|
United States47024 Posts
Munda's Vanguard is like top 5 cards in the set, and Embodiment of Fury is the best uncommon that isn't a removal spell, and arguably the best uncommon period.
Those are snap picks if you see them and huge signs that either their colors are massively open, or people at your table don't know what they're doing.
It sounds like you're thinking about reading/sending signals too early/too much. Largely in pack 1, you're just going to be taking the best card in the pack, and even in pack 2, you strongly consider a switch when cards that good are passed to you. What you've passed, and what signals you're sending/are being sent are usually only considered when you're trying to compare two cards of similar power level and make a decision between them. When something is massively better than everything else in the pack, you still take the best card. In the case of Munda's Vanguard, I cannot construct a reasonable pack where that's the case, because for me to be making that comparison with Munda's Vanguard, the pack would have to have a foil rare as well AND have both of those rares not be picked by the time the pack gets to you (for all intents and purposes, this is impossible). I would take Munda's Vanguard over every common, and probably every uncommon, though I haven't thought through all of them so I'm not sure on that.
Put it this way: when you pass a good card in an open color, you are essentially taking a gamble by saying "I'm passing a decent card in this color to bet on the fact that I will get better cards in another color later". In the case of Munda's Vanguard, there's a single digit number of "better cards" and the chance of seeing any of them is almost zero.
I had a similar situation where I got passed like a 6th pick Grasp of Darkness in pack 3 during BFZx3, and I can say definitely in retrospect that not taking the Grasp was 100% wrong (I didn't take it, sadly).
|
Would you guys want a saturday stream today? i hadn't planned on it but i have time today to do so if people wanted something to watch.
On February 14 2016 01:27 TheYango wrote: Munda's Vanguard is like top 5 cards in the set, and Embodiment of Fury is the best uncommon that isn't a removal spell, and arguably the best uncommon period.
Those are snap picks if you see them and huge signs that either their colors are massively open, or people at your table don't know what they're doing.
It sounds like you're thinking about reading/sending signals too early/too much. Largely in pack 1, you're just going to be taking the best card in the pack, and even in pack 2, you strongly consider a switch when cards that good are passed to you. What you've passed, and what signals you're sending/are being sent are usually only considered when you're trying to compare two cards of similar power level and make a decision between them. When something is massively better than everything else in the pack, you still take the best card. In the case of Munda's Vanguard, I cannot construct a reasonable pack where that's the case, because for me to be making that comparison with Munda's Vanguard, the pack would have to have a foil rare as well AND have both of those rares not be picked by the time the pack gets to you (for all intents and purposes, this is impossible). I would take Munda's Vanguard over every common, and probably every uncommon, though I haven't thought through all of them so I'm not sure on that.
Put it this way: when you pass a good card in an open color, you are essentially taking a gamble by saying "I'm passing a decent card in this color to bet on the fact that I will get better cards in another color later". In the case of Munda's Vanguard, there's a single digit number of "better cards" and the chance of seeing any of them is almost zero.
I had a similar situation where I got passed like a 6th pick Grasp of Darkness in pack 3 during BFZx3, and I can say definitely in retrospect that not taking the Grasp was 100% wrong (I didn't take it, sadly). Some people go into drafts with self challenges, which would be a reason for not picking best in pack cards.
"I want to get better at drafting blue" or whatever, and then they focus on that. you don't win the draft that is white focused that way, but if you are viewing minor drafts as learning experiences it's not a bad way of doing things.
|
United States47024 Posts
"I want to get better at drafting blue" is not at odds with playing Munda's Vanguard. And largely the biggest challenge for getting better at a given format is actually just to play with the rares, because you actually get the least games played with them.
That argument actually favors taking Munda's Vanguard even more--in the case that I got Oblivion Strike + a rare or mythic of similar power level, I would take the rare because I am less likely to have opportunities to play or draft with it and will get more unique/valuable experience from doing so.
|
On February 14 2016 01:27 TheYango wrote: Munda's Vanguard is like top 5 cards in the set, and Embodiment of Fury is the best uncommon that isn't a removal spell, and arguably the best uncommon period.
