On March 14 2016 12:08 Alaric wrote: I'm not sure I understand how Crypt Incursion can deal damage, though. I don't think I've seen a card turning your lifegain into damage to your enemy, or exiling cards into enemy damage.
Was thinking wrong card, and now I can't find the card I was thinking of, lol.
On March 14 2016 13:42 WaveofShadow wrote: The durrrrrdle is real Also I'm super proud of myself, went 3-2 and actually prized in that sealed league. I can say with certainty the the U/G deck would have been wrong yangers, and probably W/G as well. The flier removal and grind (and negate!) I needed in the end would have likely been too much for other decks. I MAYBE could have seen that R/W deck working because it had removal on par with U/W but I would have needed to play Devastator/Behemoth. You are absolutely right about having a huge top end.
I don't think you've posted the list you actually used, tough. Here here!
I don't even remember the top end. Devastator, Behemoth, a Pathfinder with 2-3 C sources iirc? And Steppeglider for punching through if you went with W. Do you actually play counterspells often? I side them in most of the time, but I assume they can become hard removal (or the equivalent to an additional trick) in sealed if it's slow enough.
1) "Story is meaningless because your choices don't matter in the end"
Missing the point. This is an episodic game. Each episode, while building up towards a bigger story, is meant to have a beginning, middle and end of its own. Kate's suicide and trying to prevent it is a story of its own (but then let's not act like fallout of it is not present in later episodes). All the other plots serve, you know, having their own developments and conclusions (like what's your relationship with Victoria and Warren, how does Chloe's story with Frank end, David's and all those others).
And here's the even more important part - living through all those and deciding the outcome makes part of the final choice be that 1) they never happened and you have to start from scratch, or 2) they all happened but it's all meaningless because they're all dead. It's an interesting and unique use of subplots, saying they are all meaningless is ignoring that. Not to mention that that's implying they aren't simply interesting on their own.
2) Max
The entire point of the game (as evidenced by the dream sequence at the end) is about how timerewinding powers change Max. The only reason you become more "fearless" and "stand on your own" is because you have fucking rewind powers that make you not-scared of fucking up because you can always just rewind it (similarly to anime Ereased where the character goes back in time to when he was 11 with mind of a 26-year-old and gee suddenly he acts way more mature and less scared and everyone notices something is off about him). Even more importantly, it's about how your version of the character changes, how you as the player use and interpret those. When you talk with the other Max, she implies that you act like you used the powers to help others, while really you were just selfish. Whether you agree with that or not might not matter for the story, but it changes how you view it and its an interesting question on its own, especially after we just saw all of Max's fears and insecurities. Plus now you're acting like shy people who want to be more outgoing but have low self-esteem don't exist and are just mix of bad acting and lack of development.
3) Other stuff
Ending You're essentially complaining that a) Chloe is a tragic character, so I guess you also hate ancient greek dramas? b) there's no happy ending/closure, except there actually is and you have to choose which of those you prefer.
"Why did Max’s power stop working only once in the entire game?" Because you don't know how they work. You are messing with unknown. God forbid an element of mystery in a plot.
"What happened to the nosebleeds?" She keeps getting them till the end and even passes out at one point.
"Why did Max ever get this power in the first place when she’s not even supposed to use it?" This question makes too many assumptions to answer seriously.
"why the entire point of the ending is that she shouldn’t ever use them." No, the point of ending is that you learn it has consequences. Just like every other choice in the game. And just like every choice in the game, you get to reverse it, or stick with it because you think it's worth it. It's like pottery.
"BUT SERIOUSLY WHY WERE THERE VISIONS OF TORNADOES BEFORE MAX EVEN DID ANYTHING?" I was expecting something Inception-esque at one point but I guess I was wrong on that. All in all I can more or less mental gymnastic myself around all the issues you wrote in that capslock paragraph.
Also there's a lot of minor points I disagree with and impressions that are personal-experience based that we differ on so I guess all I can say is fuck america.
I'm defending a telltale-style "game" made by oversensitive sjws probably just because it has a girl with blue hair, brb killing myself.
You shouldn't give excuses for poor writing just because you can. Telltale games have potential but as I keep harping on the writing in vidja games is either poor or mediocre because of the lack of talent.
