|
Immortals do not counter Thors at least not efficiently.
In a straight up fight, the Immortal will win (I assume) thanks to hardened shields and great damage, but the scales are tipped when you add in the Barrage ability which 1 shots the Immortals and SCVs repairing.
I'm not saying that Thors beat Immortals, but in a battle I think it depends more on micro from the 2 opponents, which is great (except for me, as I suck).
|
speedling and bling should be able to handle this easily
|
Well this would be horrible against zerg I would assume. A bunch of Zerglings, and they just snipe the SCV's. Then they just get a surround on the Thor's.
|
None of these players really scouted put pressure or got right counters. They all expanded and tryed to focus fire the thors down with SCV repairing them /shrug
I would say its a cool little funny cheese but thats about it. Good play/micro like any cheese will get crushed.
|
On April 02 2010 07:53 xnub wrote: its very easy to overrun somone trying to go quick thors and its really not worht it /shrug ive hade guys do this to me very easy to focus the thor with its paper thin armor or kill the SCV in 2 sec then kill thor
and Who would focus the thor with SCV repairing it ? kill the scv in like 2 sec then what lol
You can kill 15 scvs repairing a thor alongside his army in 2 seconds without taking massive losses?
I do this strat as well however it's a bit different. I open 2 factory hellions with ignitor upgrade. The upgrade finishes just before your 5th hellion is built, at which time you attack his drones. The more drones you kill obviously the better off you will be. Most zergs counter factory openings with muta tech (due to factory openings being super weak against air pre-patch). While hellion harassing I make sure to get 1 thor out to defend his mutas when they counter. While defending I build 2 more thors, so that once his muta harassment fails, I can push out immediately before he has a chance to switch tech. Yesterday I did this exact strat, and had 3 thors counter the zergs natural expansion, and pretty much rape everything (I brought 12 scvs to repair thors). In the end, My 3 thors had a total of 145 kills between them. He kept sending wave after wave of zerglings, but due to scvs repairing the thors, and sending hellions constantly as backup, he had no chance at stopping me. (he was 16 in platinum euro)
|
You are not talking about the same strat that he is all he is doing is getting a few rines and rauds for def teching right to thors and pushing with 2 thors and about 6 other units with SCV's around the 10 min mark or w/e
And yes you can kill the SCV quick never said kill the whole army in 2 sec just the SCV and its alot better then trying to focus fire the thor with SCV repairing it lol
|
humm i tried it and failed against (pure) focusing marauders [but ye... i dont know what im doing in platinum tbh -.-]
|
Someone mentioned the build is weak vs lings in tvz, delay your push a bit if needed (if gas is a limitation) and get reapers along with your push. They actually do wonders along side thors. Thors are plenty strong vs both roach and hydra, so you shouldn't need marines or maurauders too critically; scanning and scv scouting ahead of time should give you an idea of his unit-mix, the more lings you see the more reapers you make instead of maurauder. The extra minerals you get can make a quicker cc.
|
The other day a few banelings killed my support scvs, not only was the push no longer viabloe, it totally eco gimped me.
|
The two Thor push comes at 11 minutes into the game, I've tested a build many times now and I'm able to have 20+ Marines, 2 Thors, and one Medevac out and ready to go at the same time an MMM timing push comes out (about 11 minutes). So far I've had very strong results versus Protoss and especially Zerg - I have not tried this build versus Terran, however MM/Helion/Banshee seems much more viable in TvT anyways. Yes you can overwhelm Thors if prepared for them, but you can't do it if two Thors and a Marine squad hit your base at the point in time for Protoss where only one Immortal may be out, or for Zerg the lair is probably just finishing. Scouting the Thor tech before 8 minutes is the only option to stop it as far as I've seen. I'll keep doing the build and perfect it, get some reps up to show everyone.