Those are snap picks if you see them and huge signs that either their colors are massively open, or people at your table don't know what they're doing.
It sounds like you're thinking about reading/sending signals too early/too much. Largely in pack 1, you're just going to be taking the best card in the pack, and even in pack 2, you strongly consider a switch when cards that good are passed to you. What you've passed, and what signals you're sending/are being sent are usually only considered when you're trying to compare two cards of similar power level and make a decision between them. When something is massively better than everything else in the pack, you still take the best card. In the case of Munda's Vanguard, I cannot construct a reasonable pack where that's the case, because for me to be making that comparison with Munda's Vanguard, the pack would have to have a foil rare as well AND have both of those rares not be picked by the time the pack gets to you (for all intents and purposes, this is impossible). I would take Munda's Vanguard over every common, and probably every uncommon, though I haven't thought through all of them so I'm not sure on that.
Put it this way: when you pass a good card in an open color, you are essentially taking a gamble by saying "I'm passing a decent card in this color to bet on the fact that I will get better cards in another color later". In the case of Munda's Vanguard, there's a single digit number of "better cards" and the chance of seeing any of them is almost zero.
I had a similar situation where I got passed like a 6th pick Grasp of Darkness in pack 3 during BFZx3, and I can say definitely in retrospect that not taking the Grasp was 100% wrong (I didn't take it, sadly). First of all grasp is OGW. Second, if you're not in black in pack 3, how exactly would you switch at pick 6, or even splash black for grasp, which is BB?
|
|
|
United States47024 Posts
Bleh mistyped, should say Grip of Desolation.
|
On February 14 2016 02:31 TheYango wrote: Bleh mistyped, should say Grip of Desolation. Same issue though. Isn't grip 4BB? That's not particularly splashable, especially in BFZx3
|
United States47024 Posts
I was already in 3 colors anyway and Black in the 3rd pack would have been significantly better than my 3rd color otherwise.
|
So I'm back from my gamesday. Here's a short writeup on how it went.
+ Show Spoiler +Deck - I was running a UG ramp. I can write down the list if anyone really wants but I'm tired now. If you look at the usual UG ramp with Ulamog/Part the Waterveil then you'll have a decent idea of the list.
Swiss rounds - I don't really have much to say here since I can't really remember my games. Overall it wasn't particularly good performance by me. Some miss plays, some bad sideboarding and just deck not really operating how I wanted. Score 2-1-1
Bracket - My meager score squeaked me into 7th place for the event. Really lucky there I think lol.
Match 1(BW Warriors) The girl piloting the deck has been on it for the last year and she manages to sneak wins at FNM all the time. It's pretty crazy what the deck can do when it hits critical mass which isn't even a lot. She finished 2nd in the standings after swiss so I was dreading this. Game 1 - I had a decent start but she had even better. Things started going out of control until I managed to ramp into 6 mana. My hand was 2 land drops, ugin and part. Thankfully I saw the play of Land -> part -> land -> Ugin which stablized and won me the game. Winning game 1 on the draw without SB is massive for me. Game 2 - I got wrekt Game 3 - Her start was a bit weird this time with just double Bloodsoaked while I managed to start with 2 Advocates. It was a grindy game that finished in style. I had managed to stabilize on 3 life when she resolves a Sorin and puts a flier into play. Now I had 3 creatures on the field(Ulamog,Adovcate/Mystic) while she had Vampire/Bloodsoaked/Sorin. I attacked into Sorin with mystic/ulamog killing it but still had no answer for the vampire. She attacks next turn but draws a land. Now I'm on 1 life with nothing else to play while she's on 15. Oh my mystic died I think in the exchange. So I think I've completely lost the game on 1 life when I swing for 15 with ulamog/advocate/lumbering falls thinking she'll just block the one and swing back for 2 in the air. turns out Bloodsoaked can't block. Holy shit! 2-1
Match 2(Bant Company) This was actually a rematch from my first match of the day. It was pretty interesting series. Lots of back and forth with me losing game 1 and winning post board games with dispels in to hit the coco. Not much to say here other than dispel is a great card. 2-1
Match 3(4C Rally) This is one of the craziest Rally matches I've ever played. I was a bit out of it by the end of the day so the games are a bit of a blur. Game 1 - He just rolled me, pre-sideboard I can't fight Coco/Rally so there's not much chance Game 2 - I think he had a slow start and I had double advocate with dispel backup as a start so I just rolled him patiently Game 3 - This went down to the freaking wire. I opened strong with him being slow taking him down to 10 HP before he got his board set up. Now I have 2 dispels in hand but only 1 blue mana available while he has Jace so I counter his first coco but he flashes it back. All is not lost though!. I draw a drowner which lets me save a turn and set up ramp for ulamog next turn. Only problem is I'm still down to 1 blue mana source late into the game. Having no option I tap out for ulamog saccing the scions which he responses with by saccing his board to husk leaving me on 10 life. On his turn he follows up with a rally and wins the game. I can't help but feel I was 1 blue mana away from winning the series 1-2
