|
United States47024 Posts
On March 05 2016 10:27 oneofthem wrote: well for high school level you cna learn stuff like algorithm design to get the basic theory of programming. it doesn't have to be mandatory for every kid.
I mean, this is essentially why the AP CS exams exists, the problem is that the AP CS exams, and by extension, most AP CS classes, are pretty shit.
To be quite honest, the awful state of AP CS classes compared to like AP Calc or Physics or US History just shows that the public school system would be inadequately equipped to properly implement widespread programming education anyway.
And seeing as anyone with decent enough programming skills to teach a class could make massively more money in industry than working as a school teacher, it would be slow for that to change.
|
On March 05 2016 12:18 TheYango wrote:Show nested quote +On March 05 2016 10:27 oneofthem wrote: well for high school level you cna learn stuff like algorithm design to get the basic theory of programming. it doesn't have to be mandatory for every kid.
I mean, this is essentially why the AP CS exams exists, the problem is that the AP CS exams, and by extension, most AP CS classes, are pretty shit. To be quite honest, the awful state of AP CS classes compared to like AP Calc or Physics or US History just shows that the public school system would be inadequately equipped to properly implement widespread programming education anyway. the public school system is very poorly equipped to adapt. it's designed for a set amount of information to be transferred to students. but the modern world is adapting so many things so quickly there is little way for school board members (as many of them are long term positions, and older people in the community), to keep up.
|
On March 05 2016 09:37 Alaric wrote:Crown of worst draft ever awarded without second thoughts. Shit deck, 0-6, no enjoyment at all, forcing myself to crack jokes because I don't want to ruin the others' mood (including when they pretend it's ridiculous from me to call a loss). From now on I'll walk straight out the door any evening when we're 10 people. 6 is already bad, 10 is a joke. + Show Spoiler [deck] ++ Show Spoiler [Deck match 3] +Island x3 Forest x5 Mountain x7 Unknown Shores x2
Reality Hemorrhage Zada's Commando Lead by Example
Spell Shrivel Void Shatter Lifespring Druid Natural Connection Retreat to Kazandu Tajuru Stalwart Herald of Kozilek Eldrazi Aggressor Scion Summoner Relentless Hunter
Eyeless Watcher Comparative Analysis Embodiment of Fury
Cyclone Sire Stonefury Boulder Salvo Tajuru Pathwarden
Sphinx of the Last Word
Breaker of Armies
Other cards used at some point: Another Herald of Kozilek, Eldrazi Immobiliser, Grip of the Roil. Other cards: Tar Snare x2, another Natural Connection, Crab, the Collector Troll, Brute Strength. I have even less removal/tricks than yesterday. The counters got sided in (starting build was Herald and Immobiliser in, counters out) because it was the only semblance of removal I had for "tapping out a big guy out" stuff since my meager removal would need to get used early. Grip was sided in during match 2 for one Herald. Yes, it's 3 colours. No, I couldn't do it in any way possible (which I kinda knew even before the BFZ pack). No, I had no mana issues except once when I had an Unknown Shores out so couldn't get the 3/4 Stalwart nor the Cultivator on curve (didn't matter). I thought Heralds were going to be good but unless I curved them out they wouldn't reduce much stuff. Again, bad early game, empty midgame, late game not worth it. I'll put it simply: I saw 8 of the other 9 decks. All of them had 4+ hard removal available. You know how I'm the guy overvaluing removal? I still fucking managed to be the guy with likely the least removal in his viable pool of the entire table. + Show Spoiler [draft] +P1P1 has Embodiment, Oblivion Strike, Essence Depleter, and the unco -2/-2 exile deads. I heeded Yango for once, and made a note that B was likely dead in pack 2. Even if I had picked O. Strike of Essence Depleter, I'd just pass too much good stuff for them not to try B.
I got a Commando and Hemorrhage rather early, same with Relentless Hunter. Saw a couple W (Ondu War Cleric) that I passed 'cause I had better, picked a couple Tar Snares because I didn't see better. Shrieker and Immobiliser were picked early too, and later in the pack I had the first Unkown Shores (I think I passed a Stalker Drone early-ish too).
P2P1 was the Sphinx I opened. I didn't see much G in this pack, almost no W, no B at all, so I picked some U (Void Shatter, Cyclone Sire, Analysis) and some G crumbs. At that point it was clear R was my primary colour, and I didn't have enough in U or G yet to make one the other primary. I picked another Unknown Shores but passed a Holdout Settlement right after (thought about picking it and running one of each, I think it'd have been the better choice). There was a Blinding Drone early in the pack, I didn't really have C yet and only the Sphinx and maybe a crab, so I kinda wanted to pick it (thought it meant U open) but without stuff around it I picked something else. Oh, I passed a Pulse too. To pick another G card, I hesitated to pick it (didn't have Breaker yet or Pathwarden, only Sphinx as a solid target).
