|
On August 18 2019 04:02 raynpelikoneet wrote:Show nested quote +On August 18 2019 03:57 Vivax wrote:On August 18 2019 03:51 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Who cares jock? Why does cake mske that read as mafia? What do you mean who cares. It should be obvious to any townie that right now the game is pretty stale, Jock is trying to move it forward cause he feels it too (wildly guessing). This is also mafia-y from you. You don't recognize the game's situation from what I think is a townie point of view and make it all about the content in jocks post. No Vivax. It doesnt matter to me because shit reads are shit reads and i think that questioning already will end up in a shit read. You could argue cake would make that read if she is mafia exactly with hf but i dont thonk thats the case here or at least the current evidence doesnt suggest that in any way. So the other outcome is useless discussion about something irrelevant.
Could you describe mafia cake? You are very confident in your townread, so it should be doable.
|
Please.
And I'm guessing that eywa overslept the start of the game.
|
On August 18 2019 04:02 raynpelikoneet wrote:Show nested quote +On August 18 2019 03:57 Vivax wrote:On August 18 2019 03:51 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Who cares jock? Why does cake mske that read as mafia? What do you mean who cares. It should be obvious to any townie that right now the game is pretty stale, Jock is trying to move it forward cause he feels it too (wildly guessing). This is also mafia-y from you. You don't recognize the game's situation from what I think is a townie point of view and make it all about the content in jocks post. No Vivax. It doesnt matter to me because shit reads are shit reads and i think that questioning already will end up in a shit read. You could argue cake would make that read if she is mafia exactly with hf but i dont thonk thats the case here or at least the current evidence doesnt suggest that in any way. So the other outcome is useless discussion about something irrelevant.
Why couldn't she do it if HF is town? Is there a cake mafia meta where she hard defends teammates?
|
On August 18 2019 05:00 Jockmcplop wrote:
Pfft.
Whatever copcake. I'd like to know what everyone else thinks about all this.
To me it looks like everything you are posting is contradictory and nonsensical.
Yep that's how I scumread her when she was town too
|
Although I wouldn't call it nonsensical or contradictory, what you pointed out was hypocrisy about making a big deal out of a townlean.
|
On August 18 2019 05:06 raynpelikoneet wrote:Show nested quote +On August 18 2019 04:51 Vivax wrote:On August 18 2019 04:02 raynpelikoneet wrote:On August 18 2019 03:57 Vivax wrote:On August 18 2019 03:51 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Who cares jock? Why does cake mske that read as mafia? What do you mean who cares. It should be obvious to any townie that right now the game is pretty stale, Jock is trying to move it forward cause he feels it too (wildly guessing). This is also mafia-y from you. You don't recognize the game's situation from what I think is a townie point of view and make it all about the content in jocks post. No Vivax. It doesnt matter to me because shit reads are shit reads and i think that questioning already will end up in a shit read. You could argue cake would make that read if she is mafia exactly with hf but i dont thonk thats the case here or at least the current evidence doesnt suggest that in any way. So the other outcome is useless discussion about something irrelevant. Why couldn't she do it if HF is town? Is there a cake mafia meta where she hard defends teammates? Would you make that read if youre mafia and hf is town?
I'd be suicidal as mafia if I tried to lynch HF on a D1, which is why it's a wet dream of mine.
To add to the previous post:
Townies tend to be hypocrites all the time. Or at least are more prone to accusing others of things they did themselves. Mafia doesn't think they know how mafia thinks, they just know it.
So they don't get hypocritical if they try to keep the story straight and remember what they posted. When I'm mafia, accusing someone of something I did myself while being conscious about having done it would give me the feeling that I'm leading you straight to myself.
But anyway, I think that, even if the little theory is completely wrong, at most cake's hypocrisy should be treated as null.
|
But I really answered that a bit badly rayn:
If I were mafia, I'd not throw an early read at HF like that, most likely. I'd probably only start building a scumread on him if he was looking my way for the lynch.
|
Unless it's futile which is going to be the case mostly, then I'm better off buddying him and aiming at lynch bait. Which is what cake could be doing. Except for the lynch bait part, but a lot of people haven't posted.
|
On August 18 2019 05:22 CopCake wrote:Show nested quote +On August 18 2019 05:17 Vivax wrote:
Unless it's futile which is going to be the case mostly, then I'm better off buddying him and aiming at lynch bait. Which is what cake could be doing. Except for the lynch bait part, but a lot of people haven't posted. And wouldnt jock be all buddy buddy trying to town read you? Just a question.
Yes if I didn't townread him already for being helpful at baiting more content and invested in his reads. What makes you think he is faking his suspicion on you?
|
Anyway I'm off for today. Going to trust my first impression and a bit on top.