That was my games day. I know rationally I should feel proud to go lose in such a tight finals in my first ever games day but the competitive side of me can't help but feel disappointed. I lost and I lost to a problem I know I was meant to have fixed in the deck but got lazy. At least my years of competitive gaming at lans has left me with the ability to play 8 hours of magic on an empty stomach and still perform! :<:<
That was me. How were your peeps days?
|
went 3-1 into IDing 5th round for 3-1-1 guaranteed top8, fourth seed meant i was on the play quarters which was coolio, then in the semis i had a 50 minute topdeckfest against esper dragon but eventually lost 1-2
instantly traded the promo away - i swear people will want anything if its foil fullart promo version, even jori en
|
On February 14 2016 04:36 Numy wrote:So I'm back from my gamesday. Here's a short writeup on how it went. + Show Spoiler +Deck - I was running a UG ramp. I can write down the list if anyone really wants but I'm tired now. If you look at the usual UG ramp with Ulamog/Part the Waterveil then you'll have a decent idea of the list.
Swiss rounds - I don't really have much to say here since I can't really remember my games. Overall it wasn't particularly good performance by me. Some miss plays, some bad sideboarding and just deck not really operating how I wanted. Score 2-1-1
Bracket - My meager score squeaked me into 7th place for the event. Really lucky there I think lol.
Match 1(BW Warriors) The girl piloting the deck has been on it for the last year and she manages to sneak wins at FNM all the time. It's pretty crazy what the deck can do when it hits critical mass which isn't even a lot. She finished 2nd in the standings after swiss so I was dreading this. Game 1 - I had a decent start but she had even better. Things started going out of control until I managed to ramp into 6 mana. My hand was 2 land drops, ugin and part. Thankfully I saw the play of Land -> part -> land -> Ugin which stablized and won me the game. Winning game 1 on the draw without SB is massive for me. Game 2 - I got wrekt Game 3 - Her start was a bit weird this time with just double Bloodsoaked while I managed to start with 2 Advocates. It was a grindy game that finished in style. I had managed to stabilize on 3 life when she resolves a Sorin and puts a flier into play. Now I had 3 creatures on the field(Ulamog,Adovcate/Mystic) while she had Vampire/Bloodsoaked/Sorin. I attacked into Sorin with mystic/ulamog killing it but still had no answer for the vampire. She attacks next turn but draws a land. Now I'm on 1 life with nothing else to play while she's on 15. Oh my mystic died I think in the exchange. So I think I've completely lost the game on 1 life when I swing for 15 with ulamog/advocate/lumbering falls thinking she'll just block the one and swing back for 2 in the air. turns out Bloodsoaked can't block. Holy shit! 2-1
Match 2(Bant Company) This was actually a rematch from my first match of the day. It was pretty interesting series. Lots of back and forth with me losing game 1 and winning post board games with dispels in to hit the coco. Not much to say here other than dispel is a great card. 2-1
Match 3(4C Rally) This is one of the craziest Rally matches I've ever played. I was a bit out of it by the end of the day so the games are a bit of a blur. Game 1 - He just rolled me, pre-sideboard I can't fight Coco/Rally so there's not much chance Game 2 - I think he had a slow start and I had double advocate with dispel backup as a start so I just rolled him patiently Game 3 - This went down to the freaking wire. I opened strong with him being slow taking him down to 10 HP before he got his board set up. Now I have 2 dispels in hand but only 1 blue mana available while he has Jace so I counter his first coco but he flashes it back. All is not lost though!. I draw a drowner which lets me save a turn and set up ramp for ulamog next turn. Only problem is I'm still down to 1 blue mana source late into the game. Having no option I tap out for ulamog saccing the scions which he responses with by saccing his board to husk leaving me on 10 life. On his turn he follows up with a rally and wins the game. I can't help but feel I was 1 blue mana away from winning the series 1-2
That was my games day. I know rationally I should feel proud to go lose in such a tight finals in my first ever games day but the competitive side of me can't help but feel disappointed. I lost and I lost to a problem I know I was meant to have fixed in the deck but got lazy. At least my years of competitive gaming at lans has left me with the ability to play 8 hours of magic on an empty stomach and still perform! :<:< That was me. How were your peeps days? How did you miss Bloodsoaked's drawback? lol  Budget, lifting and some work for me today.
