notes after reading like 10 pages:
i like ever's case on pg 101. so df and rux are 98% town
ruxxar continues to be weird and inane - fundamentally not getting the power dynamic. [ACTUALLY his later stuff is solid vote analysis]
i like that one rels post on pg 106
sl is insane town. egotistic in an sl sort of way

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

June 17 2017 18:16 GMT

#2370

OOHHHHHHHH that's why everyone is voting xata

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

June 18 2017 05:45 GMT

#2546

no way am i believing for a second cop has a redcheck on disfo. and even if he does, no cop ever has been this concerned about unaware millers

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

June 20 2017 05:20 GMT

#3201

definite PoE game on our hands

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

June 20 2017 05:23 GMT

#3202

oh dear i have eliminated much less than i thought. fuck, i was hoping to coast this game, but now i have to sift through like 10 names

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

June 21 2017 06:29 GMT

#3806

i was just about to come back with a sick case on grack + Show Spoiler +

that may or may not have been a rehash of disfo's case

but grack's last page is making me feel he's actually town

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

June 21 2017 06:31 GMT

#3807

On June 21 2017 13:43 Grackaroni wrote:
Every question seems like a loaded gotcha question rather than something that could possibly help you figure out my alignment.

If you're trying to find some inconsistency so that you will look better after voting me, you're just going to look worse after I flip.

specifically this post is very relatable and something i've never seen scum try to fake. of course they might be able to but i don't think it's the kind of thing scum thinks of organically

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

June 21 2017 06:43 GMT

#3811

i think i'm giving that way too much weight actually. because either grack is scum, fefe is scum, i know even less than i thought i knew, or the annul wagon is pure sans xatalos. and the last one i don't believe for a second.
gonna filter fefe and weigh the possibilities

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

June 21 2017 06:45 GMT

#3812

On June 21 2017 15:39 Eversince wrote:
Specifically he goes from Votes on Annul for Koshi tunnel.
Changes that to include Rux tunnel. Koshi had posted 10 pg filter lala.

He's also now scum reading Disfo in the exact same fashion. EoD read says Disfo is mafia despite the fact Disfo has a ton of post since then but he's not going to read them. Using Grack's own logic we should lynch him just for that.

oh hey
i have not read enough of this game for that to make sense. what does Votes on Annul for Koshi tunnel mean?

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

June 21 2017 06:54 GMT

#3816

what i'm thinking is — this is subjective, but the annul wagon was shit. shit wagons form of course but usually they stay limited to tunneled/bad players. but for annul to die despite not having an amazing case on him (or her? idk) and not being a complete afk i think there has to be scum involved. and fefe is the only early voter i think at all is scum, but there was little actual pushing of anything from fefe himself. and rels had a legit push but was kinda late and otherwise has a super townie filter. so that just leaves grack, as the tying vote.
tl;dr — like ??? it's either grack or fefe or nothing makes sense. but already nothing makes sense

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

June 21 2017 07:02 GMT

#3819

On June 21 2017 16:01 Eversince wrote:

Show nested quote +

You do realize that if you sit on Xata being the only mafia on Annul both Xata's and Annul's trains where almost entirely town driven. Which puts all the other scum as off wagon/ modkills right?

yeah. i said that i don't think that's the case. no way that annul wagon is pure

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

June 21 2017 07:03 GMT

#3820

On June 21 2017 15:57 Grackaroni wrote:
Tumble do you still dislike Rayn?

tbh i've seen like 10 posts from him since i said i disliked him. not particularly bad posts, mind you. how about i filter him now and then telll you

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

June 21 2017 07:14 GMT

#3823

On June 21 2017 16:04 Grackaroni wrote:

Show nested quote +

He was in a big Rels shit fight recently.

ah yes, i see that now. it seems like the rayn thing to do. my opinion on this varies in secret ways based on the thread opinion of rels, who i unsecretly think is town.
most of d1 he seemed unfocused for sure. like jumping around calling people scum and then dropping it. so that gives me pause. but there is no more of the fake anger i saw. he looks more frustrated, which is what i'd expect in a tvt argument moreso than svt
i'll get back to you again if you remind me closer to eod with a more clarified read

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

June 21 2017 07:16 GMT

#3824

temp voting fecalfeast until i wake up tomorrow

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

June 21 2017 18:02 GMT

#4017

even though im' pretty out of it i know for sure you guys are doing something stupid right now
sl is 90% town and imma see if i can explain why

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

June 21 2017 18:10 GMT

#4022

now i have no idea what i saw. i remember seeing a really nice caseable point last night but it is lost in the blue. so instead can you like use the exact same lens i do to read him

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

June 21 2017 18:28 GMT

#4029

lynch pool 2.0 (or maybe 1.0, i forgot)

grack OR sl (thinkin it's grack right now. votes def point to grack)
fefe - probably with sl
chez - probably with grack
btdt
va
palmar
skynx

(just remembered to tell you, grack - rels v rayn is probably tvt)