|
On November 02 2017 06:35 ruXxar wrote:Show nested quote +On November 02 2017 06:14 Oatsmaster wrote:
But you disagree with the assessment that your post is swinging back and forth between calling damerion townie and scummy? Cause it looks like you totally meant that and that darth analysed it correctly.
1) damerion's posting is scummy
2) damerion's posting is townie
3) it might be either I DUNNO?!?!
That's literally what darth said. And you clearly agree with it. So how does that make darth overanalysing every little thing?? Because it was obvious he was looking for reasons to call me scum, and not trying to objectively evaluate why I said what I did. He was looking for plausible cause to push his scum read.
No, no, tell me how darth's analysis is wrong because it seems like he got it on the nose.
Am I scum too? Cause I agree with what he said.
|
On November 02 2017 06:36 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On November 02 2017 06:34 darthfoley wrote:On November 02 2017 06:33 Holyflare wrote:
Is zen guy new? Way too much of a wall of text for a new mafia to make. That's actually exactly what I would expect a new mafia to do Well you have bad expectations then?
More liek good expectations amirite
|
You are a strange strange man
|
On November 02 2017 06:39 Oatsmaster wrote:Show nested quote +On November 02 2017 06:35 ruXxar wrote:On November 02 2017 06:14 Oatsmaster wrote:
But you disagree with the assessment that your post is swinging back and forth between calling damerion townie and scummy? Cause it looks like you totally meant that and that darth analysed it correctly.
1) damerion's posting is scummy
2) damerion's posting is townie
3) it might be either I DUNNO?!?!
That's literally what darth said. And you clearly agree with it. So how does that make darth overanalysing every little thing?? Because it was obvious he was looking for reasons to call me scum, and not trying to objectively evaluate why I said what I did. He was looking for plausible cause to push his scum read. No, no, tell me how darth's analysis is wrong because it seems like he got it on the nose. Am I scum too? Cause I agree with what he said.
|
Ooo I changed my mind, the horror?!?
|
On November 02 2017 07:03 Conversion wrote:
someone explain to me why shockey is bad town instead of scum for his leaps in logic and deflecting shit back onto me because I'm not seeing it and he should be lynched because he is scum
I don't see any leaps in logic from him, point it out. Also, you might be slightly biased
|
On November 02 2017 07:08 Conversion wrote:Show nested quote +On November 02 2017 07:07 Oatsmaster wrote:On November 02 2017 07:03 Conversion wrote:
someone explain to me why shockey is bad town instead of scum for his leaps in logic and deflecting shit back onto me because I'm not seeing it and he should be lynched because he is scum I don't see any leaps in logic from him, point it out. Also, you might be slightly biased I can pull out quotes if you want, but he literally bases half of his scum read on me because I tried to form a wagon on him with Damerion. He refuses to answer me on why I would be scum with Damerion and make such a shitty play early in telling Damerion his play is bad or feels weird. Also Damerion actually never voted on him, so I wasn't "forming a wagon" on him a lot of the crap before it was just semantics that he and I couldn't see eye to eye on, but he constantly dodges that question when he has no reason to as town
I want quotes.
|
No I want his quotes and how they are leaps of logic. Being wrong =/= a leap of logic
|
Technically if you want to call that a Dodge, you have dodged plenty of times yourself
|
On November 01 2017 09:33 Conversion wrote:but you know what you're right. why do I care so much I  bye bye
|
On November 02 2017 07:33 Conversion wrote:Show nested quote +On November 02 2017 07:22 Oatsmaster wrote:
No I want his quotes and how they are leaps of logic. Being wrong =/= a leap of logic ? what is a leap of logic to you. he cane to the wrong conclusion with wrong information and tried to piece together something to call me scum. this is pedantic
You said that him calling damerion and yourself the only ones on his bandwagon was a leap of logic.
It isn't. It's him being wrong.
|
On November 02 2017 07:31 Conversion wrote:
what have I dodged? I’ll answer it immediately here. no one asked me anything, I called myself out for being a shitty player early on, and all of you are just telling me to believe this guy is town but are not convincing me. I’m not moving my vote
That's just generally not good play to tunnel one person
|
On November 02 2017 07:50 Conversion wrote:
and I don’t have to answer you bc you don’t care if this guy dodges me so yeah I’ll dodge your pedantic questions
Yeah I don't really think his "dodging" is any more alignment significant as your "dodging".
Whatever dude, you need more than one vote to lynch someone
|
On November 02 2017 08:57 Tictock wrote:Show nested quote +On November 02 2017 03:57 Oatsmaster wrote:On November 01 2017 11:06 Tictock wrote:
Screw it I guess I'll sheep Damer for now, all of Shockey's posts are terrible.