|
Straight outta Johto18973 Posts
Grats on all the MtG matches y'all. Nice to see how well Alaric and Numy are doing!
|
also had a guy miss bloodsoakeds no-block today
i was wondering what crazy plan he had when he only left that one up but then he just died to not reading his cards
it happens
|
On February 14 2016 04:53 mordek wrote:Show nested quote +On February 14 2016 04:36 Numy wrote:So I'm back from my gamesday. Here's a short writeup on how it went. + Show Spoiler +Deck - I was running a UG ramp. I can write down the list if anyone really wants but I'm tired now. If you look at the usual UG ramp with Ulamog/Part the Waterveil then you'll have a decent idea of the list.
Swiss rounds - I don't really have much to say here since I can't really remember my games. Overall it wasn't particularly good performance by me. Some miss plays, some bad sideboarding and just deck not really operating how I wanted. Score 2-1-1
Bracket - My meager score squeaked me into 7th place for the event. Really lucky there I think lol.
Match 1(BW Warriors) The girl piloting the deck has been on it for the last year and she manages to sneak wins at FNM all the time. It's pretty crazy what the deck can do when it hits critical mass which isn't even a lot. She finished 2nd in the standings after swiss so I was dreading this. Game 1 - I had a decent start but she had even better. Things started going out of control until I managed to ramp into 6 mana. My hand was 2 land drops, ugin and part. Thankfully I saw the play of Land -> part -> land -> Ugin which stablized and won me the game. Winning game 1 on the draw without SB is massive for me. Game 2 - I got wrekt Game 3 - Her start was a bit weird this time with just double Bloodsoaked while I managed to start with 2 Advocates. It was a grindy game that finished in style. I had managed to stabilize on 3 life when she resolves a Sorin and puts a flier into play. Now I had 3 creatures on the field(Ulamog,Adovcate/Mystic) while she had Vampire/Bloodsoaked/Sorin. I attacked into Sorin with mystic/ulamog killing it but still had no answer for the vampire. She attacks next turn but draws a land. Now I'm on 1 life with nothing else to play while she's on 15. Oh my mystic died I think in the exchange. So I think I've completely lost the game on 1 life when I swing for 15 with ulamog/advocate/lumbering falls thinking she'll just block the one and swing back for 2 in the air. turns out Bloodsoaked can't block. Holy shit! 2-1
Match 2(Bant Company) This was actually a rematch from my first match of the day. It was pretty interesting series. Lots of back and forth with me losing game 1 and winning post board games with dispels in to hit the coco. Not much to say here other than dispel is a great card. 2-1
Match 3(4C Rally) This is one of the craziest Rally matches I've ever played. I was a bit out of it by the end of the day so the games are a bit of a blur. Game 1 - He just rolled me, pre-sideboard I can't fight Coco/Rally so there's not much chance Game 2 - I think he had a slow start and I had double advocate with dispel backup as a start so I just rolled him patiently Game 3 - This went down to the freaking wire. I opened strong with him being slow taking him down to 10 HP before he got his board set up. Now I have 2 dispels in hand but only 1 blue mana available while he has Jace so I counter his first coco but he flashes it back. All is not lost though!. I draw a drowner which lets me save a turn and set up ramp for ulamog next turn. Only problem is I'm still down to 1 blue mana source late into the game. Having no option I tap out for ulamog saccing the scions which he responses with by saccing his board to husk leaving me on 10 life. On his turn he follows up with a rally and wins the game. I can't help but feel I was 1 blue mana away from winning the series 1-2
That was my games day. I know rationally I should feel proud to go lose in such a tight finals in my first ever games day but the competitive side of me can't help but feel disappointed. I lost and I lost to a problem I know I was meant to have fixed in the deck but got lazy. At least my years of competitive gaming at lans has left me with the ability to play 8 hours of magic on an empty stomach and still perform! :<:< That was me. How were your peeps days? How did you miss Bloodsoaked's drawback? lol  Budget, lifting and some work for me today.
