Yep, was odd. I still thought he was pretty town at that point if I'm remember right though. I just understood it as 'game is confusing' not a scum claim

. How anyone got 'scumslip' from that comment seems like misconstruing reflecting on it now..

Eversince

Philippines2303 Posts

July 30 2019 06:48 GMT

#1516

Oops you are right!! How embarrassing! I just counted up base names but that excluded both Branch and myself xD! How did I do this for days.. I should sleep more.

Eversince

Philippines2303 Posts

July 30 2019 17:57 GMT

#1619

What HF is saying is Eywa is playing remarkably close to his last town game (only one I have seen). General pain in the butt to work with, doesn't explain things well (or at all), ego in the clouds, none of these make him mafia when you realize he did this exact same thing as town.. You trying to spin it as m!Eywa when you won't even do the groundwork study makes you questionable.

Eversince

Philippines2303 Posts

July 30 2019 18:01 GMT

#1623

@ Eywa

Wasn't meant to say you were wrong

! Just the way you go about interacting people makes most people scrunch eyebrows :/.. My point was more: unless there is active mafia agenda to how you are acting (which a little bit of skimming shows it's NAI at best) means it's a dumpster reason to read you mafia for it.

Eversince

Philippines2303 Posts

July 30 2019 18:02 GMT

#1624

Which best I can tell "lynch the '?' instead of actively scummy player" is just terrible.

Eversince

Philippines2303 Posts

July 30 2019 18:07 GMT

#1630

@ Jock

Between Koshi and FF. I'm still deciding.

Koshi is my easy choice. I could vote for FF too though. His play today when I tried to interact with him especially made me really go from waffle to a 'why the hell would town play this way?' So bleh, took me long enough, he's got a good chance of flipping mafia to imo.

Eversince

Philippines2303 Posts

July 30 2019 18:10 GMT

#1634

@ Branch

Did you miss the multiple times I've listed why I m!Koshi? Miss the whole end of D2 where Pandain/myself pushed for a switch to Koshi over Chezinu? Or are you just trying to cast shadows on me?

Eversince

Philippines2303 Posts

July 30 2019 18:11 GMT

#1636

You can find them. My filter is remarkably short (darn life and it's responsibilities!)

Eversince

Philippines2303 Posts

July 30 2019 18:13 GMT

#1638

Agree Eywa push is trash. Happens that all my scum reads are on it is enough reason for me to never vote there :p!

Eversince

Philippines2303 Posts

July 30 2019 18:18 GMT

#1646

And I'm saying Eywa played this same way as town so I see it as more NAI. I won't support people being a pain but being a pain doesn't make you mafia by itself. If I'd never seen Eywa play before I might be swayed here..

Eversince

Philippines2303 Posts

July 30 2019 18:23 GMT

#1649

You're giving Koshi/FF pass based on volume of post then?

Eversince

Philippines2303 Posts

July 30 2019 18:24 GMT

#1653

On July 31 2019 03:23 Branch.AUT wrote:

Show nested quote +

I have never seen her play before, so forgive me if I'm not convinced. The way I see it rolling scum is an excellent occasion to use your established meta to backstab everyone.

Then you policy lynch Eywa every game?? Your not lynching Eywa because they are mafia then it's because you don't like how he plays?

Eversince

Philippines2303 Posts

July 30 2019 18:32 GMT

#1660

Okok, I think I'll vote FF. All my scum reads are on Eywa, so I don't really care between Koshi/FF.. I'll switch to consolidate to save Eywa if stupid shenanigans happen.

##vote: FecalFeast

Eversince

Philippines2303 Posts

July 30 2019 18:42 GMT

#1669

@ FF

#1667 translates to "I don't care about this game enough to play when I can. Now that I'm dying for it, I can't even play!!"

And you wonder why you are mafia read by people? When you've been like this for a while now?

Eversince

Philippines2303 Posts

July 30 2019 18:45 GMT

#1672

@ FF

Starts on Pg 9 of NSH filter.

Eversince

Philippines2303 Posts

July 30 2019 18:55 GMT

#1679

@ FF how is paraphrasing your conversations on how you/ partner develop your reads dirty? It's the same as me posting my reasoning for how I develop reads but with hydra you have two and of course town wants the logic on how you as a pair come to decisions.

Eversince

Philippines2303 Posts

July 30 2019 18:58 GMT

#1686

Fair. I don't agree with you in this case but you are entitled to your opinion :p..

Eversince

Philippines2303 Posts

July 30 2019 19:40 GMT

#1720

..why?

Eversince

Philippines2303 Posts

July 30 2019 19:44 GMT

#1728

-shrugs- The closest thing I've done to 'lurking' in this game is like right now, I'm bored with no input so I'll do something else and just check in on thread. I obviously respond to things when I think it's needed and I can