On March 15 2016 06:40 WaveofShadow wrote: Where do the Harry Potter movies fall?
Never read the books so no idea. I do remember at the time it was more "man Emma Watson is my soulmate" teenage crush so that may have changed my view on the movies. Movies themselves were kind of meh which could be the movies being bad or the books just not being great.
I tried reading the first two books but just couldn't handle. Surely Moonybear knows? Although his taste has been confirmed questionable.
On March 15 2016 06:40 WaveofShadow wrote: Where do the Harry Potter movies fall?
Never read the books so no idea. I do remember at the time it was more "man Emma Watson is my soulmate" teenage crush so that may have changed my view on the movies. Movies themselves were kind of meh which could be the movies being bad or the books just not being great.
I tried reading the first two books but just couldn't handle. Surely Moonybear knows? Although his taste has been confirmed questionable.
PoA is god-tier compared to the others. Cuaron really made something good there.
On March 15 2016 06:40 WaveofShadow wrote: Where do the Harry Potter movies fall?
Overall they were pretty decent. I had a major disconnect about halfway through the series when it was obvious that the actors/actresses were outpacing their characters age wise.
I think it's important to keep a broad perspective on what we mean when we say "video game movie". I know you're mostly talking about Hollywood live-action adaptations of video games, but some of the points raised so far in the discussion don't hold up if you try to universalize them beyond that specific context, imo.
Some "good (enough to come to mind)" video game movies that I've seen in order of preference: + Show Spoiler +
All those examples aren't so much good video game movie adaptations more than they are Anime/Film-like stories written for the original games. I'd argue that they made poor video game stories to begin with and function better in the "adapted" media because they aren't real adaptations.
Japan has a markedly different approach to video game writing where they don't use the interactivity of the medium as a storytelling tool. Layton and Final Fantasy are good examples of games where the gameplay plays almost no part in actually advancing story.
A lot of western games are designed this way as well but I think this is just bad game design and game writing. I simply don't think this is where the future of the medium lies. Because the end result is that you have an episodic anime where you have to run from point A to B on a world map or fight monsters in a dungeon before you're allowed to watch the next episode. Even if the individual components are good, they clash with one another rather than enhancing each other in the final product.
On March 15 2016 08:39 TheYango wrote: All those examples aren't so much good video game movie adaptations more than they are Anime/Film-like stories written for the original games. I'd argue that they made poor video game stories to begin with and function better in the "adapted" media because they aren't real adaptations.
Could you explain your conceptualization of the differences between these two categories a bit more?
On March 15 2016 08:39 TheYango wrote: Japan has a markedly different approach to video game writing where they don't use the interactivity of the medium as a storytelling tool. Layton and Final Fantasy are good examples of games where the gameplay plays almost no part in actually advancing story.
I think this is false, at least when generalized over all of Japanese game design. I don't think this claim any more accurately describes Japanese game design than it does Western game design, as there are certainly examples of both styles from both schools of design.
The Layton games at least approach this, and do occasionally get it right (maybe like 5-10% of the time?), but frequently drop the ball and resort to "Solve this puzzle to continue". Final Fantasy is a good example for your point. I would posit that the Phoenix Wright games integrate gameplay into the storytelling medium very thoroughly relative to most games (Japanese, Western, or otherwise) though, to reference the same list. To leave the list, and I acknowledge that this is an unpopular opinion, but I actually think (multiple-choice) VNs integrate gameplay into their storytelling medium very well, albeit in a minimalistic way, and Japan certainly has no shortage of these (although I'm not sure how much cultural penetration they have here).
On March 15 2016 08:39 TheYango wrote: A lot of western games are designed this way as well but I think this is just bad game design and game writing. I simply don't think this is where the future of the medium lies. Because the end result is that you have an episodic anime where you have to run from point A to B on a world map or fight monsters in a dungeon before you're allowed to watch the next episode. Even if the individual components are good, they clash with one another rather than enhancing each other in the final product.
