So, I'm using the correct pronouns. Take that Wave.
I'm not even sure that the Thai language has pronouns.
| Forum Index > The Shopkeeper′s Inn |
|
Ketara
United States15065 Posts
December 11 2015 22:29 GMT
#17141
So, I'm using the correct pronouns. Take that Wave. I'm not even sure that the Thai language has pronouns. | ||
|
Seuss
United States10536 Posts
December 11 2015 22:36 GMT
#17142
On December 12 2015 07:15 WaveofShadow wrote: Show nested quote + On December 12 2015 06:25 Seuss wrote: I miss Overwatch. It's definitely going to take over my gaming life. I haven't had this much fun being bad at a video game since I first played LoL. I'm totally Wood League in Overwatch but it's awesome. This comment brought to you by JimmiC's latest in GD, reminding me of all the advice I ever gave people about rank/performance and how all of it now applies to me again (especially "if you're losing most/all of your games, the common denominator is you"). If you're wood league I'm cellophane or paper league. You haven't seen me play Overwatch (or FPSs)! It's literally been a decade since I played an FPS versus other people with any regularity. | ||
|
jcarlsoniv
United States27922 Posts
December 11 2015 22:43 GMT
#17143
On December 12 2015 07:36 Seuss wrote: Show nested quote + On December 12 2015 07:15 WaveofShadow wrote: On December 12 2015 06:25 Seuss wrote: I miss Overwatch. It's definitely going to take over my gaming life. I haven't had this much fun being bad at a video game since I first played LoL. I'm totally Wood League in Overwatch but it's awesome. This comment brought to you by JimmiC's latest in GD, reminding me of all the advice I ever gave people about rank/performance and how all of it now applies to me again (especially "if you're losing most/all of your games, the common denominator is you"). If you're wood league I'm cellophane or paper league. You haven't seen me play Overwatch (or FPSs)! It's literally been a decade since I played an FPS versus other people with any regularity. You also haven't seen Wave play, lol but I agree, it's prob gonna take up a lot of my gaming focus | ||
|
Gahlo
United States35174 Posts
December 11 2015 22:46 GMT
#17144
On December 12 2015 06:28 Requizen wrote: Watching the All Stars makes me want to play LoL again But then I remember that I hate playing LoL Give Overwatch invite plz Eh, just wait till the season starts for gold skin. | ||
|
TheHumanSensation
Canada1210 Posts
December 11 2015 22:54 GMT
#17145
On December 12 2015 00:31 Eppa! wrote: Every harem needs a trap. Is this actually a thing in harem anime? I'm not a big anime person and the little I watch isn't hetshit, but I'd be down to watch something like a non-cisandrocentric polyamorous series (prefs more romance than sex), if those actually exist and if anyone has any recommendation(s). On December 12 2015 02:31 jcarlsoniv wrote: Has everyone who wants to be involved in Steamcret Santa given their info to dandelion? Dandel, do you have what you need from everyone who's shown interest? woops I'll do that now On December 12 2015 07:24 wei2coolman wrote: Show nested quote + On December 12 2015 07:15 WaveofShadow wrote: On December 12 2015 06:25 Seuss wrote: I miss Overwatch. It's definitely going to take over my gaming life. I haven't had this much fun being bad at a video game since I first played LoL. I'm totally Wood League in Overwatch but it's awesome. This comment brought to you by JimmiC's latest in GD, reminding me of all the advice I ever gave people about rank/performance and how all of it now applies to me again (especially "if you're losing most/all of your games, the common denominator is you"). If you're wood league I'm cellophane or paper league. Also want to make some sort of comment at pronoun usage when ladyboys are involved but.... triggered much? I'm pretty sure there are like a million culturally progressive problems that need to be reached first in Thailand before proper pronoun usage becomes a trigger problem for ladyboys. Gendered pronoun usage is purely about respect / respectability politics, so it's not an "oppression olympics" competition between issues. Using someone's preferred pronouns shows a respect for them and their lived experiences, intentionally disregarding it is disrespectful, and mistakes are just mistakes. Also, you don't have to respect everyone. However, keep in mind that "ladyboy" is for the most part simply a category of porn with the term promoted heavily by western industry, though it has roots in early thai->english translations. The actual terms in Thai are broad and don't refer to a singular gender experience (it's more like "[trans* and/or intersex +/- a few other things]" than it is like "trans women"), so a wide variety of english pronouns may be expected. There's also of course issues of translation, because pronouns don't necessarily reflect contemporary experiences of gender, nor does gender always translate cross-culturally. + Show Spoiler + Also if anyone cares I don't have a preference for pronouns referring to myself / anything is fine. | ||
