EPTGreatest for me would be Branch and Pandain.
If you feel the same. Mine are:
Eversince
Eywa
MZ
If we 4 have a common mafia read. Let's vote him. We need 3 days in a row to be correct anyway.
Cupid's Arrow Mafia - Page 96
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Koshi
Belgium38799 Posts
Greatest for me would be Branch and Pandain. If you feel the same. Mine are: Eversince Eywa MZ If we 4 have a common mafia read. Let's vote him. We need 3 days in a row to be correct anyway. | ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38799 Posts
On August 01 2019 20:10 NoSmurfHere wrote: My PoE says eversince if we have to choose one. Eywa and MZ both seem mafia but I don't like them being mafia together. -J I am fine with Eversince. For me eywa is my biggest scumread. But we need 3 in a row so I dont mind going for Eversince. | ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38799 Posts
| ||
|
NoSmurfHere
New Zealand613 Posts
Let me filter him first? Anything in particular i should pay attention to? I like the idea that the mafia is protecting us. That would be something that the following people have in common: Eywa MZ Koshi Pandain (to a lesser degree) -J | ||
|
NoSmurfHere
New Zealand613 Posts
Yeah fuck it I'm completely changing our reads. Bugs is off the hook if koshi is mafia because he's afk and wanted to kill him twice already. Branch is out, koshi is out, mafia is between the other 4. ES is a great vote. She just hasn't been playing like herself: no posts that say "I'm here now let's talk". She seems kinda nervy and less relaxed than usual. This: On July 27 2019 17:29 Eversince wrote: EBWOP Before people start crying 'BURN THE WITCH!!' There wasn't anything for me to comment on. Your recap reasoning post (Which I'd already gave my opinion for), Tube tunnels (k, I tunneled the shit out of Pandain but I'm not going to fight a null[tube] and you [hydra] to try to convince otherwise. Is so fucking defensive. You gotta be extra worried about what people are thinking of your alignment to be posting pre-emptive defense posts like this. -J | ||
|
NoSmurfHere
New Zealand613 Posts
##vote Eversince -J | ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38799 Posts
I think HF point out to the scumslip might have been real as well. | ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38799 Posts
| ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38799 Posts
| ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38799 Posts
OR You need to tell us why both Koshi and the hydra are mafia. Because town need to vote together. All 4. | ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38799 Posts
Pandain... Pandain. I townread you. So I need you to vote with me. Do you townread the hydra? Can you live with voting Eversince? If not. Can you suggest another name that we commonly scumread? | ||
|
Branch.AUT
Austria853 Posts
| ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38799 Posts
| ||
|
NoSmurfHere
New Zealand613 Posts
On August 01 2019 20:41 Branch.AUT wrote: Voting Everysince Go on then you don't have to ask in the QT if you're going to bus ES just go for it! -J | ||
|
Branch.AUT
Austria853 Posts
On August 01 2019 19:56 NoSmurfHere wrote: Branch which combinations of players do you think couldn't be mafia together? I'm hesitant to call out three people in connection. It is no how I approach this game. I'll try anyway because youve asked me too My strongest scumreads are MZ/Pandain. Both sheeped Slam during lynches, except when Slam changed his vote close to deadline. Both post constructive just enough to not be supiciously inactive, but way too little to actually catch mafia. Eywa/ES im less sure of, Eywa because HF went all out defending them on meta reason. ES mostly posts prior to deadline and willingly gives her vote to anyone interacting, except when I pushed to lynch Eywa. Could see ES+Eywa together mafia. I consider any combination of these four possible. | ||
|
NoSmurfHere
New Zealand613 Posts
On August 01 2019 20:51 Branch.AUT wrote: I'm hesitant to call out three people in connection. It is no how I approach this game. I'll try anyway because youve asked me too My strongest scumreads are MZ/Pandain. Both sheeped Slam during lynches, except when Slam changed his vote close to deadline. Both post constructive just enough to not be supiciously inactive, but way too little to actually catch mafia. Eywa/ES im less sure of, Eywa because HF went all out defending them on meta reason. ES mostly posts prior to deadline and willingly gives her vote to anyone interacting, except when I pushed to lynch Eywa. Could see ES+Eywa together mafia. I consider any combination of these four possible. Its worth noting that HF's defense of eywa wasn't a townread. His point about eywa's meta is true, but we'ev never seen eywa play as mafia here so its not a townread - he's just saying that you can't scumread eywa based on tone. I'll be able to give you a proper read on eywa by the end of today. -J | ||
