|
On November 21 2015 04:22 Requizen wrote: Ugh, the tourney I'm going to on Sunday changed their ruleset from 1 LoW to "up to 700 points". And just like that, I don't want to go anymore... What do you mean by LoW?
Also aren't 500 - 550 point armies standard?
I assume that you're talking about Warhammer 40k!
|
On November 21 2015 04:24 Frudgey wrote:Show nested quote +On November 21 2015 04:22 Requizen wrote: Ugh, the tourney I'm going to on Sunday changed their ruleset from 1 LoW to "up to 700 points". And just like that, I don't want to go anymore... What do you mean by LoW? Also aren't 500 - 550 point armies standard? I assume that you're talking about Warhammer 40k! No way man, the tournament standard is 1850. 500 points is barely enough for like 4 squads of dudes, depending on army.
LoW is Lord of War. These are your Titans, your Baneblades, your Eldar Revenants. You know, the big things that can take on armies by themselves.
The issue is, nowadays, that GW decided to make the Wraithknight into a Lord of War, which came with substantial boosts - Destroyer Weaponry, Feel No Pain, immunity to Poison and Sniper weapons, the ability to shoot at multiple units, and Stomp, which is the most bullshit rule in the game. Which would have been fine - if they decided to not make it only 300 points. Which is about the cost of 3-4 squads of Space Marines. This is extremely underpriced, especially since most worthwhile LoWs live in the 400+ point range and are much less effective.
Now, limited to one, that's not too bad and you can kind of just play around it. Sacrifice it some mooks every other turn and run your expensive models away from it while trying to chip away at the rest of his army. But at 700 points you can bring two, which is, in a word, stupid.
|
On November 21 2015 04:15 Alaric wrote: Being in borderless windowed def. doesn't help my performances, I guess. If I slow down too much I'll try getting back to full screen.
I didn't get an email, btw. I was noticing some stuff updating when I went for my HS quests (I think it was some SC2 or Heroes optimisation?) so I clicked on the Overwatch tab and noticed I could download it. That's all. So we could just check if you haven't already. Well I look forward to seeing I got in when I check my launcher tonight! 
I've actually never played a PC FPS so that should be interesting.
|
On November 21 2015 04:38 Requizen wrote:Show nested quote +On November 21 2015 04:24 Frudgey wrote:On November 21 2015 04:22 Requizen wrote: Ugh, the tourney I'm going to on Sunday changed their ruleset from 1 LoW to "up to 700 points". And just like that, I don't want to go anymore... What do you mean by LoW? Also aren't 500 - 550 point armies standard? I assume that you're talking about Warhammer 40k! No way man, the tournament standard is 1850. 500 points is barely enough for like 4 squads of dudes, depending on army. LoW is Lord of War. These are your Titans, your Baneblades, your Eldar Revenants. You know, the big things that can take on armies by themselves. The issue is, nowadays, that GW decided to make the Wraithknight into a Lord of War, which came with substantial boosts - Destroyer Weaponry, Feel No Pain, immunity to Poison and Sniper weapons, the ability to shoot at multiple units, and Stomp, which is the most bullshit rule in the game. Which would have been fine - if they decided to not make it only 300 points. Which is about the cost of 3-4 squads of Space Marines. This is extremely underpriced, especially since most worthwhile LoWs live in the 400+ point range and are much less effective. Now, limited to one, that's not too bad and you can kind of just play around it. Sacrifice it some mooks every other turn and run your expensive models away from it while trying to chip away at the rest of his army. But at 700 points you can bring two, which is, in a word, stupid. So what you're saying is the Wraithknight is too oppressive in the meta with many defined strengths, no solid weaknesses, and an overabundance of mechanics that makes it unfun to play against.