|
Gahlo
United States35174 Posts
December 11 2015 22:57 GMT
#17146
| ||
|
wei2coolman
United States60033 Posts
December 11 2015 23:03 GMT
#17147
On December 12 2015 07:54 TheHumanSensation wrote: Show nested quote + On December 12 2015 07:24 wei2coolman wrote: On December 12 2015 07:15 WaveofShadow wrote: On December 12 2015 06:25 Seuss wrote: I miss Overwatch. It's definitely going to take over my gaming life. I haven't had this much fun being bad at a video game since I first played LoL. I'm totally Wood League in Overwatch but it's awesome. This comment brought to you by JimmiC's latest in GD, reminding me of all the advice I ever gave people about rank/performance and how all of it now applies to me again (especially "if you're losing most/all of your games, the common denominator is you"). If you're wood league I'm cellophane or paper league. Also want to make some sort of comment at pronoun usage when ladyboys are involved but.... triggered much? I'm pretty sure there are like a million culturally progressive problems that need to be reached first in Thailand before proper pronoun usage becomes a trigger problem for ladyboys. Gendered pronoun usage is purely about respect / respectability politics, so it's not an "oppression olympics" competition between issues. Using someone's preferred pronouns shows a respect for them and their lived experiences, intentionally disregarding it is disrespectful, and mistakes are just mistakes. Also, you don't have to respect everyone. However, keep in mind that "ladyboy" is for the most part simply a category of porn with the term promoted heavily by western industry, though it has roots in early thai->english translations. The actual terms in Thai are broad and don't refer to a singular gender experience (it's more like "[trans* and/or intersex +/- a few other things]" than it is like "trans women"), so a wide variety of english pronouns may be expected. There's also of course issues of translation, because pronouns don't necessarily reflect contemporary experiences of gender, nor does gender always translate cross-culturally. + Show Spoiler + Also if anyone cares I don't have a preference for pronouns referring to myself / anything is fine. It very is an oppression olympics, that's why the whole idea of "respecting pronoun usage" has historically not been a talking point until modern times. There are a ton of other social aspects a society needs address first, before proper pronoun usage for transgendered becomes a legitimate concern. For example, the whole idea of using "he or she" is a completely moot and non-existant problem if the reveal of being transgendered involves the transgendered individual being killed/lynched/beat-up/socially ostracized, etc. It'd be like complaining about a car tire that stops functioning after 50,000km, when the car blows up after 10,000km. While, yes, on this forum, where a majority of the people here live in a society where it's a legitimate sign of social respect to use proper pronouns, in other countries this is a legit non-problem because of a list of various other things. | ||
|
Dandel Ion
Austria17960 Posts
December 11 2015 23:06 GMT
#17148
On December 12 2015 02:31 jcarlsoniv wrote: Dandel, do you have what you need from everyone who's shown interest? i dont know if it's everyone that's shown interest but i probably have what i need from everyone that PM'd me. except asmo who seemed interest, but not much smart € also if you're not sure apparantly you can link your profile mite b gud if you dont know what your name is. i am not looking at soniv. | ||
|
Eppa!
Sweden4641 Posts
December 11 2015 23:07 GMT
#17149
| ||
|
Ketara
United States15065 Posts
December 11 2015 23:33 GMT
#17150
That's not to say there aren't problems. There are stigmas and issues. I've heard that gay people here have very poor social or job mobility, and are restricted to service industry type positions generally. But in my experience gay people here are openly gay and there isn't much reprisal. I have openly gay students in my high school classes. Ive literally been hit on and once straight up molested by gay Thais in public in broad daylight. I see a lot more guys walking around in skirts here than I do in America. I don't think it's a culture that lives underground at all. Which is not to say its more progressive than American homosexual culture. It's just different. The problems are different. I don't know that much about it though. I'd like to know more! | ||
|
Eppa!
