|
On June 25 2015 08:25 Mig wrote: I retired from mafia for 1.5 years and just came back. Obviously I didnt play well this game but it is what it is.
So in your first game back after 1.5 years, you were confident enough to fake claim vs someone who you thought was mafia even after they claimed det?
|
On June 25 2015 08:30 rsoultin wrote: enough of this
you want me to treat you like a newbie, nyd? i'll tell you what i tell the newbies i've coached
find scum. that's how you get townread
your weak defenses won't convince anyone and if you're really town, you should want to help us, not whine about being scumread for a terrible play
you mean mig right? :<
|
LOL or MiG could be donkey town, and VA could have fake claimed jailer rofl but I doubt that...
|
RS if you think that ruxxar is not a real save, you have to believe that mafia mig SOMEHOW guessed that ruxxar was jailed. That's such a leap. If the mafia decided to double stack the night that ruxxar was supposedly saved, they already decided that bugs wasn't an important kp target so how would he get into the mindset that he would be an important save target? I dunno.
|
RS, is it likely for there to be jailkeeper, detective, and masons in one game? It would be balanced by strong mafia roles right?
|
On June 26 2015 01:57 Onegu wrote: LS just claimed red to lynch HF
When did you decide LS was scum after saying he was most likely town?
|
On June 26 2015 03:01 rsoultin wrote: read the part on ruxx nyd
if mig is scum he 100% knew WHICH of the two ends of the exchange (who was saved vs. who was doing the killing) was the one actually jailed. he can't possibly know that unless the one doing the killing had a secondary action that either WAS or WAS NOT interfered with so that he could narrow it down to ruxx
from there it's just how realistic is a NIGHT ONE RUXXAR night kill
I think I'm dumb and have no reading comprehension. Can you explain that more clearly please ><
|
I think I'm just less experienced with these roles
|
On June 26 2015 03:15 rsoultin wrote: anyway i'm at
mig/ruxx/hf/shockey <- post-game cred
outside chance of oneg
mig, ruxx, hf almost definitely scum...if i'm not here tomorrow and y'all don't lynch mig -_- well, there's not much i can do about it but you should be feeling my DISPLEASURE beating on all your heads the WHOLE TIME lol ><
I'm at mig/shockey/onegu and last one is probably hf? But I think he's townier than whoever the other guy is I forgot to mention
|
Ohhhhh so you're saying ruxxar could have had a secondary power as scum and jk role blocks so he's not out of the clear. How does that explain the missing second kp then? I don't think scum would show only 1 kp when they could knock out a towny or a roley
|
On June 26 2015 04:47 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On June 26 2015 03:01 rsoultin wrote: read the part on ruxx nyd
if mig is scum he 100% knew WHICH of the two ends of the exchange (who was saved vs. who was doing the killing) was the one actually jailed. he can't possibly know that unless the one doing the killing had a secondary action that either WAS or WAS NOT interfered with so that he could narrow it down to ruxx
from there it's just how realistic is a NIGHT ONE RUXXAR night kill I think you don't understand the word logic lol, if 2 people deliver kp and one of them goes through have a guess how you know who was saved. You don't need a power role to know that's a huge leap in confirmation bias. Mafia member x shoots town bugs = save Oh noes bugs must have been saved! Your wifom is crazy. Obviously a n1 ruxxar kill is not unlikely if the jailkeeper thought he was towny enough to save and like i said, the wifom argument i posed is far more realistic.
RS is saying that the reason why there was 1 kp could also be because ruxxar can deliver his own personal kp and he was roleblocked so by JK so there was 1 kp.
|
Can we like expedite this day/night phase? We all know MiG is dying and then we'll see tomorrow
|
On June 27 2015 12:28 ShoCkeyy wrote: ##vote VayneAuthority
Just got caught up with thread, your filter is just riddled with scum and you just gave yourself away. Thanks for making it easier!
did you miss mig?
|
At least we know mig is mafia. If game was going to be over with the mig lynch, I don't think mafia would even bother posting.
|
On June 28 2015 04:36 Damdred wrote:Show nested quote +On June 28 2015 04:25 NydusHerMain wrote: At least we know mig is mafia. If game was going to be over with the mig lynch, I don't think mafia would even bother posting. Why you have to drop off
Are you trying to say activity is alignment indicative? I've given my stance on this game
|
On June 28 2015 04:49 Damdred wrote:Show nested quote +On June 28 2015 04:40 NydusHerMain wrote:On June 28 2015 04:36 Damdred wrote:On June 28 2015 04:25 NydusHerMain wrote: At least we know mig is mafia. If game was going to be over with the mig lynch, I don't think mafia would even bother posting. Why you have to drop off Are you trying to say activity is alignment indicative? I've given my stance on this game For son people activity is indicative, I still,think your activity and ideas day one were pretty good so I still think you have a good shot at town. However dropped off pretty hard and on an afk day when we probably have mafia up you have been,pretty mia instead of helping a bot more. Which granted is a little,hypocritical of me
I don't think there's much to talk about. MiG is going to die, and there are people who are associated with him and I've laid it out.
|
|
I'm not going to lie, I'm town reading HF lightly but since we're in triple LyLo and he's red checked, I feel like he's coin to get lynched anyways. Should we just do it now?
|
Otherwise I want a shockey/onegu lynch.
|
I just feel like no matter what, the red check is going to get you in the end regardless of your alignment.
|
|
|
|