TL Mafia LXVIII: Fanfic Crossover Edition - Page 164

On September 19 2014 10:53 justanothertownie wrote:

Exactly.

On September 19 2014 10:44 justanothertownie wrote:

I don't think I remember a single game where someone got lynched for claiming miller. At least no game I played in.

On September 19 2014 10:33 GlowingBear wrote:


HAHAHAHA I like you.

Your top scumreads please

On September 19 2014 10:53 Damdred wrote:


are you not reading the thread GB? Palmar was talked about last day cycle for not pushing a miller lynch like normal, hf said it was suicide cause of people in game I asked who else besides palmar. Pay attention please

On September 19 2014 11:04 Superbia wrote:


You care to elaborate?

On September 19 2014 10:57 GlowingBear wrote:


So what? I also believe he is scum for that, but I want the conclusion on why's that particular a mafia move and not town move.

On September 19 2014 10:57 Superbia wrote:
All right, I'm here.

I read the push on me earlier today and was hoping more people would join in so I could get some more easy reads off it.

Let's start off with why pressuring me is good, but actually wanting to lynch me is scummy:

- I was basically not present during d1.
- My two during n1 were partially (but genuinely) erroneous.

As a result, there is no way that any VT will have a hard read on me. I have simply done too little. As a result, reading me somewhat or possibly scum/town is good. Having a hard read on me either way is most likely bad.

These three people have read me hard-scum (no one has read me hard-town):
- BloodyC0bbler (#2954)
- Chairman Ray (#2978)
- geript (#3091)

I think that there is at least 1 mafia between these three.

Let's start off with the most townie out of the three, Chairman Ray. CR's read on me is based on my play during the newbie's game in which I participated (LVIII, Disney Princess Mafia) and concludes that my participation factor is way off! Congratulations, CR, you are correct! I haven't had as much time as I would've liked. Read into this however you like. You get townpoints for checking out my (albeit short) history to analyze my playstyle, spend them well! I also like his recent contemplation on geript, this also makes geript seem more scum to me (overarching assumption + PoE). Would not like to lynch CR (right now)!

Moving on to BloodyC0bbler. Oh, BC... Your push on me makes little sense given the context. I have said before I voted on kush how I was going to vote d1. From your entire read I can gather that your analysis of my filter has just been sloppy. My missread on CR was mostly based on the fact that I thought kush was another player (I've said this before). My missread on geript was admittedly a little sloppy (I've said this before). Moving on to another point: you were pretty adamant about lynching Palmar d1, yet he completely disappeared off your scum list during d2. What's up with this?

Finally, geript. I don't have a very strong read on him. That being said, I'm definitely leaning scum on him at the moment. His PGO claim still feels very weird for me, but I can imagine scenarios in which I would do this (hint: that's why I specifically asked about it). I think his single active mafia scenario is very possible from a town perspective, though I believe there are at least 2 active mafia. At this point in time I think I would prefer to lynch BC over geript. I would really like geript to elaborate on why he thinks I'm scum, in a manner that's not obnoxious and with appropriate elaboration.

##Vote: BloodyC0bbler

Some additional reads/things:
ShiaoPi starts d2 very well and I like him! Short and to the point. I'm expecting you to keep it up, however.
Lord Tolkien keeps pinging me out to post. I'm almost in your pocket bro, just one more ping! (i.e. I like Tolkien)
IAmRobik is fucking weird and scary. Very unsure of you, man.
Palmar has picked it up a little d2 compared to what I read about him d1. I'm not sure what kind of game he's playing. Palmar, I would like to see you start a wagon today.

I don't have strong reads on other people right now, but I haven't had much time to filterdive a lot today. Will be around to interact for some time.

On September 19 2014 11:06 justanothertownie wrote:

This sentence. Sense it does not make.

On September 19 2014 11:01 Holyflare wrote:
Palmar's day 1 was actually better than his day 2

On September 19 2014 11:11 justanothertownie wrote:

Yes. What superbia posted about this is weird.
After rereading palmars foundation filter I almost think we should just wagon him until he starts doing shit.

On September 19 2014 11:07 Holyflare wrote:
Hahahaha wtf "i think he's mafia for that but you tell me why he's mafia for that and not town!"

On September 19 2014 11:11 GlowingBear wrote:


Sorry, language problems. Let me rephrase it.

I think geript is scum for claiming PGO and unclaiming.

But I want the scum motivation behind it. Just saying "he is scum for doing that" is bad. I want to hear "he is scum for doing that because as scum he can get away from this, force a push on this", etc.

I want to know what is the scum motivation behind the unclaim.

On September 19 2014 11:12 Hopeless1der wrote:

wont work. wagon palmar to kill him if you must, but it isnt likely to motivate him.

On September 19 2014 11:13 justanothertownie wrote:

Well, the motivation for the unclaim is surviving. As either alignment. The mafia motivation for the claim itself is that a counterclaim was very unlikely at that point and nobody would check/track/lynch a claimed PGO. I see no town motivation for it.

On September 19 2014 11:07 GlowingBear wrote:
So you're basically saying your reads is based on how people pushed you.

1) tell me what do you think of palmar
2) what are the possible scenarios you've come to, regarding geript?