Sweden4641 Posts
December 12 2015 00:10 GMT
#17151
On December 12 2015 08:03 wei2coolman wrote: Show nested quote + On December 12 2015 07:54 TheHumanSensation wrote: On December 12 2015 07:24 wei2coolman wrote: On December 12 2015 07:15 WaveofShadow wrote: On December 12 2015 06:25 Seuss wrote: I miss Overwatch. It's definitely going to take over my gaming life. I haven't had this much fun being bad at a video game since I first played LoL. I'm totally Wood League in Overwatch but it's awesome. This comment brought to you by JimmiC's latest in GD, reminding me of all the advice I ever gave people about rank/performance and how all of it now applies to me again (especially "if you're losing most/all of your games, the common denominator is you"). If you're wood league I'm cellophane or paper league. Also want to make some sort of comment at pronoun usage when ladyboys are involved but.... triggered much? I'm pretty sure there are like a million culturally progressive problems that need to be reached first in Thailand before proper pronoun usage becomes a trigger problem for ladyboys. Gendered pronoun usage is purely about respect / respectability politics, so it's not an "oppression olympics" competition between issues. Using someone's preferred pronouns shows a respect for them and their lived experiences, intentionally disregarding it is disrespectful, and mistakes are just mistakes. Also, you don't have to respect everyone. However, keep in mind that "ladyboy" is for the most part simply a category of porn with the term promoted heavily by western industry, though it has roots in early thai->english translations. The actual terms in Thai are broad and don't refer to a singular gender experience (it's more like "[trans* and/or intersex +/- a few other things]" than it is like "trans women"), so a wide variety of english pronouns may be expected. There's also of course issues of translation, because pronouns don't necessarily reflect contemporary experiences of gender, nor does gender always translate cross-culturally. + Show Spoiler + Also if anyone cares I don't have a preference for pronouns referring to myself / anything is fine. It very is an oppression olympics, that's why the whole idea of "respecting pronoun usage" has historically not been a talking point until modern times. There are a ton of other social aspects a society needs address first, before proper pronoun usage for transgendered becomes a legitimate concern. For example, the whole idea of using "he or she" is a completely moot and non-existant problem if the reveal of being transgendered involves the transgendered individual being killed/lynched/beat-up/socially ostracized, etc. It'd be like complaining about a car tire that stops functioning after 50,000km, when the car blows up after 10,000km. While, yes, on this forum, where a majority of the people here live in a society where it's a legitimate sign of social respect to use proper pronouns, in other countries this is a legit non-problem because of a list of various other things. But the children in Africa... | ||
|
TheHumanSensation
Canada1210 Posts
December 12 2015 00:12 GMT
#17152
On December 12 2015 07:57 Gahlo wrote: Please, can we not have this discussion again? Regardless of who is right or wrong, it's a shit show every time. I will keep my posts on the matter spoiler tagged and content labelled so you can ignore it. Let me know if this proves insufficient. On December 12 2015 08:07 Eppa! wrote: Swedish recently (ie last couple of years) got a gender neutral pronoun at it's quite useful. I heard about this and am a fan! Personally, I prefer the non-gendered model american sign language uses. There's only two pronouns (other than names and titles), one that points with 1 finger and roughly means "that person" (it can also be "me/I" or "you"), and an open-handed point that means the same thing but denotes possession. Titles (ex mother / father / parent) are still gendered using the same signs in different areas of the head (forehead for masculine, chin for feminine, ear for non-gendered / unspecified), though. On December 12 2015 08:03 wei2coolman wrote: Show nested quote + On December 12 2015 07:54 TheHumanSensation wrote: On December 12 2015 07:24 wei2coolman wrote: On December 12 2015 07:15 WaveofShadow wrote: On December 12 2015 06:25 Seuss wrote: I miss Overwatch. It's definitely going to take over my gaming life. I haven't had this much fun being bad at a video game since I first played LoL. I'm totally Wood League in Overwatch but it's awesome. This comment brought to you by JimmiC's latest in GD, reminding me of all the advice I ever gave people about rank/performance and how all of it now applies to me again (especially "if you're losing most/all of your games, the common denominator is you"). If you're wood league I'm cellophane or paper league. Also want to make some sort of comment at pronoun usage when ladyboys are involved but.... triggered much? I'm pretty sure there are like a million culturally progressive problems that need to be reached first in Thailand before