EPTTB interrupted gretorp a lot and that was a bit distracting.
[NASL] Day 6-2 - Page 66
| Forum Index > StarCraft 2 Tournaments |
|
ishboh
United States954 Posts
TB interrupted gretorp a lot and that was a bit distracting. | ||
|
Shalaiyn
Netherlands2735 Posts
| ||
|
mcc
Czech Republic4646 Posts
On May 20 2011 23:46 Doodsmack wrote: So your entire argument is that Totalbiscuit should stop talking here and there during play-by-play moments because his co-caster may have seen something on the minimap that is happening elsewhere on the map? The problem is that things happen so quickly during big battles that even one caster can barely describe it all in the time that the battle takes. No SC2 casting duo that I'm aware of will both describe the same battle. One person talks for a time, then gives up the mic to the other. It's what Day9 and Chill did in teh TSL3 and it's what Tastosis do. I did not say that two people should describe the same battle, and by pause I meant very small pause that the second caster might use to note that while the battle being described seems to end in draw in the meantime dts/drops/... killed all the workers. If the second caster has nothing to say the play-by-play one can continue with his WPM attack after pause as short as 1-2 seconds. Of course if both casters are at one place this becomes even easier and even such short pauses unnecessary. And in other caster duos there is more space for the other caster to note something as they do not have the WPM of TB. Also just to note, there is no need for a caster to describe the battle in total detail, viewers can see it. And for some people that do not get it : I am not saying TB's casting is bad, I mostly enjoy it quite a lot. I just think it has some small flaws, but I was more commenting on his argument that sports casting style is good style for casting sc2. | ||
|
superjoppe
Sweden3694 Posts
| ||
|
Nightfly
150 Posts
| ||
|
Frankon
3054 Posts
On May 21 2011 02:01 ishboh wrote: i think that total biscuits casting was fine, i just think he needed to give more of the time on the mic to gretorp, its a dual cast, and i think each caster should get approximately the same quantity of time discussing the game. TB interrupted gretorp a lot and that was a bit distracting. TB and Day[9] are pure solo casters. If they have cocasters they need to have a mute button to ever speak. | ||
|
GP
United States1056 Posts
On May 21 2011 02:07 Nightfly wrote: Gretorp + some annoying brit? Guess I'll skip NASL today. Is that comment even necessary? QXC's control has looked really awful lately, I feel so bad, but ever since he moved to Spain his play has been really lackluster. | ||
|
Jakalo
Latvia2350 Posts
-.- | ||
|
arQ
1033 Posts
On May 21 2011 02:06 superjoppe wrote: Oh god I hate TB so much Thank you for your mature and useful reply, as well as your delightful contribution to this community. There's the door, don't let it hit you on your way out! | ||
|
Jakalo
Latvia2350 Posts
| ||
|
doffe
Sweden636 Posts
 Hes really more of a comedian then a caster. | ||
|
Fleebenworth
463 Posts
| ||
|
Nightfly
150 Posts
On May 21 2011 02:12 GP wrote: Is that comment even necessary? QXC's control has looked really awful lately, I feel so bad, but ever since he moved to Spain his play has been really lackluster. Just venting frustration. I feel good commentators are really important. Some, like Demuslim during Dreamhack, can enrich the experience greatly, while others can cheapen it. Incontrol + Gretorp is pretty harmless. Sure, Gretorp is awful but Incontrol is pleasant to listen to. Incontrol + Idra is actually good, I want to listen to what they say. Gretorp + this guy is pretty awful. I can't focus on the game. The only thing that would be worse would be to add a screamer like Day9 to completely ruin it. | ||
|
Fyzar
Netherlands8010 Posts
I like to give credits for that to TB, with TB doing the nice play-by-play, Gretorp can really throw out his analysis and he doesn't have to talk around IdrA/Incontrol. | ||
|
Casablancas
Denmark145 Posts
Why not cheer and praise on the forums when your favorite caster is on instead of bitching when one you dont like is casting? | ||
|
Fyzar
Netherlands8010 Posts
On May 21 2011 02:20 Casablancas wrote: I really like the diversity in NASL casters. But yeah, for most people it seems the glass is always half empty... Why not cheer and praise on the forums when your favorite caster is on instead of bitching when one you dont like is casting? That's the problem with forums; there's not many people who will talk about the things they like, there will be a shit-ton of whiners whining about things they don't like. | ||
|
Jman5
United States745 Posts
| ||
|
Jakalo
Latvia2350 Posts
| ||
|
WniO
United States2706 Posts
| ||
|
doffe
Sweden636 Posts
On May 21 2011 02:20 Casablancas wrote: I really like the diversity in NASL casters. But yeah, for most people it seems the glass is always half empty... Why not cheer and praise on the forums when your favorite caster is on instead of bitching when one you dont like is casting? Should we not complain when we have things to complain about? Thats pretty dumb since it will in no way help the progress of the scene. If people are unhappy with a certain commentator why should they not say so? This is not a charity, some of us are paying to see these games and want to atleast be able to voice our opinions about what we get for that money. E-sports is nothing without the spectators and their opinions therefor matters alot. Sure, comments like "I just hate TB" and nothing more is pretty useless but why should the public be forced to have a commentator if they do not like him, I can see no reason | ||
| ||
