Newbie Student Mafia XIII

Post a Reply

1 2 3 4 5 12 13 14 Next All

raynpelikoneet

Finland43266 Posts

July 22 2015 16:36 GMT

#35

/in

raynpelikoneet

Finland43266 Posts

July 22 2015 17:11 GMT

#37

If you get a full line-up are you planning on starting tonight?

raynpelikoneet

Finland43266 Posts

July 23 2015 09:39 GMT

#81

Back off Fidei already said he will coach me!!

raynpelikoneet

Finland43266 Posts

July 23 2015 10:22 GMT

#86

On July 23 2015 18:46 Rels wrote:

Show nested quote +

Really though are you coaching this game ? I would love to have tips on townreading people.

I am playing.

raynpelikoneet

Finland43266 Posts

July 23 2015 10:23 GMT

#87

lol geript is your bday on sunday?

raynpelikoneet

Finland43266 Posts

July 23 2015 19:53 GMT

#116

On July 24 2015 03:54 Blazinghand wrote:
In newbie games like this especially, you can expect a more relaxed and friendly environment, so I wouldn't worry about it too much.

Hey hey now Blazinghand. I am in the game

raynpelikoneet

Finland43266 Posts

July 23 2015 22:03 GMT

#131

posting so i don't get modkilled.

raynpelikoneet

Finland43266 Posts

July 24 2015 07:19 GMT

#236

Damdred town.
Noobking town.
Ruxxar town.
Moosy town.
Dis-something guy town.

Barakos mafia.
##vote Barakos

raynpelikoneet

Finland43266 Posts

July 24 2015 09:48 GMT

#249

Yeah Rels that's not very good case.
I will answer you when i get home from work. Quoting pain in the ass On phone.
I basically just read and post simple thoughts when i am not on computer.

raynpelikoneet

Finland43266 Posts

July 24 2015 09:49 GMT

#251

Oh wait. Yeah that in fact makes more sense Rels.

raynpelikoneet

Finland43266 Posts

July 24 2015 09:53 GMT

#253

So Barakos claims he is scummy.
Barakos why would you make intentionally scummy posts as town?

raynpelikoneet

Finland43266 Posts

July 24 2015 09:55 GMT

#256

On July 24 2015 18:50 ruXxar wrote:

Show nested quote +

On July 24 2015 18:46 Rels wrote:

On July 24 2015 18:42 ruXxar wrote:

On July 24 2015 17:53 Rels wrote:
Alright here I go.

On July 24 2015 07:08 NocturneMage wrote:
RNG gave me town, thank God. I'm having a beer or two. Might be three. Not sure yet.

ruXxar sounds like he's sick of playing scum though.

Although if the moderator is going to make this a Pokemon themed game, I really don't know what to say.

This first post from NocturneMage seems very prepared to me. And prepared post = scumlean. Why is it prepared ? Let me show you.

RNG gave me town, thank God. I'm having a beer or two. Might be three. Not sure yet. <= VT claim + fluff about beer.

ruXxar sounds like he's sick of playing scum though. <= Discussion about something in game.

Although if the moderator is going to make this a Pokemon themed game, I really don't know what to say. <= Funny remark about host.

So three different subjects in first post = prepared post. And prepared post means he may be afraid to post, hence why he prepared it so much.

Plus in his later posts there are lots of questions + "i'm a noob" statement. See spoiler for source. It could mean he is mafia doesn't know what to talk about; could also just mean he's newbie and doesn't know what to talk about. So NAI.

+ Show Spoiler +

On July 24 2015 07:22 NocturneMage wrote:

Show nested quote +

He seems relieved to be town, assuming he's telling the truth, though the poetry makes me think he's more high than he is mafia.

Do you think he's mafia?

On July 24 2015 07:27 NocturneMage wrote:

Show nested quote +

Is that alignment indicative for ruXxar? I'm guessing it is if that was a scum game of his?

On July 24 2015 07:32 NocturneMage wrote:
Well it's my first game here and most of my mafia experience is from real life. It seems harder to fake being town in real life and I can't see it being much different on forum mafia with the body language and tone of voice aside.