proper pronoun usage becomes a trigger problem for ladyboys. Gendered pronoun usage is purely about respect / respectability politics, so it's not an "oppression olympics" competition between issues. Using someone's preferred pronouns shows a respect for them and their lived experiences, intentionally disregarding it is disrespectful, and mistakes are just mistakes. Also, you don't have to respect everyone. However, keep in mind that "ladyboy" is for the most part simply a category of porn with the term promoted heavily by western industry, though it has roots in early thai->english translations. The actual terms in Thai are broad and don't refer to a singular gender experience (it's more like "[trans* and/or intersex +/- a few other things]" than it is like "trans women"), so a wide variety of english pronouns may be expected. There's also of course issues of translation, because pronouns don't necessarily reflect contemporary experiences of gender, nor does gender always translate cross-culturally. + Show Spoiler + Also if anyone cares I don't have a preference for pronouns referring to myself / anything is fine. + Show Spoiler + It very is an oppression olympics, that's why the whole idea of "respecting pronoun usage" has historically not been a talking point until modern times. There are a ton of other social aspects a society needs address first, before proper pronoun usage for transgendered becomes a legitimate concern. For example, the whole idea of using "he or she" is a completely moot and non-existant problem if the reveal of being transgendered involves the transgendered individual being killed/lynched/beat-up/socially ostracized, etc. It'd be like complaining about a car tire that stops functioning after 50,000km, when the car blows up after 10,000km. While, yes, on this forum, where a majority of the people here live in a society where it's a legitimate sign of social respect to use proper pronouns, in other countries this is a legit non-problem because of a list of various other things. Content warning: I respond to wei2 + Show Spoiler + I don't think you understand what I said. I mean, I don't expect you to have a great grasp of anti-oppression frameworks, given your conceptualization of the issues as "triggers triggers triggers", but I'm still gonna try to explain what I said in more detail here. I said "Gendered pronoun usage is purely about respect / respectability politics". What I mean by this statement is that respect / respectability politics is an underlying issue, and gendered pronouns are simply one instance/symptom of this underlying issue. Other examples of this same underlying issue would be conversational racism, conversational sexism, or conversational classism. Generally, conversational [any form of oppression]. These issues are for the most part merely about respect / respectability politics. Some issues are more deeply intertwined with or purely about violent and/or institutional oppression. For example, gendered or racialized acts of violence / hate crimes, restrictions on who can vote, or contemporary economic barriers in a capitalist society with a long history of unequal wealth distribution along lines of race. I agree with you that violent and institutional issues are a more serious/pressing matter and are more worthy of focused attention than issues of respectability politics (though the two are intertwined systemically). However, this is not what the term "oppression olympics" refers to. An "oppression olympics" is conceptualization of oppression, typically used by people with no particularly significant experience dealing in issues of non-personal oppression, in which different groups have to compete for attention on the same issues. For example, a person from a long time ago may think "I won't what's more serious in America - same sex marriage or letting black people vote?" or any other variation of the "gays v blacks" situation. This conceptualization is typically considered joke-tier, because it doesn't reflect reality very well or have any scholarly backing to it - this is to say that there isn't really a "gays v blacks" situation, it's just an abstraction. Your examples aren't examples of an "oppression olympics", just examples of "step 1 before step 2". You can google the term to learn more about it if you want, but it's mostly here due to miscommunication between us. However, your examples are problematic or false. Specifically... "the whole idea of "respecting pronoun usage" has historically not been a talking point until modern times This is false - it just hasn't entered the mainstream media attention in America / captured your attention. It's historically been significant in many smaller trans*/queer communities throughout both America and the rest of the world, or a non-issue because pronouns were already respected. For example, the whole idea of using "he or she" is a completely moot and non-existant problem if the reveal of being transgendered involves the transgendered individual being killed/lynched/beat-up/socially ostracized, etc. Yes, someone