|
On October 22 2015 03:59 Eversince wrote: You found that mafia telling but Rels just posted where I ended up last night in his post and it's ok?
Rels counter claimed and voted sicklucker, dude. He immediately reacted to it
|
Wow.
Something just crossed my mind.
Game is pretty solvable. But I can't share it with thread until day3
|
SL if you're the veteran you claim right now.
|
On October 22 2015 09:11 sicklucker wrote:Show nested quote +On October 22 2015 09:06 GlowingBear wrote: SL if you're the veteran you claim right now. lol no i wouldnt
Are you veteran or not? You don't risk being shot anytime soon and you're wasting this day with useless discussion.
Instead you can turn into confirmed town and survive until LYLO if you're the veteran. Mafia WILL have to waste a shot on you anyway.
|
Nevermind i just read the OP and the best is roleblockable
|
On October 22 2015 09:23 sicklucker wrote:Show nested quote +On October 22 2015 04:12 GlowingBear wrote: Wow.
Something just crossed my mind.
Game is pretty solvable. But I can't share it with thread until day3 explain this or i might tunnel you because its the only remotely townie thing I can find on you
There is a guy who thought you could be the veteran trying to take a shot. If you're actually the veteran, it could be TMI since mafia team knows the setup. Also, that thing that I said about the veteran surviving for longer times.
I just thought I should talk about this later but I don't care.
There is a confirned townie talking about you and a confirmed townie to me (myself) wasting his time trying to figure you out.
You're 100% being roleblocked and killed if you're he veteran. You're role is useless now unless for confirming yourself.
So, again: are you the veteran?
|
On October 22 2015 09:30 Fecalfeast wrote: Like what if we have doctor? Telling people to claim vet is so bad wtf do you know that there's a vet gb?
IF he is the veteran, he should claim now.
Dude if he is the veteran there is no doctor, we save discussion now.
He CAN'T be any other role because there is no way he try to take a bullet as another power role
|
On October 22 2015 09:32 Fecalfeast wrote: fuck that's such a dumb play GB, if we do have a vet and you force them to claim, we lose any wifom power we have over scum, if we have a doctor, scum knows it and would love to claim vet so doctor will CC
I'M NOT ASKING SL TO FAKE CLAIM???
AND I'M NOT ASKING COUNTER CLAIMS???
JESUS CHRIST
|
On October 22 2015 09:36 sicklucker wrote: Gb if your the cop or the vet your not making it obvious to mafia at all
Rels claimed he shot lonemeow dude
Just answer this: are you the veteran or not?
|
I KNOOOOOOOW
BUT IF HE WAS VET HE WOULD CLEAR HIMSELF
SIMPLY AS THAT
JESUS
|
On October 22 2015 09:49 The Shining wrote: SL why can't GB be scum with ES?
He voted Scott, said he did not want to and was not interested in lynching ES, unvotes, votes SL, tells Farrah he doesn't have time to read her case on ES, tells LM he's town and to vote SL(TMI), then votes ES which he refused to do just to not vote with his scumread in FF? When FF asked him to give him reasons, he said he thinks he could be scum. Then he's gone until he comes back drunk in night phase.
Looks hella scummy to me. He waited until Scott was in the lead to put his vote on ES.
If you think sicklucker is town, you're saying I risked having my partner killed because lonemeow and SL weren't voting scott and could put Eversince in majority.
|
Ok SL I'm flipping my read again, your latest posts have a town vibe on them.
Your reaction to Eversince looks genuine
|
On October 22 2015 10:11 The Shining wrote:Show nested quote +On October 22 2015 10:09 sicklucker wrote:On October 22 2015 10:04 Fecalfeast wrote:On October 22 2015 10:01 sicklucker wrote: FF do you not think gb is town for his angle here? I know its frustrating as hell tho Mnneeeeeeeeeeehhhhhhhhhhhh I hate it so muc hthough well now that gb cant tunnel on me anymore he will have a chance to show some things i hope Well its a good thing he effortlessly decided you're townie now and missed my post scumming him for EoD. Inb4 I get OMGUSd by GB
Nah I'm killing Moosy 100% today
And I think I've addressed to your post?
|
What????
FF you said sicklucker was town ever since he claimed. You didn't even admitted a discussion on that
Why are you voting him?
|
On October 22 2015 23:17 Rels wrote: GB am I tunneling or is SL really similar to his mafia game and really different from his town game ?
You could be right on SL. The thing is that he presented some townie posts in his filter that is giving me pause. There are better people to look after today IMO. If you want to see if you're TUNNELED, forget the claim and try to read SL coming from a townie perspective. See if it makes sense.
To be fair, I am voting Moosy doosy but FF looks terrible.
He called SL town ALL DAY. Made a case on ME. Never votes me.
Agrees with SL that I can be coming from town angle (not without hesitation) Then agrees with a team where sicklucker and Moosy are mafia (he is town reading SL) Moosy is the main wagon He votes SL.
WHAAAAAT?
|
I think your case is a little flawed because yes, he did the same thing last game as mafia, but a "meta" case must prove not only that he does that stuff as mafia, but that he CAN'T or NEVER do that stuff as town.
|
On October 22 2015 23:39 Rels wrote:Show nested quote +On October 22 2015 23:35 GlowingBear wrote:On October 22 2015 23:17 Rels wrote: GB am I tunneling or is SL really similar to his mafia game and really different from his town game ? You could be right on SL. The thing is that he presented some townie posts in his filter that is giving me pause. There are better people to look after today IMO. If you want to see if you're TUNNELED, forget the claim and try to read SL coming from a townie perspective. See if it makes sense. It does. Except at EOD1. And I know SL is super strong at making seems like he's coming from a town perspective, I've played with him. At EOD1, he was playing his scum game, as demonstrated above.
I agree with you, Rels. And I find hard that drunk bear is wrong.
But look at Moosy doosy and FF. Especially what I just said. Don't you think they have scummier traits? I mean, your strong scum read on him started with the counter claim. Before that, I presume you had a weaker read
|
On October 22 2015 23:45 Rels wrote:Show nested quote +On October 22 2015 23:40 GlowingBear wrote: I think your case is a little flawed because yes, he did the same thing last game as mafia, but a "meta" case must prove not only that he does that stuff as mafia, but that he CAN'T or NEVER do that stuff as town. The thing is, it's not a meta case to begin with. How he played EOD1 was scummy. Thinking the two main wagons were not likely to be mafia, having a scumread; but not pushing it. The townie way to play that wuold be to defend your townreads and push your scumread. It only starts to be meta after that, because he was in kinda the same situation the last two games he played: - as mafia he did the same thing - as town he did not do the same thing; in fact, he reacted the town way described above
Did he never do that as town? I'm not sure. I've done that as town once.
Ok I will read your case thoroughlly and comment point by point. What do you think of what I said about FF?
|
So vote Moosy doosy today?
|
On October 23 2015 00:14 Rels wrote: What do you think of the meta stuff above ?
I think it's weak. I usually don't like meta. Most of the meta cases I've seen in these forums were wrong.
If FF is self aware of that meta, he can fake it anytime. I will never accept a meta over a clearly scummy post.
I simply don't see a townie saying "SL is town, Occam's razor" then when you post a team with him he says "ok good team" and instead voting a suspicious guy that is the main wagon AND part of the team he said it was good (Moosy), he votes his town read (SL).
|
|
|
|