|
United States47024 Posts
On November 08 2015 01:42 Ketara wrote: But the playerbase didn't want to watch small skirmishes or multi pronged things, they wanted macro and deathballs. They got what they wanted. I don't know if that's true.
I think macro and deathballs are a product of what the "competitive but not professional" (e.g. ladder/amateur play) wanted out of their play experience. From a spectator perspective, everyone wanted more multi-pronged action and multitasking. But the thing is, for that to be impactful requires powerful units that are fundamentally "unfair" if used well in small engagements (so that there's a big enough payoff to being able to play those engagements better than your opponent) which the majority of that middle-tier of players would consider unfun to play against.
|
My favorite memory of vanilla WoW is stealthing around Mauradon trying to kill bosses for drops without aggroing anything else to save time.
|
On November 08 2015 01:51 Ketara wrote: My favorite memory of vanilla WoW is stealthing around Mauradon trying to kill bosses for drops without aggroing anything else to save time.
Anything other than AQ gates or getting Warlord is probably wrong. Vanilla was a magical place where things were bad for the sake of making it harder to accomplish stuff. That said, it does lend to quite a few awesome set piece moments (Like AQ gates and killing C'Thun)
|
Why is there a really passive aggressive female robot?
|
Only a decade behind, doge. Not bad.
|
On November 08 2015 02:12 killerdog wrote: Why is there a really passive aggressive female robot? you never played portal 1 then, I take it.
|
I never really liked Portal much, Antichamber was a lot of fun though and I guess it's similar.
Some of the new Hearthstone cards, which I will probably never own, look fun.
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
|
On November 08 2015 01:50 TheYango wrote:Show nested quote +On November 08 2015 01:42 Ketara wrote: But the playerbase didn't want to watch small skirmishes or multi pronged things, they wanted macro and deathballs. They got what they wanted. I don't know if that's true. I think macro and deathballs are a product of what the "competitive but not professional" (e.g. ladder/amateur play) wanted out of their play experience. From a spectator perspective, everyone wanted more multi-pronged action and multitasking. But the thing is, for that to be impactful requires powerful units that are fundamentally "unfair" if used well in small engagements (so that there's a big enough payoff to being able to play those engagements better than your opponent) which the majority of that middle-tier of players would consider unfun to play against.
Yeah, when there's a main fight and the two sides are simultaneously attacking ad defending 2 or 3 other bases was the best. The casters would actually lose their shit as the observer jumped around from one area to the other. Brood War was a game of inches, SC2 is not.
|
On November 08 2015 03:05 Lord Tolkien wrote:Show nested quote +On November 08 2015 02:12 killerdog wrote: Why is there a really passive aggressive female robot? you never played portal 1 then, I take it. Not really
I vaguely remember something about defeating a giant robot at the end and then some cake meme?
Seems like they explained everything well enough in the prologue for portal 2 though. Soniv said i need to play 1 first, then holyflare said i didn't. Mixed messages qq
|
On November 08 2015 04:36 killerdog wrote:Show nested quote +On November 08 2015 03:05 Lord Tolkien wrote:On November 08 2015 02:12 killerdog wrote: Why is there a really passive aggressive female robot? you never played portal 1 then, I take it. Not really I vaguely remember something about defeating a giant robot at the end and then some cake meme? Seems like they explained everything well enough in the prologue for portal 2 though. Soniv said i need to play 1 first, then holyflare said i didn't. Mixed messages qq imo you should play it, the whole game takes like an hour
|
On November 08 2015 04:39 Frolossus wrote:Show nested quote +On November 08 2015 04:36 killerdog wrote:On November 08 2015 03:05 Lord Tolkien wrote:On November 08 2015 02:12 killerdog wrote: Why is there a really passive aggressive female robot? you never played portal 1 then, I take it. Not really I vaguely remember something about defeating a giant robot at the end and then some cake meme? Seems like they explained everything well enough in the prologue for portal 2 though. Soniv said i need to play 1 first, then holyflare said i didn't. Mixed messages qq imo you should play it, the whole game takes like an hour
Unless you suck at puzzles, in which case it'll take longer, lol
|
On November 08 2015 04:18 ticklishmusic wrote:Show nested quote +On November 08 2015 01:50 TheYango wrote:On November 08 2015 01:42 Ketara wrote: But the playerbase didn't want to watch small skirmishes or multi pronged things, they wanted macro and deathballs. They got what they wanted. I don't know if that's true. I think macro and deathballs are a product of what the "competitive but not professional" (e.g. ladder/amateur play) wanted out of their play experience. From a spectator perspective, everyone wanted more multi-pronged action and multitasking. But the thing is, for that to be impactful requires powerful units that are fundamentally "unfair" if used well in small engagements (so that there's a big enough payoff to being able to play those engagements better than your opponent) which the majority of that middle-tier of players would consider unfun to play against. Yeah, when there's a main fight and the two sides are simultaneously attacking ad defending 2 or 3 other bases was the best. The casters would actually lose their shit as the observer jumped around from one area to the other. Brood War was a game of inches, SC2 is not. 