has to be alive to be oppressed. However, not every oppressed person is killed. For example, it is very clear that not all ladyboys in thailand are dead, and you have a not-dead queer person talking to you right now. These issues affect and matter to the people who aren't dead. There are a ton of other social aspects a society needs address first, before proper pronoun usage for transgendered becomes a legitimate concern Legitimate concern to who? What makes it legitimate? A problem is a problem regardless of whether or not there are larger / more dangerous problems present. This also assumes the problems are completely unrelated, which isn't the case - transphobia is a systemic issue, which has many problematic outputs ranging from conversational to physically violent. The conversational aspects and respectability politics of it socially reinforce the legitimacy of transphobia. This is to say that the erasure of the pronoun issue defends the more violence aspects of transphobia. This is a basic tenet of systemic oppression, and it's not particularly difficult to conceptualize - if you think of some group of people as inferior, less human, or less worthy of respect, it becomes much easier to justify violence against that group (refer to any war or donald trump for examples). To give you a more thorough example related to the previous quote, while I'm obviously not dead I have been attacked verbally and physically in public before. These attacks have always involved significant amounts of conversational transphobia, and always people saying something like "triggered yet?". To be blunt, your shit understanding of the issue makes it more of an issue, because dehumanization and assault go hand-in-hand. While, yes, on this forum, where a majority of the people here live in a society where it's a legitimate sign of social respect to use proper pronouns, in other countries this is a legit non-problem because of a list of various other things. 1.) Thailand is not such a place. 2.) You can choose to (dis/)respect people regardless of how big of a social issue it is. | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31495 Posts
December 12 2015 00:14 GMT
#17153
On December 12 2015 07:36 Seuss wrote: Show nested quote + On December 12 2015 07:15 WaveofShadow wrote: On December 12 2015 06:25 Seuss wrote: I miss Overwatch. It's definitely going to take over my gaming life. I haven't had this much fun being bad at a video game since I first played LoL. I'm totally Wood League in Overwatch but it's awesome. This comment brought to you by JimmiC's latest in GD, reminding me of all the advice I ever gave people about rank/performance and how all of it now applies to me again (especially "if you're losing most/all of your games, the common denominator is you"). If you're wood league I'm cellophane or paper league. You haven't seen me play Overwatch (or FPSs)! It's literally been a decade since I played an FPS versus other people with any regularity. My only fps experience pre-overwatch is Goldeneye. | ||
|
ComaDose
Canada10357 Posts
December 12 2015 00:24 GMT
#17154
| ||
|
wei2coolman
United States60033 Posts
December 12 2015 00:27 GMT
#17155
On December 12 2015 09:24 ComaDose wrote: way too cool to try and respect people while there is poverty in Thailand man That's some FoxNews tier strawman representation of my point. + Show Spoiler + On December 12 2015 09:12 TheHumanSensation wrote: Show nested quote + On December 12 2015 07:57 Gahlo wrote: Please, can we not have this discussion again? Regardless of who is right or wrong, it's a shit show every time. I will keep my posts on the matter spoiler tagged and content labelled so you can ignore it. Let me know if this proves insufficient. Show nested quote + On December 12 2015 08:07 Eppa! wrote: Swedish recently (ie last couple of years) got a gender neutral pronoun at it's quite useful. I heard about this and am a fan! Personally, I prefer the non-gendered model american sign language uses. There's only two pronouns (other than names and titles), one that points with 1 finger and roughly means "that person" (it can also be "me/I" or "you"), and an open-handed point that means the same thing but denotes possession. Titles (ex mother / father / parent) are still gendered using the same signs in different areas of the head (forehead for masculine, chin for feminine, ear for non-gendered / unspecified), though. Show nested quote + On December 12 2015 08:03 wei2coolman wrote: On December 12 2015 07:54 TheHumanSensation wrote: On December 12 2015 07:24 wei2coolman wrote: On December 12 2015 07:15 WaveofShadow wrote: On December 12 2015 06:25 Seuss wrote: I miss Overwatch. It's definitely going to take over my gaming life. I haven't had this much fun being bad at a video game since I first played LoL. I'm totally Wood League in Overwatch but it's awesome. This comment brought to you by JimmiC's latest in GD, reminding me of all the advice I ever gave people about rank/performance and how all of it now applies to me again (especially "if you're losing most/all of your games, the