|
On June 05 2013 14:05 OfficeBrahzz wrote: swear i saw a game on demuslims stream where this happened. he just pulled 10 scv's and killed it as it was about to pop with 2marines too. IMO that is a better reaction, you dont really lose that much income imo i think its worth it
I think this is appropriate and is similar to what a toss would do in the same situation; pull workers to weaken it so that other units can make the kill before the hatch pops and creep spreads. However, keep in mind that vs CC first there is usually no wall around the front of natural to block a ling run-by. It is not uncommon for a Z player to send a few lings, 4-6 to secure the hatch getting up and I don't think in this scenario it is beneficial to lose a bunch of SCV's to delay the hatch. It is probably safer to focus on getting the tank to ward off any reinforcing units.
|
Hello Theognis, I've been hatch blocked a number of times in TvZ and what I find that works quite well is put both rax and cc scvs from your ramp to your nat, make 1 bunker, double OC followed by 2nd bunker. Bunker placements are as follows:
BUNKER < HATCH > BUNKER
Doing this I either go for few more marines and then reactor or just skip reactor until factory is done. With 2 bunkers, 2 scvs and a 2-5 marines I am able to destroy the hatch and deny queen creep tumor.
If they do kill off my bunkers then I just make a tank to deny the hatch/spines (similar to your first replay). Follow up is basically a later MVPs hellbat attack timing. If zerg is going for roach/bane then the marauders/hellbats help out immensely.
My most recent replay from NA encountering this strat:
http://drop.sc/341630
|
On June 07 2013 05:13 theMutt wrote:Show nested quote +On June 05 2013 14:05 OfficeBrahzz wrote: swear i saw a game on demuslims stream where this happened. he just pulled 10 scv's and killed it as it was about to pop with 2marines too. IMO that is a better reaction, you dont really lose that much income imo i think its worth it I think this is appropriate and is similar to what a toss would do in the same situation; pull workers to weaken it so that other units can make the kill before the hatch pops and creep spreads. However, keep in mind that vs CC first there is usually no wall around the front of natural to block a ling run-by. It is not uncommon for a Z player to send a few lings, 4-6 to secure the hatch getting up and I don't think in this scenario it is beneficial to lose a bunch of SCV's to delay the hatch. It is probably safer to focus on getting the tank to ward off any reinforcing units.
Not to mention that the Z can just cancel the hatch at that point... he's delayed his tech, but pulling 10 scvs for a good 30 seconds or more is worth it.
|
On June 12 2013 03:13 TheSambassador wrote:Show nested quote +On June 07 2013 05:13 theMutt wrote:On June 05 2013 14:05 OfficeBrahzz wrote: swear i saw a game on demuslims stream where this happened. he just pulled 10 scv's and killed it as it was about to pop with 2marines too. IMO that is a better reaction, you dont really lose that much income imo i think its worth it I think this is appropriate and is similar to what a toss would do in the same situation; pull workers to weaken it so that other units can make the kill before the hatch pops and creep spreads. However, keep in mind that vs CC first there is usually no wall around the front of natural to block a ling run-by. It is not uncommon for a Z player to send a few lings, 4-6 to secure the hatch getting up and I don't think in this scenario it is beneficial to lose a bunch of SCV's to delay the hatch. It is probably safer to focus on getting the tank to ward off any reinforcing units. Not to mention that the Z can just cancel the hatch at that point... he's delayed his tech, but pulling 10 scvs for a good 30 seconds or more is worth it.
Ahh, but it will be worth it. Look at this math: 1 scv mines 100 minerals a minute(just about this number), so it mines 50 minerals in 30 seconds. Then 10 scvs mines 500 minerals in that time. Now let's look at zerg money lost: Drone has to move 2 minutes across the map, so that's 200 minerals, plus hatchery cancel = 75 minerals. A hatch takes 80 seconds to build, which will cost the building drone another 125 minerals in build time. That is 400 minerals lost in cost for the zerg. However, we must also include inherent loss by the cancelation of the second hatch. Imagine the zerg had went normal 15 hatch at his own natural, vs him putting down a hatch at his natural either after or during the building of the hatch in the terran/protoss natural. So his natural complete at least 1 minute later. In 1 minute, the hatchery generates about 3 larvae, which can be translated into ~3 drones. Assume an average mining time loss of 30 seconds(very logical, because in the normal style of play, first drone will at least mine for a whole minute ahead of the first drone built off a late natural hatch). So 3 drones and 30 seconds, that's an extra 150 minerals lost. So, that totals to a 550 minerals lost for the zerg.
