Disclaimer/TL;DR: well-placed contestant for worst draft ever. (Also I pulled a couple little-money rares so you can harp on the redraft policy at will.) + Show Spoiler [draft] +P1P1 O. Strike over Goblin Dark Dwellers and Embodiment of Fury. I was about to take the Embodiment (plus I don't own one and it'd go right into my EDH) when I saw the strike. Hesitated. Went for strike, made a mental note that red would prob be dead after I passed both these cards. P1P2 Vampire Envoy and P1P3 Vile Redeemer, packs didn't have anything special. Amongst the stuff I passed in the following picks, Unknown Shores, Gravity Negator, Zada's Commando, foil UB tapland (I took another one, and there was a third taken by my left neighbour in the second pack), Mindmelter. I saw my neighbour pick an Isolation Zone by mistake, so W and R are probably gonna get taken, W is indeed piss poor (the guy to his right is taking a lot of it), so I'm mostly GB and some U at that point with Slaughter Drone, Lagac x2, Scion Summoner...
P2P1 Reality Smasher snap pick. I think I'll try to start looking at C sources, and a Warden of Geometries show up. Non-basics are non-existent (I pass a Wandering Fumaroles 'cause not in my colours). This pack gave me almost nothing is neither B nor G. I don't really get it, I pretty much only passed Vampire Envoy and a Stalking Drone, and the guys to my left are still hogging this shit as hard as they could. I picked up som U instead, membrane, Crab, Sweep Away, Canopy Gorger, Corpse Churn... yeah.
P3P1 is Void Winnower snap pick. I snatch Demon's Grasp, Deathless Behemoth, Kozilek's Channeler, Eldrazi Devastator since I had a bunch of ramp, like Call the Scions. + Show Spoiler [deck] ++ Show Spoiler [list] +Wastes Forest x9 Swamp x7
Unnatural Endurance Vines of the Recluse
Loam Larva Slaughter Drone Elemental Uprising (replaced by Bone Splinters during match 3)
Call the Scions Scion Summoner Pulse of Murasa Vampire Envoy Vile Redeemer x2
Mindraker (replaced with Corpse Churn for game 3) Witness the End (replaced by Mire's Malice as an additional "creature" if need be, then out for Seer's Lantern) Warden of Geometries Oblivion Strike Saddleback Lagac x2
Kozilek's Channeler Demon's Grasp Reality Smasher
Deathless Behemoth Void Winnower
Eldrazi Devastator I didn't put U in because I already felt tight and had no creatures to had. Spell Shrivel, membrane, Sweep Away, Negate, basically. Didn't add Tajuru Beastmaster because my curve was already too depleted on turn 3-4 for my liking. I didn't like this deck. It felt light on creatures after the first game when I reviewed it, but it also felt light on removal. I've mentioned it multiple times but if I don't have hard removal to fall back on I feel naked, and it's basically the first time I don't have 4+ removal cards. I don't have sturdy blockers/stuff like Spawnbinder Mage as stall/pseudo-removal either. I thought with the Lagacs and removal I could hold the midgame and then get a couple big creatures out, not straight-up ramp stuff out. Sacrificing Scions only for my card to be sent back to my end or destroyed is a massive blow-out anyway, so I didn't count on it. As said, no hard removal = weak late game for me, so I assumed I'd have to play a couple big guys, the first one acting as an anchor to give me time to find the next one, and then move out... or something. But the deck feels stretched in too many directions. Creatures, ramp, stuff to ramp to, removal/protection... there's a bit of everything, and enough of nothing save for big guys (but I don't have draw to find them). + Show Spoiler [matches] ++ Show Spoiler [Match 1] +Vs. the guy who usually wins, who went BWg, he's the reason I didn't see any W (2 places to my right), and his first pick was Baloth Null. I could have used that. Game 1: I'm kinda screwed, and he casts Grip of Deslation my Void Winnower (only hit a swamp) + my only forest. I don't draw another one till I die. Game 2: he shows me Ondu War Clerics, Relief Captain, Zulaport Chainmage. 'k. We trade a bit of removal, I get Devastator out, he loses his board to kill it, then at the end of his next turn I get it back with Pulse of Murasa. He watches me in disbelief that I'd mainboard this card (duh, when you don't have creatures, you play stuff that acts "as" creatures) and scoops because he doesn't think he'll be able to deal with it. Game 3: I'm screwed again, while I watch Kalastria Healer, War Cleric, War Cleric, Relief Captain, third War Cleric after I remove one, Chainmage, Shoulder to Shoulder. There was an Isolation Zone on my Channeler too.
He'll go on to win the whole thing, he has Isolation Zone, Smite the Monstruous, Captain and Shoulder as support, and a fuckton of lifegain. He was at 38 or 40 life at the end of game 3, even if I stabilised it'd have taken me 5+ turns just to kill him. + Show Spoiler [Match 2] +Vs. BR, devoid with a couple allies. Game 1: he's stuck on 2 mana. I play turn 5 Warden, turn 6 Reality Smasher. He doesn't draw an answer and scoops. Game 2: I flood. He plays stuff. He wins. Game 3: I forgot. At this point Mire's Malice is in, to let me get another creature if needed. I win at some point. He's larger but I'm bigger. Uninteresting match. + Show Spoiler [Match 3] +Vs. UB devoid, a match I can't win (sorry for spoilers). He's got Harvester of Thought x2, Stormchaser, Hedron Crawler, Herald of Kozilek, UB tapland x2, Mindmelter x2, Ruination Guide, Kozilek's Translator, at least as much removal as me. I can't deal with flyers and unless I get good draws (read: lands+early creatures+a ramp source+a big guy in my hand plus 2-3 first draws) I can't wait to find stuff because he'll just kill me with unblockable/flying shit. I put Bone Splinters in because I realise that's actually the best use there is for my scions.
