The LiquidLegends Lounge - Page 1076
| Forum Index > The Shopkeeper′s Inn |
|
Dandel Ion
Austria17960 Posts
| ||
|
Numy
South Africa35471 Posts
That's why Malazan needs to be an anime. Live action fantasy is just too unwieldy that eventually becomes CGI fest. So why not cut out the live action all together and go into superior medium. Only issue is I don't know if all my waifus can get roles in the story. Dam. Most of the women are either too hardcore or too heartbreaking. edit: Req - Game of Thrones is a pretty horrible adaption of Song of Ice and Fire if one wanted an adaption of the source material instead of merely writing a story for TV using source as an inspiration. Think you vastly overestimate peoples ability. It doesn't show the qualities Yanger is talking about in understanding both mediums as they just made a new story instead. | ||
|
Seuss
United States10536 Posts
On March 15 2016 05:38 Slayer91 wrote: MoonBear did anyone ever tell you that you post like a wikipedia page? Just because MoonBear always links relevant sources... | ||
|
TheYango
United States47024 Posts
On March 15 2016 05:46 Requizen wrote: Like you said, what you need it a writer that understands both, and seeing that we're in the so-called Age of the Nerd (highest grossing films are comic and book adaptations, things like Game of Thrones and Walking Dead are some of the biggest TV shows right now, etc), I honestly don't think it would be too hard to find a writer out there that can write a decent script based on a game, or a writer for one of the better game studios who can work with a film company. That you "don't think it would be too hard" is incredibly insulting to career writers in both media. | ||
|
Alaric
France45622 Posts
On March 15 2016 05:38 Slayer91 wrote: MoonBear did anyone ever tell you that you post like a wikipedia page? Would you rather he posts like me? ![]() Apart from its awful name (and too wordy flavour text—yup, I'm saying this), Anguished Unmaking looks pretty good and catch-all as far as answers go, especially in these colours... but then Modern burns a quarter of its life pool on fetches so 3 life becomes a hefty cost all of a sudden, I assume. Vindicate is good in Legacy despite the sorcery speed because it can also hit any land, right? Also what do you call multicoloured decks, starting from 2 colours, or 3 colours? A couple colourless sources in a bicolour deck wouldn't strike me as very dangerous, although Legacy being such a fast format is probably less forgiving of not having both your colours turn 2. The B enchant makes me wonder if it's funnier because it's silly, or because it works... in the context of the set at least. It looks like as long as you're into whether madness or delirium, it's good, and if a B archetype covers both it's a super value limited removal. But still, 5 lines of casting costs. :') | ||
|
jcarlsoniv
United States27922 Posts
On March 15 2016 05:52 Numy wrote: edit: Req - Game of Thrones is a pretty horrible adaption of Song of Ice and Fire if one wanted an adaption of the source material instead of merely writing a story for TV using source as an inspiration. Think you vastly overestimate peoples ability. It doesn't show the qualities Yanger is talking about in understanding both mediums as they just made a new story instead. Season 1 was an almost verbatim translation of Book 1. Not defending one argument vs the other, just pointing it out. I read Book 1 after watching Season 1 and was astounded at how well they were mirrored. | ||
|
Dandel Ion
Austria17960 Posts
| ||
|
Numy
South Africa35471 Posts
On March 15 2016 05:57 jcarlsoniv wrote: Season 1 was an almost verbatim translation of Book 1. Not defending one argument vs the other, just pointing it out. I read Book 1 after watching Season 1 and was astounded at how well they were mirrored. and even then they had to take some rather in your face approaches to convey certain thoughts that are key to the book. Like that scene with the prostitutes going at it with little finger talking about himself. It's just rather shit storytelling to have your own character explain his character lol. Also I should mention I don't mean a 1-1 translation is the only way to adapt or even the best. Certain things work in books that don't work on camera. That's why Lord of the Rings is such an amazing feat. They managed to capture the feel of the book while also making it work on camera. Game of Thrones kind of captured that but also didn't really at the same time. Part of that is the format of the books is rather hard to adapt. I think the success is more that it fills a rather large niche well that has been left untouched for so long. | ||
|
TheYango
United States47024 Posts
| ||
|
Alaric
France45622 Posts
Conspiracy is actually usable in Modern and Legacy? I thought these supplemental sets (like the Commander ones) weren't part of the usual blocks/sets and as such not legal? | ||
|
ticklishmusic
United States15977 Posts
I appreciate this post. | ||
|
Numy
South Africa35471 Posts
On March 15 2016 06:04 Alaric wrote: Goddamn it Monte. Conspiracy is actually usable in Modern and Legacy? I thought these supplemental sets (like the Commander ones) weren't part of the usual blocks/sets and as such not legal? They not legal in Modern. Only Legacy/Vintage | ||
|
Requizen
United States33802 Posts
On March 15 2016 05:54 TheYango wrote: That you "don't think it would be too hard" is incredibly insulting to career writers in both media. I'm not saying it's hard to do, I'm sure not just anyone could sit down and write it. I'm saying it's probably not too hard to find someone with an interest in both. They'd have to put a lot of work into it and it probably would still not be perfect, but the way you're saying it like we have to wait a few generations before this super movie/gaming mutant writer is born, which just doesn't make sense. | ||
