To have a rough idea of how many unit-producing structures are sensible, I took the empirical route and threw together a simple spreadsheet that shows how much resources per minute it takes to make a specific unit, if you produce it non-stop:
Starcraft Expenses (note the race tabs on the bottom)
Piousflea found out that a reasonably saturated expansion with 24 mining workers and 6 gas harvesting workers produces roughly 800 minerals and 230 gas per minute. Comparing that with the numbers in the spreadsheet, we can see that having 4 to 5 unit producing structures per expansion seems to be reasonable.
A Protoss, for example, could maintain a constant production of 2 parts zealot, 2 parts stalker from one base with 4 warpgates, because those units take (summed up) about 720 minerals and 140 gas per minute to produce. The excess gas can be used to warp in the occasional sentry or for upgrades (it doesn't quite allow for constant sentry production). If the Protoss would like to throw in some void rays from one stargate, he could still continue to push out 2 zealots and one stalker for every void ray. Barely.
The other way around, we can see that for an MMM army for terran, it might be a feasible to pull 1 or 2 SCVs from gas and let them mine minerals instead, because (for pure army-building) the Terran doesn't need 230 gas per minute to pump out marauders and the odd medivac.
All this, of course, assumes that
- The base is fully saturated with workers, meaning 24 workers on minerals and 3 on each gas. For a non-saturated expansion, see Piousflea's thread linked above.
- No workers are being produced (should be a given if your expansions are saturated and you don't plan on expanding anytime soon). They take a surprisingly large amount of resources (176 minerals per minute) to maintain constant production. That's almost as much as zealots (182 minerals per minute) and way more than marines (120 minerals per minute).
- No buildings are built. You might get away with that after that initial wave of teching for a while, but sooner or later, you'll need to save up 400 minerals for the next expansion. And when the resources from the new expansion start filling up your wallet, you will need to throw down more production facilities to make use of the new income.
- No upgrades are researched. This is a rather minor inaccuracy, as most upgrades cost as much as only 2-3 units. They just take forever.
- You have perfect macro and produce at every single opportunity, even if your opponent is knocking on your front door with a new-pants-worthy army.
Also, the numbers are pretty useless for Zerg, as they have such a different style of producing units. Especially their default-parallel production and the units that morph from other units such as banelings and Overseers.
So, in closing I (from my limited point of view of a newbie) would say that for terran and protoss, 3 to six production facilities per expansion is reasonable, depending on your other expenses like upgrades and buildings and your abilities in making sure your production lines aren't idle. What's your rule-of-thumb (or precisely calibrated law of building bases)?
