To be clear, since you posted that stuff D1 I'd have expected you to be the first dude to be happy to just jump on the HF train and push it.

Now it seems to be the opposite and you mention some other dudes being mafia in your opinion.

See where I'm coming from?

ruXxar

Norway5669 Posts

July 15 2015 19:12 GMT

#6926

On July 16 2015 02:44 Trfel wrote:
So, ruXxar, apparently you now think that I am town? Why? (I'd just like to have it clearly stated)

Also, you never answered my previous question...

If Clarity_nl's first few posts seemed scummy because they were pre-planned, how could this be true if Holyflare is town? In other words, how could Clarity_nl, as mafia plan something before the game with town!Holyflare?

Currently my working theory is this:

HF is town.
You are town.

Mafia sheeped the push on you (damdred + kelsier + ebh/vivax)
Mafia hard defended you / disrupting (rsoultin)

About clarity:

I thought it was pre-planned from clarity's side and not together with HF.
I thought that the reason she said it was due to the fact that they could both be mafia together, but the "pre-planned" part was done by her alone, so she could possibly be mafia on her own.
This doesn't really make any sense when he couldn't have known what HF was going to say, so the pre-planned argument actually falls apart and looking at it now it was an incorrect argument to make.
I admit now I was wrong and that the argument was terrible. I blame it on the early game adrenaline rush.

After that point I didn't really evaluate whether the pre-planned accusation made sense, I just automatically assumed it did. I hadn't really re-evaluated it until now when I realize how little sense it makes.

ObiWanShinobi

United States8089 Posts

July 15 2015 19:12 GMT

#6927

On July 16 2015 04:07 Vivax wrote:
To be clear, since you posted that stuff D1 I'd have expected you to be the first dude to be happy to just jump on the HF train and push it.

Now it seems to be the opposite and you mention some other dudes being mafia in your opinion.

See where I'm coming from?

I already knew what you were talking about, I just didn't feel like answering you.

Clarity_nl

Netherlands6826 Posts

July 15 2015 19:17 GMT

#6928

Still a guy

Clarity_nl

Netherlands6826 Posts

July 15 2015 19:19 GMT

#6929

Also the fact that you seem to think 3-4 mafia jumped on the same wagon early d1 is a bit ridiculous, it's actually a point against vivax being mafia, although a small one.

XEliteBlueHunter69X

155 Posts

July 15 2015 19:26 GMT

#6930

On July 16 2015 04:12 ObiWanShinobi wrote:

Show nested quote +

I already knew what you were talking about, I just didn't feel like answering you.

scumreads me for the exact same thing

snide comment complete

ruXxar

Norway5669 Posts

July 15 2015 19:28 GMT

#6931

On July 16 2015 04:17 Clarity_nl wrote:
Still a guy

Sorry, I'll do 40 pushups to punish myself.

On July 16 2015 04:19 Clarity_nl wrote:
Also the fact that you seem to think 3-4 mafia jumped on the same wagon early d1 is a bit ridiculous, it's actually a point against vivax being mafia, although a small one.

Taking what the flipped scum have in common and my individual scum-reads it sort of fits into my world.

ObiWanShinobi

United States8089 Posts

July 15 2015 19:32 GMT

#6932

Honestly I feel like the thread is too stagnant for this to be a 100% mafia lynch. I keep looking for reasons to not jump on this lynch but I can't find any aside from that.
So I'm thinking I look for mafia outside of this lynch or in the people that are jumping on it.
I can't find any.

Bleh.

ruXxar

Norway5669 Posts

July 15 2015 19:36 GMT

#6933

I'm thinking that as mafia it's very easy to latch onto strong cases that other people are making and say like "mm yeah, you're making a lot of good points" and then add the pushed person to their scum-list while someone else gets the blame for pushing that person.

Like, who ever questioned why damdred and kelsier scum-read trfel? No one, people were focused on HF since he was the main proponent of the push.
The others just scooted by and no one batted an eyelid.

XEliteBlueHunter69X

155 Posts

July 15 2015 19:39 GMT

#6934

this lynch on hf is 50/50 he could be either alignment easily.i have no idea on this one

boxerfred

Germany8360 Posts

July 15 2015 19:39 GMT

#6935

I don't like hts, still, for posting style. it's feels really similar to the game where she replaced scum.

boxerfred

Germany8360 Posts

July 15 2015 19:39 GMT

#6936

wondering why hf is so silent, and wtf what are you basing your scum read on me ows

Clarity_nl

Netherlands6826 Posts

July 15 2015 19:40 GMT

#6937

That's mainly because trfel was scummy a hell to everyone except rsoultin if I remember correctly. Look ruxxar if you're town I'm sorry that I'm throwing in 1-liners to stop your push but I really disagree with the way you're going about it. I've brought up the point of Vivax's 1st post before and HtS pointed out that you're taking quotes out of context. I'm not sure if you're town and tunneling a bit or scum doing it on purpose but either find something substantial or move on.

On July 16 2015 04:32 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
Honestly I feel like the thread is too stagnant for this to be a 100% mafia lynch. I keep looking for reasons to not jump on this lynch but I can't find any aside from that.
So I'm thinking I look for mafia outside of this lynch or in the people that are jumping on it.
I can't find any.

Bleh.

What's your read on Breshke?