EPTOn September 13 2016 19:48 Superbia wrote:
orly.
If scum are in the people not voting, why haven't they placed a vote on you then?
orly.
If scum are in the people not voting, why haven't they placed a vote on you then?
I uh, didn't say that.
[M][T] Haunted Mansion 3 - Page 3
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
fuba
United States663 Posts
I uh, didn't say that. | ||
|
fuba
United States663 Posts
[QUOTE]On September 13 2016 20:14 fuba wrote: [QUOTE]On September 13 2016 19:48 Superbia wrote: [QUOTE]On September 13 2016 19:42 fuba wrote: It is way too easy to snooze all of my alarms. I should really get one of those alarms that start running around the room when it goes off so I can't ignore it. In any case, I'm awake now. Only have 15 pages to read for my class today, which starts in ~9 hours. Should give me a good amount of time to at least read most of the filters in the game and give some input. Will probably start with people who have yet to vote, which coincidentally seems to include most of the people others are scumreading. My class starts at about an hour before EoD, so I can't be here for that (probably. Might be able to be sneaky while in class. I'd rather not get the professor angry at me on the second day of class, though XD)[/QUOTE] orly. If scum are in the people not voting, why haven't they placed a vote on you then?[/QUOTE] I uh, didn't say that.[/QUOTE] [QUOTE]On September 13 2016 19:42 fuba wrote: It is way too easy to snooze all of my alarms. I should really get one of those alarms that start running around the room when it goes off so I can't ignore it. Right. "Most others". My mistake. Who is scum then?[/QUOTE] Literally what I said I'd be doing over the next 9 hours. Why are you making such a big deal about a pretty nothing post? | ||
|
fuba
United States663 Posts
On September 13 2016 20:38 Superbia wrote: You know what has happened this game right? People voted for town d1. People voted for others d1. Go over some reads you already had, then go over votes. Then post who you think are mafia. Then read filters and adjust accordingly. You're riding me for literally no reason right now, lol. Chill out. Town reads can be fast, scum requires analysis. Situation's simple: I've said I'll have my reads in the thread. If I don't end up supplying any, just vote me and it'll be done. Honestly, not sure why you haven't voted me already lol | ||
|
fuba
United States663 Posts
| ||
|
fuba
United States663 Posts
On September 13 2016 21:00 Superbia wrote: You think I'm scum then or? Certainly a possibility, reading your filter now. | ||
|
fuba
United States663 Posts
Superbia Setup talk - Is completely wrong about everything. Doesn't mention the scumteam's abilities until he points out that he thought they had no spectral abilities until dead. I can see that explaining his spam and the absence of scum power discussion. Upon further consideration, it really seems unlikely that as scum he would enter the game in this way. "I'm going to try to get free townreads for entering the game by trying to break the setup, pretend to misinterpret every aspect of the power roles, completely ignore discussion of the scum powers, and then wrap it up by providing the completely reasonable excuse that I misinterpreted what "spectral" meant." Like, I can 100% see the town reasoning running through his train of thought. Scum would have to be really, really schemey to pull this off. At this point, since it popped into my head, what I said earlier about scott's LW being unreliable is probably untrue. From what I understand, even if someone saw the replacement post they wouldn't know who was replacing. The LW itself is likely 100% reliable, the vote will not be. In addition to what I said earlier, after reading the rest of D1 (I believe), I've found that the way he's pushing me to post is consistent with the way he, himself, plays and says he plays earlier in the thread. I don't think it's forced, and I don't think he's trying to push a wagon without being on the wagon. I also felt a strong similarity between his response to vivax's case against him and my own, which, while probably terrible reasoning, makes me lean slightly more town. (not calling vivax scum here, think he's still town too XD) Was gonna keep reading, but there's a lot for me to get through, and townreads aren't what anyone is looking for. I think super's entry was actually enough for me to consider him town. Might be underestimating his mafia cleverness, but I can't really see anyone entering like that as scum. | ||
|
fuba
United States663 Posts
| ||
|
fuba
United States663 Posts