The sad part is I actually played a deck for months that played with Bloodsoaked. My friend and I were so dam shocked when I won lol. I just did a lolz attack then was going to scoop then I win and the fact that it was the exact damage made it all the more hilarious. Maybe my body knew what to do even if my mind was going full retard 
I've been sick this week so no lifting and it was a long day so I blame those things
On February 14 2016 04:54 MoonBear wrote: Grats on all the MtG matches y'all. Nice to see how well Alaric and Numy are doing!
Thanks. Now it's time to buy this Abzan Coco deck and body some fools.
|
On February 14 2016 05:30 Numy wrote:Show nested quote +On February 14 2016 04:53 mordek wrote:On February 14 2016 04:36 Numy wrote:So I'm back from my gamesday. Here's a short writeup on how it went. + Show Spoiler +Deck - I was running a UG ramp. I can write down the list if anyone really wants but I'm tired now. If you look at the usual UG ramp with Ulamog/Part the Waterveil then you'll have a decent idea of the list.
Swiss rounds - I don't really have much to say here since I can't really remember my games. Overall it wasn't particularly good performance by me. Some miss plays, some bad sideboarding and just deck not really operating how I wanted. Score 2-1-1
Bracket - My meager score squeaked me into 7th place for the event. Really lucky there I think lol.
Match 1(BW Warriors) The girl piloting the deck has been on it for the last year and she manages to sneak wins at FNM all the time. It's pretty crazy what the deck can do when it hits critical mass which isn't even a lot. She finished 2nd in the standings after swiss so I was dreading this. Game 1 - I had a decent start but she had even better. Things started going out of control until I managed to ramp into 6 mana. My hand was 2 land drops, ugin and part. Thankfully I saw the play of Land -> part -> land -> Ugin which stablized and won me the game. Winning game 1 on the draw without SB is massive for me. Game 2 - I got wrekt Game 3 - Her start was a bit weird this time with just double Bloodsoaked while I managed to start with 2 Advocates. It was a grindy game that finished in style. I had managed to stabilize on 3 life when she resolves a Sorin and puts a flier into play. Now I had 3 creatures on the field(Ulamog,Adovcate/Mystic) while she had Vampire/Bloodsoaked/Sorin. I attacked into Sorin with mystic/ulamog killing it but still had no answer for the vampire. She attacks next turn but draws a land. Now I'm on 1 life with nothing else to play while she's on 15. Oh my mystic died I think in the exchange. So I think I've completely lost the game on 1 life when I swing for 15 with ulamog/advocate/lumbering falls thinking she'll just block the one and swing back for 2 in the air. turns out Bloodsoaked can't block. Holy shit! 2-1
Match 2(Bant Company) This was actually a rematch from my first match of the day. It was pretty interesting series. Lots of back and forth with me losing game 1 and winning post board games with dispels in to hit the coco. Not much to say here other than dispel is a great card. 2-1
Match 3(4C Rally) This is one of the craziest Rally matches I've ever played. I was a bit out of it by the end of the day so the games are a bit of a blur. Game 1 - He just rolled me, pre-sideboard I can't fight Coco/Rally so there's not much chance Game 2 - I think he had a slow start and I had double advocate with dispel backup as a start so I just rolled him patiently Game 3 - This went down to the freaking wire. I opened strong with him being slow taking him down to 10 HP before he got his board set up. Now I have 2 dispels in hand but only 1 blue mana available while he has Jace so I counter his first coco but he flashes it back. All is not lost though!. I draw a drowner which lets me save a turn and set up ramp for ulamog next turn. Only problem is I'm still down to 1 blue mana source late into the game. Having no option I tap out for ulamog saccing the scions which he responses with by saccing his board to husk leaving me on 10 life. On his turn he follows up with a rally and wins the game. I can't help but feel I was 1 blue mana away from winning the series 1-2
