5. This game follows a simple lynch. If a player has the majority of votes on him dies. If there is a tie The person who reached the tying vote first is lynched.

Reads like plurality to me.

sicklucker

Canada16987 Posts

June 06 2017 23:17 GMT

#69

/in

Onegu

United States9699 Posts

June 07 2017 00:23 GMT

#70

We are up to 20 players. Lets get 5 more at least. There are alot of you that haven't signed up yet. You know who you are!

raynpelikoneet

Finland43270 Posts

June 07 2017 01:22 GMT

#71

If Blazinghand joins i know what i will do D1.

Fidei86

United Kingdom2116 Posts

June 07 2017 09:32 GMT

#72

/obs

I promised myself after that 18 man game Onegu ran a few years ago where Kita endgamed us all that I'd never play another game with more than 13 people.

disformation

Germany8352 Posts

June 07 2017 10:27 GMT

#73

if i get rngesus'ed d1 again imma be mad salty

Onegu

United States9699 Posts

June 07 2017 11:58 GMT

#74

On June 07 2017 18:32 Fidei86 wrote:
/obs

I promised myself after that 18 man game Onegu ran a few years ago where Kita endgamed us all that I'd never play another game with more than 13 people.

That was themed, big difference

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

June 07 2017 13:01 GMT

#75

If this is a closed standard setup. I am going to suggest some things. Cuz I can. And shall.

- Count out the game but favor the town numbers a bit by adding extra vanilla's. And then modkill for inactivity till the end of N2.
- Make roles soft. Parity cop/tracker/watcher over cop. Vengeful/mad bomber over Vigi, or vigis that only shoot on even nights. Jailkeepers over docs if kp isn't delivered, otherwise docs over jailers.
- Fuck up "you-are-now-confirmed-town" night actions. Add unaware millers, add protective roles on mafia team (maybe jailer over rb, or just add a doc), give a framer/gf to the mafia team.
- If there are many blue roles, punish claiming by giving mafia an extra kp that only shoots blues, but only hits if that person claimed a blue role and is actually a blue role. It's a bit of a "dirty" role but should work. Claiming any blue role should make you eligible to get shot, but you only die if you are actually blue.
- Mafia kp should start high and end low. Town kp should be 2 each cycle on average.

Things I personally like but aren't standard:
- Never modkill a person with +3 pages of content and who was active for 2 cycles. Even if he is mia for 4 cycles.
- Do something during D3 to spike activity again. It should be known beforehand so there is no backseat modding ofc. Like mayor elections with double lynch or something. Dnu what.
- Assassins are stupid. SK and survivors are fine.
- Somehow force people to type 60 posts within the first 2 cycles.

Blue roles bring so much problems with them but at the same time are so much fun. A cop that can't say he is a cop is awesome, a cop that claims a redcheck D2 is boring as fuck.
Mafia setting up a misslynch is awesome, all your misslynches claiming blue and being prior 1 nk targets is boring as fuck.
Lynching mafia d1 is awesome, each mafia role being critical for the mafia team is boring as fuck. (what I mean is that if mafia team loses the rb d1, it shouldn't be devastating, the game shouldn't end by a claiming cop with a unknown doc in his ass directing all lynches. Same for the framer, if the framer dies it shouldn't mean that now every check is correct. Just that mafia does not have the ability to mess with the checks actively. Only a 2 shot vigi or something like that should be a "devastating" loss. But that can be salvaged with the remaining mafia members playing better.

EDIT: Same with masons for example. Great and awesome role as long as the 2 fuckers can't say they are masoned ever. When they become innocent child after the other mason died, or simply are confirmed as soon as they claim it is the most boring shit role.

EDIT PS: I am not angry.

beentheredonethat

2934 Posts

June 07 2017 13:22 GMT

#76

/in

raynpelikoneet

Finland43270 Posts

June 07 2017 21:07 GMT

#77

Watcher is an OP and dumb role. And survivor is retarded, just as retarded as jester.

Rels

France13467 Posts

June 07 2017 22:51 GMT

#78

On June 08 2017 06:07 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Watcher is an OP and dumb role. And survivor is retarded, just as retarded as jester.

Agree. I've come to think that the only good 3P role are roles that make their player to their own thing and don't disturb the outside town / mafia game too much. So an objective that don't interact with town / scum wincon; when the 3P win they leave the game instantly and the game continues normally for town / scum; and they lose if town or scum wins before the 3P manage to achieve their objective.

Rels

France13467 Posts

June 07 2017 22:56 GMT

#79

On the other hand on the Koshi post I love several things. An event mid-game when it's usually the point where people start becoming super inactive (IE after the first two days but before LYLO / LYLO-1). No 100% conf possible. No game decided by mechanics instead of talking. High KPs for both sides at the start of the game. All of this is good shit

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

June 07 2017 23:41 GMT

#80

On June 08 2017 06:07 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Watcher is an OP and dumb role. And survivor is retarded, just as retarded as jester.

Watcher is fine if kp isn't delivered.
Survivor is fine as well.
Assassasins that are veterans or bulletproof are the true cancer.

But I am fine playing w.e setup really.