Also, fucking lol $115.
|
On November 21 2015 04:52 Gahlo wrote:Show nested quote +On November 21 2015 04:38 Requizen wrote:On November 21 2015 04:24 Frudgey wrote:On November 21 2015 04:22 Requizen wrote: Ugh, the tourney I'm going to on Sunday changed their ruleset from 1 LoW to "up to 700 points". And just like that, I don't want to go anymore... What do you mean by LoW? Also aren't 500 - 550 point armies standard? I assume that you're talking about Warhammer 40k! No way man, the tournament standard is 1850. 500 points is barely enough for like 4 squads of dudes, depending on army. LoW is Lord of War. These are your Titans, your Baneblades, your Eldar Revenants. You know, the big things that can take on armies by themselves. The issue is, nowadays, that GW decided to make the Wraithknight into a Lord of War, which came with substantial boosts - Destroyer Weaponry, Feel No Pain, immunity to Poison and Sniper weapons, the ability to shoot at multiple units, and Stomp, which is the most bullshit rule in the game. Which would have been fine - if they decided to not make it only 300 points. Which is about the cost of 3-4 squads of Space Marines. This is extremely underpriced, especially since most worthwhile LoWs live in the 400+ point range and are much less effective. Now, limited to one, that's not too bad and you can kind of just play around it. Sacrifice it some mooks every other turn and run your expensive models away from it while trying to chip away at the rest of his army. But at 700 points you can bring two, which is, in a word, stupid. So what you're saying is the Wraithknight is too oppressive in the meta with many defined strengths, no solid weaknesses, and an overabundance of mechanics that makes it unfun to play against. Also, fucking lol $115. Yeah more or less. It's not... overpowered. I don't quit as soon as I see one. Some armies have ways to deal with it - Tau have lots of high-strength fire with rerolls and stuff that can chop it down, Space Marines have the extremely strong yet balanced Grav weaponry, Daemons have fast moving melee units that can chop it down reliably, and Daemons don't give a shit because they're just going to summon 1000 extra points of dudes that you have to chew through.
But if your army doesn't have the tools to deal with it reliably, it's incredibly frustrating. Necrons... don't. There are gimmick lists that can sort of deal with them, but nothing reliable and those gimmicks fail against a lot of other armies. So one can be a pain, and then two is... something even worse.
|
Sad day. Chinese Dota is dead. Azarkon was right all along.
|
Now we just need TSM to win worlds and all the prophecies will be fulfilled.
|
Czech Republic11293 Posts
holy fuck Im exhausted after studying yesterday for 12+ hours straight and now it's weekend and I have so much homework and studying to do jesus christ LT was right Im getting raped
someone please reassure me that I'll get stronger
|
Do it drunk, it'll make the time go by faster.
|
United States47024 Posts
On November 21 2015 04:15 Frudgey wrote: I can elaborate more if you want, but basically the long story short of it is that 3.5 is more realistic than 5th edition, but 5th edition plays more like a "game" than 3.5. I should also mention that I personally think 5th edition is waaaaaaaaay more balanced. That might just be me though. 3.5's not really more realistic than 5e.
One of the hallmarks of 3.5e is ridiculously fast growth in character abilities over a short period of time/number of levels (not just true of casters, but also of non-casters if you consider rate of advancement for BAB/saving throws/class skills + rate of acquisition of magic items). The only fantasy universe that actually matches this rate of character advancement are actually "game" settings e.g. Warcraft. 5e character development matches up far better with book-fantasy.
I actually had a discussion a while back with someone where I argued that 5e is actually MORE imbalanced and caster-favored than 3.5e. There's better balance in terms of numerical combat power and less purely degenerate things that actively break a game, but in terms of qualitative power (i.e. skills that solve problems in a role-playing scenario and not just ability to kill/incapacitate enemies), the gap in ability between a caster and a non-caster is actually wider in 5e for a number of reasons.
|
Is it even fair to compare though? 3.5e was an addendum on top of 3rd edition; so of course there's going to be more refinement.