BFZ pack gave me Stalwart, Herald x2, Breaker (I passed a Devastator, it wouldn't have changed anything), Natural Connection x2, snap Stonefury, Lifespring Druid, Retreat which I picked because I clearly had a shitty midgame apart from the "ramp the Sphinx/Breaker out" ""dream"" so putting some counters could help a lot. I passed Emeria Shepherd, Planar Outburst and another big W card, shaking my head.
Now. I knew the guys to my left were in B. They were also both in G which is why I got so little (the guy immediatly to my left had basically nothing in G and barely B in the 2nd pack). 2 places to my left, ending 3-0: opened Nissa's Judgement pack 1, picked the O. Strike he got passed from mine. Got another Judgement and another O. Strike pack 2, along with Sifter of Skulls, Null Caller, Shrieker, a Pathwarden, a second Stalker Drone, some C sources.
Another guy opened TKS pack 1, got passed Embodiment of Insight. Opened Reality Smasher pack 2, and then got passed a World Breaker. Just for good measure he got a Mimic too. He ended 2nd with 2-1 losing to the winner.
Another picked up Chandra, a couple Eldrazi with a Vile Aggregate in BFZ.
These are the people I did not play. And of course 10 people means once you pass a pack you'll likely only collect the trashiest when it comes back. I loath this crowded of a table. + Show Spoiler [matches] +Match 1 against UW Don't really remember what he had. Flyers, a wall, a fuckton of removal (Searing Light, Isolation Zone, Smite the Monstruous, Encircling Fissure, another one). Oh, Reflector Mage too (he had two I only saw one). Basically gummed and attacked with Flyers till I played Sphinx, got annoyed despite how massively ahead he was (aw, poor thing, you can't exile it, gotta settle for the Breaker, what a blowout for you). He topdecks Cliffside Lookout 2 turns later, I stop giving a fuck and swing because we've been at it for super long and he's wide enough to kill me soon. He doesn't fall for it of course. Game 2: fuck if I even remember. Not worth mentioning. I think it was one of the 3 games where I flooded (as in drew over half lands overall). I lost faster (because I didn't have Kazandu to win me 6-8 life this game; I used it on Cyclone Sire once, just so he could kill it with Smite the Monstruous). Match 2 against UR surge/allies/aggro Game 1: Mull to 5 vs Jori-En on curve. What happens? + Show Spoiler +He had 7 more cards than me by the end. Anticipate EoT 2, 2 from my mulls, 4 from Jori-En. Game 2: oh, yeah. He had Coralhelm Guide, 2x Firemantle Mages, a Freerunner he surged out turn 4. He showed Hemorrhage and Salvo too. Once he's got 5+ mana it doesn't matter that he doesn't drop allies for the menace, he just makes Guide unblockable and pings with it, I'm at 6 life anyway. Match 3 vs UB Eldrazi, the guy had 3 Blinding Drones, 6+ removals, and 4+ flyers. My build couldn't beat his just because of the flyers. Game 1: I burn early removal on the two blinding drones he puts out (and he has 2 C sources), start hitting, he puts out flyers. I use Eyeless Watcher to get Breaker out before I hit 8 lands, Swept Away. I play it again next turn, low on life because flyers but I can still beat him with that 2 turns clock. He's empty-handed, has a Lantern's Seer out. Scries EoT, puts bottom. Scries pre-draw, puts bottom. Topdecks Ruinous Path. Cyclone Sire got exiled too. Game 2: Cultivator Drone, Warden of Geometries, I put a couple Scions out, he swings with flyers, I use Druid+Cultivator + scions to get Breaker out early. Doesn't matter, Swept Away and plays a Blinding Drone (so I'll never get to swing). Next turn, taps with Blinding Drone, plays whatever, surges membrane on Breaker. Plays Rising Miasma following turn for the heck of it to clear my watcher+druid+scions, then also the B flyer forcing me to sacrifice something (yo I could have ued a Pulse there... na, just kidding I had already lost with low life total). Swings with flyers. + Show Spoiler [thoughts] +Look, I'm not looking for advice. It was a terrible and shit draft where I got passed almost nothing, got royally screwed in one of my colours because of my left neighbours, and only got the crumbs of another while I knew a 4th was unplayable and I didn't get into the 5th. There's simply nothing I could have done at that point. I don't care about what "can" be said, it was a drag, I wasted 4 hours tapping lands and putting cards on a table while watching my opponent win alone, playing double the removal than I had good cards/bombs while I had the reverse (esp. game 3, remove the drones get killed by flyers, remove the flyers get tapped by drones).