That was my games day. I know rationally I should feel proud to go lose in such a tight finals in my first ever games day but the competitive side of me can't help but feel disappointed. I lost and I lost to a problem I know I was meant to have fixed in the deck but got lazy. At least my years of competitive gaming at lans has left me with the ability to play 8 hours of magic on an empty stomach and still perform! :<:< That was me. How were your peeps days? How did you miss Bloodsoaked's drawback? lol  Budget, lifting and some work for me today. The sad part is I actually played a deck for months that played with Bloodsoaked. My friend and I were so dam shocked when I won lol. I just did a lolz attack then was going to scoop then I win and the fact that it was the exact damage made it all the more hilarious. Maybe my body knew what to do even if my mind was going full retard  I've been sick this week so no lifting and it was a long day so I blame those things Show nested quote +On February 14 2016 04:54 MoonBear wrote: Grats on all the MtG matches y'all. Nice to see how well Alaric and Numy are doing! Thanks. Now it's time to buy this Abzan Coco deck and body some fools. I hate that deck. Ayli plus Jace plus coco plus deathmists is disgusting.
Man everyone doing so well with not T1 decks. I'm not gonna be so lucky tomorrow probably
|
United States47024 Posts
On February 14 2016 05:37 WaveofShadow wrote: I hate that deck. Ayli plus Jace plus coco plus deathmists is disgusting. Numy means Modern Abzan Coco AKA Pod-less Melira Pod.
|
Oh the Abzan coco is the modern one, so it's the Melira/Finks/Seer or Melira/Redcap/Seer loops. Didn't know there was abzan coco standard. That's disgusting.
My deck is tier 1.5 I think so it's not really that far off. Although I'm not exactly full build so maybe Tier 2. I'm sure you'll crush Wave. Make LLL proud! Rhino some fools, Rhino them hard then Rhino them softly to give them false hope until you Rhino them harder than they've been Rhinoed before!
|
On February 14 2016 05:40 Numy wrote: Oh the Abzan coco is the modern one, so it's the Melira/Finks/Seer or Melira/Redcap/Seer loops. Didn't know there was abzan coco standard. That's disgusting.
My deck is tier 1.5 I think so it's not really that far off. Although I'm not exactly full build so maybe Tier 2. I'm sure you'll crush Wave. Make LLL proud! Rhino some fools, Rhino them hard then Rhino them softly to give them false hope until you Rhino them harder than they've been Rhinoed before! I'd rather combo off tbh, but more wins seem to come from rhino/wingmate.
Basically rally/coco are my truly awful match ups even after sideboard so if I don't run into them I'm probably fine? Still can't 100% decide on sideboard unfortunately or if I should pick up a dromoka's command.
|
i thought about doing displacer, but everyone has 2-4 hallowed moonlights sideboard even though almost nobody actually plays rally locally
netdeckers be netdecking
|
This is basically the deck I was talking about
I don't really know how you can deal with rally without counter magic or just winning in 4 turns.Hallowed is the go to tech but idk it doesn't seem that effective. I did see some quite tech at a GP a few months back of Cranial Archive to try deal with Rally. Doesn't help against the Coco but idk if you desperate you could try that. Otherwise I'd say just ignore the matchup and hope you don't play against Rally. Can't always win them all in magic.
edit: Fucking Saffron goes and makes an article on MTGgoldfish about the deck. Now I have to pull the trigger before people ramp prices up. Fk that guy.
|
|
|
|
|
|