I think we just need to assume scum exist and it’s possible for town to win. Further discussion of setup and balance only serves to dilute the thread and help scum.

Vivax, pretend you have a gun. Who do you shoot? Who would you save?

GreYMisT

United States6736 Posts

November 15 2020 15:18 GMT

#322

EBWOP: that a gun and a Medkit, I obviously don’t expect you to save someone with a gun.

Vivax

22104 Posts

November 15 2020 15:23 GMT

#323

I'd shoot you just for asking such a thing during the night phase. But I'll bite.

And I'd save cop because she's a thread driver, maybe myself. Coinflippy.

GreYMisT

United States6736 Posts

November 15 2020 15:24 GMT

#324

So am I your top scum read now?

Vivax

22104 Posts

November 15 2020 15:26 GMT

#325

On November 16 2020 00:12 Eversince wrote:
Why is me understanding the fact I'm be hard to read(always but more so when I'm pressed for time).
It seemed like most were concerned already on me.
I said what I thought, then said what I think was towns best option was?

I don't particularly like the vibes from this post btw (it reads sort of apologetic) and tone is sort of off for Ever who tends to appear very carefree as town usually.

Vivax

22104 Posts

November 15 2020 15:29 GMT

#326

On November 16 2020 00:24 GreYMisT wrote:
So am I your top scum read now?

I had a spidey sense on you from the start but you not analyzing the setup before I did when you're one of the most diligent hosts on the site was really a nail in the coffin.

GreYMisT

United States6736 Posts

November 15 2020 15:29 GMT

#327

I concur, Ever’s posts seem to restate things already posted, flip flop, or don’t say anything. She hasn’t taken a firm stance that she can be nailed to later. These are all classic mafia tells.

I would be willing to vote Ever tomorrow

Eversince

Philippines2301 Posts

November 15 2020 15:36 GMT

#328

On November 16 2020 00:26 Vivax wrote:

Show nested quote +

I don't particularly like the vibes from this post btw (it reads sort of apologetic) and tone is sort of off for Ever who tends to appear very carefree as town usually.

Im just tired r.r.. You know my occupation. Try running it from across ocean..

GreYMisT

United States6736 Posts

November 15 2020 15:37 GMT

#329

On November 16 2020 00:29 Vivax wrote:

Show nested quote +

I had a spidey sense on you from the start but you not analyzing the setup before I did when you're one of the most diligent hosts on the site was really a nail in the coffin.

I’ll own that failure. However, in the games I play, and indeed in post games of my themed setups, I often encourage players to try to play classic mafia and ignore setup speculation, as it is very easy for mafia to participate in this and look townie. So I would argue that my non analysis of the setup is irrelevant.

I would be very interested to hear from Artanis today. We have some more data from other players. I would be especially interested in hearing his thoughts on the post I quoted from Ever, and Vivax and Copcake’s interaction regarding sheeping.

Eversince

Philippines2301 Posts

November 15 2020 15:39 GMT

#330

And Grey just validated my point.
Im ? So we should of done that last cycle.

List off what I've done to further mafia agenda?

Vivax

22104 Posts

November 15 2020 15:39 GMT

#331

I have some doubts on Artanis because he tends to be more spammy.

I'd pit Ever and Artanis against each other in a MMA octahedron tomorrow fully expecting Ever to win because farm work makes you ripped and I don't think a "get ripped" on a townie seal means a whole lot except for meek boasting.

Vivax

22104 Posts

November 15 2020 15:41 GMT

#332

Or rather octagon because we're not at zero G

Vivax

22104 Posts

November 15 2020 15:57 GMT

#333

On November 16 2020 00:39 Eversince wrote:
And Grey just validated my point.
Im ? So we should of done that last cycle.

List off what I've done to further mafia agenda?

What's mafia agenda in this game? Considering the low activity and very relaxed early game I expected at least a bit of fooling around and less of a watch and wait approach. And in the I'm a cop game you and cop fooled around a lot

CopCake

4378 Posts

November 15 2020 16:02 GMT

#334

Isn't Artanis a Capoeira champ?

I think he can kick ass while dancing Lambada

Eversince

Philippines2301 Posts

November 15 2020 16:05 GMT

#335

Isn't it always the same? Discord, manipulation, kill town??

I've admittedly not done much this game. Trying my bestest but there is the other edge of the knife. I have little to work with. I just go through saying 'does this advanced game?' Sadly the amount of nai post are like 1/3 of the game. More so early on d1 when I reread and posted my thoughts..

CopCake

4378 Posts

November 15 2020 16:07 GMT

#336

Why do you think Vivax is mafia Ever?

Eversince

Philippines2301 Posts

November 15 2020 16:08 GMT

#337

On November 16 2020 01:02 CopCake wrote:
Isn't Artanis a Capoeira champ?

I think he can kick ass while dancing Lambada

(Side note I'd let Art win because his wife would poison my scotch if I ever hurt him :3 *bestest innocent eyes stare*

Vivax

22104 Posts

November 15 2020 16:11 GMT

#338

He'll hate me forever for this probably but at least I concealed his face.

[image loading]

This is the last shitpost for the day I need to sneak past the cops to attend a birthday now.

Eversince

Philippines2301 Posts

November 15 2020 16:12 GMT

#339

On November 16 2020 01:07 CopCake wrote:
Why do you think Vivax is mafia Ever?

He's coasting. The vivax I know is usually weak d1. He would of got pass for that. But he's also very smart. Which is exactly why I usually pass. He was here. He was interacting. He said 0 useful things.

Now we are talking about past games and rl concerns. While I do love to do this, it doesn't help me find mafia at all..