|
Grackaroni
United States9846 Posts
Eversince (3): NoSmurfHere, Koshi, Branch.AUT Koshi (1): Pandain Not Voting (3): Eywa, Meapak_Ziphh, Eversince Eversince is currently set to be lynched. Please let us know if you notice any mistakes! The deadline is Friday, Aug 02 8:00pm GMT (GMT+00:00), which is in | ||
|
Meapak_Ziphh
United States6786 Posts
On July 31 2019 04:47 Branch.AUT wrote: Since we're consolidating Im putting my vote on koshi. Eywa and HF too suspicious to vote with. Hydra youre on the wrong track yet again On July 31 2019 04:50 Branch.AUT wrote: Just pushed Eywa to get reaction. Only thing I got was Koshi and FF flopping onto it. Don't like the filter. If Scum then with HF I hate these posts. Branch finally comes out with a real serious push and then backs off when he realizes he's not getting traction. He provides not one but two reasons for his change of heart: He was either consolidating or "pushing for a reaction" But wait! today he says he was scumreading Eywa for real yesterday: On August 01 2019 17:28 Branch.AUT wrote: I thought the hydra was scum after bugs made a strange comment I tunneled into but their qt gave them a lot of towncred. To me, hydra town. Pandain have to filter again, but really like his early days last time I read him. Right now uncertain of him. Eywa I've called scum all day yesterday. People felt her town because town meta. But very easy to fake meta. Still think that their play is scummy. So was it a real scumread or not? Why do you never stand with a read. It feels as if every one of your reads is carefully constructed to avoid responsibility for whatever position you're taking. On August 01 2019 17:28 Branch.AUT wrote: I thought the hydra was scum after bugs made a strange comment I tunneled into but their qt gave them a lot of towncred. To me, hydra town. Pandain have to filter again, but really like his early days last time I read him. Right now uncertain of him. Eywa I've called scum all day yesterday. People felt her town because town meta. But very easy to fake meta. Still think that their play is scummy. On August 01 2019 20:41 Branch.AUT wrote: Voting Everysince On August 01 2019 20:51 Branch.AUT wrote: I'm hesitant to call out three people in connection. It is no how I approach this game. I'll try anyway because youve asked me too My strongest scumreads are MZ/Pandain. Both sheeped Slam during lynches, except when Slam changed his vote close to deadline. Both post constructive just enough to not be supiciously inactive, but way too little to actually catch mafia. Eywa/ES im less sure of, Eywa because HF went all out defending them on meta reason. ES mostly posts prior to deadline and willingly gives her vote to anyone interacting, except when I pushed to lynch Eywa. Could see ES+Eywa together mafia. I consider any combination of these four possible. This dude is literally just throwing names at a wall to see which one sticks. He mentions his is "uncertain leaning scum" on Eversince prior to his vote and then proceeds to call Pandain his strongest scum read... who he was uncertain of 4 hours prior. What changed in between those? The hydra made this post: On August 01 2019 19:34 NoSmurfHere wrote: MZ and pandain are both the same in this game. There's posts they have made that are scummy, but also some posts that seem good. Both have just enough activity not to be suspicious (not the case with eversince). I didn't actually think MZ's case on you was full of holes. That doesn't make him more or less likely to be town though imo. I think he has looked like he's hiding in plain sight the whole time. The case he made on you was contributing new stuff to the thread. The problem I have with it isn't that it was full of holes, but that you were an easy target. I'm going to filter MZ now, then ES for more detailed analysis. -J So now that the hydra is questioning Pandain and myself, we become Branch's strongest scumreads. It's all a matter of convenience and ending up where the most votes are. And what ever happened to the Eywa scumread from yesterday? Gone with the wind apparently. But regardless of these points, where is Branch's vote? It's on eversince. Rather than push his "strongest scum reads." But Hydra, Eversince, and Pandain, I need you guys to read this over and seriously think about the lynches you are pushing. Look at Branch. This dude is literally looking for the most opportune lynch to park his vote on and ride out the day. I honestly can't say I've read eversince that closely but I will not be on the same wagon as Branch at lylo. | ||
|
Meapak_Ziphh
United States6786 Posts
I don't like the post from eversince that you quoted but I could see how it could come from someone who replaced in as town. Look at who immediately jumped on the eversince lynch with you. | ||
|
Branch.AUT
Austria853 Posts
Good setup, decent executtion. Doomed to fail. Saw this push coming on day 2. Looking forward to your scum buddies piling onto it. | ||
| ||
