Newbie Student Mafia XXII - Page 3

Stutters695

2610 Posts

August 02 2016 02:33 GMT

#599

FWIW I wouldn't put too much credence in the vote patterns for them (especially Grack unless you find him scummy to begin with).

Gracks KSC vote was clearly a joke at the very start of the game.

When Silent came back and was a potential lynch target, he had to come out somewhat strong (regardless of alignment) and I was certainly an easy choice to pump something out on.

The last vote by silent was to save himself so of course he'd pick the other wagon.

Stutters695

2610 Posts

August 02 2016 02:39 GMT

#602

What was your last scum game grack?

Stutters695

2610 Posts

August 02 2016 04:46 GMT

#620

@Grack

I'll concede 358, that was a pretty convoluted point and honestly fairly inconsequential. Made more sense as I was typing it.

I didn't push your lynch because we had like an hour and a half until the lynch and I didn't have the clout to get it to go through. Last thing we needed was to shit up the thread more.

The plynch vs actual push is the crux of what's wrong with silent's vote on me. His return/vote on me was before I had him as anything other than a policy lynch. Of course I hadn't mentioned him because there was nothing to mention. He was mia and needed to post.

Yet, despite your admitted lack of trust in your own reads and your willingness to sheep someone of whom you had no idea their alignment, you defended Silent. Then when you apologized to mderg (implying at least a slight town read at that point) you could have switched to silent, which would have put him in the lead over mderg. Why not do that?

This doesn't add up.

Stutters695

2610 Posts

August 02 2016 05:15 GMT

#622

Fair. Going to wait for fresh eyes before tackling this any more.

Stutters695

2610 Posts

August 02 2016 18:50 GMT

#685

Super hungover, but I'm awake. What's up friends

Stutters695

2610 Posts