I'm not even angry. I don't think I could be angry even if I tried to muster the rage. I'm just pissed off and weary at that miserable experience.
In retrospect I should have rushed W when I saw apparently decent picks. Not bothered with U (UU in Sphinx means no splash), and maybe the change would have made the cards passed to me different. As is I had a decent colour in R and either nothing or crumbs in the rest.
Oh, yeah, prizes. Who gives a damn, there were a ton of good cards but last of a 10-man draft means "go fuck yourself dry." Chandra, Reality Smasher, World Breaker, TKS, Mimic, BR battleland, Quarantine Field,Planar Outburst, Ruinous Path x2, Sphinx. I got Ruinous Path, Sifter of Skulls and Emeria Shepherd. Sometimes it's just bad drafts and bad luck too.
|
I want someone to walk me through why they think coding would be needed as a mandatory class even starting in high school(disregarding the parts about whether or not people can handle it at that point or that our educational system could implement it).
Like, Req said something about 'we have the internet in our pocket so it would be useful'(bad paraphrasing), but... why?
I was going to type more after that to lead it in certain directions but instead I'm going to play stupid and leave it there for broader interpretation because I am genuinely interested in where this goes, especially as a person that has far better than the layman knowledge of coding(I took a pair of C++ classes in high school and have self taught myself HTML and MySQL to the point that I can do basic web development) yet still doesn't really see the need for it in such a broad spectrum.
|
On March 05 2016 13:40 red_ wrote: I want someone to walk me through why they think coding would be needed as a mandatory class even starting in high school(disregarding the parts about whether or not people can handle it at that point or that our educational system could implement it).
Like, Req said something about 'we have the internet in our pocket so it would be useful'(bad paraphrasing), but... why?
I was going to type more after that to lead it in certain directions but instead I'm going to play stupid and leave it there for broader interpretation because I am genuinely interested in where this goes, especially as a person that has far better than the layman knowledge of coding(I took a pair of C++ classes in high school and have self taught myself HTML and MySQL to the point that I can do basic web development) yet still doesn't really see the need for it in such a broad spectrum. I don't think coding does, but I think some form of logic course should be done, or at least something that requires strict development of troubleshooting by understanding how systems work. I think coding would probably be over kill, but some form of technological logics course would greatly improve thought process for a lot of students. Even so, I still think the thought process of teaching them coding would be loss on a majority of students.
For example, I thought one of the best upper division courses I took in college was Plant Pathology, but because I particularly cared about plant diseases, but because the instructor did a really good job going over diagnosing problems, and various ways of how to deal with diseased plants. While majority of my peers just took these as "oh memorize these facts for tests, discard after final". I took the "how" as more a much more illuminated way of how to think of problems and breaking them down in a problem solving situation.
|
Honestly one of the most logic driven things you can learn in high school IS chemical reactions. it's pretty simple, follows a logical pattern with easily knowable rules, can be drawn or mathed or modeled to solve as well, teaching multiple approaches with the same ruleset. but Req's stance was that chemistry reading and history were no where near as important as coding.
The important thing is that every student will find something else that engages them and helps them learn, so options should be available and encouraged.
|
United States47024 Posts
On March 05 2016 13:49 wei2coolman wrote: While majority of my peers just took these as "oh memorize these facts for tests, discard after final"/ This is exactly why it being mandatory is questionable though. The only people who are likely to get anything out of the class are those who would have willingly chosen to take it as an elective like AP CS anyway. So that still doesn't say why it should be mandatory, only why it should be offered.
|
On March 05 2016 14:12 TheYango wrote:Show nested quote +On March 05 2016 13:49 wei2coolman wrote: While majority of my peers just took these as "oh memorize these facts for tests, discard after final"/ This is exactly why it being mandatory is questionable though. The only people who are likely to get anything out of the class are those who would have willingly chosen to take it as an elective like AP CS anyway. So that still doesn't say why it should be mandatory, only why it should be offered. I think an introductory course to get more students interested is at least warranted, imo.