##Vote ShoCkeyy Like what is this post? If all of shockey's posts are terrible, why does he preface it with saying that he will sheep damer If you look I think you can tell I wanted to build pressure on Shokey. Good way to do that is point out that others wanted him dead. Wasn't too impressed by his reaction and nothing from him has stood out to me since. Dude may well be scum.
What's with the last line? You clearly think he's your top scum read but you act like it's only kinda likely that he's mafia rather than super likely
|
On November 02 2017 08:58 ruXxar wrote:Show nested quote +On November 02 2017 08:31 Holyflare wrote:
Ticktock I feel like he comes into the game to make comments that aren't particularly difficult and sounds arbitrary and made up and then he leaves again after "contributing". It feels very artificial to me and I have no idea why so many people say they like it. Despite the unorthodox running commentary style, I like the content and reasoning behind his reads. It’s very down to earth and logical. Maybe if I looked hard enough for a reason to call him scum I would call it cookie cutter reads? That a bit of a stretch though. He just seems like your regular plain straight up and down average vanilla townie.
HF you wanna lynch this dude?
|
On November 02 2017 08:43 Tictock wrote:
At pg 20 now.
DF and Oats were bickering incessantly last night but now I see DF saying he has mindmelded with Oats over their reads. Feels like a rather quick and convenient turn around to me.
Part of me wants to call BS on the whole argument they had and say it was actually a forced SvS fight, but that is probably far fetched. More likely is a Scum DF buddying Oats.
I actually like Oats calling out my HF read, it is kinda a mixed bag. I was too leinant with HF last time I played and left him slip by as scum when he pretended to be forced to speak Russian. Here I feel like his push on Conv was off when he was pushing Conv for his scum read on Damer when HF himself was voting Damer. Someone mentioned HF and Damer had a history last game though so idk how serious HF's opening vote was.
Also yea Damdred is being pretty lackluster since the game got going.
So Oats more likely Town than DF I think.
Why is it off?
Do you think that HF concocted a reason to push conversion or do you think that holyflare found something odd about why conversion thought that damerion was mafia?
|
On November 02 2017 11:11 Tictock wrote:Show nested quote +On November 02 2017 10:18 Oatsmaster wrote:On November 02 2017 08:43 Tictock wrote:
At pg 20 now.
DF and Oats were bickering incessantly last night but now I see DF saying he has mindmelded with Oats over their reads. Feels like a rather quick and convenient turn around to me.
Part of me wants to call BS on the whole argument they had and say it was actually a forced SvS fight, but that is probably far fetched. More likely is a Scum DF buddying Oats.
I actually like Oats calling out my HF read, it is kinda a mixed bag. I was too leinant with HF last time I played and left him slip by as scum when he pretended to be forced to speak Russian. Here I feel like his push on Conv was off when he was pushing Conv for his scum read on Damer when HF himself was voting Damer. Someone mentioned HF and Damer had a history last game though so idk how serious HF's opening vote was.
Also yea Damdred is being pretty lackluster since the game got going.
So Oats more likely Town than DF I think. Why is it off? Do you think that HF concocted a reason to push conversion or do you think that holyflare found something odd about why conversion thought that damerion was mafia? I think it is off that HF dropped a vote on Damer with no explanation then pushed Conv for also thinking Damer is scum. Like the post HF made above was the first time I've seen him actually give a reason for his vote. Thinking about it now it doesn't seem terribly in line for a scum!flare to attack a town!conv for having the same read if his goal is to get Damer lynched. Still though I see HF sitting on this Damer vote while attacking Conv and myself without really trying to push any of us very hard. Just a lot of what HF is doing this game doesn't add up to me. As for my read on Shokey, I'd give it a 70% chance he is scum. I'm actually debating if I want to switch to DF ATM kus I feel like he is being very opportunistic and is trying to buddy you. I'm also noting that you have basically ignored DF since you two got into it the other night. Right now I'm thankful this game isn't going too fast and I have actually had a chance to keep up. I'm gunna read DF's filter tonight and decide who I prefer between him and Shokey. I may do a list post sometime too, Right now I know both Vivax and Zen dude posted but we're completely forgettable. I think Bre is the only person to have not posted yet at this point?
Did you even read what HF and conversion posted?
Conversion straight up was totally wrong in his push. It's not as simple as HF attacked someone who pushed hf's scumread. Go and read that then come back to talk to me.
Yeah df seems pretty fine to me imo. I like being buddied.
What's your read on rux? Why haven't you talked about him even though he's pretty much hard defended you like he knows your alignment.
|
On November 02 2017 11:14 Tictock wrote:
Oh and about HF's push on Conv, I didn't agree that Conv's read on Damer was scummy. So HF's scum read on Conv just seems out of left field to me.
Go and read it again, conv posted a quote from Damerion's town game and said that he is playing similarly therefore he's scum this game.
|
Like it's facts, not opinion about what conv did
|
Meh like shockey's is lynchbait for sure
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
