No. The fact is Rels was making a factually incorrect statement he should know is one, and couldn't explain that reasonably. Instead he is trying to defend the statement.

This is the post in question right?:

On June 17 2017 08:08 Rels wrote:

Show nested quote +

wow that makes Eversince town. My big quote was about annul. So to those thinking ES was faking entering the thread (and Ithought that too befor ethat post), is she faked that she wouldn't mess up the names there. That means the entering the thread was innocent at the very least.

Which he followed within the same minute:

On June 17 2017 08:08 Rels wrote:
well that probably doesn't make her town. but that makes her not faking entering the thread

Or am I just not on the same page as to what that is about? Because I was thinking this is what that is about.

Eversince

Philippines2301 Posts

June 21 2017 00:03 GMT

#3772

I can understand your logic. Assuming he thinks I'm not lying about entering at best I should be knocked down to null at best?
But isn't that what he did? I don't recall him ever outright calling me town.

Eversince

Philippines2301 Posts

June 21 2017 00:20 GMT

#3776

That makes sense. I guess I'm failing to see the reason why he would bother doing it as mafia though.

Eversince

Philippines2301 Posts

June 21 2017 00:29 GMT

#3778

Oh, I can be daft sometimes. Now that I think about it, I don't think he's given any reasons for thinking I'm town... Thread sentiment seems to be largely either I need shot or lynched.

Eversince

Philippines2301 Posts

June 21 2017 01:16 GMT

#3780

@Rayn-
1)

On June 20 2017 06:53 Eversince wrote:
Nah, I like Grack over Rels.

@Rayn- Just read their filters back to back. They peddle around, cast doubt about, but never actually push on each other, and come lynch time it's luck that they got my random vote. But I'm pretty sure TW is mafia and he could of swung. or if BTDT is mafia he could of swung. Neither needed to because I randomed my vote and it landed on town. Just go through their D1, because I'd make a huge mess if I tried to make a large analysis post on 4 separate players.

I will try to put together a post on it later tonight since I have the time.
There's only one out of that group that has given me any reason to doubt he fits. But only because of some very wifom stuff.

2) If I didn't call in sick tonight I would have been asleep until 3 hrs ago. at work 2 hours ago, and would not have been home again until basically deadline tomorrow. I'm already on everyone's "?/scum" pile. I'm kind of surprised mafia hasn't tried to get me mislynched yet. But this wasn't my original plan for today. Since I'm around though, I'm going to try be useful instead.

Eversince

Philippines2301 Posts

June 21 2017 03:42 GMT

#3784

Grack why did you push Annul over Xata?

Eversince

Philippines2301 Posts

June 21 2017 03:42 GMT

#3785

From that time, what was your thought process that lead up to the Annul choice more than Xata?

Eversince

Philippines2301 Posts

June 21 2017 03:54 GMT

#3788

That's cutting corners.

On June 16 2017 07:30 Grackaroni wrote:
Xatalos was pretty meh. I legitimately don't think he has been any more meh than disfo. The one scum game I remember from him he played a very aggressive style.

You thought Disfo's filter was worse than his. Seemed more like you gave him a pass based on "not matching his meta" than a "looked pretty bad" Considering you basically lynched Annul for being tunneled?

Eversince

Philippines2301 Posts

June 21 2017 03:55 GMT

#3790

Also it's fair to say that Disfo had already set a standard that would be hard to play at so how was Xata looking better than him?

Eversince

Philippines2301 Posts

June 21 2017 04:02 GMT

#3792

On June 21 2017 12:46 Grackaroni wrote:

Show nested quote +

I thought Xata's filter looked pretty bad but not so bad that he would get undue attention compared to some other people. I didn't like that Annul was so confident in his Koshi push because it seemed like he was still pushing Koshi from things that happened earlier in the game rather than considering the additional 10 pages or w/e of Koshi posts that happened after he talked about his read.

Wait wait though, didn't you just post a scum read on VA for something VA did at EOD an entire night cycle and half a day ago? And if you didn't really think either would flip mafia why vote for either then? If you didn't think mafia was in it you should of voted on HF. That's the bigger thing here. You voted on Annul for being tunneled you say then that Xata isn't playing his scum meta, now his filter looked bad but not for the amount of attention that he got. HF you're only scum read that got more than a "meh" labeling out of you was ignored? Why?

Eversince

Philippines2301 Posts

June 21 2017 04:04 GMT

#3794

On June 21 2017 13:04 Grackaroni wrote:

Show nested quote +

Koshi posted lots of things since then and Vayne hasn't?

I don't see the point in throwing away my vote when HF wasn't going to be lynched.

You're not throwing away your vote if you don't think either is mafia. You're simply not lynching town.

Eversince

Philippines2301 Posts

June 21 2017 04:09 GMT

#3796

Ok, changing gears, what else other than Annul's 1 read made him worse than Xata's "pretty bad filter"?

Eversince

Philippines2301 Posts

June 21 2017 04:18 GMT

#3798

If a dirty filter can outweighed by one bad/tunnel read. You're either mafia or anti town.
You're boring

Eversince

Philippines2301 Posts

June 21 2017 04:36 GMT

#3800

On June 21 2017 13:22 Grackaroni wrote:
It's not a matter of one bad tunnel. His whole focus was two tunnels (Koshi/RuXxar) based on early game things that made it look like he wasn't weighing new information.

Then why didn't you clarify this like way sooner? Because now you've had 100+ hrs to come up for a reason on it

Eversince

Philippines2301 Posts

June 21 2017 04:50 GMT

#3803

Not really, I'm just trying to fit the vast chasms in your filter with whatever your actual thoughts were at the time. Then I take that and weigh out if I believe you or not. Not surprisingly your total disinterest in actually talking to me tells me you'll just say whatever because you either deemed me worthless ally if your town, or an easier target for your mates to paint later.

Eversince

Philippines2301 Posts

June 21 2017 06:35 GMT

#3808

On June 21 2017 15:31 Tumblewood wrote:

Show nested quote +

specifically this post is very relatable and something i've never seen scum try to fake. of course they might be able to but i don't think it's the kind of thing scum thinks of organically

psst, It was Rux's case and he already did.