TL Mafia LXXI: Gaiden - Page 27

On July 11 2015 07:53 Meapak_Ziphh wrote:

Yes indeed I gathered as much. However town wave looks much different than this in my experience. I'm trying to understand geripts meta read.

On July 11 2015 08:10 Meapak_Ziphh wrote:
I wasn't in the last game with wave so I wouldn't know. Damdred's filter, while a very interesting read, didn't really sway me one way or another on wave. However if there are multiple people stepping up to meta defend wave I guess we can work through vivax and Scott first.

On July 11 2015 11:46 rsoultin wrote:


don't obstruct me, please. i'm actually in a good mood right now, and blaming your damdy read on me when i was saying i didn't feel good about him this game...all game...just looks a lot like you're trying to shift blame

how is conjuring up a "far too accurate" list townie? how do you know it's accurate? like really ><

i mean i think it's pretty obvious how it's ego-stroking when he was sheeping several of your reads

On July 11 2015 12:00 rsoultin wrote:


complete null. he hasn't played. i'd say scum but i know he takes pride in his scum game so eh -_- maybe he fell down a hole somewhere. it's been days

On July 09 2015 06:12 Holyflare wrote:


Kelsier says some things that make sense but is wildly different from kelsier from last game, he has a lot of pointless one liners but I think he was kinda towny at the start of the game and has somewhat fallen off a bit but I still think he might be town.

Breshke said some towny stuff imo although I don't really remember any of his posts anymore. The only thing that sticks out in my mind is his town read of rsoultin which seemed really well reasoned out. <-- probably need to re-evaluate but I don't really think off my head he looked bad at all

obi seems a bit try hard which is potentially worrying but he hasn't really said anything egregious and it all seems pretty thought out and reasoned from what i remember.

On July 11 2015 12:09 rsoultin wrote:


instead of mocking me, because i actually do explain my tonereads when asked, why is it so difficult for you to point out which descriptions you liked in his list? this isn't a hard question. it's like literally the only reason you're townreading him, is it not?

On July 11 2015 12:18 Vivax wrote:
That list by scott has the interesting point that he accuses me of defending Trfel but at the same time posts something about him that says absoluely nothing about his alignment. The "that was crap but he can be not crap" stuff.

On July 11 2015 12:25 Vivax wrote:


Well you can fuck off first of all with this cause when I was ready to vote for him you magically lost interest and now you make it an issue again.

On July 11 2015 12:36 Vivax wrote:


Changing opinion cause I saw something that made me think he might start playing properly isn't scummy. I missed his second page at first, and that's where he started posting some reads.

On July 07 2015 03:50 Damdred wrote:
Hey guys I got distracted while I was finishing things up at the house cleaning days are a bitch.

ok I'll try to answer everything of I miss some things just quote them and I'll get them, or if you have a person you specifically want me to talk about I'll try to get to it.

Firstly a list of people I am town reading currently:
Ruxxor: last game we played together one of the things or a few things I caught him on was weird interactions with people suspecting them and then forgetting what he's typed. He seems to be a little more consistent with what he's said even if he is putting things a bit odd. Also tone wise he is way different, he seems a bit more relaxed and happier here while my experience with him as scum has been super angry sounding. Content wise he also makes a bit of sense with what he's posting so far.

Marv: Mostly its a tone thing plus he seems really involved in everything going on. I like and understand how he's looking at the game.

Kel: Has really put the work into the game so far that I would expect from a town kel, he has dug through posts in here and has kept brining things back up that he doesn't agree with and he keeps re evaluating as the game goes. Ie when I told him to checkour last game he did and changed a bit of what he said.

Hf: I'm scared of him bit he seems a lot more involved early and seems to be pushing things from a good angle to me. He doesn't sound really stinky to me atm so I'm ok with him being town here.

Hts is someone who I like at this point but don't have a firm handle on right now. For example I can understand the thought processes she uses in giving the reads and when others don't understand you can see a struggle to get people to understand it. Sticks to the guns but seems to really want to work with people to get them to understand the perspective. I think has a good shot at town

palmar is a Toney thing and I like him but I always do.

If anyone has any more specific questions about people not on my list ask.

@kel currently in struggling with my rsoultin read. I'm of two minds whenever her and hf fight one of them is generally scum as they usually get along pretty well. But on the other hand she's so obstinante and doesn't care what people think shed just going to say whatever the hell she wants, that's a town trait to me of hers to. Overall I'm still thinking town but a couple of misgivings about her.

False Lead (Mafia Roleblocker): False leads happen all the time. Most of the time, they’re not even anyone’s fault. They sure do eat up valuable peoples’ time, though. You are a roleblocker. Each night, you may target a player and roleblock them. You can also deliver KP while doing this. Your RB resolves before any town abilities do.