On February 28 2016 13:13 Gahlo wrote: Well guess what, I never heard of radical MRAs until now. Just another case of the radicals needing to gtfo. Why should well intentioned people have to change their designation because assholes suck?
You don't have to change your label because of assholes, but at the moment the primary exposure the general public has had to the MRM is Gamergate and similar radical kerfluffles. So the label has baggage.
It's kind of like when I say I'm a Christian. The first thing most people think of are the ultra-conservatives and fundamentalists who constantly make the news. It doesn't matter that my church and denomination are on the other end of the spectrum, very few people stop to ask "what type of Christian are you?".
Nobody owns labels. So you kind of have to deal with other people who claim them unless they're on the fringe.
On February 28 2016 13:13 Gahlo wrote: Well guess what, I never heard of radical MRAs until now. Just another case of the radicals needing to gtfo. Why should well intentioned people have to change their designation because assholes suck?
You don't have to change your label because of assholes, but at the moment the primary exposure the general public has had to the MRM is Gamergate and similar radical kerfluffles. So the label has baggage.
It's kind of like when I say I'm a Christian. The first thing most people think of are the ultra-conservatives and fundamentalists who constantly make the news. It doesn't matter that my church and denomination are on the other end of the spectrum, very few people stop to ask "what type of Christian are you?".
Nobody owns labels. So you kind of have to deal with other people who claim them unless they're on the fringe.
While i can agree that nobody owns a label, there is something to be said about group leadership.
If you say I am an "activist who focuses on men's issues in america" thats one thing, when you say "i'm a MRA" it's different, because of the people in charge of those big groups. it's easy to support a cause without lumping yourself with a group without a negative connotation. but it's generally not good to support the groups that either only pay lip service to your causes and go about them in a negative way.
You can't go "i'm a fascist, but not THAT kind of fascist, i'm the keep the trains running kind of fascist, but Not those kind of trains" it's just a lot easier to say "i'm an authoritarian conservative" without all the baggage. it lets you actually speak at the table, instead of having to answer for the idiots who have similar views but want to go about it in different ways.
On February 28 2016 13:13 Gahlo wrote: Well guess what, I never heard of radical MRAs until now. Just another case of the radicals needing to gtfo. Why should well intentioned people have to change their designation because assholes suck?
You don't have to change your label because of assholes, but at the moment the primary exposure the general public has had to the MRM is Gamergate and similar radical kerfluffles. So the label has baggage.
It's kind of like when I say I'm a Christian. The first thing most people think of are the ultra-conservatives and fundamentalists who constantly make the news. It doesn't matter that my church and denomination are on the other end of the spectrum, very few people stop to ask "what type of Christian are you?".
Nobody owns labels. So you kind of have to deal with other people who claim them unless they're on the fringe.
While i can agree that nobody owns a label, there is something to be said about group leadership.
If you say I am an "activist who focuses on men's issues in america" thats one thing, when you say "i'm a MRA" it's different, because of the people in charge of those big groups. it's easy to support a cause without lumping yourself with a group without a negative connotation. but it's generally not good to support the groups that either only pay lip service to your causes and go about them in a negative way.
You can't go "i'm a fascist, but not THAT kind of fascist, i'm the keep the trains running kind of fascist, but Not those kind of trains" it's just a lot easier to say "i'm an authoritarian conservative" without all the baggage. it lets you actually speak at the table, instead of having to answer for the idiots who have similar views but want to go about it in different ways.
On February 28 2016 13:13 Gahlo wrote: Well guess what, I never heard of radical MRAs until now. Just another case of the radicals needing to gtfo. Why should well intentioned people have to change their designation because assholes suck?
You don't have to change your label because of assholes, but at the moment the primary exposure the general public has had to the MRM is Gamergate and similar radical kerfluffles. So the label has baggage.
It's kind of like when I say I'm a Christian. The first thing most people think of are the ultra-conservatives and fundamentalists who constantly make the news. It doesn't matter that my church and denomination are on the other end of the spectrum, very few people stop to ask "what type of Christian are you?".
Nobody owns labels. So you kind of have to deal with other people who claim them unless they're on the fringe.
While i can agree that nobody owns a label, there is something to be said about group leadership.
If you say I am an "activist who focuses on men's issues in america" thats one thing, when you say "i'm a MRA" it's different, because of the people in charge of those big groups. it's easy to support a cause without lumping yourself with a group without a negative connotation. but it's generally not good to support the groups that either only pay lip service to your causes and go about them in a negative way.
You can't go "i'm a fascist, but not THAT kind of fascist, i'm the keep the trains running kind of fascist, but Not those kind of trains" it's just a lot easier to say "i'm an authoritarian conservative" without all the baggage. it lets you actually speak at the table, instead of having to answer for the idiots who have similar views but want to go about it in different ways.
Good lord the cognitive dissonance is painful.
We think your movement is corrupted, form a new, smaller, less important one. Be more vocal about fighting against radicals in your own groups because instead of standing up for your rights concern yourself with self policing.
I've heard these ideas before and you'd have to insane to think them good advice.
On February 28 2016 22:21 Scip wrote: Has the MRA movement ever actually achieved anything other than be edgy on fringe TV interviews?
In the US/europe? i don't think so, but maybe in an eastern european country, since those don't get covered much here.
in india, yeah. recently got india to downscale it's punishment of rape and prevent arresting people accused of violence against women until a trial is prepared, It being one of the few violent crimes now not resulting in immediate arrest.
i'd probably suggest that those didn't advance men's rights any but whatever. MRA groups take credit for those changes.
On February 28 2016 22:21 Scip wrote: Has the MRA movement ever actually achieved anything other than be edgy on fringe TV interviews?
In the US/europe? i don't think so, but maybe in an eastern european country, since those don't get covered much here.
in india, yeah. recently got india to downscale it's punishment of rape and prevent arresting people accused of violence against women until a trial is prepared, It being one of the few violent crimes now not resulting in immediate arrest.
i'd probably suggest that those didn't advance men's rights any but whatever. MRA groups take credit for those changes.
Have you got an article on that? Turns out googling "rape india" yields somewhat unrelated result meow