common denominator is you"). If you're wood league I'm cellophane or paper league. Also want to make some sort of comment at pronoun usage when ladyboys are involved but.... triggered much? I'm pretty sure there are like a million culturally progressive problems that need to be reached first in Thailand before proper pronoun usage becomes a trigger problem for ladyboys. Gendered pronoun usage is purely about respect / respectability politics, so it's not an "oppression olympics" competition between issues. Using someone's preferred pronouns shows a respect for them and their lived experiences, intentionally disregarding it is disrespectful, and mistakes are just mistakes. Also, you don't have to respect everyone. However, keep in mind that "ladyboy" is for the most part simply a category of porn with the term promoted heavily by western industry, though it has roots in early thai->english translations. The actual terms in Thai are broad and don't refer to a singular gender experience (it's more like "[trans* and/or intersex +/- a few other things]" than it is like "trans women"), so a wide variety of english pronouns may be expected. There's also of course issues of translation, because pronouns don't necessarily reflect contemporary experiences of gender, nor does gender always translate cross-culturally. + Show Spoiler + Also if anyone cares I don't have a preference for pronouns referring to myself / anything is fine. + Show Spoiler + It very is an oppression olympics, that's why the whole idea of "respecting pronoun usage" has historically not been a talking point until modern times. There are a ton of other social aspects a society needs address first, before proper pronoun usage for transgendered becomes a legitimate concern. For example, the whole idea of using "he or she" is a completely moot and non-existant problem if the reveal of being transgendered involves the transgendered individual being killed/lynched/beat-up/socially ostracized, etc. It'd be like complaining about a car tire that stops functioning after 50,000km, when the car blows up after 10,000km. While, yes, on this forum, where a majority of the people here live in a society where it's a legitimate sign of social respect to use proper pronouns, in other countries this is a legit non-problem because of a list of various other things. Content warning: I respond to wei2 + Show Spoiler + I don't think you understand what I said. I mean, I don't expect you to have a great grasp of anti-oppression frameworks, given your conceptualization of the issues as "triggers triggers triggers", but I'm still gonna try to explain what I said in more detail here. I said "Gendered pronoun usage is purely about respect / respectability politics". What I mean by this statement is that respect / respectability politics is an underlying issue, and gendered pronouns are simply one instance/symptom of this underlying issue. Other examples of this same underlying issue would be conversational racism, conversational sexism, or conversational classism. Generally, conversational [any form of oppression]. These issues are for the most part merely about respect / respectability politics. Some issues are more deeply intertwined with or purely about violent and/or institutional oppression. For example, gendered or racialized acts of violence / hate crimes, restrictions on who can vote, or contemporary economic barriers in a capitalist society with a long history of unequal wealth distribution along lines of race. I agree with you that violent and institutional issues are a more serious/pressing matter and are more worthy of focused attention than issues of respectability politics (though the two are intertwined systemically). However, this is not what the term "oppression olympics" refers to. An "oppression olympics" is conceptualization of oppression, typically used by people with no particularly significant experience dealing in issues of non-personal oppression, in which different groups have to compete for attention on the same issues. For example, a person from a long time ago may think "I won't what's more serious in America - same sex marriage or letting black people vote?" or any other variation of the "gays v blacks" situation. This conceptualization is typically considered joke-tier, because it doesn't reflect reality very well or have any scholarly backing to it - this is to say that there isn't really a "gays v blacks" situation, it's just an abstraction. Your examples aren't examples of an "oppression olympics", just examples of "step 1 before step 2". You can google the term to learn more about it if you want, but it's mostly here due to miscommunication between us. However, your examples are problematic or false. Specifically... "the whole idea of "respecting pronoun usage" has historically not been a talking point until modern times This is false - it just hasn't entered the mainstream media attention in America / captured your attention. It's historically been significant in many smaller trans*/queer communities throughout both America and the rest