|
United States47024 Posts
On November 08 2015 06:53 Scip wrote: 24 workers on 1 base mine cca 80% as much as 12 workers each at 1 base, I don't think that's insignificant. I mis-remembered the numbers, since inefficiency starts to come into play on the 17th worker, but mining efficiency loss being delayed from the 9th worker (in BW) to the 17th worker (in SC2) is massive.
Given the practical number of workers you can actually produce in a given game, it still means that you don't really see efficiency benefits for more than 3 active mining bases (since that's 66 active workers with full efficiency). At a reasonable top-end worker count of 75, the difference in mineral income per minute for 3 bases vs. 4 is <100 minerals per minute, which is not insignificant, but does not outweigh the cost of supporting the 4th base, and it still means there's zero benefit at all to having an active 5th base.
|
Czech Republic11293 Posts
On November 08 2015 07:01 TheYango wrote:Show nested quote +On November 08 2015 06:53 Scip wrote: 24 workers on 1 base mine cca 80% as much as 12 workers each at 1 base, I don't think that's insignificant. I mis-remembered the numbers, since inefficiency starts to come into play on the 17th worker, but mining efficiency loss being delayed from the 9th worker (in BW) to the 17th worker (in SC2) is massive. Given the practical number of workers you can actually produce in a given game, it still means that you don't really see efficiency benefits for more than 3 active mining bases (since that's 66 active workers with full efficiency). Yeah but the idea is that it's really fucking hard to get 3 active mining bases when bases mine out twice as fast if they mined out twice as fast as they do now you'd be left with like no mineral patches in your main at 9:00? ish in game timer, the closest ones would disappear a bit earlier I think. That's REALLY fast, you'd see Protoss players start mining from their 3rd base at around that time lol. Obviously it'd create some balance concerns, mainly Toss would just get raped unless you significantly adapted map architecture, but it'd sure as fuck stop the game from being a deathbally turtle game.
|
United States47024 Posts
It helps some, sure, but you could do a LOT better if the game, rather than just FORCING you to take new bases at a steady rate (while still not actually rewarding you for having more than 3 active bases at a time), provides natural benefits for a 4th, 5th, or even 6th active mining base with the corresponding drawbacks.
Again, this topic was discussed in far more detail than I can do it justice during LotV beta, and it shouldn't be hard to find the detailed treatise Zeromus wrote on it in the LotV beta forum.
EDIT: Found it: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/legacy-of-the-void/482775-a-treatise-on-the-economy-of-scii
|
Czech Republic11293 Posts
Well I'm not saying that's not the case, I'm just saying doing that alone would be enough to make the game a lot better
|
United States47024 Posts
Sure, then I agree with that, assuming none of the unintended consequences don't break the game in half (which is a risk of any systemic change to core game mechanics, including mining efficiency-based changes).
|
Rather then changing how fast bases mine out, what about just making workers have to mine for 50% longer to get minerals, so two workers mining a patch is only 150% the effectiveness of one. Then just rebalance how much they get in each run so that the rate a fully saturated base mines is the same.
I don't remember that being brought up when it was discussed last time, but i might have just missed it.
|
United States47024 Posts
Longer mining time was one of the solutions examined in the article I linked (though they tried double mining time rather than 1.5x, the effect on the mining efficiency curve would be the same, just less extreme).
|
Man my solution is to just make some maps where the areas are small enough that deathballs can't fit in them.
Seems pretty fucking easy to me.
|
United States47024 Posts
Poor incentives for expanding beyond 3 bases is still a gameplay problem even if you have map design that *directly* punishes deathballs.
|
On November 08 2015 07:32 Ketara wrote: Man my solution is to just make some maps where the areas are small enough that deathballs can't fit in them.
Seems pretty fucking easy to me.
Then you're just trading one problem for another. That's more a band-aid than a real "fix".
|
Czech Republic11293 Posts
On November 08 2015 07:32 Ketara wrote: Man my solution is to just make some maps where the areas are small enough that deathballs can't fit in them.
Seems pretty fucking easy to me. Errr if you do that all you get is flying deathballs (from P or Z anyway, T can still drop and be fine) Tight chokes make it easier to defend (for P or T) so they can turtle away p well, Z would kinda be rekt but if they weren't they'd probably be able to go infestor broodlord pretty viably as long as 3rd base would be avaliable, at least in WoL, Im not sure how things are in HotS right now.
|
The solution is clearly to triple the size of all the maps, and remove the supply cap. :p
Increasing the supply cap could be interesting though. Hardware limitations aside, so much of sc2 is spent with two max supply blobs sitting across from each other, (and the fact you're limited to 60ish workers cus you still want an army.)
Would make having 4+ bases mining efficiently a viable option, and might end up giving more incentive to the person with the supply lead to spread out battles to abuse their advantage, rather then risk just getting aoe'd.
|
On November 08 2015 07:39 Scip wrote:Show nested quote +On November 08 2015 07:32 Ketara wrote: Man my solution is to just make some maps where the areas are small enough that deathballs can't fit in them.