@Ghandi Although I just watch like an hour (?) of game play on your stream. The game runs like a young adult / teen book. It encapsulated the general weak writing of genre and the characters. Max is a twilight girl (a character to mirror yourself) but is so poorly done that she lacks personality enough to even see yourself in here. The rest are simply more or less forced plot devices which lack the proper writing to make them believe able.
On March 14 2016 19:01 Eppa! wrote: You shouldn't give excuses for poor writing just because you can. Telltale games have potential but as I keep harping on the writing in vidja games is either poor or mediocre because of the lack of talent.
@Ghandi Although I just watch like an hour (?) of game play on your stream. The game runs like a young adult / teen book. It encapsulated the general weak writing of genre and the characters. Max is a twilight girl (a character to mirror yourself) but is so poorly done that she lacks personality enough to even see yourself in here. The rest are simply more or less forced plot devices which lack the proper writing to make them believe able.
Then again they say NERD ALERT so 10/10.
You'd be surprised how much bitching went on when the game was new when people didn't like something Max did. While the game's design does let you have a decent amount of autonomy, there are things that are unshakably Max.
Which is the inherent flaw of poor character writing. The aim of the character is either missed on they were to dumb to see that this is what she should have been.
On March 14 2016 21:13 Eppa! wrote: Which is the inherent flaw of poor character writing. The aim of the character is either missed on they were to dumb to see that this is what she should have been.
Or the gaming community is so used to piloting an empty shell that they forgot how to actually play a role.
On March 14 2016 21:13 Eppa! wrote: Which is the inherent flaw of poor character writing. The aim of the character is either missed on they were to dumb to see that this is what she should have been.
Or the gaming community is so used to piloting an empty shell that they forgot how to actually play a role.
Disagree. See undertale. While frisk is by definition an empty shell, to get the two 'main' endings you have to play roles in very specific ways and your choices are made for you.
Edit: although mehhhh it's probably not a good example because frisk really isn't much of a character
And Alaric I'll post the list for you a little later.
SOI spoiler start and the first one is a cheaper Utter End that loses you life. I'm playing a lifegain deck, I don't care, I'll get 3 of these as replacement (plus if there's enough life to gain, it actually beats Stasis Snare mana-wise so even better).
On the other hand, a big guy from our client just started redirecting all the redmine "issues" they answered to without telling us for the last 3+ weeks, so now we've got 20 or so issues to resolve, some of them "urgent" which means we've got under 3 hours to solve 6 of them or else we incur penalties. I swear, if they fucking try to make us responsible fo rnot working fast enough when they drop almost a week's worth of work on us in half a day with a bunch of them tagged "asap"...
im on a phone so I'll keep it short, but I want to talk about the tornado. Why it's there already makes little sense at all, since the game gives no real hints of being absurdist outside maxs head, and no butterfly effect can explain how Chloe caused a series of natural disasters, so it just felt like a cheap plot device to stir emotion. I think the creators just had this ending in mind from the beginning, and basically wanted it in even if they couldn't give a good reason for it. Also, killing an ENTIRE TOWN is a bad ending whether they like it or not, but I talked about that already.
I don't really like Greek tragedies as a personal thing, but I don't think these two are comparable in this case, especially my complaints. In Greek tragedies, the death is something the character either deserved, or is the result of coincidence that loops the beginning of the story back. Chloes ending just trivializes her character, and it isn't the result of any of the themes of her character that we've built throughout the game. If this were a Greek Tragedy, Chloe would die because someone cared about her too much, as the theme she's built is one of abandonment. Chloe's character, for that ending, didn't matter at all. The second ending justifies her character somewhat, but it still makes no sense for a character to ever choose that.
