On March 14 2016 21:13 Eppa! wrote: Which is the inherent flaw of poor character writing. The aim of the character is either missed on they were to dumb to see that this is what she should have been.
So you're calling it poor writing because Max isn't Kristen Stewart blank slate?.
Or because you think she is?
I'm rather confused about what your point on poor writing even is.
Regardless, I have my own thoughts on the game I'll publish to my TL blog.
I was referencing the books, Bella is cleverly written in a way that she has the intellectual superiority over her classmates (reads wuthering heights and listens to Debussy.) While having weakness in her age complex and her shyness. She is a pretty blank character but these thing make the reader empathize with her and makes its easier to see yourself as the main character and gives you the feeling that all of it matters.
This is what is lacking in Max she is unrelatable because of the poor writing.
On March 14 2016 21:13 Eppa! wrote: Which is the inherent flaw of poor character writing. The aim of the character is either missed on they were to dumb to see that this is what she should have been.
So you're calling it poor writing because Max isn't Kristen Stewart blank slate?.
Or because you think she is?
I'm rather confused about what your point on poor writing even is.
Regardless, I have my own thoughts on the game I'll publish to my TL blog.
I was referencing the books, Bella is cleverly written in a way that she has the intellectual superiority over her classmates (reads wuthering heights and listens to Debussy.) While having weakness in her age complex and her shyness. She is a pretty blank character but these thing make the reader empathize with her and makes its easier to see yourself as the main character and gives you the feeling that all of it matters.
This is what is lacking in Max she is unrelatable because of the poor writing.
you are comparing a book to a video game while excluding characterization from every option and her journal. a telltale style game's characters are written into everything instead of just a block of text. so it can be easy to confuse a characters dialogue choices that YOU pick as her only characterization. when in fact it's the sum of all dialogue trees and the world building that characterize those characters. max is not the max that you drive through the plot. max is the max that exists with every choice. they aren't different characters. they are all aspects of her.
On March 14 2016 21:13 Eppa! wrote: Which is the inherent flaw of poor character writing. The aim of the character is either missed on they were to dumb to see that this is what she should have been.
So you're calling it poor writing because Max isn't Kristen Stewart blank slate?.
Or because you think she is?
I'm rather confused about what your point on poor writing even is.
Regardless, I have my own thoughts on the game I'll publish to my TL blog.
I was referencing the books, Bella is cleverly written in a way that she has the intellectual superiority over her classmates (reads wuthering heights and listens to Debussy.) While having weakness in her age complex and her shyness. She is a pretty blank character but these thing make the reader empathize with her and makes its easier to see yourself as the main character and gives you the feeling that all of it matters.
This is what is lacking in Max she is unrelatable because of the poor writing.
you are comparing a book to a video game while excluding characterization from every option and her journal. a telltale style game's characters are written into everything instead of just a block of text. so it can be easy to confuse a characters dialogue choices that YOU pick as her only characterization. when in fact it's the sum of all dialogue trees and the world building that characterize those characters. max is not the max that you drive through the plot. max is the max that exists with every choice. they aren't different characters. they are all aspects of her.
Well said.
I personally had no problems relating to Max, but I also didn't try to see myself as her either.
Either way, I wrote a blog, and I'd certainly appreciate feedback and opinions.
Video game characterization is detailed in everything they do. a book is all written, a comic book characterization is also in imagery, not just the text. and as you move further from "wall of text" and closer to "visual and auditory experiences" you get movie characterization, which ALSO puts in elements from a director. camera angles lighting, cuts between shots, all change how a character is portrayed and how it exists. video games add even another element, choice. if you play a character and walk everywhere vs jog/sprint key everywhere that changes how a characters mental state is in those situations, clearly one is more urgent than the other, but Both are the character. you are just playing out different elements of that character.
Take final fantasy 7 for example. cloud has a big huge sword and he's clearly very strong to swing it around, but you can load him with materia and only use him as a spellcaster. It doesn't mean cloud is no longer a swordsman trained by Shinra, it's just the player exploring his interest in materia.
Video game characterization is closer to an inner look on people than a movie or a book is.you actively explore the elements of a character you want to explore. but only the sum of all possible playthroughs is truly encompassing that character's being.
im on a phone so I'll keep it short, but I want to talk about the tornado. Why it's there already makes little sense at all, since the game gives no real hints of being absurdist outside maxs head, and no butterfly effect can explain how Chloe caused a series of natural disasters, so it just felt like a cheap plot device to stir emotion. I think the creators just had this ending in mind from the beginning, and basically wanted it in even if they couldn't give a good reason for it. Also, killing an ENTIRE TOWN is a bad ending whether they like it or not, but I talked about that already.
