|
On November 07 2015 10:26 Requizen wrote: I dunno, I've found pretty much every Blizz game I've played to be enjoyable. Maybe I'm easy to please with games, but they're all really polished and fun imo.
I was thinking the same thing. I haven't played a Blizz game that I've truly hated/disappointed. D3 for me and my friends sucked at beginning, but got a lot better imo.
And while don't play HS anymore, it held down my TCG cravings for almost 2 years before I picked MTG back up.
|
Diablo gives me motion sickness
|
11589 Posts
On November 07 2015 10:26 Parnage wrote:Show nested quote +On November 07 2015 10:09 yamato77 wrote: Games have to be profitable. You can't simply make AAA games for the love of the game anymore. This is a reality that gamers need to understand. If the quality of your product suffers for the sake of earning more money it is a bad product for the consumer. This is true no matter what it is. I'm not going to accept a car with bad breaks just because it was more profitable to make a deal with the company who made those break pads. Only in gaming is it even acceptable to release products with stripped out features and content sold back piecemeal. On disc dlc, preorder bonus content, abusive f2p models. All accepted because it's just required to be profitable? You can be profitable without ruining your games, if you make a good game. This is straying from the original point, which is that Blizzard is somehow getting worse because of making profitable games, which I contend with.
1) Diablo 3 is the only recent game you could have truly made this argument for and they rectified that pretty quickly. Current day D3 is a pretty great game with at least as much content as D2 and its modern-day competitor PoE. HotS can be criticised but they followed a LoL-model with this which I don't think anyone on this forum can honestly complain about.
2) SC2 had absolutely no problems due to Blizzard trying to "make the game more profitable". They simply didn't understand the nuances that made BW great and released it with poor social features. It was still an amazingly successful game and has gotten progressively better with each expansion.
3) Hearthstone is a CCG. No more or less an abusive pay model than any other CCG. I'd say all the free pack mechanics make it arguably better. Amazingly successful, even somewhat competitive.
4) Overwatch is following a traditional boxed game model. I love this. I think it makes the game more fun and competitive. I doubt anyone honestly contests this if they actually know the details.
5) WoW set the standard for MMO models and seems fairly reasonable? I know nothing about it, I've never played an MMO in my life and I doubt I will. I don't think profitability ruined any game.
If you mean that they are designing for a wider audience, I agree and there's definitely a trade-off there but I don't fault Blizzard for it. The games aren't objectively worse because of this, they are just different. Some might say better. Not a solid argument.
Now, if you want to argue about on-disc DLC and pre-order exclusive content, I think you have some misdirected rage. GameStop and used game sales are more to blame for this. Developers feel more and more pressure to lock content behind buying a new game and/or content for the game after you've already bought it because they lose many sales of their product to used game sales which give them 0$.
Day 1 DLC is also a function of the long verification cycles that console makers force developers to plan around. Essentially there is a dead period where the game is "finished" but unreleased where a bunch of designers sit around and would be doing nothing, so instead they make content for their game! Content you wouldn't have otherwise.
|
What I will say about blizzard games is that if you look at each title in the isolated genre of which its trying to compete, its often the top game within that genre.
WoW is obviously the most successful/best PvE/raid focused MMO.
Hearthstone is obviously the best online ccg.
SC2 is probably the best RTS.
D3 is probably the best game within that genre.
HotS isn't as good as LoL, but LoL is friendship and friendship is magic.
I guess it's more for me that blizzard makes games for genres that I don't like/care about.
I like sandbox and pvp focused MMOs. I don't like RTS games, and even so I temporarily liked sc2. I don't like ccgs. I don't like shooters. Etc.
|
There is no good MOBA, only different levels of allowed sodium and cancer.
|
|
|
On November 07 2015 10:13 sung_moon wrote: I know everybody here's talking about Fallout 4/Blizz games, but I just started playing Osu! for the first time. Watching videos of people playing mouse only insanity levels. Wow lol.
Also, thanks for the headups about the Skype Soniv. For whatever reason, I still use Skype quite a bit.
Osu is the bomb, loved the fuck out Elite Beat Agents on the DS. I'm just terrible as FUCK at it.
|
Into the finals of the pptq, this game so easy. If my buddy wins the semi he's in hell scoop me into the invite to the ptq and I'll give him the box. Makes it so easy when you're friends live with you lol
|
United States47024 Posts
On November 07 2015 10:02 Parnage wrote: Starcraft 2 was at best and still is okay.
Diablo 3 is a trimmed down modernized neutered version of Diablo 2 with less customization that came with a auctionhouse for real money so they could tune drop rates to be terrible and profit off of it. All of this simplification by the way merely heralding a console release. Which you know works great for consoles but it's terrible for the core base. Parn D3 is actually fine now, it's SC2 thats bad.
On November 07 2015 11:43 yamato77 wrote: 2) SC2 had absolutely no problems due to Blizzard trying to "make the game more profitable". They simply didn't understand the nuances that made BW great and released it with poor social features. It was still an amazingly successful game and has gotten progressively better with each expansion.
SC2 lost it's chance. The problem wasn't social features, the problem was utterly nonexistent support for custom games (in fact, the game launched with a system that actively impeded discovery and promotion of new custom games), when pretty much custom games were the lifeblood of both BW and War3 beyond anything but the most competitive level.
Literally every other flaw of the game could be overlooked for this because honestly, if the custom game system of SC2 lived up to the standard set by BW and War3, that alone would drive player retention more than anything else. There are plenty of mediocre-to-bad games that are redeemed purely by custom content (e.g. Neverwinter Nights) and games that were very good pushed to the level of timeless classics by custom content (e.g. Half Life).