As far as advancement, that's super dependent on the DM, regardless of edition.
|
United States47024 Posts
On November 21 2015 05:55 wei2coolman wrote: Is it even fair to compare though? 3.5e was an addendum on top of 3rd edition; so of course there's going to be more refinement. The comparative imbalance in 5e that I refer to is still present if you compare 3e to 5e and ignore 3.5.
It's actually a fundamental problem of how WotC scaled back the strengh of spells numerically but still preserved the qualitative effects of most spells--while at the same time toning down the rate of growth of mundane abilities through skills and drastically reduced the power of by-the-book magic items. The end result being that "qualitative-power" spells like image spells, Charm Person, Invisibility, Polymorph, etc. are strictly speaking less powerful than their 3rd edition counterparts, but are more powerful in a relative sense due to their effects now being harder/impossible to replicate through mundane means, and harder to acquire through acquisition of magical tools for mundane characters.
On November 21 2015 05:55 wei2coolman wrote: As far as advancement, that's super dependent on the DM, regardless of edition. What does a DM do though? The only real solutions without massively overhauling the entire ruleset result in just slowing down XP acquisition. All you can do is space out levels further apart and leveling once every 10 sessions is kind of boring.
|
On November 21 2015 05:49 TheYango wrote:Show nested quote +On November 21 2015 04:15 Frudgey wrote: I can elaborate more if you want, but basically the long story short of it is that 3.5 is more realistic than 5th edition, but 5th edition plays more like a "game" than 3.5. I should also mention that I personally think 5th edition is waaaaaaaaay more balanced. That might just be me though. 3.5's not really more realistic than 5e. One of the hallmarks of 3.5e is ridiculously fast growth in character abilities over a short period of time/number of levels (not just true of casters, but also of non-casters if you consider rate of advancement for BAB/saving throws/class skills + rate of acquisition of magic items). The only fantasy universe that actually matches this rate of character advancement are actually "game" settings e.g. Warcraft. 5e character development matches up far better with book-fantasy. I actually had a discussion a while back with someone where I argued that 5e is actually MORE imbalanced and caster-favored than 3.5e. There's better balance in terms of numerical combat power and less purely degenerate things that actively break a game, but in terms of qualitative power (i.e. skills that solve problems in a role-playing scenario and not just ability to kill/incapacitate enemies), the gap in ability between a caster and a non-caster is actually wider in 5e for a number of reasons. I don't think my friends will even think to use spells in non-combat scenarios since they're totally brand new. I thought about 3.5e cause there is an online archive of most of the rules but the basic rules on the WotC site should be more than enough for this short quest.
I'm more trying to gauge interest with this, if they actually end up liking it I'll think harder on coming up with an actual campaign.
|
On November 21 2015 06:01 Nos- wrote:Show nested quote +On November 21 2015 05:49 TheYango wrote:On November 21 2015 04:15 Frudgey wrote: I can elaborate more if you want, but basically the long story short of it is that 3.5 is more realistic than 5th edition, but 5th edition plays more like a "game" than 3.5. I should also mention that I personally think 5th edition is waaaaaaaaay more balanced. That might just be me though. 3.5's not really more realistic than 5e. One of the hallmarks of 3.5e is ridiculously fast growth in character abilities over a short period of time/number of levels (not just true of casters, but also of non-casters if you consider rate of advancement for BAB/saving throws/class skills + rate of acquisition of magic items). The only fantasy universe that actually matches this rate of character advancement are actually "game" settings e.g. Warcraft. 5e character development matches up far better with book-fantasy. I actually had a discussion a while back with someone where I argued that 5e is actually MORE imbalanced and caster-favored than 3.5e. There's better balance in terms of numerical combat power and less purely degenerate things that actively break a game, but in terms of qualitative power (i.e. skills that solve problems in a role-playing scenario and not just ability to kill/incapacitate enemies), the gap in ability between a caster and a non-caster is actually wider in 5e for a number of reasons. I don't think my friends will even think to use spells in non-combat scenarios since they're totally brand new. I thought about 3.5e cause there is an online archive of most of the rules but the basic rules on the WotC site should be more than enough for this short quest. I'm more trying to gauge interest with this, if they actually end up liking it I'll think harder on coming up with an actual campaign. 3.5e still way better just because wealth of resources.
