recruits for bad quirks is essentially equivalent to the common Isaac practice of resetting until you get a decent starting item in your 1st floor item room. And nobody seems to have any problems with doing that.
And that actually is hugely relevant to the comparison here because as it turns out, such a practice has a huge impact on the possibility of RNG fucking you over. Almost any time I've had a string of bad luck put a party at risk of an affliction spiral, it's been a character with some relevant negative quirk leading the charge (e.g. successive Bone Courtier fights while bringing someone with +20% Stress Damage vs. Unholy).
The idea of "player skill trumps RNG" is fair, but that isn't a comparison that can reasonably be made between Isaac and DD right now because a) the top end of Isaac skill right now is clearly much higher, with the game having existed for so much longer, and b) because the speedrunning/racing community exists, there's a much bigger communal emphasis on "optimal" play.
On December 30 2015 02:27 WaveofShadow wrote: This is debatable. There is RNG inherent in any roguelike but in one like Isaac for example (let's not get into a discussion on the semantics of what a 'true roguelike' is right now, it doesn't change the point I'm trying to make since Isaac is at the very least considered as such) player skill vastly trumps RNG to the point where the best players are speedrunning/streaking with wins over 200.
Isaac is actually a very interesting comparison here because the practice of pruning recruits for bad quirks is essentially equivalent to the common Isaac practice of resetting until you get a decent starting item in your 1st floor item room. And nobody seems to have any problems with doing that.
And that actually is hugely relevant to the comparison here because as it turns out, such a practice has a huge impact on the possibility of RNG fucking you over. Almost any time I've had a string of bad luck put a party at risk of an affliction spiral, it's been a character with some relevant negative quirk leading the charge (e.g. successive Bone Courtier fights while bringing someone with +20% Stress Damage vs. Unoly).
The idea of "player skill trumps RNG" is fair, but that isn't a comparison that can reasonably be made between Isaac and DD right now because a) the top end of Isaac skill right now is clearly much higher, with the game having existed for so much longer, and b) because the speedrunning/racing community exists, there's a much bigger communal emphasis on "optimal" play.
Yes but 'resetting' is only done in speedruns. The 200-game-long streaks are people who start with whatever run (usually Eden I believe) they are given, and still manage to completely succeed hundreds of times over.
On December 30 2015 02:27 WaveofShadow wrote: This is debatable. There is RNG inherent in any roguelike but in one like Isaac for example (let's not get into a discussion on the semantics of what a 'true roguelike' is right now, it doesn't change the point I'm trying to make since Isaac is at the very least considered as such) player skill vastly trumps RNG to the point where the best players are speedrunning/streaking with wins over 200.
Isaac is actually a very interesting comparison here because the practice of pruning recruits for bad quirks is essentially equivalent to the common Isaac practice of resetting until you get a decent starting item in your 1st floor item room. And nobody seems to have any problems with doing that.
And that actually is hugely relevant to the comparison here because as it turns out, such a practice has a huge impact on the possibility of RNG fucking you over. Almost any time I've had a string of bad luck put a party at risk of an affliction spiral, it's been a character with some relevant negative quirk leading the charge (e.g. successive Bone Courtier fights while bringing someone with +20% Stress Damage vs. Unholy).
The idea of "player skill trumps RNG" is fair, but that isn't a comparison that can reasonably be made between Isaac and DD right now because a) the top end of Isaac skill right now is clearly much higher, with the game having existed for so much longer, and b) because the speedrunning/racing community exists, there's a much bigger communal emphasis on "optimal" play.
I don't understand why you'd prune recruits for bad quirks though.
Quirks make very little difference, IMO. I don't even know what quirks my guys have I never check or read them or care and I'm doing just fine in the game.
If I could change one thing about DD I'd make quirks appear less often but be more serious, to make me actually give a shit about them.
Do they start to matter once you start doing Long dungeons and get to like resolve level 5 and shit? I keep getting bored and restarting my game before I get to that point.
On December 30 2015 02:37 nafta wrote: Say you have 18 champs at 3 or higher it is just so hard to level up the newbies. They always tilt so incredibly fast you just gotta get a new group going regularly.
I don't really get this. Leveling 0-2s is so easy compared to running 3+s. Since Trinkets have no level requirement, having any number of Rare/Very Rare/Ancestral trinkets disproportionately helps those low level characters (e.g. stacking Stun % trinkets lets level 0s permastun enemies through the stun resist buff that comes after because base stun resist for apprentice enemies is so low).
