|
United States15536 Posts
On February 24 2016 05:31 AlterKot wrote:Show nested quote +On February 24 2016 05:13 AsmodeusXI wrote: No, Undertale is not about memes. It actually has some impressive and evocative storyline beneath its silly exterior. I'd rate it among some of the best written games recently, especially since it pulls off something even more rare than video game drama: video game comedy. I don't care, I just don't believe it would have 1/10th of the popularity it didn't have such "unique" artstyle or the dank imagery/language. In fact I suspect it would be just as popular even if the writing isn't/wasn't as good as some claim.
I think a game has to resonate with people on a higher level than "dank memes" to gain the kind of popularity Undertale has. It's writing and music is what's doing that.
|
On February 24 2016 05:41 Frolossus wrote:Show nested quote +On February 24 2016 05:36 Eppa! wrote:On February 24 2016 05:18 Frolossus wrote:On February 24 2016 05:10 Numy wrote:On February 24 2016 05:08 Frolossus wrote:On February 24 2016 04:32 Numy wrote:On February 24 2016 04:15 Dandel Ion wrote: legacy and affordable are not two things that go together, which for me is actually enough to not want to play it. ez
legacy and sc2 include sc2 of course it'll be terrible Yea but legacy online is within the budget I had for modern paper which is what's causing all the problems. Oh also coz next year I may move back down to Cape Town which has a way more active magic base so I could potentially find more modern there but at the same time I'll be doing it alone and may not like the people. I gave up on Blizzards storytelling years ago. Don't know how game companies have such dog shit writing most of the time. maybe because the focus of most games is gameplay instead of story? i think that most of the time the story only exists to give context to gameplay elements. The issue is when the story is done so badly it actively detracts from the gameplay experience. An example of this would be Diablo 3. I'm not asking for anything fancy or even good. Merely competent story telling that doesn't ruin the rest of the game. It shouldn't be that hard. i don't agree honestly everyone who plays diablo 3 right now does it for the gear treadmill and addicting gameplay and loot model. we never gave a shit about the story mostly cause the game is played in adventure mode, not story mode. On February 24 2016 05:11 Eppa! wrote:Isn't undertale just about dank maymays anyway? The single player is really big in sc didn't half only play sp in wings? The talent pool is just a couple of generations from getting into games the market is there but the there is a lack of talented people that are into writing in that genre. On February 24 2016 05:08 Frolossus wrote:On February 24 2016 04:32 Numy wrote:On February 24 2016 04:15 Dandel Ion wrote: legacy and affordable are not two things that go together, which for me is actually enough to not want to play it. ez
legacy and sc2 include sc2 of course it'll be terrible Yea but legacy online is within the budget I had for modern paper which is what's causing all the problems. Oh also coz next year I may move back down to Cape Town which has a way more active magic base so I could potentially find more modern there but at the same time I'll be doing it alone and may not like the people. I gave up on Blizzards storytelling years ago. Don't know how game companies have such dog shit writing most of the time. maybe because the focus of most games is gameplay instead of story? i think that most of the time the story only exists to give context to gameplay elements. could say the same for action movies but the most profitable ones are the ones with a story. I think at least a couple of people have played transistor which in most cases function like an interactive movie rather than a game, which is fine but the issue in current games writing is it's b or c level scifi/fantasy writers trying to make a living. movies aren't games though. the primary selling point of games is gameplay. Primary selling point of games are gameplay just like primary selling point of action films are action doesn't make my point less valid. you can't really compare a medium to a genre story has very little to do with how well a movie sells, just look at avatar. the point of movies is viewing experience and the ones that provide the best of that sell the best. That is what I was stating? If gameplay was so important MKX would be DOA.
|
United States47024 Posts
On February 24 2016 07:01 AsmodeusXI wrote: I think a game has to resonate with people on a higher level than "dank memes" to gain the kind of popularity Undertale has. It's writing and music is what's doing that. You would hope so, until you look at the kind of garbage games that have managed to get popular.
|
United States15536 Posts
On February 24 2016 07:06 TheYango wrote:Show nested quote +On February 24 2016 07:01 AsmodeusXI wrote: I think a game has to resonate with people on a higher level than "dank memes" to gain the kind of popularity Undertale has. It's writing and music is what's doing that. You would hope so, until you look at the kind of garbage games that have managed to get popular.
Well sure, but Undertale seems to be on a higher level of popularity than most games. At that level (which needs better definition than I'm willing to think out atm), I'd posit that most games have more redeeming qualities than not.
|
On February 24 2016 07:11 AsmodeusXI wrote:Show nested quote +On February 24 2016 07:06 TheYango wrote:On February 24 2016 07:01 AsmodeusXI wrote: I think a game has to resonate with people on a higher level than "dank memes" to gain the kind of popularity Undertale has. It's writing and music is what's doing that. You would hope so, until you look at the kind of garbage games that have managed to get popular. Well sure, but Undertale seems to be on a higher level of popularity than most games. At that level (which needs better definition than I'm willing to think out atm), I'd posit that most games have more redeeming qualities than not. Spoken like a true fanboy
|
I'd rather be a fanboy than a hater.
