|
I don't know why I'm awake right now..
Brood War is a fun game to play and watch people better then you play.
Age of Empires 2 is a fun game to play and learn about.
I like them both. I wanted to like SC2. I think we all did to a degree. I worry that Overwatch despite a good box model will try to sell DLC characters later down the road and won't allow for people to do all the fun mapmaking, custom games, private servers of varying degrees of hilarity that has made TF2 last for so long.
Lastly, nostralrius is on what vanilla patch? IE: on a scale of 1 to 10 how screwed am I by Rogues? Yeah I remember those days. I even contributed to it once the ZG trinkets hit and things got really out of hand.
|
Nostralrius is on ZG patch right now, 1.10 coming soon, AQ in the spring, naxx next summer. info on their homepage. Dunno how much is shifting regarding the basics of the game or if it's just content that's following the schedule. Hmm win-fury shaman or another warrior... Or a warlock or another hunter... I'll just make one of each on the different realms so long.
|
On November 07 2015 13:47 Ketara wrote: You know what I wanted to see in sc2?
More stuff in maps.
Like, one of the coolest sc2 moments for me was in the first gsl finals, when fruitdealer used the high grass terrain to kill a reaper with a zergling. That shit was so cool.
Stuff like gold minerals, tall grass, watchtowers, those sorts of mechanics actually change gameplay from map to map and are awesome. I wanted more of that. I wanted terrain that slowed ground units. I wanted terrain that blocked vision between air and ground, etc.
The community by and large wanted less of that.
Sc2 died for me when I felt like maps were all big identical blobs with different tilesets. They talked about wanting to increase the amount of interesting maps for LotV, dunno if it will actually happen because people tend to complain. One of the maps that got shown in a video had like 6 gold bases or something though.
|
On November 07 2015 22:11 Ansibled wrote:Show nested quote +On November 07 2015 13:47 Ketara wrote: You know what I wanted to see in sc2?
More stuff in maps.
Like, one of the coolest sc2 moments for me was in the first gsl finals, when fruitdealer used the high grass terrain to kill a reaper with a zergling. That shit was so cool.
Stuff like gold minerals, tall grass, watchtowers, those sorts of mechanics actually change gameplay from map to map and are awesome. I wanted more of that. I wanted terrain that slowed ground units. I wanted terrain that blocked vision between air and ground, etc.
The community by and large wanted less of that.
Sc2 died for me when I felt like maps were all big identical blobs with different tilesets. They talked about wanting to increase the amount of interesting maps for LotV, dunno if it will actually happen because people tend to complain. One of the maps that got shown in a video had like 6 gold bases or something though.
Sounds horribly terran favored tho. They really just cant do shit like that with such a different ressource profile on the races. Easily accessible golds always favor terrans.
|
Don't you dare shittalking BW's music. Terran best race.
And yeah I find BW much easier to watch just because units clump up less, and the absence of units like Colossi makes ground armies and fights a lot easier to watch. Whether it's a carpet of storms or a handful of Colossi, a bio army will melt away, but in one case you don't have 10 lasers randomly covering the army, and death sprites are much shorter in BW (not saying it's huge, it just helps clarity).
Plus SC2 doesn't have chess into drop madness everywhere TvT, or the odd Deep Six or Sparks/Sunken Break timing attack to shake things up.
|
United States15536 Posts
|
Would anyone watch a stream of me and scip doing portal 2 coop?
On November 07 2015 23:47 Alaric wrote: Don't you dare shittalking BW's music. Terran best race.
And yeah I find BW much easier to watch just because units clump up less, and the absence of units like Colossi makes ground armies and fights a lot easier to watch. Whether it's a carpet of storms or a handful of Colossi, a bio army will melt away, but in one case you don't have 10 lasers randomly covering the army, and death sprites are much shorter in BW (not saying it's huge, it just helps clarity).
Plus SC2 doesn't have chess into drop madness everywhere TvT, or the odd Deep Six or Sparks/Sunken Break timing attack to shake things up. bw wasn't all that easy to watch unless you were very familiar with the game. You had stacked mutas, stacked scv's, a few storms wiping 3 screens hydras in about half a second. Stuff like feedback and ghost emp's were pretty hard to work out what was hitting where, and stuff like plague wasn't very intuitive either.
Definitely some nostalgia going on here.
|
On November 08 2015 00:27 killerdog wrote:Would anyone watch a stream of me and scip doing portal 2 coop? Show nested quote +On November 07 2015 23:47 Alaric wrote: Don't you dare shittalking BW's music. Terran best race.