On December 30 2015 02:27 WaveofShadow wrote: This is debatable. There is RNG inherent in any roguelike but in one like Isaac for example (let's not get into a discussion on the semantics of what a 'true roguelike' is right now, it doesn't change the point I'm trying to make since Isaac is at the very least considered as such) player skill vastly trumps RNG to the point where the best players are speedrunning/streaking with wins over 200.
Isaac is actually a very interesting comparison here because the practice of pruning recruits for bad quirks is essentially equivalent to the common Isaac practice of resetting until you get a decent starting item in your 1st floor item room. And nobody seems to have any problems with doing that.
And that actually is hugely relevant to the comparison here because as it turns out, such a practice has a huge impact on the possibility of RNG fucking you over. Almost any time I've had a string of bad luck put a party at risk of an affliction spiral, it's been a character with some relevant negative quirk leading the charge (e.g. successive Bone Courtier fights while bringing someone with +20% Stress Damage vs. Unholy).
The idea of "player skill trumps RNG" is fair, but that isn't a comparison that can reasonably be made between Isaac and DD right now because a) the top end of Isaac skill right now is clearly much higher, with the game having existed for so much longer, and b) because the speedrunning/racing community exists, there's a much bigger communal emphasis on "optimal" play.
ALso a) Fair point I suppose but there is mechanical skill involved here as well so it's also difficult to compare. I would argue that Isaac is overall a harder game simply because of the fact that no 'guide' could ever get you through like a DD guide could. I'm not sure the 'ceiling' being higher is relevant. b) But like people were saying last night or the night before, 'optimal' play is almost the only thing you could possibly strive for in DD, and way easier to achieve. So much so that this is PRECISELY what the people giving negative reviews are complaining about. People wrote guides on how to 'beat' DD essentially and RH destroyed numerous strategies that were previously viable in favour of RNG shenanigans determining your outcomes more often.
On December 30 2015 02:51 Ketara wrote: If I could change one thing about DD I'd make quirks appear less often but be more serious, to make me actually give a shit about them.
I mean, the majority of quirks *are* ignorable (basically any relating to stress relief in town or conditional effects based on low light or low HP) but the few that are really bad are really bad.
If you let a character lock Kleptomania, that character basically will never pull his weight for their entire career.
On December 30 2015 02:51 Ketara wrote: Do they start to matter once you start doing Long dungeons and get to like resolve level 5 and shit? I keep getting bored and restarting my game before I get to that point.
I basically never do Long dungeons. It simply doesn't feel worth it when I'm already throwing away a ton of items finishing Medium dungeons.
On December 30 2015 02:56 WaveofShadow wrote: b) But like people were saying last night or the night before, 'optimal' play is almost the only thing you could possibly strive for in DD, and way easier to achieve. So much so that this is PRECISELY what the people giving negative reviews are complaining about. People wrote guides on how to 'beat' DD essentially and RH destroyed numerous strategies that were previously viable in favour of RNG shenanigans determining your outcomes more often.
I mean, if the complaint is about corpses in particular, that argument is total bullshit because adding corpses enables just as much as it takes away.
People are just mad that now when you kill melee skeletons it doesn't move the archers to the front letting you stall and heal/destress forever while they use the useless Bayonet Jab move over and over again. But the existence of corpses also means that stuff that hits the backline doesn't become totally unusable if you kill people in rows 1-3. In aggregate it helps more than it hurts, people just get overly attached to their pet strategy.
The reason why you can make a really good guide for DD is because it's turn based. You can stop and think about everything and write a guide that covers real specific nitpicky scenarios.
An Isaac guide would be like "Stop getting hit. OMG STOP GETTING HIT."
On December 30 2015 02:37 nafta wrote: Say you have 18 champs at 3 or higher it is just so hard to level up the newbies. They always tilt so incredibly fast you just gotta get a new group going regularly.
I don't really get this. Leveling 0-2s is so easy compared to running 3+s. Since Trinkets have no level requirement, having any number of Rare/Very Rare/Ancestral trinkets disproportionately helps those low level characters (e.g. stacking Stun % trinkets lets level 0s permastun enemies through the stun resist buff that comes after because base stun resist for apprentice enemies is so low).
Hard was the wrong word. If you just have a group leveling together it is very easy but boring. But it never works well if I put lvl 0 guy in the lvl 3 group.
On December 30 2015 03:02 Ketara wrote: The reason why you can make a really good guide for DD is because it's turn based. You can stop and think about everything and write a guide that covers real specific nitpicky scenarios.