On July 24 2015 07:39 NocturneMage wrote:

Show nested quote +

I played it a lot at parties in uni and in grad school. It was the party game of party games. I also have played a board game called Resistance which is somewhat similar except people don't die but you also do figure out if people are lying or not and try to include them on your team or not and then pass or fail the expedition party.

What is your experience with mafia or is forums just it?

On July 24 2015 07:41 NocturneMage wrote:

Show nested quote +

It would seem like it. I don't know if I should make anything the way he's addressing people, ignoring his poetry, that could come from town or mafia. I'm assuming no ill-will means a town read? or a null read?

I can't tell actually. ruxxar is that even a read on noobking?

So, ##Vote NocturneMage

@NocturneMage: if you're town, I want you to read Flexes' filter, who is also playing his first game. Only two posts, but he already discussed something relevant to the game. If you don't know: in the OP, if you click Flexes' name, you have access to all the posts he did in this thread.

Ah, the pre-planned accusation.
Classic mafia style. #self-meta.

Your prepared argument is non-sense.
How are they prepared when #2 and #3 are based on events that happened after the game started?

No you don't get it.

I'm not saying NocturneMage prepared his post before the game started.
I'm saying he thought long and hard before he posted it, instead of being free of mind and posting what he felt.
The evidence that he thought long and hard before posting it is the fact that there are 3 different subjects in the post.

Then, I'm saying that the fact that he is not free of mind posting his first post may indicate he's mafia.

I disagree. Weak argument.
His later posts shows he's not afraid to ask questions and share of himself.

It is not a weak argument.
Rels is talking about his opening post. Not about what he posted after.
Mafia (especially newer ppl) often have hard time entering the thread.

raynpelikoneet

Finland43266 Posts

July 24 2015 10:14 GMT

#261

On July 24 2015 19:12 Barakos wrote:

Show nested quote +

Obviously to get reactions from people?

And I even got some reactions, that gave me reads about Rels and disformation as I explained in my post...

I expected to get called out on it by the people that played with me in NSM X, so call it a reactiontest, that Rels passed, whereas Tictock, Breshke and disformation failed.

And to answer your next question, which will be, why I only called out disformation and not tictock and breshke as well:
Breshke died N2, so he didn't play the whole game with me and tictock only came in, wrote some stuff about tarot and then left without leaving the impression of having read the thread, whereas disformation played the game till endgame.

Rels picking up on this, even though he was lynched N1 in NSM X just shows how attentative he is when reading people.

Quoted for my filter so i remember this tonight.

raynpelikoneet

Finland43266 Posts

July 24 2015 13:31 GMT

#281

Oh yeah breshke... i forgot about breshke.
FYI i wanna hear moose answer damdred before elaborating further.

raynpelikoneet

Finland43266 Posts

July 24 2015 13:35 GMT

#283

Barakos i would like you to elaborate onto your read on Barakos.
Why is the post you have been called out for scummy?

raynpelikoneet

Finland43266 Posts

July 24 2015 14:25 GMT

#304

I also think nocturnemage could be mafia.

raynpelikoneet

Finland43266 Posts

July 24 2015 15:07 GMT

#318

On July 24 2015 23:18 NocturneMage wrote:

Show nested quote +

Well I'm trying to see past the poetry and just look at the words he's using to describe people, although I see Damdred was able to get a read off ruxxar, my only hesitation with Damdred is when he says "tone and frequency" how is he so sure that ruXxar or anyone else isn't faking the tone with his poetry? I know the argument is made that mafia have hard time making reads but I thought from some of the games I've read before mafia can spam the thread too, so the frequency part of the argument doesn't make sense to me.

As for the disformation read, he is saying he waffles a lot which makes me hesistant to read him town, I don't know if he should be scum whether he's trying to make an excuse for himself early on but I need to read the rest of the thread.

I don't like the bolded part at all.

raynpelikoneet

Finland43266 Posts

July 24 2015 15:09 GMT

#320

I also don't like the fact basically every read of his is "could be this BUT could also be that".

raynpelikoneet

Finland43266 Posts

July 24 2015 15:20 GMT

#323

I didn't see his answer.
I look again when i get home and elaborate further.

I don't buy Barakos' explanation btw. He is very likely to be mafia. I think there is one thing at least from what you can tell he is lying.