of the world, or a non-issue because pronouns were already respected. For example, the whole idea of using "he or she" is a completely moot and non-existant problem if the reveal of being transgendered involves the transgendered individual being killed/lynched/beat-up/socially ostracized, etc. Yes, someone has to be alive to be oppressed. However, not every oppressed person is killed. For example, it is very clear that not all ladyboys in thailand are dead, and you have a not-dead queer person talking to you right now. These issues affect and matter to the people who aren't dead. There are a ton of other social aspects a society needs address first, before proper pronoun usage for transgendered becomes a legitimate concern Legitimate concern to who? What makes it legitimate? A problem is a problem regardless of whether or not there are larger / more dangerous problems present. This also assumes the problems are completely unrelated, which isn't the case - transphobia is a systemic issue, which has many problematic outputs ranging from conversational to physically violent. The conversational aspects and respectability politics of it socially reinforce the legitimacy of transphobia. This is to say that the erasure of the pronoun issue defends the more violence aspects of transphobia. This is a basic tenet of systemic oppression, and it's not particularly difficult to conceptualize - if you think of some group of people as inferior, less human, or less worthy of respect, it becomes much easier to justify violence against that group (refer to any war or donald trump for examples). To give you a more thorough example related to the previous quote, while I'm obviously not dead I have been attacked verbally and physically in public before. These attacks have always involved significant amounts of conversational transphobia, and always people saying something like "triggered yet?". To be blunt, your shit understanding of the issue makes it more of an issue, because dehumanization and assault go hand-in-hand. While, yes, on this forum, where a majority of the people here live in a society where it's a legitimate sign of social respect to use proper pronouns, in other countries this is a legit non-problem because of a list of various other things. 1.) Thailand is not such a place. 2.) You can choose to (dis/)respect people regardless of how big of a social issue it is. + Show Spoiler + I'd mirror it akin to the hierarchy of needs. Proper gender pronouns, while yes, should be respected, because it is important to respect a way someone wants to be identified as (such a Doctor who's insistent you call him/her 'Doctor XYZ'). While my initial comment may seem like I don't care for proper gender pronouns, it was more a commentary on the current ambiguity of current Thailand social interactions between the transgendered culture and population to the more traditionally conservative majority. So while, yes in the pockets of transgender Thai's, the whole "proper pronoun" usage might be a legitimate concern and topic at hand, the overarching interaction and public conversations (discussions) between the public and the transgendered population haven't reached a point where this conversation makes sense to have. I'm not saying this conversation isn't important to have, but I'm saying in the current social climate in Thailand, it's putting the cart before the horse. | ||
|
Ketara
United States15065 Posts
December 12 2015 00:29 GMT
#17156
I forgot his name already. | ||
|
TheHumanSensation
Canada1210 Posts
December 12 2015 00:36 GMT
#17157
On December 12 2015 09:29 Ketara wrote: Who's the guy that trolled us with issues like this and made us all ragey. I forgot his name already. Good 'ol sonnyboy. Also his pms to me were at least a little funny. | ||
|
Ketara
United States15065 Posts
December 12 2015 00:51 GMT
#17158
https://www.into-asia.com/thai_language/grammar/pronouns.php Apparently when referring to people other than yourself there's no gender on pronouns in Thai. | ||
|
crimethinking
Vietnam765 Posts
December 12 2015 01:04 GMT
#17159
On December 12 2015 07:57 Gahlo wrote: Please, can we not have this discussion again? Regardless of who is right or wrong, it's a shit show every time. I go to LLL to escape from political correctness and SJWism, turns out I am wrong. | ||
|
Dandel Ion
Austria17960 Posts
December 12 2015 01:12 GMT
#17160
| ||
| ||
StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War Britney Dota 2Calm Bisu EffOrt Horang2 Light Larva Stork ggaemo actioN [ Show more ] Counter-Strike Heroes of the Storm Other Games Organizations Other Games
StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War League of Legends Other Games |
|
OSC
Replay Cast
University League
GSL
Maru vs Dark
Patches Events
OSC
Replay Cast
KCM Race Survival
Ultimate Battle
ZerO vs Bisu
RSL Revival
[ Show More ] BSL
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
IPSL
Ret vs ggnore13
nOmaD vs Aether
BSL
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
WardiTV Weekly
Kung Fu Cup
Solar vs Classic
ByuN vs SHIN
PiGosaur Cup
|
|
|