|
TheYango
United States47024 Posts
A great comic book that's a little bit lost in adaptation is still a decent movie. A mediocre video game story that's a little bit lost in adaptation is a bad movie. The strength of the adaptation depends both on the quality of the adaptation and the strength of the original media. If the original media isn't good, adaptation isn't going to make it better. And no, we're nowhere close to how good video game writing could/needs to be. 50 years from now video game writing is going to be lightyears ahead of what we're getting now. | ||
|
MoonBear
Straight outta Johto18973 Posts
On March 15 2016 06:00 TheYango wrote: Vindicate isn't good in Legacy, lol. It was great when it was in Standard, but you usually don't want to pay 3 mana for sorcery-speed counterable removal in Legacy when cards like StP and Abrupt Decay exist. Council's Judgment is more or less a strict upgrade on Vindicate, since it doesn't target, and is still only a one-of or a sideboard card in 2 specific decks. Critically for Miracle decks it also acts as a 3-drop for your Counterbalance flips. On March 15 2016 05:39 TheYango wrote: Like, you raised the Marvel movies as an example of good comic book adaptations, but you're ignoring the fact that comic book movie adaptations were complete ass for literally DECADES. Good comic book adaptations are really only a product of like the last 10-15 years (starting with the 2000 X-Men film), which is incredibly recent compared to the age of the medium. Adaptations are hard because to really write a good adaptation you need a writer that understands both the media being adapted from and adapted to. Video games as a medium simply aren't old enough for there to exist experienced writers familiar with both flim and game writing. As I said, the industry is deficient even in writers that are good at just the game writing part. I want to emphasise this part. For a lot of comic book movies, previously some bigwig mobster at the studios just went "Nyah look here, see. The peoples want the comic books do they? Let's green light ten of them!" And then just throw money and expect it to work. The problem is you take people who don't understand the source material and expect them to just make something and you'll end up mostly with trash. Extra Credits did a good episode on this. See below. | ||
|
Requizen
United States33802 Posts
On March 15 2016 06:27 TheYango wrote: It's not "waiting a few generations before this super movie/gaming mutant writer is born", it's waiting for video game writing as a whole to be actually good enough that even an adaptation that loses some of its essence is still good. A great comic book that's a little bit lost in adaptation is still a decent movie. A mediocre video game story that's a little bit lost in adaptation is a bad movie. The strength of the adaptation depends both on the quality of the adaptation and the strength of the original media. If the original media isn't good, adaptation isn't going to make it better. That's assuming that all video game writing is, at best, mediocre. Which I would argue against. There are great stories out there to draw from. | ||
|
Numy
South Africa35471 Posts
Adapting material into a different medium is incredibly difficult. I'd say it may even be harder than writing your own content. This process is made even worse by how little power the writers actually have in these situations. We never get to see the process taking place but instead only see the end result. So if that's written terribly the writing team is often blamed even if the issues come more from executives themselves. On March 15 2016 06:31 Requizen wrote: That's assuming that all video game writing is, at best, mediocre. Which I would argue against. There are great stories out there to draw from. Writing and story quality isn't exactly the same thing. Writing in gaming means using the medium to it's fullest and not merely being movie/book in a game. I can't think of the great stories in games to draw from. I can think of great experiences but that doesn't really translate. | ||
|
TheYango
United States47024 Posts
On March 15 2016 06:31 Requizen wrote: That's assuming that all video game writing is, at best, mediocre. Which I would argue against. There are great stories out there to draw from. Then you're being impatient and/or not respecting how much time and experience vastly improves the quality of work in a medium. | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31495 Posts
| ||
|
Requizen
United States33802 Posts
On March 15 2016 06:34 TheYango wrote: Then you're being impatient and/or not respecting how much time and experience vastly improves the quality of work in a medium. That's not what I'm doing at all. I said that I realize it's not an easy task. But I can want it to be good. I get that you're just trying to pass it off as being "reasonable and realistic" but I think it's also kind of silly to just assume all game movies will necessarily be shit just based on that principle. Why can I not want them to be good? Why can I not expect something that I like to not be terrible? Call me idealistic if you want, but there's nothing saying I can't hope and expect for improvement rather than just letting myself be accepting of another shitty adaptation. I have high hopes for Warcraft. Assassin's Creed probably as well, as long as they don't dwell too much on anything relating to the later games. Uncharted will probably be fine as long as they just embrace the fact that it's a 2000's version of Indiana Jones. I think it's fine not to walk into the theater thinking that they'll be garbage and expecting more, especially when the studios are involved. | ||
| ||