There may be errors in the math, but the numbers won't fluctuate a lot. Therefore, I would still argue that the zerg is behind if the terran/protoss pull workers to kill the hatch for 30 seconds.
|
On June 12 2013 04:04 Shaoer wrote:Show nested quote +On June 12 2013 03:13 TheSambassador wrote:On June 07 2013 05:13 theMutt wrote:On June 05 2013 14:05 OfficeBrahzz wrote: swear i saw a game on demuslims stream where this happened. he just pulled 10 scv's and killed it as it was about to pop with 2marines too. IMO that is a better reaction, you dont really lose that much income imo i think its worth it I think this is appropriate and is similar to what a toss would do in the same situation; pull workers to weaken it so that other units can make the kill before the hatch pops and creep spreads. However, keep in mind that vs CC first there is usually no wall around the front of natural to block a ling run-by. It is not uncommon for a Z player to send a few lings, 4-6 to secure the hatch getting up and I don't think in this scenario it is beneficial to lose a bunch of SCV's to delay the hatch. It is probably safer to focus on getting the tank to ward off any reinforcing units. Not to mention that the Z can just cancel the hatch at that point... he's delayed his tech, but pulling 10 scvs for a good 30 seconds or more is worth it. Ahh, but it will be worth it. Look at this math: 1 scv mines 100 minerals a minute(just about this number), so it mines 50 minerals in 30 seconds. Then 10 scvs mines 500 minerals in that time. Now let's look at zerg money lost: Drone has to move 2 minutes across the map, so that's 200 minerals, plus hatchery cancel = 75 minerals. A hatch takes 80 seconds to build, which will cost the building drone another 125 minerals in build time. That is 400 minerals lost in cost for the zerg. However, we must also include inherent loss by the cancelation of the second hatch. Imagine the zerg had went normal 15 hatch at his own natural, vs him putting down a hatch at his natural either after or during the building of the hatch in the terran/protoss natural. So his natural complete at least 1 minute later. In 1 minute, the hatchery generates about 3 larvae, which can be translated into ~3 drones. Assume an average mining time loss of 30 seconds(very logical, because in the normal style of play, first drone will at least mine for a whole minute ahead of the first drone built off a late natural hatch). So 3 drones and 30 seconds, that's an extra 150 minerals lost. So, that totals to a 550 minerals lost for the zerg. There may be errors in the math, but the numbers won't fluctuate a lot. Therefore, I would still argue that the zerg is behind if the terran/protoss pull workers to kill the hatch for 30 seconds. So much wrong in this post... 1. worker mines about 40 minerals per minute, 2. I don't know about your workers, but mine rarely take 2 minutes to cross the map, atleast not on 2 player maps. 3. Hatch takes 100 seconds to build 4. The hatch at the terrans is the 3rd, not the 2nd. 5. You need 300 hits from scvs on their own to kill the hatch. That is a minimum of 3 hits per second and with a 1.5sec attack speed, 4.5 workers if you start from 0 seconds into the hatch building. That means lost mining time will be around 300 for the terran(the 1st rine pops out in mid of hatch building, so hard to say exactly, rine has slightly more than double dps vs scv).
The biggest loss the zerg has is the late queens for injects. If the terran pulls workers to kill the hatch into cancel, I'd always say it's worth it(t wastes almost all his potential income for the 3rd CC into killing the hatch). This however seems like a pretty good way to force the zerg to commit to the hatch and then not take to much dmg from it aswell as get your infrastructure/tech running to be it seems ahead in the midgame.
Was late in spotting this thread. Thanks for it. Personally I stopped going CC first partly because of this, so maybe I'll start whipping it out again.
|
On June 12 2013 04:33 Zarahtra wrote: So much wrong in this post... 1. worker mines about 40 minerals per minute, 2. I don't know about your workers, but mine rarely take 2 minutes to cross the map, atleast not on 2 player maps. 3. Hatch takes 100 seconds to build 4. The hatch at the terrans is the 3rd, not the 2nd. 5. You need 300 hits from scvs on their own to kill the hatch. That is a minimum of 3 hits per second and with a 1.5sec attack speed, 4.5 workers if you start from 0 seconds into the hatch building. That means lost mining time will be around 300 for the terran(the 1st rine pops out in mid of hatch building, so hard to say exactly, rine has slightly more than double dps vs scv).