I don't really like Greek tragedies as a personal thing, but I don't think these two are comparable in this case, especially my complaints. In Greek tragedies, the death is something the character either deserved, or is the result of coincidence that loops the beginning of the story back. Chloes ending just trivializes her character, and it isn't the result of any of the themes of her character that we've built throughout the game. If this were a Greek Tragedy, Chloe would die because someone cared about her too much, as the theme she's built is one of abandonment. Chloe's character, for that ending, didn't matter at all. The second ending justifies her character somewhat, but it still makes no sense for a character to ever choose that.
Also about the episodic nature, that's all well and good if it has at least SOME relevance to ANYTHING about the ending. It did affect characters in the later chapters but that never mattered because realistically every single one of their roles is nothing more than filler to give max something to do other than bond with Chloe. An example of how episodic nature can work is Wolf Among Us. I'll admit that a crime drama is easier to drop relevant cliffhangers, but I don't see why LiS had to drop cliffhangers. I would have kept playing even without them as long as they used their time to do something interesting like ensure that a single one of of,my choices affects the ending in any way.
I feel like you have a reason in mind for why choices "should" contribute towards the ending that I don't quite understand. If it's just frustration that western-3d-visual-novel-slash-interactive-drama makers could do interesting stuff with choices forming the story but instead always go the route of making the most important events out of your control or making it so that your last choices overwrite your previous ones then I can understand that. But here it really works. You're making it sound like first 4 episodes are tied together, and then 5th randomly puts you in a different location, different cast and new plotlines, which just isn't true. It's a direct continuation of the story you've been living through for the past 4 episodes. Besides, what is "the ending" anyway. Is it the last hour of the game? Last 5 minutes? Everything that happens after your last interactive bit? The state of events after the credits roll? For me the nightmare scene and the streets are just as important (if not more) than the final decision. The choices you made in the game make you invested in the town, the people and the story, and then when the game asks you what parts of each would you rather sacrifice, I think it's an interesting decision to make.
I'm not too hot for hurricane myself, but do you really think it doesn't work here? That you basically have this huge threat over your head, but you decide to ignore it because a) there's constantly something going on and b) you don't really know what to do about it, until it hits you in the face and you're forced to take desperate measures? Also I don't think the game really needs to explain how timetravel and tornado are connected - personally, when I was making my choice, I was even thinking "Fuck I can't be sure that hurricane is actually connected to my powers, what if I sacrifice someone and everyone else still dies?" Remember when the hurricane actually happens for the first time - it's right as you escape Jefferson and get a happy ending, that's when shit hits the fan even harder. It's established, then purposely swept away and then hits you in the worst possible moment. So when at the end of that she's trying to figure out what to do, as she's getting nosebleeds and dizziness and all that stuff, I think it's pretty natural to link those two.
As for Chloe, again you're looking for purpose. How I remember some of the greek dramas was literally "sometimes fate just hates you and no matter what you do you'll get fucked". There that premise was usually used to create stories about how fate can be ironic. Here it's used to be another weight on whether your choice will be to continue fighting fate or accept it (either begrudgingly because you're not ready to sacrifice thousands of people, or because you're afraid that it might do something even worse than hurricane). Besides, sure she's pretty unlucky to lose a parent and have her friend be a victim of a killer. But all the time she dies in the game are her own fault (dealing with drug dealers, trying to blackmail rich kids, wanting to get revenge, shooting guns for fun). Whether you decide she's actually a tragic character or if it's just life and you gotta deal with it best you can (and perhaps want to help her) is also up to you.
The primary means of learning about these characters is obviously through dialogue with them, and that is perhaps one of the more obviously flawed things about the game overall. For how much it relies on the words these characters say, some of the idioms and slang used throughout the story seems over-the-top, especially in the beginning of the game. Some of this can be excused, as the studio (and thus the primary writer of the game) is French. Given that the lines had to be translated for the English voice acting, it is understandable that the localization team for the game took some liberty with how the teenage characters talked. It can be immersion-breaking at times to hear some of the quirky phrasing, but overall the dialogue remains sufficiently believable and does improve as the game goes on.
The game had a second writer who was American and worked closely with the studio, had input on the story and especially on how people talked and behaved. Personally I just accept that no creator will ever get the lingo right and besides, I finished high school only few years ago and I already cringe at conversations between high or middle schoolers, so I'd argue that it really doesn't matter if teenagers in the game really speak like they do now because it won't matter in few years anyway.
The primary means of learning about these characters is obviously through dialogue with them, and that is perhaps one of the more obviously flawed things about the game overall. For how much it relies on the words these characters say, some of the idioms and slang used throughout the story seems over-the-top, especially in the beginning of the game. Some of this can be excused, as the studio (and thus the primary writer of the game) is French. Given that the lines had to be translated for the English voice acting, it is understandable that the localization team for the game took some liberty with how the teenage characters talked. It can be immersion-breaking at times to hear some of the quirky phrasing, but overall the dialogue remains sufficiently believable and does improve as the game goes on.
The game had a second writer who was American and worked closely with the studio, had input on the story and especially on how people talked and behaved. Personally I just accept that no creator will ever get the lingo right and besides, I finished high school only few years ago and I already cringe at conversations between high or middle schoolers, so I'd argue that it really doesn't matter if teenagers in the game really speak like they do now because it won't matter in few years anyway.
