I'm not sure why you guys didn't sheep me... Rayn was obvious and Jock was PoE with 50/50 shot.

I think both HF and Jock are probably better scum players than town players, but the rest of the town felt very obvious with associative reads.

Eywa-

Canada4876 Posts

August 25 2019 21:31 GMT

#1497

Like, I get the lynch... Though, if your followup plan is lynching squishy, you should at least give my reads a shot first because the chain lynch was an objectively bad play and the entire reason I didn't want to lynch squishy over me.

Beyond that though, after the flip, you need to give more attention to my reads, because I've never shown to have bad reads in my town games here.

Also, @HF, cases don't make sense because if I'm scum reading player A correctly and you're incorrectly scum reading player B... That means your view of what makes someone scum is incorrect, so in order to persuade you, I need to make up reasoning that is not actually alignment indicative... Since you're reading the game wrong, you're also not going to see why what I'm seeing is alignment indicative.

Eywa-

Canada4876 Posts

August 25 2019 22:16 GMT

#1499

On August 26 2019 07:10 Holyflare wrote:

Show nested quote +

What you stated in the obs qt about following my reads is because I used to be a really good town player (at least, actually lynching mafia consistently) but that's changed nowadays and it feels like nobody really plays the style that is compatible with me and nobody has the time either (and neither do I to be honest. Don't care enough).

I think town people played relatively well in displaying their towniness though.

Yeah, I mean, I could see that. We definitely have very different play styles. I think everyone in the game needs to just understand better where they fit (within the current game state) and play accordingly in order for town to have success... This is 3 scum wins in a row, definitely a bit out of the ordinary.

Eywa-

Canada4876 Posts

August 26 2019 01:19 GMT

#1509

On August 26 2019 10:14 Grackaroni wrote:
From the parts I saw I really thought Jock was legit town and Squishy mafia from where Jock was pushing Squishy.

Rayn fooled me with his rage quit post but it seems like most of OBS aside from me wasn't fooled.

I don't really get why people were scum reading Squishy tbh... Like, I saw the arguments for it, but I think those arguments are critically flawed and generally NAI.

Eywa-

Canada4876 Posts

August 26 2019 01:57 GMT

#1511

On August 26 2019 10:33 Grackaroni wrote:

Show nested quote +

Mine came from the posts around the start of day 2.

Show nested quote +

That's the thing, cherry picking reads and information isn't alignment indicative whatsoever... There is a ton of information in the thread, everyone is cherry picking what they believe is relevant or what they believe people will buy into.

Eywa-

Canada4876 Posts

August 26 2019 04:35 GMT

#1517

On August 26 2019 13:08 CopCake wrote:
It is just a game, people need to relax.
I feel embarrased a little bit but I know my “moon magic” logic is not taken seriously.

The first person ever to call out Jock was me for his “ he is doing filters to look town” and I got shut down.

o.o I had him in a poe of 2 and you refused to vote for him at any point this game. I don't think that one time you called him out counts for much.