Good for you to point out the REALLY wrong post above you, but your info is also wrong.
Hatcheries have 1 base armor, so your SCVs are only doing 4 damage/hit, meaning it'll take 375 SCV attacks (1500/4). It also depends on the number of SCVs attacking, since Hatcheries regenerate HP at a rate of .27 hp/second once they're buiilt.
If you pull 10 SCVs, it'll take them 56.25 seconds to do 1500 damage (375 attacks * 1.5 attacks/second / 10 scvs). Considering that you also have to react to the hatch being put down (you don't start attacking right away), it's likely that it'll take ~10 seconds of travel time each way, for a total of 76.25 seconds that those SCVs aren't mining. At ~40minerals/minute, that's over 400 minerals not mined at least. If the zerg decides to cancel his hatchery at the last second, they've delayed their tech and lost ~75 minerals (125 if you can kill the drone).
I'd say that that still favors the zerg quite a bit.
|
On June 13 2013 05:54 TheSambassador wrote: Good for you to point out the REALLY wrong post above you, but your info is also wrong.
Hatcheries have 1 base armor, so your SCVs are only doing........ Actually, I'm pretty certain zerg buildings have no armour while building. They gain the 1 armour once they are complete.
|
On June 13 2013 06:54 Hairy wrote:Show nested quote +On June 13 2013 05:54 TheSambassador wrote: Good for you to point out the REALLY wrong post above you, but your info is also wrong.
Hatcheries have 1 base armor, so your SCVs are only doing........ Actually, I'm pretty certain zerg buildings have no armour while building. They gain the 1 armour once they are complete. Indeed, they have no armor while building.
|
And they dont have their hp regeneration
|
On June 13 2013 17:13 Zarahtra wrote:Show nested quote +On June 13 2013 06:54 Hairy wrote: Actually, I'm pretty certain zerg buildings have no armour while building. They gain the 1 armour once they are complete. Indeed, they have no armor while building.
Are we sure about this? There's no way to verify this in-game, so I'm guessing that maybe it's in the editor somewhere... but I see no "source" for this.
|
On June 14 2013 03:10 TheSambassador wrote:Show nested quote +On June 13 2013 17:13 Zarahtra wrote:On June 13 2013 06:54 Hairy wrote: Actually, I'm pretty certain zerg buildings have no armour while building. They gain the 1 armour once they are complete. Indeed, they have no armor while building. Are we sure about this? There's no way to verify this in-game, so I'm guessing that maybe it's in the editor somewhere... but I see no "source" for this.
Haven't you ever noticed that when you are killing a building hatchery it's' health drops a lot faster and dies a lot quicker then a finished hatchery?
If you have ever been killing a building hatch you'll notice it's health drops significantly faster and when if it finishes and still being attacked by the same units you'll see it's health drop slower then when it's building.
|
On June 14 2013 03:10 TheSambassador wrote:Show nested quote +On June 13 2013 17:13 Zarahtra wrote:On June 13 2013 06:54 Hairy wrote: Actually, I'm pretty certain zerg buildings have no armour while building. They gain the 1 armour once they are complete. Indeed, they have no armor while building. Are we sure about this? There's no way to verify this in-game, so I'm guessing that maybe it's in the editor somewhere... but I see no "source" for this. The source for this is going inside the game, building a building and hovering over the armor and volla "armor: 0" and then when building finishes volla "armor: 1"(or whichever armor the building has). If you are going to be proving someone is wrong, it might be a nice idea to actually check it out first.
This can be seen in unit testers, or quite frankly just by attacking the building once while building.
|
I was going to write up a guide for this but glad to see a good one already done -- and by Theognis no less! I watch so many streams and am still floored by how many people still don't respond properly to this Hatch block play (which seems to be common on NA masters for some reason).
The most common mistake I continue to see is players who build the 1st bunker too far away from the hatch instead of where it should be == directly next to it.
|
I believe 14 cc 15 rax is standard, however has anyone tried a 14cc 14rax and compared the difference? Will getting a marine and orbital earlier make it worth it, considering its significantly safer against 6 pool also?
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|