Like I said in the blog, it was just a minor annoyance. Nothing that takes away from the game too much. But it is undoubtedly noticeable, especially early.
When does it come out? I need to know when all my friends do nothing but play it/talk about it for a couple months and then complain how it's ass and they're never playing "that shitty game" again.
On March 15 2016 04:19 Gahlo wrote: When does it come out? I need to know when all my friends do nothing but play it/talk about it for a couple months and then complain how it's ass and they're never playing "that shitty game" again.
Septemberish? I don't remember off the top of my head. Its after the movie tho (HYPE)
On March 15 2016 04:19 Gahlo wrote: When does it come out? I need to know when all my friends do nothing but play it/talk about it for a couple months and then complain how it's ass and they're never playing "that shitty game" again.
Septemberish? I don't remember off the top of my head. Its after the movie tho (HYPE)
On March 15 2016 04:19 Gahlo wrote: When does it come out? I need to know when all my friends do nothing but play it/talk about it for a couple months and then complain how it's ass and they're never playing "that shitty game" again.
Septemberish? I don't remember off the top of my head. Its after the movie tho (HYPE)
On March 15 2016 04:19 Gahlo wrote: When does it come out? I need to know when all my friends do nothing but play it/talk about it for a couple months and then complain how it's ass and they're never playing "that shitty game" again.
Septemberish? I don't remember off the top of my head. Its after the movie tho (HYPE)
On March 15 2016 04:19 Gahlo wrote: When does it come out? I need to know when all my friends do nothing but play it/talk about it for a couple months and then complain how it's ass and they're never playing "that shitty game" again.
Septemberish? I don't remember off the top of my head. Its after the movie tho (HYPE)
It's gunna suck so hard that I can only hope to have things to laugh about it.
You tend to be even more of a negative nancy than I about these kinds of things. From the preview it actually appears to have potential if you're not a ridiculous mega lore nerd, which, since I barely play Blizz games anymore, I once was but decidedly am not anymore. I remain cautiously optimistic. It'll probably be just a movie to see for WoW nostalgia purposes and for funz.
For me it's not just about WoW or Warcraft nostalgia. If this tanks, what gaming movie will take that risk for another decade? My fear is that, if Warcraft bombs, every movie company is just gonna go "oh well, a movie that big with those names behind it and that big of a playerbase didn't do well, why bother trying to make video game movies work?", and we'll never see another attempt until it's forgotten.
Not that many games need to be made into movies. Some just don't make sense. But I just worry that the chance will get written out altogether.
On March 15 2016 04:47 Requizen wrote: For me it's not just about WoW or Warcraft nostalgia. If this tanks, what gaming movie will take that risk for another decade? My fear is that, if Warcraft bombs, every movie company is just gonna go "oh well, a movie that big with those names behind it and that big of a playerbase didn't do well, why bother trying to make video game movies work?", and we'll never see another attempt until it's forgotten.
Not that many games need to be made into movies. Some just don't make sense. But I just worry that the chance will get written out altogether.
They are literally starting up on a tomb raider reboot movie.
Warcraft movie is gonna bomb, and it's because it's not something that should be done like this. it's going to be a multi hour mediocre cinematic, instead of a movie with people in it. you make a warcraft movie by making it about the civilians in Dalaran pre arthas, not by making an epic. you don't start with the epic.
On March 15 2016 04:47 Requizen wrote: For me it's not just about WoW or Warcraft nostalgia. If this tanks, what gaming movie will take that risk for another decade? My fear is that, if Warcraft bombs, every movie company is just gonna go "oh well, a movie that big with those names behind it and that big of a playerbase didn't do well, why bother trying to make video game movies work?", and we'll never see another attempt until it's forgotten.
Not that many games need to be made into movies. Some just don't make sense. But I just worry that the chance will get written out altogether.
They are literally starting up on a tomb raider reboot movie.
Warcraft movie is gonna bomb, and it's because it's not something that should be done like this. it's going to be a multi hour mediocre cinematic, instead of a movie with people in it. you make a warcraft movie by making it about the civilians in Dalaran pre arthas, not by making an epic. you don't start with the epic.
I actually had heard about the Tomb Raider reboot, has a lot to do with how well received the two new ones have been. I'm excited for it, if for no other reason than it can't be any worse than the Angelina Jolie ones.
I disagree about your other point, sort of. I agree that going all out and doing (what seems to be so far) the full first war of Orcs and Men seems too big, but also you can't make a Warcraft movie that's too small. If you want to capture what it means to be one of the biggest RTS series in existence and the biggest MMO of all time (in most ways of measuring), then you can't just have a movie about random wizards living in a city.
They could have easily found another point of the story to make the focus, though. Something small enough scale, following a few characters in a self contained arc. It just seems that they're going too big at first.