The major issue is that Blizzard thought "speed = skill" so they sped up SC2 considerably over BW. They didn't realize that taking time to do things or die actually increases the potential out of those actions. Well that and defenders advantage. I'll never stop saying the removal of the highground mechanic in BW to the binary one in SC2 was an absolutely huge fundamental mistake. You have to give some advantage to the defending player since naturally being the proactive one is already an advantage. They further expanded on this mistake by the implementation of Warpgates(At least WoL, no idea HotS or LoV). It's like they just forgot all the fundamentals of RTS or just the basics of strategy in general. How can you ever think removal supply lines is smart. It's like the biggest concern of an invading force and one of the greatest avenues of exploitation of the defending force.
|
Czech Republic11293 Posts
Im a pretty big fan on sc2 and I'd say by far the biggest issue was that passive play was encouraged way too much. I think if they just made bases mine out twice as fast (both minerals and gas) back in WoL beta and rebalance the game around that sc2 woulda been way better.
|
That's partly a product of what I mentioned earlier. If you can't defend a position utilizing terrain to deal with or stall a larger force with a smaller force then it becomes a battle of numbers and in such a situation it's all about the big ball getting the best fight. Much like how league devolves to two teams dancing around an objective in the late game both waiting for the other to make a mistake. That's what mad BW so great. You could force all these small battles all over the place because you were able to leverage your defenders advantage to make sure the enemy couldn't just roll over you with superior numbers. Well that's not quite true as sometimes if you overextend the enemy could just roll over you but the dynamic was there at least. Battle also lasted longer mostly due to no clumping and just things taking longer to die. Kind of why watching perfect storms were so amazing, when aoe wiping out an enemy isn't super easy it becomes even more fascinating when it happens.
There are just so many small design decisions they did back at the start of the game that kind of killed any hope I have for it. Hope LoV revives dead game for a bit though :>
|
Czech Republic11293 Posts
There were a lot of ways to hold off bigger forces with smaller ones to a certain extent planetary fortress can beat like 100 supplies of units or siege tanks rekk stuff forcefields? forcefields! zerg doesn't really but zerg never really has the smaller force so it doesn't matter I honestly think if you just made a custom map in WoL right now that would have all the mineral patches and gases have half the value it'd make a better game.
the combination of defensive positioning being so powerful AND 4th base and following bases being useless for a really really long time is what made the games stale and turtly. Take one of those away and it doesn't stay that way imo.
|
United States47024 Posts
On November 08 2015 06:40 Scip wrote: the combination of defensive positioning being so powerful AND 4th base and following bases being useless for a really really long time is what made the games stale and turtly. Take one of those away and it doesn't stay that way imo. This solution was actually discussed in-depth early in LotV beta, and I believe the consensus was that it's an inadequate solution. It forces you to expand earlier, but does not provide smooth incremental benefit for *additional* bases so long as you are not mining out your current ones. You'll mine out your bases faster, but you still have no incentive to have more than 3 actively mining bases at a time.
The problem being that due to the worker pathing AI being so good in SC2, additional workers on 1 base don't lose *efficiency*. 2 base with 12 workers at each vs. 1 base with 24 workers have similar mineral income in SC2 (because workers all have perfect pathing and never interfere with one another), whereas there actually is a difference in BW because worker pathing and imperfect mineral patch selection means that being on more bases not only gets you access to more minerals and more worker production, but allows the same number of workers to mine more efficiently.
Solutions proposed by TL writers suggested various mechanics to mimic this degrading mining efficiency beyond 1 worker per patch, but to my knowledge Blizzard never paid them any heed.
|
Wait, so your solution is to dumb down the engine because it's too good?
|
Czech Republic11293 Posts
On November 08 2015 06:47 TheYango wrote:Show nested quote +On November 08 2015 06:40 Scip wrote: the combination of defensive positioning being so powerful AND 4th base and following bases being useless for a really really long time is what made the games stale and turtly. Take one of those away and it doesn't stay that way imo. This solution was actually discussed in-depth early in LotV beta, and I believe the consensus was that it's an inadequate solution. It forces you to expand earlier, but does not provide smooth incremental benefit for *additional* bases so long as you are not mining out your current ones. The problem being that due to the worker pathing AI being so good in SC2, additional workers on 1 base don't lose *efficiency*. 2 base with 12 workers at each vs. 1 base with 24 workers have similar mineral income in SC2 (because workers all have perfect pathing and never interfere with one another), whereas there actually is a difference in BW because worker pathing and imperfect mineral patch selection means that being on more bases not only gets you access to more minerals and more worker production, but allows the same number of workers to mine more efficiently. Solutions proposed by TL writers suggested various mechanics to mimic this degrading mining efficiency beyond 1 worker per patch, but to my knowledge Blizzard never paid them any heed. 24 workers on 1 base mine cca 80% as much as 12 workers each at 1 base, I don't think that's insignificant. I mean you could also just make it so that there are like 7 mineral patches/base if you think going from n->n+1 bases is too big of a jump with half the minerals things mine out REALLY fast. Like as a zerg your main base would mine out usually like 1-2 minutes after you fully saturate your 3rd base I think? So you have to keep base hopping a LOT.
|
On November 08 2015 06:52 Requizen wrote: Wait, so your solution is to dumb down the engine because it's too good?
Well yea that could be the solution to the deathball issue as well. This lends itself well to the WoW discussion we had the other day in fact. How efficient is too efficient? There may be other ways to fix the issue but that seems like the simplest solution that doesn't add needless confusion.
|
|
|
|
|
|