EPTOn January 19 2016 08:39 marvellosity wrote:
Yes
Show nested quote +
On January 19 2016 08:38 ExO_ wrote:
You're trying to tell me you'd look at a guy who was going to die day 1, didn't claim his role, then claimed 2 different roles the next day and say he's town?
On January 18 2016 20:45 marvellosity wrote:
everything about this post is incorrect
the large majority of the time, messy, all over the place claims are gonna wind up town
On January 17 2016 08:57 ExO_ wrote:
Because I don't think it's realistic. A guy literally didn't claim on d1, and then claimed blue followed by miller. Looks scummy. If town has a chance to lynch scum day 2 I think they're gonna take it. I guess you could sorta confirm him, but it relies on the real Gun Smith actually wanting to CC, and there's is no guarantee of that. People in mafia do strange things, but here you have a guy really all over the place with his claims. It makes more sense to lynch him
On January 17 2016 08:54 Rels wrote:
What is wrong with what I just said ? I agree with what you say, it s difficult to believe he's blue, but if nobody counter claims him d3 he's confirmed town. If anybody counterclaims d3 you lynch him.
I won't defend that he was not scummy cause I wanted to lynch him d1 :p
On January 17 2016 08:49 ExO_ wrote:
idk was a pretty big fuckup for him not to claim d1, then to claim miller and all that d2. Like would you actually take him seriously at that point?
On January 17 2016 08:45 Rels wrote:
Meh
Gunsmith is a vanilla town after D2
You being gunsmith meant you could play as bad as you humanly wanted and still be confirmed town if mafia doesn't 1v1 you
The correct play for town after your claim was to not lynch you and wait D3, where the real gunsmith if there is one would claim (since he has already given his two guns, he s only a named vt now)
Damdred fucked up super badly counter claiming you when there was a way to confirm you
On January 17 2016 08:40 Tictock wrote:
Gg, obv. I failed prett hard this game, though I did correctly concluded Onegu was scum for his cop,claim and Damdred was still town despite fake CC'ing me.
Yea really suprised people took the one burst of activity from palmar and his case on GB and decided he was town for the rest of the game, and then not lynching Onegu... But w/e
Sorry again for my throw.
Gg, obv. I failed prett hard this game, though I did correctly concluded Onegu was scum for his cop,claim and Damdred was still town despite fake CC'ing me.
Yea really suprised people took the one burst of activity from palmar and his case on GB and decided he was town for the rest of the game, and then not lynching Onegu... But w/e
Sorry again for my throw.
Meh
Gunsmith is a vanilla town after D2
You being gunsmith meant you could play as bad as you humanly wanted and still be confirmed town if mafia doesn't 1v1 you
The correct play for town after your claim was to not lynch you and wait D3, where the real gunsmith if there is one would claim (since he has already given his two guns, he s only a named vt now)
Damdred fucked up super badly counter claiming you when there was a way to confirm you
idk was a pretty big fuckup for him not to claim d1, then to claim miller and all that d2. Like would you actually take him seriously at that point?
What is wrong with what I just said ? I agree with what you say, it s difficult to believe he's blue, but if nobody counter claims him d3 he's confirmed town. If anybody counterclaims d3 you lynch him.
I won't defend that he was not scummy cause I wanted to lynch him d1 :p
Because I don't think it's realistic. A guy literally didn't claim on d1, and then claimed blue followed by miller. Looks scummy. If town has a chance to lynch scum day 2 I think they're gonna take it. I guess you could sorta confirm him, but it relies on the real Gun Smith actually wanting to CC, and there's is no guarantee of that. People in mafia do strange things, but here you have a guy really all over the place with his claims. It makes more sense to lynch him
everything about this post is incorrect
the large majority of the time, messy, all over the place claims are gonna wind up town
You're trying to tell me you'd look at a guy who was going to die day 1, didn't claim his role, then claimed 2 different roles the next day and say he's town?
Yes
I know what I'm doing next time as scum