Shapelog First thing I felt was of consequence was when he returned for the second half of D2. Gave an unasked for self-meta of his scum play, then implies he's scumreading TW for TW's reasons for townreading him. I'm not 100% sure what bugs me about the post. It feels slimy. The self-meta disclosure doesn't seem to fit with the generally more free-flowing thoughts from his other posts. I think what I don't like about the TW stuff is that it all seems pointless. It depends on whether TW feels the same way about shape's meta as shape does, and generally ignores whether or not a post like that is more likely to come from town or scum TW. Like, it seems to imply "this post is wrong and it makes him scummy" but only says why it's wrong. Feels scummy. Addendum after reading the rest of the filter: he eventually gets around to calling TW scum. The meta aspect I can't argue with, not really great with meta. But why would TW just make up BS about shape to call him town if he knows he's town. He wouldn't have to make anything up. I just don't see how shape sees it as alignment indicative. I must have missed the sheeping skynx thing, but regardless, does TW just become a moron when he rolls scum? The argument feels more like "this isn't TW" than "this is scum TW". Looking at his reason for voting TT - His comments about the vote count are correct. He then says that TT's filter is crap, after having mildly defended him against HF the day before. I can see someone who hasn't been able to catch up having no idea who else to really vote for, so I'm gonna go with NAI for his vote at EoD. As for his walls of text that I missed in my first readthrough cuz of spoilers, There's probably a lot that can be discussed, but I don't have the time to really go into them. From what shape himself says, the WoTs help him understand the thread, so I think he'd probably need them as either alignment to either contain his thoughts as town or to keep his story straight as scum. So NAI. Leaning scum on shape. | ||
|
fuba
United States663 Posts
| ||
|
fuba
United States663 Posts
Shoot. | ||
|
fuba
United States663 Posts
| ||
|
fuba
United States663 Posts
| ||
|
fuba
United States663 Posts
| ||
|
fuba
United States663 Posts
On September 14 2016 00:21 Superbia wrote: What was your goal going into this game? Like what was your plan as mafia and what was your plan as town. My usual plan is to not be mafia in the first place. It really doesn't turn out well. I tend to have trouble outright lying. The only person I remember pushing as scum was my scummate, because I knew I was right XD When I play town my plan every game is to post more stream-of-consciousness, but that never works out. I hate being wrong too much to let myself be unsure of something I say. And this game I haven't had the time to read the thread actively until now, so I had 0 chance of pulling it off this game either, lol. I tend to not have discussions, I observe and report what I see. I kinda play a side game rather than participating. My goal is usually to get to end game and find the last scum. I did it once in a dr who game and it was a thrill XD | ||
|
fuba
United States663 Posts
| ||
|
fuba
United States663 Posts
On September 14 2016 02:18 Holyflare wrote: I always get town feels from whatever fuba posts until i actually focus on the content  Could take a look at... basterds mafia, I think? I can't pull off town feels as scum :S (though iirc, I got vivax lynched because I'm an idiot lol) Just finished reading what NU and calix wrote about damdred, gonna dive into his filter now :D | ||
|
fuba
United States663 Posts
On September 10 2016 07:17 Damdred wrote: This looks like a town post, 5 points to anyone who can say why. Damdred, did you ever say why this was the case? I think you responded once, but in response to a different post or something. | ||
|
fuba
United States663 Posts
On September 14 2016 04:10 Tumblewood wrote: I'm gonna change and see if anybody follows I'm tempted to, because I'm completely unsure of damdred. Dunno if I've tried to go through too much too fast, but I can't even seem to think enough to make a decision on him. Calix's case had me going into his filter seeing him as scum already, and then I tried to pick it out myself on a readthrough and I couldn't do it. Maybe I was trying too hard to discount bias, maybe I'm letting myself be buddied, maybe I'm just too tired to focus after about 8 hours of (attempted) critical reading. It's down to either sheeping calix, NU, and scott, or going with my own scumread despite the fact that I have 4-5 other people to read still. Ugh, sticking with Damdred. The three I mentioned were able to read him in real time in the context of what was going on in the thread and come to an agreement. Class has already basically started, I can't think about it anymore today. | ||
|
fuba
United States663 Posts
| ||
|
fuba
United States663 Posts
| ||
| ||