On March 05 2016 14:06 PrinceXizor wrote: Honestly one of the most logic driven things you can learn in high school IS chemical reactions. it's pretty simple, follows a logical pattern with easily knowable rules, can be drawn or mathed or modeled to solve as well, teaching multiple approaches with the same ruleset. but Req's stance was that chemistry reading and history were no where near as important as coding.
The important thing is that every student will find something else that engages them and helps them learn, so options should be available and encouraged. Problem is the way it's taught is pretty awful, and pretty abstract considering how little people actually use these skill on a day to day basis, and majority of the introductory course is essentially a math class.
|
United States47024 Posts
On March 05 2016 14:06 PrinceXizor wrote: but Req's stance was that chemistry reading and history were no where near as important as coding. Req is also super biased from the perspective of:
a) being someone whose livelihood currently depends on his coding expertise, and b) someone for whom coding and logical thinking came pretty naturally and therefore is more apt to find places where a similar approach to problem solving would be applicable.
His experience isn't really extensible to the general public and most people for whom b would be true would already elect to take AP CS in high school if the AP CS class at their high school isn't terrible (it usually is). Again, this is not a problem that really makes sense to solve by overhauling the system when the system already can't adequately support the options already in place.
|
I'm not saying that coding is more important than those, it's that none of them are any more important than any others. Like, you might never use coding, but I'm never going to use anything I learned in most of my grade/high school classes. I think knowing what HTML/CSS/C#/SQL are will probably come up as much (if not more) than anything you learn in Western History.
If you're going to make anything mandatory, it should probably be something that you can use in a multitude of career paths, rather than things that kids are just going to retain long enough to regurgitate and then forget.
|
On March 05 2016 14:56 Requizen wrote: I'm not saying that coding is more important than those, it's that none of them are any more important than any others. Like, you might never use coding, but I'm never going to use anything I learned in most of my grade/high school classes. I think knowing what HTML/CSS/C#/SQL are will probably come up as much (if not more) than anything you learn in Western History.
If you're going to make anything mandatory, it should probably be something that you can use in a multitude of career paths, rather than things that kids are just going to retain long enough to regurgitate and then forget.
I think they should just give kids Arduino's/Raspberry Pi's and let them be creative (guided ofc). Let people make some cool shit.
|
On March 05 2016 14:56 Requizen wrote: I'm not saying that coding is more important than those, it's that none of them are any more important than any others. Like, you might never use coding, but I'm never going to use anything I learned in most of my grade/high school classes. I think knowing what HTML/CSS/C#/SQL are will probably come up as much (if not more) than anything you learn in Western History.
If you're going to make anything mandatory, it should probably be something that you can use in a multitude of career paths, rather than things that kids are just going to retain long enough to regurgitate and then forget. I don't think i've ever had a moment in my life where coding knowledge would have come in handy. i don't live a life where I've needed it ever. but i've definitely used stuff from european history, from economics, from statistics and basic maths, literature classes, etc. i use all that stuff at least once a week each. significantly more for stuff related to my field.
But if there was a useful trade skill that could be taught to kids, baking or cooking would probably be it. it's an every single day sort of thing, it involves physics and chemistry and biology and math, it's creative and analytical, and it's genuinely something the kids will use.
a close second would be brewing probably. just as full of science and stuff, but also pretty important to our country.
But that one would be a really tough sell to parents haha.
|
United States15536 Posts
I would feel a lot less on a random tether in economic space if I didn't feel like I was constantly guessing about doing my finances. That would be a damn good thing to learn in school.
|
On March 05 2016 17:11 AsmodeusXI wrote: I would feel a lot less on a random tether in economic space if I didn't feel like I was constantly guessing about doing my finances. That would be a damn good thing to learn in school. I've heard YNAB is really really good for that.
|
On March 05 2016 17:11 AsmodeusXI wrote: I would feel a lot less on a random tether in economic space if I didn't feel like I was constantly guessing about doing my finances. That would be a damn good thing to learn in school. definitely. idk how widespread it is but in high school we had a mandatory class where you had to learn about insurance, how to write checks, how credit cards work, basic shit like that and it was pretty useful even if I knew alot of that stuff. Going more in depth and talking about how to budget and saving money etc. would definitely be pretty useful.
I dont know about making it mandatory but I definitely think making coding classes in HS more widespread would be a good thing. Like others said it's not just about coding but about teaching logic/reasoning skills etc. My old high school started offering coding classes and basic engineering classes as electives since I graduated, I kinda wish they'd been around when I was there cause they seem like really useful/interesting classes to take.
|
United States47024 Posts
Again, most of what qualifies as an intro coding class falls under the realm of an AP CS class, it's just the AP CS curriculum is hugely neglected compared to the core science/humanities APs.