And yeah I find BW much easier to watch just because units clump up less, and the absence of units like Colossi makes ground armies and fights a lot easier to watch. Whether it's a carpet of storms or a handful of Colossi, a bio army will melt away, but in one case you don't have 10 lasers randomly covering the army, and death sprites are much shorter in BW (not saying it's huge, it just helps clarity).
Plus SC2 doesn't have chess into drop madness everywhere TvT, or the odd Deep Six or Sparks/Sunken Break timing attack to shake things up. bw wasn't all that easy to watch unless you were very familiar with the game. You had stacked mutas, stacked scv's, a few storms wiping 3 screens hydras in about half a second. Stuff like feedback and ghost emp's were pretty hard to work out what was hitting where, and stuff like plague wasn't very intuitive either. Definitely some nostalgia going on here. The easy you're talking about is different from his easy. I don't think i'd disagree on the stacked muta thing. The limited information always annoyed me.
I don't really understand what you mean by ghost's emp though, as that was a science vessel ability in bw. And rather easy to follow (big missile creating a shockwave). The plague wasn't really unintuitive, but i do agree that it's hard to see were it's coming from, same with dark swarm for example.
|
Seuss send me vanilla wow info so I can consider it
|
On November 08 2015 01:10 Yorbon wrote:Show nested quote +On November 08 2015 00:27 killerdog wrote:Would anyone watch a stream of me and scip doing portal 2 coop? On November 07 2015 23:47 Alaric wrote: Don't you dare shittalking BW's music. Terran best race.
And yeah I find BW much easier to watch just because units clump up less, and the absence of units like Colossi makes ground armies and fights a lot easier to watch. Whether it's a carpet of storms or a handful of Colossi, a bio army will melt away, but in one case you don't have 10 lasers randomly covering the army, and death sprites are much shorter in BW (not saying it's huge, it just helps clarity).
Plus SC2 doesn't have chess into drop madness everywhere TvT, or the odd Deep Six or Sparks/Sunken Break timing attack to shake things up. bw wasn't all that easy to watch unless you were very familiar with the game. You had stacked mutas, stacked scv's, a few storms wiping 3 screens hydras in about half a second. Stuff like feedback and ghost emp's were pretty hard to work out what was hitting where, and stuff like plague wasn't very intuitive either. Definitely some nostalgia going on here. The easy you're talking about is different from his easy. I don't think i'd disagree on the stacked muta thing. The limited information always annoyed me. I don't really understand what you mean by ghost's emp though, as that was a science vessel ability in bw. And rather easy to follow (big missile creating a shockwave). The plague wasn't really unintuitive, but i do agree that it's hard to see were it's coming from, same with dark swarm for example. Meant ghost lockdown, not emp. Brain not working :p
There were just lots of abilities that had no real projectile and just appeared. Storm, lockdown, maelstrom, feedback, plague etc etc
Whatever you say about sc2, if you watch fights closely you could generally tell who was winning. 10 collosi lasers destroying a ton of marines might not look particularly fun or pretty, but it's a lot easier to follow then half the abilities in broodwar which had absolutely no missile animation or anything, and just completely ended fights.
Blizzard did a pretty good job with clarifying animations in that sense, almost every sc2 spell has a clear start and end point, even if the start point is just a unit animation. It's pretty easy to see which ht stormed, or which ghost emp'd, or which infestor fungaled or neuraled.
|
Yeah the issue was morre with identifying Defiler positioning inside a huge swarm of Zerg units. Storms were pretty hype I thought (at least I liked them more than SC2's, regardless of the particles being uglier).
Of course you've got to learn some before you can watch, but I had the same issue when I started watching UMvC3 at EVO the first year for example (same with KoF but my friend loves the series so he was able to explain it to me at the same time), and I don't think you'd call that nostalgia if I tell you KoF 13 or UMvC3 make me more hype than Smash Bros or SF for example.
Lockdown once you know what it does it's fine, the projectile is slow and the effect clearly visible. Plus it's rarely used, same as feedback, if you start telling me about hallucinations I can more clearly see your case.  Muta stacking and the run-by of vultures is easily explained once, so it's not an issue for me.
Plus the match-ups had a real dynamic in terms of timings, when someone's stronger, etc. (more so TvZ and PvZ than TvP) that shifted the momentum of a match. I didn't feel that watching SC2, but I'm aware it was the start of the game so things weren't as refined as they were in BW. How is it now?
|
On November 08 2015 01:24 Alaric wrote: Yeah the issue was morre with identifying Defiler positioning inside a huge swarm of Zerg units. Storms were pretty hype I thought (at least I liked them more than SC2's, regardless of the particles being uglier).