|
On April 03 2010 03:10 SichuanPanda wrote: The two Thor push comes at 11 minutes into the game, I've tested a build many times now and I'm able to have 20+ Marines, 2 Thors, and one Medevac out and ready to go at the same time an MMM timing push comes out (about 11 minutes). So far I've had very strong results versus Protoss and especially Zerg - I have not tried this build versus Terran, however MM/Helion/Banshee seems much more viable in TvT anyways. Yes you can overwhelm Thors if prepared for them, but you can't do it if two Thors and a Marine squad hit your base at the point in time for Protoss where only one Immortal may be out, or for Zerg the lair is probably just finishing. Scouting the Thor tech before 8 minutes is the only option to stop it as far as I've seen. I'll keep doing the build and perfect it, get some reps up to show everyone.
Looking forward to this. im sure you could get 2 thors a bit faster with a rax first build and a early supply drop. speed up the push by 45 secs or so.
|
if ur not scouted, it could work no as a normal strat, of cource, but bc its unexpected
|
On April 02 2010 07:53 Nilaus wrote: Immortals do not counter Thors at least not efficiently.
In a straight up fight, the Immortal will win (I assume) thanks to hardened shields and great damage, but the scales are tipped when you add in the Barrage ability which 1 shots the Immortals and SCVs repairing.
I'm not saying that Thors beat Immortals, but in a battle I think it depends more on micro from the 2 opponents, which is great (except for me, as I suck).
Thors will oneshot immortals with barrage as mentioned, but this is a huge risk for the thor.
Immortals without shield will die very fast to thors (but an immortal with no shield can still a-move a single sieged tank and survive)
Any other situation and the thor will need repairs or support to win vs immortals.
Dropships are cool with thors and can heal the any supporting bio/SCVs. You can reinforce faster, lift to high ground, shuffle damaged thors away from trouble (when otherwise stuck) and so on.
|
On April 03 2010 14:12 jackofclubs81 wrote: if ur not scouted, it could work no as a normal strat, of cource, but bc its unexpected hummm not sure. there's going to be a techlab'ed factory and then an armory by the time the wall-off is in place. terrans can scan, sure. but i cannot recommend thors against massed marauders anyways, which is (almost) all there is atm.
|
It really just depends on your opponent. I do a speedling/baneling push vs terran almost every game and as you know speedlings destroy thors, even though they wouldn't even be out by then. Normally I make 6 banelings and have 40 speedlings when I push.
|
I think it could be viable but the real hard part is living through the early game. I can see once you have 2 thors that you can easily push out but if there is any early game aggression the T is in big trouble.
|
do a thor drop and use it like a reaver to pick workers / map control while you expand.
|
Thor-dropping a la Reavers sounds awesome.
|
When I first read this I thought this might be good, but then I watched those replays...
I mean those opponents had some serious leaks in their game. That protoss had no idea at all and that Zerg had an average of like 800 unspent minerals in the first few minutes and then went Mutas/Banelings without harassing or scouting at all? The terran reaperharass was just bad. Not effective against Terra and not effective on that map. And altho he wasted his reapers he still tried to get a FE up...
I would love to see a successful thorpush but in my opinion it was way too close against the Zerg and the Terra. If they hadn't screwed up their early and the fights so much or put any kind of pressure on you those Thors would've failed miserably.
It has some potential tho. I think you could've gotten those Thors a little earlier and on some maps this push might be viable. I'm gonna try it out myself and tweak around a little cuz I like the idea of a thorpush.
|
On April 04 2010 11:31 Optimator wrote: Thor-dropping a la Reavers sounds awesome.
it gets more fun when u have 2 thors to drop.
nexus gone in 8-10 secs. even if he has stuff at the nat or cannons around the nex it will die before anything happens to the thors .
screwing around with thors in custom games quite a bit and haven tlost so far. but since mostly superbads play custom games its not exactly special ~
but really. a thor drop is scary. kill 5 probes, oneshot 2 sentrys, kill a stalker and fly your 150 hp thor out,,repair and come back with 2 thors and kill the nex. huge fun ^^
|
|
|
|
|
|