Game 1: Flooded. Kept a 3 lands, Loam, one big guy hand, thinking with my 3-drops and a Lagac and/or mana guy I could get by, assuming I drew these missing pieces in my first 4 turns. I drew 4 lands, straight up. Next. He kills whatever I can play with removal either way, Bone Splinters > my big guys. Game 2: I don't remember how I won that. I think I got Winnower to stick, managed to play a Lagac after that supporting it and the Envoy, pinged with the flyer then attacked with everything when even the scions getting through was lethal. I kept Unnatural Endurance in hand to counter his Bone Splinters, which worked. Game 3: I flooded in the midgame. He played Nettle Drone, I should have baited him into trading by attacking with my Slaughter Drone because it ended up dealing ~6 damage to me. He also played Stormchaser, and Ruinaton Guide. I got Reality Smasher out and attacked with it, which was my mistake. He double blocked and saved with Unnatural Endurance. I hoped to trade because I'd put Corpse Churn in as another recursion source when I saw how much removal he had, and had it in hand. Then he got 4 additional damage because I didn't have it to block and my mana guys were tapped. Corpse Churn gave me a choice between it and Deathless Behemoth, I went for the bigger, Vigilance Behemoth. Didn't matter, he was hitting me for 3+ a turn between the drone and stormchaser, then just went wide and swung. I looked at my deck while unsleeving rares and lands, and all but one of my removal pieces, and the pulse, were at the very bottom of my deck. Game 3 was lost at the post-mulligan shuffle.
Actually the more interesting match of the evening, which says a whole lot about said evening's "quality", and even then, just because it gave me some exercising about sideboarding and card choice. I think I sideboarded well, but my pool couldn't do shit to his and RNG decided rape was fun. + Show Spoiler [conclusion] +I mulliganed to 6 in all but one of my 9 games. I didn't write individual games down well, but I straight flooded in 2+ (3 if you count flooding in the midgame rather than from the start), and was screwed in 3+. One of my wins was off of my opponent getting screwed. Over half my games decided this way.
My final opponent had Stormchaser Mage and the UB tapland (he had 2, but the other was foiled so I knew it was always the same one) in his opening hand all 3 games, in comparison. Seer's Lantern played on curve every time but I dunno if it was in his starting hand.
Apart from that, I'm really pissed at how the fucking draft went. Obviously there's only 6 people so we'll see a lot less cards. But for the fucking love of God, I passed you a single Vampire Envoy, Witness the End wheeled, and a Stalker Drone, what the heck makes you decide when you only see this and shitty cards to cut all the G and B stuff in the second pack? One of them ended 2nd but the only G I saw from him was a Scion Summoner and the rest was from the BFZ pack. He rode victory on the back of Hemorrhage x3. The guy to my right going B I can get, but the guy who had the embodiment went BR off of Null Caller and the B that costs you life during upkeep if you don't have another colourless creature. My round 3 opponent took B stuff but pretty much only splashed stuff from BFZ in the end (bone splinter, the UB deathtouch eldrazi (which he didn't draw), etc.).
I'd envision GB as removal + fixing (maybe ramp, meh) + decent midgame bodies, and some recursion for added value. My deck was inconsistent as fuck because I didn't get to pick 2-drops, my value/tempo stuff (Redeemers) was fucked over by shit like support and Ruination Guide, and I was in general reliant on drawing my ramp sources (5 cards pretty much) so I could leap over midgame to my big guys. Not enough creatures -> weak early game Ramp guys + Lagacs as midgame -> dependant on specific conditions for my midgame to matter (either creatures stick, or I can curve out a big guy) Barely any removal, and costly one -> Going wide early or small evasive drops deal masssive damage to me, and I can't compete with midrange value shit (luckily no Pathwardens orr Cyclone Sires today).
I knew R and W weren't open, and suddenly all of G and B was being cut on pack 2, that's when I got fucked over. I probably should have thrown myself at any U or fixing cards I came across. In the end U didn't patch my issues (no creatures) and I didn't have the land base/fixing to allow a splash/3rd colour. I don't even know where I went wrong because 6-man draft has so little cards that it's easy to get nothing if a single person cuts, let alone 2, and there's nothing I could have done with P2 (Akoum Flameseeker won't give me a RX draft, U only had a crab as creature so switching for real wouldn't have helped).
Ended up 4th of 6, "money stuff" was the Smasher, the Winnower, and Dark-Dwellers. I'd have taken the Winnower I think, had I been first (guy took Reality Smasher but I don't play Modern). I got Radiant Flames, Vile Redeemer, Desolation Twin and one guy didn't want a foil Territorial Baloth so I'll add that to my bulk selling list.
Only thing I'm satisfied with is the call to add Bone Splinters (turn scions into favourable trades), Corpse Churn (card selection+recursion) and Seer's Lantern (less so ramp than card selection since my deck was so inconsistent and unreliable in terms of what it needed to get there), although I did it too late, my build was still shit after that, and it didn't change a thing because when I got to play with them everything I'd have needed was at the bottom of the deck anyway (and I fucked up with the Smasher).
|