|
On February 23 2008 11:54 JeeJee wrote:
L2W, romance, since you're actually reading the thread right now
what do you have to gain by lynching fakesteve? assuming best case scenario, town STILL becomes worse off when he's dead
comments?
How do you figure? He's using his advantage votes to vote for TRACIL, I don't see how it could possibly be worse if he were dead. If he were to use his stacked votes to go with us, or at least have a better explanation as to why to stray from our path, other than Tracil being "pessimistic", then yes, I would reconsider. But...
|
On February 23 2008 12:01 Romance_us wrote:Show nested quote +On February 23 2008 11:54 JeeJee wrote:
L2W, romance, since you're actually reading the thread right now
what do you have to gain by lynching fakesteve? assuming best case scenario, town STILL becomes worse off when he's dead
comments? How do you figure? He's using his advantage votes to vote for TRACIL, I don't see how it could possibly be worse if he were dead. If he were to use his stacked votes to go with us, or at least have a better explanation as to why to stray from our path, other than Tracil being "pessimistic", then yes, I would reconsider. But...
uhm
we don't have double lynches if he's dead?
btw there's no "us" right now. have you seen how the voting is spread? you can't seriously think that FS's 4 votes are going to change anything (as of now, tracil's nowhere near being lynched)
|
On February 23 2008 12:02 JeeJee wrote:Show nested quote +On February 23 2008 12:01 Romance_us wrote:On February 23 2008 11:54 JeeJee wrote:
L2W, romance, since you're actually reading the thread right now
what do you have to gain by lynching fakesteve? assuming best case scenario, town STILL becomes worse off when he's dead
comments? How do you figure? He's using his advantage votes to vote for TRACIL, I don't see how it could possibly be worse if he were dead. If he were to use his stacked votes to go with us, or at least have a better explanation as to why to stray from our path, other than Tracil being "pessimistic", then yes, I would reconsider. But... uhm we don't have double lynches if he's dead?
Better one townie dead than two, right? Look at last double lynch...
|
On February 23 2008 12:03 Romance_us wrote:Show nested quote +On February 23 2008 12:02 JeeJee wrote:On February 23 2008 12:01 Romance_us wrote:On February 23 2008 11:54 JeeJee wrote:
L2W, romance, since you're actually reading the thread right now
what do you have to gain by lynching fakesteve? assuming best case scenario, town STILL becomes worse off when he's dead
comments? How do you figure? He's using his advantage votes to vote for TRACIL, I don't see how it could possibly be worse if he were dead. If he were to use his stacked votes to go with us, or at least have a better explanation as to why to stray from our path, other than Tracil being "pessimistic", then yes, I would reconsider. But... uhm we don't have double lynches if he's dead? Better one townie dead than two, right? Look at last double lynch...
that has got to be the most retarded thing i've read
you're assuming we only lynch townies and while the facts are on your side for now ( ) i am hoping that will change.
edit: just to clarify, it's not FS's fault we voted for townies
edit#2: just to make your point further, why lynch at all? we don't have to. 0 townies better than 1 right?
|
After reviewing day one clues I change my votes to Wurm and Miss the mark.
|
The Mafia/Towny ratio is such right now that it is profitable for us to lose 3 of our own to catch 1 mafia.
Why would you say something like that, Romance_us? It makes you look suspicious.
|
On February 23 2008 12:04 JeeJee wrote:Show nested quote +On February 23 2008 12:03 Romance_us wrote:On February 23 2008 12:02 JeeJee wrote:On February 23 2008 12:01 Romance_us wrote:On February 23 2008 11:54 JeeJee wrote:
L2W, romance, since you're actually reading the thread right now
what do you have to gain by lynching fakesteve? assuming best case scenario, town STILL becomes worse off when he's dead
comments? How do you figure? He's using his advantage votes to vote for TRACIL, I don't see how it could possibly be worse if he were dead. If he were to use his stacked votes to go with us, or at least have a better explanation as to why to stray from our path, other than Tracil being "pessimistic", then yes, I would reconsider. But... uhm we don't have double lynches if he's dead? Better one townie dead than two, right? Look at last double lynch... that has got to be the most retarded thing i've read you're assuming we only lynch townies and while the facts are on your side for now ( ) i am hoping that will change. edit: just to clarify, it's not FS's fault we voted for townies
I'm going by the facts. YOU are assuming.
|
On February 23 2008 12:06 Romance_us wrote:Show nested quote +On February 23 2008 12:04 JeeJee wrote:On February 23 2008 12:03 Romance_us wrote:On February 23 2008 12:02 JeeJee wrote:On February 23 2008 12:01 Romance_us wrote:On February 23 2008 11:54 JeeJee wrote:
L2W, romance, since you're actually reading the thread right now
what do you have to gain by lynching fakesteve? assuming best case scenario, town STILL becomes worse off when he's dead
comments? How do you figure? He's using his advantage votes to vote for TRACIL, I don't see how it could possibly be worse if he were dead. If he were to use his stacked votes to go with us, or at least have a better explanation as to why to stray from our path, other than Tracil being "pessimistic", then yes, I would reconsider. But... uhm we don't have double lynches if he's dead? Better one townie dead than two, right? Look at last double lynch... that has got to be the most retarded thing i've read you're assuming we only lynch townies and while the facts are on your side for now ( ) i am hoping that will change. edit: just to clarify, it's not FS's fault we voted for townies I'm going by the facts. YOU are assuming.
read my second edit. reply please 
also, what have i assumed?
|
Live2Win
United States6657 Posts
If he was a mafia, how do you think he will use his double lynches?