Reinventing the wheel isn't going to fix the underlying problem that makes it hard for high schools to properly teach AP CS.
|
On March 05 2016 13:40 red_ wrote: I want someone to walk me through why they think coding would be needed as a mandatory class even starting in high school(disregarding the parts about whether or not people can handle it at that point or that our educational system could implement it).
Like, Req said something about 'we have the internet in our pocket so it would be useful'(bad paraphrasing), but... why?
I was going to type more after that to lead it in certain directions but instead I'm going to play stupid and leave it there for broader interpretation because I am genuinely interested in where this goes, especially as a person that has far better than the layman knowledge of coding(I took a pair of C++ classes in high school and have self taught myself HTML and MySQL to the point that I can do basic web development) yet still doesn't really see the need for it in such a broad spectrum.
Coding is essentially basics maths in that they both teach the same logical approach to things. I don't think Coding should be mandatory, merely improve how you teach your basic maths so that people can get those fundamentals in logical thinking which would allow them to go try coding in whatever language they wanted.
On March 05 2016 14:06 PrinceXizor wrote: but Req's stance was that chemistry reading and history were no where near as important as coding.
This I find kind of funny. When people talk about Chemistry what exactly are they talking about? There are 2 massively different branches of chemistry that completely change the discussion at hand. Organic chemistry is largely useless for anyone not specifically working in that field and even then it's pretty useless if you aren't working in a lab(I should know, no chem eng guy I know uses 2nd year organic for anything). Physical Chemistry on the other hand can be very useful. That's where you can do basic stuff like heat exchange, pressure systems etc. It might not be applicable every day kind of stuff but it's information that may help you identify problems one day.
History is massively important and the fact that I read anyone on LLL saying it's not has made me very sad. History isn't just about memorizing events that happened in the past. History is about interpreting and discussing why these events happened while forming your ability to not only critically think but also to problem argue a point using evidence. It teaches you skills to better form your own arguments as well as how to convey that argument across. This isn't even breaching the subject of how learning from history is one way we can avoid mistakes in the present. History is one of the most important subjects children should be talk at school along with maths. They teach skills that apply to almost every facet of life.
On March 05 2016 10:01 TheHumanSensation wrote:Show nested quote +On March 05 2016 04:38 Numy wrote: You can try moe anime. 10 years of watching serious anime all ruined when my life went to shit and moe was all these was to keep going. I don't know why but dam I got into K-ON hard man. It''s a dark hole though. Avoid it! Next you'll go watch To-love RU for the story!
In all seriousness just try take 1 day at a time. Find something you enjoy regardless of what it is or how good you are at it. Numy I just want you to know that I think you're one of the most endearing characters in LLL and I thoroughly enjoy learning your backstory.
I don't know how I feel about this . My backstory is rather boring passage riddled with failure without even a cute woman to cuddle with. Well at least I got a teddy from one to cuddle with. He's awesome.
edit: Hmm now that I think about I don't know if I should call Tracey cute, think she may kill me. Although at this rate she may kill me for a whole host of things. She's pretty though. Let's go with that shall we.
|
It refelcts public opinion, and then people are surprised the school system is shit after you push from actual learning towards just aquiring skills. Not that that's the only reason but eyy.
Plus I don't really know why people think it's bad that your parents teach you something. It's kind of what they do. The school isn't and shouldn't be responsible for everything.
|
There's nothing wrong with teachings specific skills, it's just that one shouldn't compromise learning in general just to focus on those specific skills. There should be a balance between the two where you are teaching children fundamentals like basic logic and how to form/build an argument but also teaching them specific skills they'll need for employment. In general though I find education is far too focused on what you need to get a job. If your fundamentals are good you'll be able to learn the skills you need for the job anyway while being malleable enough to keep learning. If you just focus on those skills one may not be able to continue to grow.
Anyway for Req or whoever reads Prachet I finished Feet of Clay. Thoughts:+ Show Spoiler +Really enjoyed the philosophical golem. The thing with Nobby was a bit weird but everything else was cool. Cheri's blight was about how to be a women was cute. Angua is annoying me a bit. She needs to make up her mind if she wants to be with Carrot or not. Stop being so afraid girl! Carrot also needs to get over his upbringing at times. The whole thing with Cheri was a bit much but then he was so cool with the golem so idk. Man is confusing. The Patriarch is still awesome
|
Saw Zootopia a couple nights ago, pretty decent. Weekday at night meant we were the only 4 people in the theater. Was nice.
|
|
|
|
|
|