##Vote rayn
|
On August 18 2019 05:34 CopCake wrote:Show nested quote +On August 18 2019 05:29 Vivax wrote:On August 18 2019 05:22 CopCake wrote:On August 18 2019 05:17 Vivax wrote:
Unless it's futile which is going to be the case mostly, then I'm better off buddying him and aiming at lynch bait. Which is what cake could be doing. Except for the lynch bait part, but a lot of people haven't posted. And wouldnt jock be all buddy buddy trying to town read you? Just a question. Yes if I didn't townread him already for being helpful at baiting more content and invested in his reads. What makes you think he is faking his suspicion on you? Where did I claim he is faking suspicion on me?
I had the impression you two were at it trying to find something to poke the other because of his claim that your read on HF is wrong or scummy, and your claim that it was too early for his read on me. You didn't try to find out what that was about without being suspicious about Jock?
|
On August 18 2019 16:49 reps)squishy wrote:Show nested quote +On August 18 2019 05:15 Vivax wrote:
But I really answered that a bit badly rayn:
If I were mafia, I'd not throw an early read at HF like that, most likely. I'd probably only start building a scumread on him if he was looking my way for the lynch. Ok OJ Simpson
???
|
Squishy is town I think. It might look odd with the "if I were mafia" thing is not seen in the context that I was being widely townread. The point anyway was that I didn't want to snap vote rayn just cause HF was trying to tempt me.
So I suppose I'm back to killing rayn.
|
Or actually I'll reflect upon squishy a bit longer. I'm about to have dinner and have just thought it through quickly.
|
On August 18 2019 23:53 reps)squishy wrote:Show nested quote +On August 18 2019 22:33 Holyflare wrote:On August 18 2019 19:37 Jockmcplop wrote:
Y'all need to start playing some mafia cos I have no idea who needs to get lynched right now. Mafia can just hide if 50% of the players have gone missing. We can just vote reps for catching up on like 3 pages and posting one off hand comment and leaving again. Easy. You could. However I just went to bed forty minutes after catching up and making my comment. (I just woke and the first thing I did was check responses). Psychologically I don’t like Vivax’s “if I were mafia” sentient, seems like OJ Simpson’s “If I did it”. I know Vivax knows that he will not convince us of him being town in D1. I am suspicious of him because he has played that sentiment multiple times now if you read their filter.
What does this mean? That's not at all how I read the game. I've been doing my thing and from the start I was showered with townreads. Sure, if someone made that read, then I commented on its reasoning, like when jock pointed out I was posting in other threads, because it was also a good line of thought that you call playing sentiment.
|
On August 19 2019 00:34 reps)squishy wrote:Show nested quote +On August 19 2019 00:29 Holyflare wrote:
Can you explain how you came to the conclusion that Vivax and I are scummy? Just because we're voting you?
Can you also explain why Vivax and I should interact if we were both town and I have said not to lynch him today either? Because if you were town, you would want to get a read on each other. Best way to do that is not sitting passive, but quoting a post and getting them to talk. As far as not voting for each other is that you guys don’t want to lynch a veteran D1. Not that you guys are town reading each other
I complained about HF not posting enough for my liking. Twice iirc.
And you say I don't consider veterans for lynch while I've had my eye on rayn all day. More false facts.
I really don't know what game you are reading. More likely you're just scum tbh.
|
HF how could you move squishy to null? He's far from cleared given that his story is just meeeeh , although the initial ingenuity made him seem townie to me too.
|
On August 19 2019 02:42 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On August 18 2019 03:06 Vivax wrote:
I wouldn't mind if you also told a bit about how your new home thingy progressed. I actually wouldn't mind at all if you didn't even talk about mafia, just anything. And sorry to everyone I seem to be super tryharding right now, but it's mostly a sleep deprivation thing leading to this verbal diarrhea today. Was this directed at me?
I thought it was obvious yes
|
The best is that he says I'm not voting HF because I don't vote veterans on D1, and not because I don't have a scumread on HF.
|
On August 19 2019 02:45 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On August 19 2019 02:43 Vivax wrote:On August 19 2019 02:42 Holyflare wrote:On August 18 2019 03:06 Vivax wrote:
I wouldn't mind if you also told a bit about how your new home thingy progressed. I actually wouldn't mind at all if you didn't even talk about mafia, just anything. And sorry to everyone I seem to be super tryharding right now, but it's mostly a sleep deprivation thing leading to this verbal diarrhea today. Was this directed at me? I thought it was obvious yes Oh :D Sorry lol. House move went good, just chilling out! GF's parents came to visit yesterday for her bday. Bought a bike and a digital piano and going climbing a lot so basically just enjoying not having a job for a while.
Sweet. Do you do the climbing where you carry your rope along the route or along fixed rope routes?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