Of course you've got to learn some before you can watch, but I had the same issue when I started watching UMvC3 at EVO the first year for example (same with KoF but my friend loves the series so he was able to explain it to me at the same time), and I don't think you'd call that nostalgia if I tell you KoF 13 or UMvC3 make me more hype than Smash Bros or SF for example. Just because it's hype doesn't mean it's at all clarity-ful or easy to follow :p
Seems like you just don't like how sc2 teamfights work from a gameplay standpoint, and so decide to complain about it with reference to clarity when it's really just not liking how sc2 fights work. The clarity angle just feels like a really weak argument that only really exists because of a combination of sc2 clumping saltiness and trying to squint through low res GSL streams, more then any actual graphical design flaws.
|
You can call that personal taste then, but stuff like the death animations and a lot of the cartoony over the top stuff from BW was clarity in a sense to me. And yes, while stuff like marine micro and stutter-stepping is enjoying to watch, it works a lot more toward the early game and skirmishes than later on maxed out armies and stuff. It's hard to deny that the clumping is a major issue because of how it makes it harder to move big armies around, makes AoE king too, and also reduces these micro moments (not because they aren't doable, but because requiring much more work you don't see them as often and sometimes they aren't impactful either because the clumping is so huge).
As much as it was hell for me to play through, the stage of TvZ where the terran had to setup a siege and be ready to react to dark swarms, while trying to track down defilers and kill them to prevent having to deal with dark swarms to begin with, was really enjoyable. You had the dance of these specialist units, the positioning (which looks much more dynamic because you don't have to waste time and effort dealing with the clumping whenever you move), and thanks to the tanks' range and the threat of dark swarms the battlefield tended to be very wide too, sometimes spanning 2-3 entire screens as the Terran player tries to bait the Zerg army out with his siege, then funnel it toward his secondary line of defense.
|
United States47024 Posts
Again, I think the relative visual clarity of HotS vs. BW comes down to maps. Certain tilesets in SC2 coupled with lighting effects result in poor contrast with unit colors. It's largely a non-issue on some tilesets (and on those maps, visibility is probably better than BW due to the visual design choices), but on others it's a chore to watch.
BW doesn't run into this problem because high-contrast 2d graphics preserve similar visibility on all tilesets.
|
On November 08 2015 01:37 Alaric wrote: You can call that personal taste then, but stuff like the death animations and a lot of the cartoony over the top stuff from BW was clarity in a sense to me. And yes, while stuff like marine micro and stutter-stepping is enjoying to watch, it works a lot more toward the early game and skirmishes than later on maxed out armies and stuff. It's hard to deny that the clumping is a major issue because of how it makes it harder to move big armies around, makes AoE king too, and also reduces these micro moments (not because they aren't doable, but because requiring much more work you don't see them as often and sometimes they aren't impactful either because the clumping is so huge).
As much as it was hell for me to play through, the stage of TvZ where the terran had to setup a siege and be ready to react to dark swarms, while trying to track down defilers and kill them to prevent having to deal with dark swarms to begin with, was really enjoyable. You had the dance of these specialist units, the positioning (which looks much more dynamic because you don't have to waste time and effort dealing with the clumping whenever you move), and thanks to the tanks' range and the threat of dark swarms the battlefield tended to be very wide too, sometimes spanning 2-3 entire screens as the Terran player tries to bait the Zerg army out with his siege, then funnel it toward his secondary line of defense. I agree, I also found BW a much more entertaining game both to play and watch, but I would definitely say what you just described is basically the opposite of clarity :p
Also scip just wants to play pascal calculator :< Guess i'll stream solo portal 2 gameplay.
This game is meant to be like a retard test or something right? http://www.twitch.tv/ismellpeanuts
|
On November 08 2015 01:24 killerdog wrote:Show nested quote +On November 08 2015 01:10 Yorbon wrote:On November 08 2015 00:27 killerdog wrote:Would anyone watch a stream of me and scip doing portal 2 coop? On November 07 2015 23:47 Alaric wrote: Don't you dare shittalking BW's music. Terran best race.
And yeah I find BW much easier to watch just because units clump up less, and the absence of units like Colossi makes ground armies and fights a lot easier to watch. Whether it's a carpet of storms or a handful of Colossi, a bio army will melt away, but in one case you don't have 10 lasers randomly covering the army, and death sprites are much shorter in BW (not saying it's huge, it just helps clarity).