Just sayin.
|
United States47024 Posts
On February 24 2016 07:11 AsmodeusXI wrote: Well sure, but Undertale seems to be on a higher level of popularity than most games. ???
I don't even know what basis you have for that lol. It's an indie game that's met widespread critical acclaim, but at the end of the day it's still only sold like 500,000 copies. It's an outstanding game and those numbers are pretty damn good for an indie game, but at large, its level of popularity is not at all noteworthy. It's just a drop in the pond compared to AAA titles--even LotV sold like 1 million copies on launch day, and that's a PC title, to say nothing of your yearly shitty COD release.
Don't confuse critical recognition and cult classic status with mainstream popularity. Undertale is a *good* game, but very little of what's good gets popular, and very little of what's popular is good.
|
Meh cod is pretty good from what I have seen and the hate comes from it's pricing model which is less exploitative than f2p
|
|
|
United States15536 Posts
On February 24 2016 07:31 TheYango wrote:Show nested quote +On February 24 2016 07:11 AsmodeusXI wrote: Well sure, but Undertale seems to be on a higher level of popularity than most games. ??? I don't even know what basis you have for that lol. It's an indie game that's met widespread critical acclaim, but at the end of the day it's still only sold like 500,000 copies. It's an outstanding game and those numbers are pretty damn good for an indie game, but at large, its level of popularity is not at all noteworthy. It's just a drop in the pond compared to AAA titles--even LotV sold like 1 million copies on launch day, and that's a PC title, to say nothing of your yearly shitty COD release. Don't confuse critical recognition and cult classic status with mainstream popularity. Undertale is a *good* game, but very little of what's good gets popular, and very little of what's popular is good.
Fair point.
I'll amend my statement.
For an indie game to grow that popular on next-to-no graphics and little gameplay, something more than dank memes is resonating with people.
|
On February 24 2016 09:12 AsmodeusXI wrote:Show nested quote +On February 24 2016 07:31 TheYango wrote:On February 24 2016 07:11 AsmodeusXI wrote: Well sure, but Undertale seems to be on a higher level of popularity than most games. ??? I don't even know what basis you have for that lol. It's an indie game that's met widespread critical acclaim, but at the end of the day it's still only sold like 500,000 copies. It's an outstanding game and those numbers are pretty damn good for an indie game, but at large, its level of popularity is not at all noteworthy. It's just a drop in the pond compared to AAA titles--even LotV sold like 1 million copies on launch day, and that's a PC title, to say nothing of your yearly shitty COD release. Don't confuse critical recognition and cult classic status with mainstream popularity. Undertale is a *good* game, but very little of what's good gets popular, and very little of what's popular is good. Fair point. I'll amend my statement. For an indie game to grow that popular on next-to-no graphics and little gameplay, something more than dank memes is resonating with people. Indie games grow popular all the time for less reasons than dank memes.
|
I know nothing about the game to comment. Literally nothing.
on another note I'm apparently getting ads trying to get me to convert to mormonism so I can then convert girls to mormonism or something like that. I'm slightly scared
also I haven't been having a great week.
|
United States15536 Posts
|
On February 24 2016 09:12 AsmodeusXI wrote:
Fair point.
I'll amend my statement.
For an indie game to grow that popular on next-to-no graphics and little gameplay, something more than dank memes is resonating with people. I mean, Viral videos are almost always indie made and spread to larger popularity with little to no positive qualities.
Honestly Undertale is just an average good indie game. that alone wouldn't be notable in any way, except for the dev team that made it. It's impressive for a lone developer.
But a nostalgia bomb game isn't exactly amazing that people like it so much. It's not a game for me, but there is nothing wrong with liking it. and a lot of people do.
|
Sigh. Need to do a more thorough review when someone else creates the slides you're going to present to the Sr. VP of the company. If I only had time... 
But seeing some progress in my side project so that's exciting. And vacation starts Friday
|
When you can feel your heart beating in your chest even when at rest, that's probably not good, right?
|
I feel like I've become incredibly error prone despite my best efforts since I started work (8 months ago?). Might be due to the fact I'm still pretty new and my bosses have been doing this for years and years. It still feels weird to have them check all my work because I was that guy for most of college/ high school though.
|
On February 25 2016 01:08 Requizen wrote: When you can feel your heart beating in your chest even when at rest, that's probably not good, right? could be an anxiety attack
|
or just too much caffeine or excitement.
webmd says you have cancer tho
|
On February 25 2016 01:09 Frolossus wrote:Show nested quote +On February 25 2016 01:08 Requizen wrote: When you can feel your heart beating in your chest even when at rest, that's probably not good, right? could be an anxiety attack It's been going on for like 3 days now though.
|
|
|
|
|
|