Cupid's Arrow Mafia - Page 4

On July 24 2019 02:38 NoSmurfHere wrote:
Immediate gut reactions:

Don't like koshi's first post. No redeeming features of that one.

Don't like the way hf misunderstands the day post and then uses his own misunderstanding as evidence that he is town. Although rayn is right that it would be convoluted for mafia hf to do that, I wouldn't put convoluted out of hf's range.

Vivax - nothingburger

Coagulation - Scumclaims suck dude.

FF - dunno

Eywa - Very quick to scumread rayn but I wouldn't say that's impossible for town eywa.

rayn - waiting to see on this one.

Leaving now, won't be back until later tonight. Might have a chance to post something more fleshed out then.


Despite what I said about rayn wanting to lynch us, I think in a game this size lynching a lurker would be a good move.

J

On July 25 2019 00:21 Tubesock wrote:
Meap



This was 21 hours ago. So, basically first half of the cycle. This is after he said no reads posts until deliberating with Bugs.

This entire post is fluff. Did anyone like Koshi's first post? I doubt anyone say any redeeming value in it either. You can say that about almost everyone in the game for most games. So that's a nothingburger.

He didn't like how HF tried to dumbclaim his way to town, but then eosn't arrive anywhere with it. It's convoluted for mafia but in HF's mafia range. Ok, that's a nothingburger statement too.

Vivax - nothingburger, well he said it best. Saying V is a nothingburger leaves the rest of us with nothing. It would have at least said something if Jock then said Vivax being a nothingburger is most likely mafia. That would be substantial, and useful for town.

Coag - of course scumclaims suck. He got heat for it immediately too. So this is a useless comment from town.

FF - dunno. More nothingburger. Why not have a line about Chezinu and Alakaslam? They both are most likely similiar as in complete tossups. Why include FF? Feels like it's easier to later throw shade on FF than succomb to the law of Brown or Chupazi.

Eywa - quickly scumreading someone isn't scummy. But apparently it is for Jock, so why isn't HF scumread too?

rayn - he just finished a shitfight and has no read??? From the tone I would think he would scumread him. That isn't neccessarily scummy, but yet another player listed with zero information for town.

This entire post is fluffy fluff. What is the purpose of it? To give town his reactions? How did any of them help town?

On July 25 2019 00:04 Eywa- wrote:

I agree with all of your points and none of those make him scum. I think Rayn started the game very opportunistically, then transitioned to a lot more of a defensive game. Yes, some of that is reaction to pressure being applied to him, but this is his scum game, I'm very confident.

Also, if I'm drinking as town, I'm more likely to rant (incoherently) about people not voting for my target than I am to just come in to say "fuck you" repeatedly in as many posts as possible.

On July 25 2019 01:54 NoSmurfHere wrote:
Man I can’t believe I’m actually saying this but Koshi has been making a lot of sense in the past page or so.

The best two choices we have for lynch today are rayn and MZ. Personally I’m not accepting any others, as I honestly don’t have much reason to suspect anyone else yet and I don’t really have that many town reads either. I prefer killing rayn over MZ:

I find MZ scummy but I waffle on him because last game he did similar things, where he didn’t provide many reads or vote at all until very late, and was wishy washy throughout. Also, he seems to defend me & jock based on believing the reasoning for voting us is bad and partly rayn drunk posting but then tries to get tube to explain why we’re scum. If MZ is actually town and legitimately believes we’re town then I could see him potentially trying to just shore up his read here but it comes off as extremely passive & non-committal.

Jock I think felt more confident on MZ being scum than I did but now is backtracking (?) a bit. I’ll let him comment with his own thoughts if he wants to.

I’m off to bed and won’t be back for another 9-12 hours or so.

-wherebugsgo

On July 25 2019 02:49 Alakaslam wrote:
From the look of things we lose Rayn.

Not good. He is a strong player.


Rayn when you return please just make cases in last bit don’t waste too much time on defense. There comes a point where people won’t change their minds, period.

Anyway, so people can make associations later:

My reason for believing Rayn to be town are mostly on meta. The case against him is basically that he is anti town because he is able to get angry. And not understand sarcasm. Basically.

Bad case. My reasons for scumreading the smurf is trying to shut me down, and a few other things but those are wifom. Not enough to vote on.

I vote him to save Rayn.

On July 25 2019 07:17 Fecalfeast wrote:

Read the op

What the fuck is with you claiming to be some golden mafia god with a 90% winrate because you lynch scum d1?

On July 24 2019 23:21 Alakaslam wrote:
Eywa-

Will you call someone bad for being town if you Lynch them?

On July 25 2019 07:41 Alakaslam wrote:

There it is. Holy shit prophet of CHUPAZI the great Alakaslam called it again

OK good luck without me Eywa-

Anyway, to the rest of the town, next time we need to be semi critical thinkers and use all of the tools at our disposal. There was no case here. You folks went along with something pretty foolish.

Not everyone of course.

Not happy to see the brown inactive

On July 25 2019 07:41 Alakaslam wrote:

There it is. Holy shit prophet of CHUPAZI the great Alakaslam called it again

OK good luck without me Eywa-

Anyway, to the rest of the town, next time we need to be semi critical thinkers and use all of the tools at our disposal. There was no case here. You folks went along with something pretty foolish.

Not everyone of course.

Not happy to see the brown inactive

On July 25 2019 08:11 NoSmurfHere wrote:


Where do you stand now that rayn flipped town?

In particular how do you read slam, MZ, and Pandain?

-wherebugsgo

On July 25 2019 08:15 Eywa- wrote:

I think Alakaslam and FecalFeast Holier than thou attitude is pretty bad, I could see one or both being scum.

Still scum on MZ FecalFeast having a strong read and not pushing it could be a scum team.