Plus SC2 doesn't have chess into drop madness everywhere TvT, or the odd Deep Six or Sparks/Sunken Break timing attack to shake things up. bw wasn't all that easy to watch unless you were very familiar with the game. You had stacked mutas, stacked scv's, a few storms wiping 3 screens hydras in about half a second. Stuff like feedback and ghost emp's were pretty hard to work out what was hitting where, and stuff like plague wasn't very intuitive either. Definitely some nostalgia going on here. The easy you're talking about is different from his easy. I don't think i'd disagree on the stacked muta thing. The limited information always annoyed me. I don't really understand what you mean by ghost's emp though, as that was a science vessel ability in bw. And rather easy to follow (big missile creating a shockwave). The plague wasn't really unintuitive, but i do agree that it's hard to see were it's coming from, same with dark swarm for example. Meant ghost lockdown, not emp. Brain not working :p There were just lots of abilities that had no real projectile and just appeared. Storm, lockdown, maelstrom, feedback, plague etc etc Whatever you say about sc2, if you watch fights closely you could generally tell who was winning. 10 collosi lasers destroying a ton of marines might not look particularly fun or pretty, but it's a lot easier to follow then half the abilities in broodwar which had absolutely no missile animation or anything, and just completely ended fights. Blizzard did a pretty good job with clarifying animations in that sense, almost every sc2 spell has a clear start and end point, even if the start point is just a unit animation. It's pretty easy to see which ht stormed, or which ghost emp'd, or which infestor fungaled or neuraled. I would agree with the last alinea. But like I said, I think that's just another kind of easy. Sc2 definitely is easier to follow in terms of where abilities came from. The way bw was imo easier to follow was that given you know a player's possibilities in a battle, you could distinguish each particular action (note, not necessarily an ability). In sc2 i find that really tough to call. It's obviously very subjective, though.
Btw, in my memory, the lockdown was a projectile coming from a ghost as well. But I'm not so sure anymore
|
The one thing that I really appreciate about BW over SC2 is that in BW you can have many small fights going on over a big spread out area where small numbers of well controlled units really matter, whereas what SC2 turned into was whoever macro'd the best and created the best death ball.
But I'd argue that SC2 going in that direction was a byproduct of map design rather than racial balance or game mechanics. I think early SC2 when it was a lot of 1 and 2 base games you did have small spread out fights and it was a much more interesting game.
But the playerbase didn't want to watch small skirmishes or multi pronged things, they wanted macro and deathballs. They got what they wanted.
|
United States47024 Posts
On November 08 2015 01:24 killerdog wrote: There were just lots of abilities that had no real projectile and just appeared. Storm, lockdown, maelstrom, feedback, plague etc etc Lockdown has an animation. It fires a missile while also making a very characteristic sound that nothing else in the game uses. Once you recognize the sound, you can actually very easily pick it out over many other ambient combat sounds.
I agree on your other examples but Lockdown is possibly the clearest ability in the game due to the combination of projectile, audio cue, and distinct debuff visual. It's just rarely ever used.
|
On November 07 2015 18:15 Parnage wrote: I don't know why I'm awake right now..
Brood War is a fun game to play and watch people better then you play.
Age of Empires 2 is a fun game to play and learn about.
I like them both. I wanted to like SC2. I think we all did to a degree. I worry that Overwatch despite a good box model will try to sell DLC characters later down the road and won't allow for people to do all the fun mapmaking, custom games, private servers of varying degrees of hilarity that has made TF2 last for so long.
Lastly, nostralrius is on what vanilla patch? IE: on a scale of 1 to 10 how screwed am I by Rogues? Yeah I remember those days. I even contributed to it once the ZG trinkets hit and things got really out of hand. Ugh. You guys are actually tempting me a little. I have time for an MMO right now...
|
On November 07 2015 18:54 Duvon wrote: Nostralrius is on ZG patch right now, 1.10 coming soon, AQ in the spring, naxx next summer. info on their homepage. Dunno how much is shifting regarding the basics of the game or if it's just content that's following the schedule. Hmm win-fury shaman or another warrior... Or a warlock or another hunter... I'll just make one of each on the different realms so long.
It actually depends on whether you do PvP or PvE. PvP is up to ZG, but PvE launched middle of last month and is pre-Azuregos.
Anyway I'm playing on the PvE server, Alliance side. Add Akujo if you decide to join me.
|
|
|
|
|
|