On February 17 2016 08:40 Breshke wrote:
Too be totally honest I don't really have strong scum feelings about anything and im really struggling because of it.

The trefel/eden "fight" really seems like it comes from two towns to me. I agree with eden and i think I understand what trefels argument actually is but don't think it was right since there wasnt really much going on in the thread for eden to be disjointed from but that is my opinion. I said it was a town on town fight because I feel like either one of them as scum could take it to that next level and start shitting up the thread which would push the other player (who would be town in this scenario) to do this as well.

I also think Ticktock is town just of how happy/relaxed he seems but I have no idea of his scum meta so this could be totally wrong but im fine with it for today.

I would lynch SL just because i can never read him and I don't think with the way he is playing this game I ever will be able to.

Taking back my breshke scumread for this post.
It's townie How He admits he doesn't have sttrong scum feelings.
And his take on trfel 's Eden is quite considered.

Shapelog

United States5188 Posts

February 18 2016 18:29 GMT

#1090

On February 16 2016 15:29 GlowingBear wrote:
I've asked a friend whio is madia , she said the ahining is

Vote: The Shining

Druuuuuuuunk

GB, What do you recall of your drunken slur here. Who is She?

nooniansoong

1538 Posts

February 18 2016 18:31 GMT

#1091

Tt is still mafia though. Nothing townie in his filter. How tinfoil looks takes. I know he likes to tinfoil as scum I think. Opportunistic scum reads which I'll explain later.

Shapelog

United States5188 Posts

February 18 2016 18:33 GMT

#1092

Oh so you felt weirded out by his Tinfoil as well?

nooniansoong

1538 Posts

February 18 2016 18:36 GMT

#1093

His tinfoil looks fake I meant

The Shining

United States2406 Posts

February 18 2016 18:37 GMT

#1094

On February 19 2016 03:31 nooniansoong wrote:
Tt is still mafia though. Nothing townie in his filter. How tinfoil looks takes. I know he likes to tinfoil as scum I think. Opportunistic scum reads which I'll explain later.

TT tinfoiled as town in pyp. If he's scum, it's not for that. Im rereading TT to see if I still think he's scum but I wanted to point this out. Do you have an example of him tinfoiling as scum?

Shapelog

United States5188 Posts

February 18 2016 18:40 GMT

#1095

I do, He Tinfoiled Rikotry in nutcracker for easy buddy on me.

Shapelog

United States5188 Posts

February 18 2016 18:41 GMT

#1096

On February 19 2016 03:36 nooniansoong wrote:
His tinfoil looks fake I meant

Like it was focused a bit too much on tumble? B/c that was the feeling i got from it.

nooniansoong

1538 Posts

February 18 2016 19:38 GMT

#1097

scumreads 1.2

Ticktock
GB
(Rsoul)
(Scott)
(SL)
(Tumble)

Shapelog

United States5188 Posts

February 18 2016 20:14 GMT

#1098

Final Read Post

Well, It is this time of the game in which I die. So since that is the case, it is time for a final post. And in a Ironic twist, A helpful last post. One that is free, and majestic. One that I can look back on this game and say "Yes, that was only thing that i provided to help town." One that will make up for the almost 9 pages of filter, which I failed to address. Oops. One that Will....

Alright I shut up now. Let start. I am behind and got to work fast.

Town

Eden, Asking millers to claim while speculating a DT to be in the game, long posts that could be summed up in 2 sentences ( a accordance in her town games) and some other stuff as well. Also his reaction to Trofl makes me think he is town. Also him ending up voting for palmar makes sense if you look at his read progression.

Breshke, Coming around the game by seeing both angles. Fights for and against people at the same time. And Is caring enough to see my contradiction in my mafia sick stat post (even if it was incorrect). His logic thought out the game has been sound, and his reaction to me claiming strikes me as town.

Town Leans

Trofl, I decided, after much debate, to put Trofl here. Trofl wants to see the game progress. And wants help for reading people he cannot read (kush). Mafia would prob. Push Kush instead of that. There is some stuff i do not like about him (his aggressive behavior for one, which feels out of place for Trofl) but lately he is showing more of his town self.

TT, I was really liking TT until that tinfoil post. I feel like he focused a lot on Tumble (Though this is prob. town tbh). A lot of the reasoning I am TR him is b/c of my interaction with him and his underwhelming posting. ScumTT made big helpful posts to town, something he is not doing. Though, watch him for D2

Null Folk

GB, I find that during the lynch and a tad before hand he was being reasonable, kinda like a weaker version of Bresh. But he has not really done anything else. I would like him to start posting. IF you have to pressure him.

Kush, He is active, and being himself. But normally I never been good at reading him D1. His reads on D2 needs to be checked. I still have problems with him from my last read (Blowing out of water me asking him for help with reading R-girl) and then semi-pushing for a full claim.

Scum Leans

R-Girl, She started this post High on my town list. But I reread her filter, and there is a few things I do not like. 1 is her town read on Tumble. She asks Tumble a question, Tumble answers, She buys it, then gives tumble a town lean, without really explaining why. Weird for me. Especially since,

Townlean
tumbler (going w/ first instinct though honestly the read changes for notes i don't quite get o.0)

She seems to not really understand why she is continuing to town read him. Idk, maybe she is stubborn?

On February 18 2016 01:30 rsoultin wrote:
i think shape is scum ^^ you should be a hero and lynch him with me! \o/ or show me how i'm wrong

Then there is this. For some reason it just gives me pause. I can understand her "show me how i'm wrong' to bring out scott, but why the "be a hero and lynch him" part. I am sure that there is a perfect explanation for this but that is about it.

Plus Rsoul pushed a shapelog OR Scott lynch. But instead of going, "-bonce- Well then lil' Scotty is a scummy" or something like that, she votes for Palmar 1st. Why did she not just push her other Lynch read?

Still Rsoul is my weakest Scum lean (and prob. the least certain), she does show some town merit on solving the game.

Scott2scummy, Still no content.......One page filter......And Afk. Thought was being sus. heavily, someone said no. He left. Other then that, he has not posted anything so not much to go after. Vote was weird too.

The Shining, I reviewed his WoT, and there was 1 stated scum read (TT) and 2 scum reads (Me, tumble) that could be scum, but not together. Most people winded up being Null, either because not enough info. Some townie stuff from him though.

Scum

SaltShaker, I have not committed much about him as of late. But there is some things I really do not like. 1, He rode the fact that people thought he was blue through the lynch and backs away, calling himself VT. It makes no sense for him to do this.

Tumble, Makes no sense in filter or reads. Based his read on me on meta. Lynched Palmar after saying Palmar was a bad lynch. He is just way too jumpy to be town. Really have said everything about why i think he is scum.

Also worth noting, looking into EoD is prob. the best thing to do (i do not have time to do it). See who was not there and who was, and try to find the general reasoning for people's votes.

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

February 18 2016 20:24 GMT

#1099

Wow I am regretting my Palmar vote more and more by the hour. The reason I voted was because there were three wagons sitting at two votes (Scott, Shining, and... GB, I think) and I thought they all sucked. They were all effectively p-lynches on people who hadn't been active, and those hit town more often than not.