On November 07 2015 10:02 Parnage wrote: Hearthstone is a card game online. With all the pros and cons that entails.
Well no. Hearthstone has a lot of things that it got right that it does better than any other online CCG. On the flip side, a lot of the things WRONG with Hearthstone have nothing to do with it being a CCG, but just errors/idiocy made by Blizzard.
|
On November 07 2015 12:00 Ketara wrote: What I will say about blizzard games is that if you look at each title in the isolated genre of which its trying to compete, its often the top game within that genre.
WoW is obviously the most successful/best PvE/raid focused MMO.
Hearthstone is obviously the best online ccg.
SC2 is probably the best RTS.
D3 is probably the best game within that genre.
HotS isn't as good as LoL, but LoL is friendship and friendship is magic.
I guess it's more for me that blizzard makes games for genres that I don't like/care about.
I like sandbox and pvp focused MMOs. I don't like RTS games, and even so I temporarily liked sc2. I don't like ccgs. I don't like shooters. Etc.
MAybe I'm wrong since I don't play thge genre but isn't bastion pretty popular opinions over diablo?
also age2 for best rts not the steam version
|
i'm super happy about diablo 3 announcements at blizzcon. it's literally everything that we've been asking for since reaper of souls was launched.
|
United States47024 Posts
Brood War is the best RTS game ever made, bar none.
SC2 is the best RTS game that is still widely played; but that doesn't say a lot because the genre as a whole is dying.
On November 07 2015 13:30 TheHumanSensation wrote: MAybe I'm wrong since I don't play thge genre but isn't bastion pretty popular opinions over diablo? Bastion isn't in the same genre as Diablo. It's closer to Zelda than it is to Diablo, honestly.
|
no fuck you yango age2 was better
unless you count like watching ouraments as part of the game, then yeah bw was better because it has better comunit ycontent
|
United States47024 Posts
Even on a casual level BW was better due to having a better editor that supported deeper and more meaningful custom maps.
There's basically a tiny niche of "competitive but not professional" where Age2 has a legitimate argument. At casual and professional play BW is indisputably the better game.
|
I would argue that sc2 is a better game than brood war, but HOLY SHIT LETS NOT GO THERE AHAHAHAHAHA
Custom map support in sc2 was definitely terrible.
I'd agree with Yango that very little of what killed sc2 had much to do with the actual game at all. It was the peripheral support around the game that was bad.
Which I think is in huge contrast with LoL which takes the opposite approach. Very few of the things that make LoL so popular or competitive have much to do with the actual game itself.
|
United States47024 Posts
On November 07 2015 13:37 Ketara wrote: I would argue that sc2 is a better game than brood war, but HOLY SHIT LETS NOT GO THERE AHAHAHAHAHA Again, the argument is only reasonable for the "competitive but not professional" niche. Basically the only area where SC2 has an advantage is for competitive games that are not at a professional level (e.g. ladder play). As a top level competitive/spectator game, I don't think much needs to be said for Brood War's superiority. And at a totally casual level, Starcraft 2's inability to create a mapmaking environment and tap into the years of latent BW/War3 custom mapmakers seals its fate.
The only possible competition for BW is Warcraft 3, which is a vastly weaker competitive game, but a vastly superior casual game due to Blizzard actually improving the editor (and by extension casual play) by leaps and bounds. Hell, MOBA games EXIST because of the Warcraft 3 editor.
EDIT: Also, SC2's comparative weakness as a casual game is compounded by it's weaker single player content as well. SC/BW's single-player campaigns are still on the whole better than SC2's.
|
Isn't the SC2 custom scene much better now?
|
United States47024 Posts
On November 07 2015 13:37 Ketara wrote: Which I think is in huge contrast with LoL which takes the opposite approach. Very few of the things that make LoL so popular or competitive have much to do with the actual game itself. I'm actually not sure I agree with that. A lot of things that Riot did with LoL (antiquated client for years, extremely slow lag time on introducing new features such as spectator functionality, relatively exploitative business model) would not have sat well with the community if the game was not as good as it is. On the contrary, Riot got away with a LOT that no other developer could because the game was so good.
|
You know what I wanted to see in sc2?
More stuff in maps.
Like, one of the coolest sc2 moments for me was in the first gsl finals, when fruitdealer used the high grass terrain to kill a reaper with a zergling. That shit was so cool.
Stuff like gold minerals, tall grass, watchtowers, those sorts of mechanics actually change gameplay from map to map and are awesome. I wanted more of that. I wanted terrain that slowed ground units. I wanted terrain that blocked vision between air and ground, etc.
The community by and large wanted less of that.
Sc2 died for me when I felt like maps were all big identical blobs with different tilesets.
|
On November 07 2015 13:47 Ketara wrote: You know what I wanted to see in sc2?
More stuff in maps.
Like, one of the coolest sc2 moments for me was in the first gsl finals, when fruitdealer used the high grass terrain to kill a reaper with a zergling. That shit was so cool.
Stuff like gold minerals, tall grass, watchtowers, those sorts of mechanics actually change gameplay from map to map and are awesome. I wanted more of that. I wanted terrain that slowed ground units. I wanted terrain that blocked vision between air and ground, etc.
The community by and large wanted less of that.
Sc2 died for me when I felt like maps were all big identical blobs with different tilesets. this is something that broodwar map makers handled pretty well. a lot of neat map concepts didn't really exist in normal maps but got added by the map makers later
|
|
|
|
|
|