Also, using spells and skills outside of combat always a hallmark in DnD imo. Brute forcing shit is pretty boring, if I just wanted to play a combat oriented RPG, I'd just play a computer game.
|
United States47024 Posts
Elaborating a bit on my earlier point:
The example I use for this is the Invisibility spell. In 3.5e, Invisibility is, in an absolute sense, much stronger than it's 5e counterpart--no concentration limitation and scaling duration on caster level. It's effect is, however, fundamentally replaceable. While at the level it acquired, it typically isn't, full-advancement skill users raise Hide skill very quickly. +1 skill point per level, temporary boosts to Dexterity, synergy bonuses, masterwork tools, etc.--a skill user can very quickly reach +20 or more Hide skill. While not granting him actual invisibility, this subsumes the expected function of Invisibility in most cases, while being outright better in many others (i.e. situations where anti-magic or divinations are involved), all the while being an at-will power. And if magical invisibility is truly necessary, magical sources of invisibility that can be used by mundane characters can easily be acquired even at the time when Invisibility becomes available to the Wizard. All in all, the Invisibility spell is powerful but replaceable--role-playing scenarios that can be overcome using it can be overcome through methods that do not require a caster in the party.
Contrast this with 5e. The slow proficiency-based advancement of skills means that the mundane skill-user NEVER catches up to real invisibility. The modifier needed to replicate it is simply too high, and the rate of skill advancement too low. Compounded with the lower availability of powerful magic items in general, you have a situation where, despite Invisibility being weaker, it is actually irreplaceable because a party that does not have a Wizard never gains analogous abilities that can serve its function.
On November 21 2015 06:06 wei2coolman wrote: 3.5e still way better just because wealth of resources. Well, first of all there's literally no reason for a new play-group to play stock 3.5 over Pathfinder. Functionally, Pathfinder is just a better system, and the only real argument for 3.5 over Pathfinder is familiarity, which is not applicable to a new play-group. Resources such as the SRD for 3.5 also exist for Pathfinder, so this is not an argument in favor of 3.5.
Pathfinder vs. 5e is a more interesting discussion. As I said before, I think Pathfinder is a more robust system overall than 5e, but 5e is undoubtedly more accessible to a new player.
|
Haven't observed any high level 5e, this still true at higher levels?
|
United States47024 Posts
On November 21 2015 06:12 wei2coolman wrote: Haven't observed any high level 5e, this still true at higher levels? Proficiency bonuses for all characters scale from +2 to +6 over 20 levels, which is absolutely tiny. If you look at the function of all "skill-replicable" spells like Invisibility or Charm spells, the effect of those spells is essentially unbeatable through mundane means.
In some cases in 3e/3.5e the mundane methods became rapidly more effective due to opposed skill checks being far more reliable than hoping for failed saves.
|
Yango you bring up some very interesting points of discussion about Dungeons and Dragons. I'd like to ask you more if that's not a problem!
What makes you say that Pathfinder is better than 3.5? Is there anything in particular?
But I never thought about balance from a role playing perspective. Very, very interesting point you bring up with the invisibility spell as an example.
I also assume you prefer Pathfinder over 5th edition? I know that one of the reasons why I like 5th edition more than 3.5 is because there is less source material. With 3.5 character creation can feel pretty stressful sometimes because I feel a very strong urge to optimize my character. I would also argue (perhaps with lack of understanding!) that 3.5 allows you to min/max more than fifth edition, which can be exhausting for me sometimes.