I dunno, multiple choice VNs to me seem more like the natural evolution of choose-your-own-adventure books than a game. At the same time though I definitely think Phoenix Wright fits the bill for a game with pretty well integrated story and mechanics, and FF maybe not so much. Still, I don't want to discount the episodic-anime-within-a-game style because in my mind that style boils down to gameplay->cutscene reward->gameplay loops and I don't see anything intrinsically wrong with that. The use of it may change but I don't think you can say that the method will disappear.
As for the movies, I feel like Req to an extent. I'm not a huge CGI fan but I don't think it's a coincidence that LotR and all these superhero movies have chosen *now* to start being successful, when campy effects are no longer a problem (not to mention the spreading of nerd culture as Req stated. Remember those celebrity WoW ads?). Yes, precedent goes against the Warcraft movie, but saying that it's doomed from the start and suggesting that we won't see a good video game movie for decades seems very premature for me, even if that comic book comparison was hyperbole to some extent.
On March 15 2016 08:39 TheYango wrote: All those examples aren't so much good video game movie adaptations more than they are Anime/Film-like stories written for the original games. I'd argue that they made poor video game stories to begin with and function better in the "adapted" media because they aren't real adaptations.
Japan has a markedly different approach to video game writing where they don't use the interactivity of the medium as a storytelling tool. Layton and Final Fantasy are good examples of games where the gameplay plays almost no part in actually advancing story.
A lot of western games are designed this way as well but I think this is just bad game design and game writing. I simply don't think this is where the future of the medium lies. Because the end result is that you have an episodic anime where you have to run from point A to B on a world map or fight monsters in a dungeon before you're allowed to watch the next episode. Even if the individual components are good, they clash with one another rather than enhancing each other in the final product.
I could not agree with this post more. Seriously. Trying to play the typical AAA game is like doing two different things, neither of them done as well as they could have been. It's frustrating.
Also, to address the original discussion, I think that the insularity of Hollywood and its aversion to trying new or interesting things is a large inhibitor to the possibility of adapting a video game into a particularly great movie. Young writers that have an interest in both have yet to break into the upper echelons of the industry, and even if they have, adapting a AAA game (think lowest-common-denominator here) is generally going to require a blockbuster-size budget to have any hope of succeeding. There simply isn't enough precedent to make that a safe enough bet at the moment, even with game sales trending solidly upward over the past decade.
The WarCraft movie is an obvious exception as Blizzard likely has staked quite a bit of that sweet ATVI money in this movie, and can justify doing so because it serves as part of their marketing for World of Warcraft itself. Assassin's Creed is another AAA exception as it's certainly possible to tell a story adapted from that universe in a rather small number of settings and without extensive CGI or expensive props.
Just think of adapting a game like Mass Effect, for example. It would be astronomically expensive to make a passable film based on that game, and there's no reason to expect that it would sell more tickets than a similar film only with more of the budget spent on top-notch writers (or more CGI) rather than having to pay for the license to even use the name Mass Effect.
I have no idea what AlphaGo's reasons are behind these moves. Feels like it misread something again. AlphaGo is making weird mistakes again. It's interesting. I wonder if it feels behind already.
On March 15 2016 14:20 ketchup wrote: I have no idea what AlphaGo's reasons are behind these moves. Feels like it misread something again. AlphaGo is making weird mistakes again. It's interesting. I wonder if it feels behind already.
I wonder if Lee Sedol figured out moves that might cause AlphaGo to misplay obvious moves to pros.
On March 15 2016 14:20 ketchup wrote: I have no idea what AlphaGo's reasons are behind these moves. Feels like it misread something again. AlphaGo is making weird mistakes again. It's interesting. I wonder if it feels behind already.
I wonder if Lee Sedol figured out moves that might cause AlphaGo to misplay obvious moves to pros.
Well, in this case, alphago is choosing the moves. These aren't forced at all. This was alphago's decision to force this exchange. It's not really that great for white since it wasn't actually needed right this moment.
I don't think White has lost yet, but it's really weird exchange no matter what.