When we "idiots" vote and the two leading candidates to get lynched are both townies. That's when he'd use his double lynch. If the top ones were mafia and townie, would he use his double? No.
|
On February 23 2008 12:08 Live2Win wrote:
If he was a mafia, how do you think he will use his double lynches?
When we "idiots" vote and the two leading candidates to get lynched are both townies. That's when he'd use his double lynch. If the top ones were mafia and townie, would he use his double? No.
you don't know that he wouldn't, L2W. when he refuses to double lynch and provides no reasoning, that's a scumtell. has that happened? when it does, we can lynch him. Until then, it's silly to do so.
|
On February 23 2008 12:04 JeeJee wrote:
edit#2: just to make your point further, why lynch at all? we don't have to. 0 townies better than 1 right?
I didn't imply that, and you call my post retarded but completely misunderstand my logic at the same time. That makes sense, doesn't it? We are misusing double lynch as a whole incorrectly. When day comes and we see 5-6 townies dead, we start yelling out "DOUBLE LYNCH!!!!!!" before we really even review the clues or any leads. You are completely assuming FakeSteve is Townie. You cannot deny that. It's in your words.
L2W makes a good point.
You are so set on protecting FakeSteve, but primarily for his mayor advantage, when it should be that PLUS his willingness to contribute and help us. At least Tracil is in-depth about nearly everything.
|
So why doesn't tracil pardon FS, we keep both of them, and smb gets a quick drop on a short rope?
|
On February 23 2008 12:12 Romance_us wrote:Show nested quote +On February 23 2008 12:04 JeeJee wrote:
edit#2: just to make your point further, why lynch at all? we don't have to. 0 townies better than 1 right? I didn't imply that, and you call my post retarded but completely misunderstand my logic at the same time. That makes sense, doesn't it? We are misusing double lynch as a whole incorrectly. When day comes and we see 5-6 townies dead, we start yelling out "DOUBLE LYNCH!!!!!!" before we really even review the clues or any leads. You are completely assuming FakeSteve is Townie. You cannot deny that. It's in your words. L2W makes a good point. You are so set on protecting FakeSteve, but primarily for his mayor advantage, when it should be that PLUS his willingness to contribute and help us. At least Tracil is in-depth about nearly everything.
yes i should be protecting him for his willingness to help and contribute to us. has he done so? of course not, you'd have to be stupid to say he actually contributed anything for the town aside from his role. of course i am protecting his role. and i'm not voting for tracil either, so i don't even know where that came from.
and the logic applies. re-read if you don't see how. it's not as if us lynching is any different when we use single or double. in both cases, the same amount of analysis has been done, and we're as sure as we're going to be given the time and effort put in at the time.
and i'm assuming fakesteve is townie? have you READ what i wrote? i believe that he's mafia.. one of my posts started with "disclaimer: i believe FS is mafia"
also keep in mind, the mayor has to decide to Dlynch early in the voting. he has no way of knowing whether mafia will be on the top of the voting list by the time the voting closes ..
|
If you are running for mayor, either you're scum, you believe that you would make a good mayor, or you're semi-joking around.
As it is, various indicators in the thread have demonstrated that I no longer trust anyone who was in the running. Could be a mafia charade or just a ridiculous series of coincidences but regardless of what the lynch flips my suspicions are set. SoMuchBetter has just been lurkering, FakeSteve has been rather hostile, and I'm not entirely sure that I trust Tracil right now.
Vote: Tracil and SoMuchBetter
(Keep in mind: I am not stupid, and neither is Tracil for that matter.)
|
Tracil is always leading the the mobs against villagers
fakesteve is calling double lynches everytime everyone wants villagers lynched
|
my skin is sensitive and will break on the rope
may i request a different method of execution
|
On February 23 2008 12:26 SoMuchBetter wrote:
my skin is sensitive and will break on the rope
may i request a different method of execution
What exactly did you have in mind? Maybe an old trial by fire? See if you're a witch?
Wait this is mafia damn...
|
On February 23 2008 12:24 SoMuchBetter wrote:
Tracil is always leading the the mobs against villagers
fakesteve is calling double lynches everytime everyone wants villagers lynched
You might be correct..
We will see when night comes though
|
On February 23 2008 12:24 SoMuchBetter wrote:
Tracil is always leading the the mobs against villagers
fakesteve is calling double lynches everytime everyone wants villagers lynched Your signature has scum in it, you're definetly mafia.
|
On February 23 2008 12:26 SoMuchBetter wrote:
my skin is sensitive and will break on the rope
may i request a different method of execution
Can we see if he floats? To the RIVER!
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