And I know that I *could* not worry about making a super optimized character, but if I don't create such a character, the thought "I could have made him better" lingers with me. I know this criticism is more personal weakness than the game's fault, but I just figured I'd mention it.
|
United States47024 Posts
On November 21 2015 07:33 Frudgey wrote: What makes you say that Pathfinder is better than 3.5? Is there anything in particular? From the last time the discussion came up:
On October 24 2015 03:16 TheYango wrote:+ Show Spoiler +On October 24 2015 03:06 Zdrastochye wrote: Is Pathfinder similar to 3.5? Yes. The core design is the same, but certain aspects of the system were cleaned up. Of note: - XP gain cleaned up and variant XP gain options introduced that allow you to better tailor the power growth of a party (party leveling up and gaining unrealistically powerful abilities too quickly is a problem of 3E) - Rules for special combat maneuvers vastly simplified (grappling, bull rushing, sundering, disarming, etc. are all pointlessly complicated in 3E) - Multiclassing tweaked to be less punishing/more flexible (you don't get an XP penalty but instead get minor bonus stats for staying single-classed). 3E multiclassing was pointlessly punishing for players who didn't know what they were doing while failing to be a deterrent for players who abused the fact that prestige classes don't count toward the multiclass XP penalty in 3E. - Feats are granted more frequently but are less powerful (every odd level rather than every 3rd level) - Skill system cleaned up. Pointlessly specific skills were aggregated, the level 1 4x skill points granted was removed, and the class/cross-class distinction was removed for skill point spending/caps. You instead just get a flat +3 to skills your class is proficient in if you've spent skill points in them. Much simpler, less bookkeeping, and less prone to powergaming abuses. - More class abilities, spread out across class levels, most of which scale with class levels. This accomplishes 2 things: 1) discourages 1-level "dipping" to powergame and get level 1 value abilities, and 2) avoids "dead levels"--levels where a character does not gain any notable new abilities, which are universally regarded as bad design - Rebalance of spells. Cantrips are at-will like in 5E, general cleanup of acknowledged broken spells in 3E (polymorph neutered, rebalance of all XP-cost spells to not have XP costs but produce correspondingly weaker effects) A lot of similar changes were made in 5E, though 5E also introduced some vastly more radical design philosophy changes, partly inherited from 4E. Pathfinder is preferable for people who want that 3.5E "feel", while 5E has somewhat smoother and slower progression (attack bonuses/skills don't scale up on a level-by-level basis, lower rate of gold and magic item acquisition, and systemic restrictions on certain aspects of spellcasting tend to temper a party's overall power growth--making for a very different campaign experience from 3.5E/Pathfinder).
In general Pathfinder addresses a lot of the same issues that 5e has in somewhat different ways, while still sticking to the spirit of 3.5e much more.
On November 21 2015 07:33 Frudgey wrote: I also assume you prefer Pathfinder over 5th edition? I know that one of the reasons why I like 5th edition more than 3.5 is because there is less source material. With 3.5 character creation can feel pretty stressful sometimes because I feel a very strong urge to optimize my character. I would also argue (perhaps with lack of understanding!) that 3.5 allows you to min/max more than fifth edition, which can be exhausting for me sometimes.
I prefer Pathfinder over 3.5e, but I've played more 3.5e simply due to being personally more familiar and my play group being more familiar. I think that's a completely legitimate reason to play 3.5e instead of Pathfinder, but also not relevant to the case being discussed with regard to a new play group.
I personally would also rather play Pathfinder than 5e but that's again because my play group is relatively experienced with 3.5e. With a fresh play group, I would start them on 5e.
|
On November 21 2015 05:38 Scip wrote: holy fuck Im exhausted after studying yesterday for 12+ hours straight and now it's weekend and I have so much homework and studying to do jesus christ LT was right Im getting raped
someone please reassure me that I'll get stronger I know the feeling; worked 70 hours the past 6 days and I am working tomorrow.
On November 21 2015 00:54 AlterKot wrote:Show nested quote +On November 21 2015 00:00 AlterKot wrote: Probably
Fuck asmo is gonna warn me errr penis penis kill la kill
User was warned for this post Reason is "martyring" btw so i guess artificially increaasing word count is ok. User was temp banned for this post.
Worth!
|
|
|
|
|
|