Seems pretty fucking easy to me. Errr if you do that all you get is flying deathballs (from P or Z anyway, T can still drop and be fine) Tight chokes make it easier to defend (for P or T) so they can turtle away p well, Z would kinda be rekt but if they weren't they'd probably be able to go infestor broodlord pretty viably as long as 3rd base would be avaliable, at least in WoL, Im not sure how things are in HotS right now.
Infestor Broodlord has been long dead. If you want to pinpoint one annoying bullshit build its the swarm host build, but Z play is pretty fluid right now.
Also, flying death balls are T endgame as well.
|
On November 08 2015 07:39 Scip wrote:Show nested quote +On November 08 2015 07:32 Ketara wrote: Man my solution is to just make some maps where the areas are small enough that deathballs can't fit in them.
Seems pretty fucking easy to me. Errr if you do that all you get is flying deathballs (from P or Z anyway, T can still drop and be fine) Tight chokes make it easier to defend (for P or T) so they can turtle away p well, Z would kinda be rekt but if they weren't they'd probably be able to go infestor broodlord pretty viably as long as 3rd base would be avaliable, at least in WoL, Im not sure how things are in HotS right now.
So if you don't want flying deathballs, make maps with areas that flying units can't move through. Make an underground map where flying units aren't even allowed.
And you don't have to restrict that shit with tight chokes. Make patches of lava that damage ground units if they stand on them for too long so you can engage through them but can't fight on them. Or do something else yadda yadda.
You know.
Make terrain different so that armies have to be different. If the terrain is the same every time then the game will be the same every time.
I think it's okay to have individual maps in a pool that are flawed in one direction and create a certain sort of game, as long as the map pool overall is varied and balanced.
That's just my opinion though and I know its not popular.
|
On November 08 2015 07:45 Ketara wrote:Show nested quote +On November 08 2015 07:39 Scip wrote:On November 08 2015 07:32 Ketara wrote: Man my solution is to just make some maps where the areas are small enough that deathballs can't fit in them.
Seems pretty fucking easy to me. Errr if you do that all you get is flying deathballs (from P or Z anyway, T can still drop and be fine) Tight chokes make it easier to defend (for P or T) so they can turtle away p well, Z would kinda be rekt but if they weren't they'd probably be able to go infestor broodlord pretty viably as long as 3rd base would be avaliable, at least in WoL, Im not sure how things are in HotS right now. So if you don't want flying deathballs, make maps with areas that flying units can't move through. Make an underground map where flying units aren't even allowed. And you don't have to restrict that shit with tight chokes. Make patches of lava that damage ground units if they stand on them for too long so you can engage through them but can't fight on them. Or do something else yadda yadda. You know. Make terrain different so that armies have to be different. If the terrain is the same every time then the game will be the same every time. I think it's okay to have individual maps in a pool that are flawed in one direction and create a certain sort of game, as long as the map pool overall is varied and balanced. That's just my opinion though and I know its not popular. Reminds me of the wc3 scandal.
"lets just make marines have 4 less damage on this map, that'll make it balanced"
|
On November 08 2015 07:49 killerdog wrote:Show nested quote +On November 08 2015 07:45 Ketara wrote:On November 08 2015 07:39 Scip wrote:On November 08 2015 07:32 Ketara wrote: Man my solution is to just make some maps where the areas are small enough that deathballs can't fit in them.
Seems pretty fucking easy to me. Errr if you do that all you get is flying deathballs (from P or Z anyway, T can still drop and be fine) Tight chokes make it easier to defend (for P or T) so they can turtle away p well, Z would kinda be rekt but if they weren't they'd probably be able to go infestor broodlord pretty viably as long as 3rd base would be avaliable, at least in WoL, Im not sure how things are in HotS right now. So if you don't want flying deathballs, make maps with areas that flying units can't move through. Make an underground map where flying units aren't even allowed. And you don't have to restrict that shit with tight chokes. Make patches of lava that damage ground units if they stand on them for too long so you can engage through them but can't fight on them. Or do something else yadda yadda. You know. Make terrain different so that armies have to be different. If the terrain is the same every time then the game will be the same every time. I think it's okay to have individual maps in a pool that are flawed in one direction and create a certain sort of game, as long as the map pool overall is varied and balanced. That's just my opinion though and I know its not popular. Reminds me of the wc3 scandal. "lets just make marines have 4 less damage on this map, that'll make it balanced" LS is part of SC2 balance team now?
|
Czech Republic11293 Posts
None of your suggestions make sense Ketara did you even sc2?
|
United States15536 Posts
|
United States47024 Posts
I mean, you can have lopsided maps, but there's still a difference of degrees between Andromeda and Rush Hour, lol.
|
'Make an underground map where flying units aren't even allowed.'
RIP Zerg.
|
|
|
|
|
|