An Isaac guide would be like "Stop getting hit. OMG STOP GETTING HIT."
Yes that was my point.
I mean, if the complaint is about corpses in particular, that argument is total bullshit because adding corpses enables just as much as it takes away.
People are just mad that now when you kill melee skeletons it doesn't move the archers to the front letting you stall and heal/destress forever while they use the useless Bayonet Jab move over and over again. But the existence of corpses also means that stuff that hits the backline doesn't become totally unusable if you kill people in rows 1-3. In aggregate it helps more than it hurts, people just get overly attached to their pet strategy.
I agree with you for the most part, I'm just wondering if there is any validity to any of these complaints. I often find I'm on the 'fanboy' side of the arguments that get communities up in arms in the sense that 'let the dev do what they want.' This includes the Isaac community that almost universally panned all the shit that went down early in the Afterbirth cycle and high level players saying that all of the item changes and nerfs that went through after the game was released shouldn't have happened. Personally, I just don't care and will adapt/adjust to whatever necessary despite the arguments for or against.
On December 30 2015 02:27 WaveofShadow wrote:I think it's pretty dependent on the game itself how much a factor RNG plays into the difficulty or perceived difficulty. In the case of DD they very clearly wanted RNG to be a much bigger factor than some others in more recent years (FTL, Necrodancer just to name a couple), and perhaps this is what's rubbing some members of the community the wrong way?
I think part of what ruined FTL for me was the enhanced edition level of RNG was way over the top. The original was much more skill reliant, but if you wander into a pulsar because you don't have scanners yet, you're pretty much jacked. Or get mind control jacked while someone is boarding. So much more variance in what ship loadout you'll face in the expansion, and it is hard to be prepared against everything if you're not save scumming (I had a friend do this).
On December 30 2015 02:51 Ketara wrote: Quirks make very little difference, IMO. I don't even know what quirks my guys have I never check or read them or care and I'm doing just fine in the game.
The accuracy ones and the ones that give +stress are pretty noticeable. It is also possible to get locked out of using any destresser until you deal with their quirk. I could dump dudes with bad traits but they cycle in and out so frequently even without any intervention. I don't really see the point when someone is inevitably going to get a bad trait. Might as well just level them and deal with it when it occurs, even if it is early.
I also think I solved the "not making enough gold problem." Just yolo it with no torch light. I made 17.1k in one medium run, and probably close to 15k after expenses, since cutting down on torch usage saves quite a bit of money. If I count item value, it was actually 22k pre-expenses. x_X
The biggest problem with FTL's difficulty at base is how much easier the game becomes to win once you unlock any other ship.
DD's issue is how spikey the difficulty is with the tiered dungeon system. Nafta's issue with leveling fresh recruits to 3 is corollary to this--there's no intermediate level between apprentice and veteran so the only way to safely get recruits to 3 is to grind them through easy dungeons.
In general, the most divisive mechanic in the game for most people seems to be the low level dungeon lockout. I'm curious what other people's feelings are on that.
On December 30 2015 03:57 TheYango wrote: The biggest problem with FTL's difficulty at base is how much easier the game becomes to win once you unlock any other ship.
DD's issue is how spikey the difficulty is with the tiered dungeon system. Nafta's issue with leveling fresh recruits to 3 is corollary to this--there's no intermediate level between apprentice and veteran so the only way to safely get recruits to 3 is to grind them through easy dungeons.
In general, the most divisive mechanic in the game for most people seems to be the low level dungeon lockout. I'm curious what other people's feelings are on that.
It's fine.
Keeps people from bringing high level heroes to babysit low level ones. You can still bring Level 1s to high level dungeons to level up with +exp scrolls, you just need to use some of the "Guard" skills like on Man at Arms to keep them from dying.
As there's no DnD tonight, I'm just going to continue and write the next part of my DD guide, characters/camping skills.
The vocals are fairly unique and I totally understand why some people wouldn't like it, but they've really grown on me in the last couple days.
My buddy just saw them in Cleveland a few weeks ago and I'm bummed because I didn't give them a chance until they came up on my Spotify Weekly Playlist last week. The whole album this song is on is real good. This is the song that came up: + Show Spoiler +
I beat the necromancer with my level 3 party. Was pretty proud of it! No losses in 17 weeks, mowed down the sonorous prophet, the siren, wizened hag, the inchoate flesh, the necromancer, and a collector+shambler combination during this time.
Only real two defeats were having to go home early after the collector+shambler got wasted, and then the brigand 8 pounder nearly one shot me... but I got away with no losses.