Also about the episodic nature, that's all well and good if it has at least SOME relevance to ANYTHING about the ending. It did affect characters in the later chapters but that never mattered because realistically every single one of their roles is nothing more than filler to give max something to do other than bond with Chloe. An example of how episodic nature can work is Wolf Among Us. I'll admit that a crime drama is easier to drop relevant cliffhangers, but I don't see why LiS had to drop cliffhangers. I would have kept playing even without them as long as they used their time to do something interesting like ensure that a single one of of,my choices affects the ending in any way.
im on a phone so I'll keep it short, but I want to talk about the tornado. Why it's there already makes little sense at all, since the game gives no real hints of being absurdist outside maxs head, and no butterfly effect can explain how Chloe caused a series of natural disasters, so it just felt like a cheap plot device to stir emotion. I think the creators just had this ending in mind from the beginning, and basically wanted it in even if they couldn't give a good reason for it. Also, killing an ENTIRE TOWN is a bad ending whether they like it or not, but I talked about that already.
I don't really like Greek tragedies as a personal thing, but I don't think these two are comparable in this case, especially my complaints. In Greek tragedies, the death is something the character either deserved, or is the result of coincidence that loops the beginning of the story back. Chloes ending just trivializes her character, and it isn't the result of any of the themes of her character that we've built throughout the game. If this were a Greek Tragedy, Chloe would die because someone cared about her too much, as the theme she's built is one of abandonment. Chloe's character, for that ending, didn't matter at all. The second ending justifies her character somewhat, but it still makes no sense for a character to ever choose that.
Also about the episodic nature, that's all well and good if it has at least SOME relevance to ANYTHING about the ending. It did affect characters in the later chapters but that never mattered because realistically every single one of their roles is nothing more than filler to give max something to do other than bond with Chloe. An example of how episodic nature can work is Wolf Among Us. I'll admit that a crime drama is easier to drop relevant cliffhangers, but I don't see why LiS had to drop cliffhangers. I would have kept playing even without them as long as they used their time to do something interesting like ensure that a single one of of,my choices affects the ending in any way.
It's playing off the black hole in Donnie Darko, something that is referenced a lot in the game. Except by having it be a tornado that eventually dissipates and not being a black hole that destroys the universe eventually, the greater impact is lost.
im on a phone so I'll keep it short, but I want to talk about the tornado. Why it's there already makes little sense at all, since the game gives no real hints of being absurdist outside maxs head, and no butterfly effect can explain how Chloe caused a series of natural disasters, so it just felt like a cheap plot device to stir emotion. I think the creators just had this ending in mind from the beginning, and basically wanted it in even if they couldn't give a good reason for it. Also, killing an ENTIRE TOWN is a bad ending whether they like it or not, but I talked about that already.
I don't really like Greek tragedies as a personal thing, but I don't think these two are comparable in this case, especially my complaints. In Greek tragedies, the death is something the character either deserved, or is the result of coincidence that loops the beginning of the story back. Chloes ending just trivializes her character, and it isn't the result of any of the themes of her character that we've built throughout the game. If this were a Greek Tragedy, Chloe would die because someone cared about her too much, as the theme she's built is one of abandonment. Chloe's character, for that ending, didn't matter at all. The second ending justifies her character somewhat, but it still makes no sense for a character to ever choose that.
Also about the episodic nature, that's all well and good if it has at least SOME relevance to ANYTHING about the ending. It did affect characters in the later chapters but that never mattered because realistically every single one of their roles is nothing more than filler to give max something to do other than bond with Chloe. An example of how episodic nature can work is Wolf Among Us. I'll admit that a crime drama is easier to drop relevant cliffhangers, but I don't see why LiS had to drop cliffhangers. I would have kept playing even without them as long as they used their time to do something interesting like ensure that a single one of of,my choices affects the ending in any way.
It's playing off the black hole in Donnie Darko, something that is referenced a lot in the game. Except by having it be a tornado that eventually dissipates and not being a black hole that destroys the universe eventually, the greater impact is lost.
On March 14 2016 21:13 Eppa! wrote: Which is the inherent flaw of poor character writing. The aim of the character is either missed on they were to dumb to see that this is what she should have been.
So you're calling it poor writing because Max isn't Kristen Stewart blank slate?.
Or because you think she is?
I'm rather confused about what your point on poor writing even is.
Regardless, I have my own thoughts on the game I'll publish to my TL blog.
Oh yeah I've gotta watch Donnie Darko one day too... damn. (Also not sure of what to think about Nahiri. Looks more like a story card than a character card, apart from maybe her minus it doesn't really ooze lithomancy. )