[M][N] A Simple Game of Mafia - Page 8

On December 14 2017 06:21 darthfoley wrote:


Here's where I am: confused.

Ignoring your alignment for a second, I'm not sure why there wasn't a legitimate counter wagon against Oats. He was a strong role.

I look to either Koshi or HF. Both of them are strong willed enough to try and push a Conversion lynch down town's throats if they're mafia with Oats. They also have an ally in me who has shown some flashes of being able to sway lynches in the past. Neither of them try. Koshi especially seems content just sitting back.

Their play doesn't make sense from mafia POV.

The only strong willed player who seemingly tried to divert any attention away from Oats was Palmar with his case on Forumite. It wasn't a bad case, but mafia!Palmar can make good cases.

I think Oats/Palmar/+1 bandwagoner or off wagon makes sense. There is a world where you and Oats are both mafia and mafia are just kinda fucked altogether, but I think the first scenario I laid out is more likely.

On December 14 2017 06:33 prplhz wrote:

I think it's not as clear as you say in your big post. The conversion lynch was pushed hard but never gained traction. So I don't think it makes sense to say scum could have gone for him instead. Same about Forumite. I think this lynch just kind of happened and no one really knows why.

I feel like the game is not just following Joshis list.

On December 13 2017 19:16 Koshi wrote:

It's posts like this that makes me pause.
If you read all Oats post knowing Oats has the answers to the game. He is saying here Palmar is mafia. Just like the following posts:

On December 13 2017 19:47 Koshi wrote:

Obviously my Palmar town read was a bit tongue in cheeck. Oats reacting on it in capslock makes me think he has the answers to this game already.

It's super thin so I dont put too much weight in it. But the capslock "THIS IS A NONSENSE READ" was a bit too serious too fast.

On December 14 2017 09:52 Conversion wrote:
I also remember you calling me mafia for the entirety of day 1

On December 14 2017 21:33 Eversince wrote:


I never did scum read Oats over you. I only ever said he was 'bleh' and that was what Oats could be either way (Of he's un-involved............. He's un-involved. Period.)

On December 14 2017 21:48 Eversince wrote:
This night hasn't developed into anything. It's developed into a claim game of 'what bullshit can I get away with'.
I've been around over two years now. I don't play much here but this night is typical 'TL stuff that I will continue to ignore'

On December 14 2017 21:56 Eversince wrote:
Why, if I or Koshi, or DF, not push on you if we are mafia and you are town? You are basically claiming we either are mafia with you're, or that mafia just let their RB get lynched for no reason.

On December 14 2017 22:06 Eversince wrote:
You look bad, Palmar looks bad, Grack looks bad, A bunch of lower volume guys look iffy (I know I can't really complain right? xd!) I think Koshi, DF, VE look alright and I'll have to do a lot of filter diving tomorrow. I should have some free time tomorrow because it's one of my shorter shifts. But that still won't be until after very late for most people.

No one put a ton of pressure on Oats though. So it's hard to put lines between lines of 'this person defending Oats' vs 'this person calling Oats on one liners everywhere and nothing else'. Oats's done that plenty of times to make this flip really problematic for me and I haven't had the time to process much...

On December 15 2017 00:02 Palmar wrote:
also I'm sure koshi the medic will protect me.